Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, now please answer my question.

Cause Pelosi saw a problem. You don't call the vote unless you know you can win. So I guess you're technically right. The progressives have the leverage to kill the bill if they want to do that. But that is cutting one's nose off to spite one's face.
 
I don't care whose fault it is. I want to see the investment in Infrastructure.
When someone disparages one side and is suspiciously silent or blithely accepting of the other, it doesn't come across like not caring about fault.
 
Last edited:
They have precisely what S&M have: the ability to vote for a bill so it passes or vote against it so it doesn't.

Why are there no "political realities that" S&M "need to face"?

What good do S&M think they are accomplishing? Do they think this will get progressives to change their minds?

What's left of it is about the same as nothing anyway, so ya, why not?

On that point, we have finally reached a real difference between the two sides: S&M are going out of their way to make it fail, while progressives are merely willing to allow it to fail if S&M manage to damage it badly enough.

The reason for lack of progressive leverage is their obvious utility function. Any amount of progressive spending is more progressive than the current system, and preferable to not spending it. The argument that not voting for it advances a long term strategy is dubious.
 
The reason for lack of progressive leverage is their obvious utility function. Any amount of progressive spending is more progressive than the current system, and preferable to not spending it. The argument that not voting for it advances a long term strategy is dubious.

Wow!

We agree on something.

A half a loaf is better than none at all.
 
Wow!

We agree on something.

A half a loaf is better than none at all.

Now, there probably are philosophical progressives and socialists out there that would have some point where a small number of dollars is worse than zero dollars. There might be a representative or two.....


...not a chance it is a senator.
 
You don't think so? 1.5 or 1.75 Trillion dollars vs nothing?

Have Manchin and Sinema actually properly nailed themselves down with what they'll actually vote for, yet? Or will the bar just keep lowering more and more and more because they refuse to?
 
You don't think so? 1.5 or 1.75 Trillion dollars vs nothing?

Progressive House Democrats have a reasonable fear that if they vote and pass the bipartisan bill that Manchin likes, Manchin will insist on gutting the Build Back Better bill until it is useless or worse than useless. Assuming he won't just say, "The Bipartisan bill (with all its fossil fuel industry perks) is good enough, we don't need the BBBA", and refuse to vote for it at all. Manchin could ease these fears by simply having a framework or the BBBA that he says he will vote for, or saying that the Senate will vote for the BBBA before the House votes for the Bipartisan bill. Manchin has refused to do either of these things for months, for no reason he cares to articulate. "I am not going to stab you in the back, I just insist that I be allowed to stand behind you with this very sharp knife and I refuse to tell you why..."

So the House Progressives are holding the Bipartisan bill hostage. By refusing to vote for it until Manchin puts up or shuts up, they can force him to the table at least. And if they are willing to kill the hostage, then that could work out for them in the long run, as people in DC might finally start to take the Progressive caucus seriously, and not as some losers than can be easily pushed around.

No one knows what Kyrsten Sinema is doing, including Kyrsten Sinema...
 
You don't think so? 1.5 or 1.75 Trillion dollars vs nothing?
The last budget was 2.3 trillion for a single year, CARES was 2.2, and this new bill we're talking about is spread out over 10 years, making its real value to the budget a tenth of what is claimed if they're compared honestly instead of with that 10x skew built in. (Costs for things that would actually help the American people are always reported on a 10-year projection; costs for stuff the politicians have taken corporate bribes for are reported on either a 1-year projection or a single-instance-never-again basis.) There's going to be a budget for the usual stuff anyway, and this is hardly a blip of a fluctuation from the usual. And it's not going to the people. At best, to the extent that anything would happen at all, it would go to administration & enforcement of the laws & regulations (and it's hard to picture how that can add up to the claimed amount so something's already fishy there anyway)... which, since the new laws & regulations are so skimpy and selective, means it won't affect people's lives significantly (literally none at all for most of us), which was supposed to be the whole point all along.

But, look beyond the dollars, and it's worse than nothing.

For one thing, it's stapled to another bill that already passed the Senate which would be a giveaway to the Senate's corporate masters, privatizing our infrastructure so it can all be managed after the glorious example of the Texas power grid the last time the weather got hot... and the last time it got cold... while charging people extra. The only way out of this combination of the two bills would be to vote against that one first and then for this one, but the HoR is run by a corporatist who won't schedule them in that order for exactly that reason.

Then there's the fact that caving in now would be yet another example of the progressives' pattern of reliably folding on every hand, with or without having bluffed a bit first, only with even more emphasis this time after bluffing slightly longer than usual. The more solidly you establish that just bluffing & folding is who you are, the more you prove to your opponents that you are not to be taken seriously or listened to. They'll just keep running over you because you'll keep letting them and they'll know you will.

Then there's the electoral issue. Remember, the whole point all along was supposed to be to make Americans' lives observably better, and one of the reasons for that was so they'd start to feel that Democrats are the party that makes life better so they'd be more likely to vote for Democrats afterward. Even a bill that does some tiny hypothetical good for some fraction of the populace in some obscure indirect way still feels overall like nothing, as far as general public sentiment is concerned. And passing a bill which throws away the positive effects for the peasants is throwing away votes, which is throwing away the next few elections... especially with Pelosi & Biden/Harris almost certain (if it passes) to try to run the next campaign or two on bragging about what a huge life-altering history-making success it wasn't, thus highlighting their own uselessness-at-best better than a Republican attack ad ever could. That would just look like more of the same old business as usual (because that's what it would be), and the more of that the voters get, the more they give up & drop out. Of course, if passing the mockery of a bill won't make a difference in people's lives, not-passing it won't either, but at least then those who resisted can base a campaign on having resisted those who made the bill so useless in the first place, complete with pointing out that fights like that can succeed if they can just get more like themselves in on it. The line practically writes itself.

You don't call the vote unless you know you can win.
That is what Pelosi thinks. Pelosi is not somebody from whom strategic advice should be taken.

Demonstrating & emphasizing & highlighting, as much as possible, the division within the party right now, is the only way for the party to survive.
 
Last edited:
The problem is the progressives have no leverage whatsoever. None. It the Dems had a 60/40 split in the Senate Manchin and Sinema would be irrelevant. Lose one vote and it crashes down.

I'm on the progressives side, but there are political realities that they need to face.

The progressives have more leverage than Manchin and Sinema to totally gridlock the Democratic legislative agenda, should they chose to behave in a similar fashion.
 
Last edited:
Then there's the electoral issue. Remember, the whole point all along was supposed to be to make Americans' lives observably better, and one of the reasons for that was so they'd start to feel that Democrats are the party that makes life better so they'd be more likely to vote for Democrats afterward. Even a bill that does some tiny hypothetical good for some fraction of the populace in some obscure indirect way still feels overall like nothing, as far as general public sentiment is concerned.
And as far as the general public is concerned, the failure to pass legislation of any import is something to hang on the necks of all Democrats. Saying "but but but Manchinema" doesn't mean anything. They're Democrats. Democrats are blocking the Democratic bill because Democrats don't want what's in it. Remember when the GOP finally got a chance to repeal the ACA but didn't because they couldn't all agree on what to replace it with, and that was basically the end of their political momentum?
 
With all the focus on Sinema and Manchin, if neither bill passes, they will get most of the blame. Progressive Democrats are mostly in states where they are not so vulnerable.

Manchin will want to run at least one more time, for his career and income, so he will come around. Sinema is a totally unpredictable factor at this point. I predict that politics is not her long term career. She will move on to some "big thing" that will be acceptable but not embarrassing and a failure.
 
.....
Remember when the GOP finally got a chance to repeal the ACA but didn't because they couldn't all agree on what to replace it with, and that was basically the end of their political momentum?

Let me just note that the Repubs never had any plan to replace the ACA. Killing it was their sole goal. Eliminating the ACA was never contingent on enacting some replacement plan, and no such plan was ever offered. And you might recall that the Repubs came within one vote of succeeding, until McCain literally thumbed down the bill.
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/john-mccain-health-care-vote_n_59786066e4b0a8a40e83d75b
 
Last edited:
The GOP plan for healthcare was something like a 4000 tax deduction. Not sure who all were going to get it. No paperwork, no agencies.

It's sort of like a Manchin climate plan. It might be there, it might not. At best we could stop half a climate change. Sometime. Maybe starting in 2050.
 
Last edited:
Demonstrating & emphasizing & highlighting, as much as possible, the division within the party right now, is the only way for the party to survive.

Political party
A political party is an organization that coordinates candidates to compete in a particular country's elections. It is common for the members of a party to hold similar ideas about politics, and parties may promote specific ideological or policy goals.

A 'party' that is constantly divided on policy is a party in name only.

Tero said:
With all the focus on Sinema and Manchin, if neither bill passes, they will get most of the blame.
And once again, progressives avoid facing the real reason for their failure. Both Arizona and West Virginia lean conservative, so by rights they should have Republican senators. If you want more progressive policies, you must convince the public to vote for candidates who want them.
 
Then there's the electoral issue. Remember, the whole point all along was supposed to be to make Americans' lives observably better, and one of the reasons for that was so they'd start to feel that Democrats are the party that makes life better so they'd be more likely to vote for Democrats afterward.
I'll vote for any party (or parties) that makes our lives observably better - or even one that only manages to stop it from getting worse - vs one that makes it worse by insisting on holding out for the impossible. Who would want to vote for a party that makes things worse because they won't compromise? That's right, people who don't really care about making lives observably better.
 
I'll vote for any party (or parties) that makes our lives observably better - or even one that only manages to stop it from getting worse - vs one that makes it worse by insisting on holding out for the impossible. Who would want to vote for a party that makes things worse because they won't compromise? That's right, people who don't really care about making lives observably better.

Except the GOP doesn't even try.

I get mad at liberals/progressives that thinking making a statement is better than making our lives even marginally better. Sinema and Manchin are barely Democrats. Sinema voted for Trump's policies 50.4 percent of the time. More than any Democrat. What do the progressives expect. Manchin's WV voted for Trump by more than 20 points.

It is dangerous and stupid to try and put these two Senators feet to the fire when you have no margin of victory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom