Tony Szamboti
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2007
- Messages
- 4,976
So, at minimum, you agree that the Korol analysis is complete garbage and you apologize for this whole back and forth, right? You also agree you completely fabricated your 99% heating in 25-30 min claim to try to win an argument? You see now that the beam could have already been heated to nearly 400 C when Korol begins his heating at 20 C, right?
Come on--muster your intellectual honesty for once.
No, I believe the Korol analysis is the closest to reality, with NIST quite a bit to the high side and Beyler's analysis way out of the ballpark.
I didn't fabricate anything. I was saying that most of the heating would take place in the time frame where the fire was directly under the structural members. That is true.
You know unlike the case of WTC 7, NIST actually got and tested some of the steel from the fire affected zones in the Twin Towers to see what temperatures it had experienced. All but three pieces out of the 170 tested hadn't experienced anything beyond 250 C with nothing beyond 600 C.
Last edited: