The ballad of the 911 shill

Status
Not open for further replies.
A court of law cannot ignore the structural buckling of WTC 7 as observed by a number of people just prior to its collapse, which is firm evidence that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7.

As pointed out on a number of occasions, there is absolutely no evidence the collapse of WTC 7 was a CD operation and that explains why after 15 years, investigations have found no such evidence.

To prove a valid point that CD explosives had nothing to do with the collapse of WTC 7, please point out video timelines where CD explosions are heard in the following video as WTC 7 collapses, and if you fail to post such times lines for everyone to see, the case will be closed due to lack of CD evidence. In case you missed it, here's the video.


WTC 7 Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A


.

The study I provided the link too is publicly available for a price, and lends support to NIST and shows Tony wrong.

It is only a matter of time until Tony self destructs, chocking on his own words.
 
You keep squirming trying to get there in areas you don't have enough detail on.

The reality is there is currently no valid publicly available analysis that shows WTC 7 collapsed due to fire.

Tony, is there currently a valid publicly available analysis, that would stand up in court, that shows WTC 7 collapsed due to a CD. If so, please provide a link.
 
You are talking like a lawyer working for a client trying to nitpick and make your case no matter what the reality is. I am talking reality. Go get the Beyler analysis. I really don't have any more to say to you until you get it.

Tony, you took NIST to task and declared the entire report as fraudulent due to omission of stiffeners.
Yet now its just peachy that Korol ingores that he should start with steel at least at 200C rather than 20C.
Are we getting that right?
Or will you be calling for Korol to redo his analysis?
 
Tony, is there currently a valid publicly available analysis, that would stand up in court, that shows WTC 7 collapsed due to a CD. If so, please provide a link.

Actually there us a valid current, publically available analysis that finds WTC7 collapsed dye to an initial failure caused by fire that DID stand up in court.
 
Is Tony presenting himself as an "expert witness" in the legal sense?
If so, he is in for a shock. A semi-competent lawyer would take him apart. I am qualified in that I have the proper credentials. I am not qualified by temperament. My BS filter is set to way too small a notch, and my tolerance for idiocy is non-existent. Our side's lawyers reccomendations that we use my stuff presented by someone else (who participated fully in the preparation, in case you wondered about professional ethics).
Case never went to court anyway.
 
Even then direct radiation is where most of the energy transfer occurs and that only lasts for 25 to 30 minutes and the heat release rate isn't nearly high enough to get to any more than about 500 C on the girders and maybe 600 C on the beams due to mass and specific heat requirements.
I'm sure this has been pointed out, but I haven't seen it yet, and I'm curious.
If you're right, and those are the max temps the beams reached, do you not think that is enough to cause the collapse? I'm learning as I read along here, and just before you posted this assertion the first time, someone posted that at 400°C the beams, girders, etc, are significantly reduced in strength. (45%). Why do you think that wouldn't cause structural failure?
 
Is Tony presenting himself as an "expert witness" in the legal sense?
If so, he is in for a shock. A semi-competent lawyer would take him apart....
As an engieer half trained in law I would love to see "them" get the "New investigation" with "subpoena powers" AKA para judicial powers.

The Gage, Jones, Szamboti nonsense would not last the first minutes of cross examination.

I recommend to anyone who is interested that they read the transcript of Behe, M cross examination in Kitzmiller v Dover - one of the classic "creationists v evolutionary biology" cases.

He was committed to lie for his version of God and was carved to shreds. The same would happen for any 9/11 truthers who ever got before a para-judicial empowered investigation.

I I am qualified in that I have the proper credentials. I am not qualified by temperament. My BS filter is set to way too small a notch, and my tolerance for idiocy is non-existent. Our side's lawyers recommendations that we use my stuff presented by someone else (who participated fully in the preparation, in case you wondered about professional ethics).
Case never went to court anyway.
I was only in that situation once - the lawyers deliberately excluded me from their discussions to leave open the option of me being an expert witness. As I understand our AU legal system in common with UK is no where near as testing on quals as "expert witness" as the US courts...acceptance is easier than US.

But forget "expert witness" and all the extra rules. Just as a witness for one side the truther "leaders" would not last through the first session.
 
As an engieer half trained in law I would love to see "them" get the "New investigation" with "subpoena powers" AKA para judicial powers.

The Gage, Jones, Szamboti nonsense would not last the first minutes of cross examination.

I recommend to anyone who is interested that they read the transcript of Behe, M cross examination in Kitzmiller v Dover - one of the classic "creationists v evolutionary biology" cases.

He was committed to lie for his version of God and was carved to shreds. The same would happen for any 9/11 truthers who ever got before a para-judicial empowered investigation.

I was only in that situation once - the lawyers deliberately excluded me from their discussions to leave open the option of me being an expert witness. As I understand our AU legal system in common with UK is no where near as testing on quals as "expert witness" as the US courts...acceptance is easier than US.

But forget "expert witness" and all the extra rules. Just as a witness for one side the truther "leaders" would not last through the first session.

Under the Daubert test in US federal court, it would be extremely easy to get Tony disqualified as an expert witness on any of the aspects of the wtc collapse. He simply doesn't have the experience, publication history, or professional accomplishment to opine on these matters in court. That said, however, if he were on the other side, I'd never move to disqualify him because he'd be too good a witness to cross. On this forum, Tony can and does constantly evade reasonable questions about his theories and the bases for them. Just look at the whole 99% heat transfer in 25 min argument and his claim that there is no significant heating in figure 10-1 for the first 4.5 hours. Such chutzpah is a litigator's dream. And all his theories boil down similarly--bald assertions that he cannot back with any actual analyses and that fall apart when he does try to tether them to reality, as when he thought he could cite NIST's fire model in support of his 25 min heat transfer theory.
 
Last edited:
Under the Daubert test in US federal court, it would be extremely easy to get Tony disqualified as an expert witness on any of the aspects of the wtc collapse. He simply doesn't have the experience, publication history, or professional accomplishment to opine on these matters in court.
Understood and agreed.

That said, however, if he were on the other side, I'd never move to disqualify him because he'd be too good a witness to cross.
Don't I - you - we - some of us - know it? It would be cruel fun. ;)

On this forum, Tony can and does constantly evade reasonable questions about his theories and the bases for them. Just look at the whole 99% heat transfer in 25 min argument and his claim that there is no significant heating in figure 10-1 for the first 4.5 hours. Such chutzpah is a litigator's dream. And all his theories boil down similarly--bald assertions that he cannot back with any actual analyses and that fall apart when he does try to tether them to reality, as when he thought he could cite NIST's fire model in support of his 25 min heat transfer theory.
Yes. Part of the reason for my personal opinion as to why Tony is here. He is playing for a different audience.

Saw a lot of that when I was moderating in a different setting - creationists v evolutionary science. The analogy to "trutherism" on 9/11 is strong. There simply are NOT "two sides".
 
Last edited:
Understood and agreed.

Don't I - you - we - some of us - know it? It would be cruel fun. ;)

Yes. Part of the reason for my personal opinion as to why Tony is here. He is playing for a different audience.

Saw a lot of that when I was moderating in a different setting - creationists v evolutionary science. The analogy to "trutherism" on 9/11 is strong. There simply are NOT "two sides".

I think Tony would be justified using the insanity defense, to prevent him from going to jail for perjury.:D
 
I'm sure this has been pointed out, but I haven't seen it yet, and I'm curious.
If you're right, and those are the max temps the beams reached, do you not think that is enough to cause the collapse? I'm learning as I read along here, and just before you posted this assertion the first time, someone posted that at 400°C the beams, girders, etc, are significantly reduced in strength. (45%). Why do you think that wouldn't cause structural failure?

The factors of safety for the columns in WTC 7 was at least 3 and they never got hotter than 300 C where structural steel has lost almost no strength.

The floor framing factor of safety was well above 3 and at worst the beams and girders may have gotten to 600 C where structural steel loses about 50% of its yield strength.

At 400 C structural steel has still not lost much strength. Whoever said it loses 45% there wasn't right and in case you aren't aware, there is a lot of smoke blowing on this forum (no pun intended).

You can see the yield strength reduction in structural steel at elevated temperatures on the bottom of page 9 in the AISC publication here https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/aisc/publications/facts-for-steel-buildings-1-fire-facts.pdf
 
Last edited:
Under the Daubert test in US federal court, it would be extremely easy to get Tony disqualified as an expert witness on any of the aspects of the wtc collapse. He simply doesn't have the experience, publication history, or professional accomplishment to opine on these matters in court. That said, however, if he were on the other side, I'd never move to disqualify him because he'd be too good a witness to cross. On this forum, Tony can and does constantly evade reasonable questions about his theories and the bases for them. Just look at the whole 99% heat transfer in 25 min argument and his claim that there is no significant heating in figure 10-1 for the first 4.5 hours. Such chutzpah is a litigator's dream. And all his theories boil down similarly--bald assertions that he cannot back with any actual analyses and that fall apart when he does try to tether them to reality, as when he thought he could cite NIST's fire model in support of his 25 min heat transfer theory.

It wouldn't be a goofball situation like an argument on a silly forum like this. You won't even discuss this issue with me by e-mail. You obviously have to stay in a place like this to confuse the situation. You are not discussing things in a legitimate way and you know it.

The first two WTC 7 reports (NIST and ARUP) have been shown to have huge invalidating issues.

Your last hope is the WAI report and it too seems to have big problems with its extreme steel temperature claims. Interestingly, the heat transfer analysis it depends on is not publicly available.

The reality you want to evade in your defense of the WAI report is that direct radiation is the dominant method of heat transfer into protected steel, which that in WTC 7 was. Direct radiation needs to see the item to heat it and that means the fires would have to be under the steel to heat it in any significant way. Unfortunately for you, the fires can be shown to have lasted in a given area for only about 30 minutes. The fire protection with its low thermal conductivity would severely limit heating of the steel for much longer than that, and the temperatures of the steel framing would not reach anywhere near the extreme temperatures the WAI report claims.

You cannot say the WAI report is valid, as there is no way to substantiate its extreme steel temperature claims publicly. They are nothing more than unsupported assertions at the moment. I would bet the Beyler analysis will not be released to the public because it probably uses assumptions which can't be supported and can be shown to be erroneous.

You are trying to defend the indefensible. Simply put there is currently no valid analysis showing WTC 7 came down due to fire that is publicly available.
 
Last edited:
ballad of a failed CD fantasy - BS born in paranoid minds

The ballad is summarized by the evidence 9/11 truth offers - the empty set
 
It wouldn't be a goofball situation like an argument on a silly forum like this. You won't even discuss this issue with me by e-mail. You obviously want to stay in a place like this allowing others to chime in here and there to confuse the situation. You are not discussing things in a legitimate way and you know it.

The reason you need to do it this way is that you are trying to defend the indefensible. That is that there is currently no valid analysis showing WTC 7 came down due to fire that is publicly available.

The reality you want to evade is that direct radiation is the dominant method of heat transfer into protected steel, which that in WTC 7 was, and the fires provably would only have lasted in a given area for about 30 minutes, the fire protection with its low thermal conductivity would severely limit heating of the steel for much longer than that, and the temperatures of the steel framing would not reach anywhere near the temperatures the WAI report claims.

You cannot say the WAI report is valid as there is no way to substantiate its extreme steel temperature claims publicly. They are nothing more than unsupported claims at the moment. I would bet the Beyler analysis will not be released to the public because it probably uses assumptions which can't be supported and can be shown to be erroneous.



Hey benthamitemetric, Tony seems to not know about the paper I link please inform him about soot, and black body radiation, or about conduction from convection gases.

If you PM me an email address I will try to send you some videos, where I stand exstreamly close to huge fires, burst into flames, and burn up alive, because we all know Tony has to be right about radiatant heating, being the dominant heat source in a fire.

There is no way a human being could take a sprayer of biodiesel, and super heat a huge green wet stump pile, or a leaf blower and burn a stump without bursting into flames!

Oh look how this poor man melts his leaf blower, and bursts into flames from the radiation!
Burning a stump with the leaf blower 2: http://youtu.be/gHMR-2HXBGE

Oh, and look at this poor fellow fried to bits by radiation!

Tree Stump Removal with Leaf Blower: http://youtu.be/7bTpmFGiuZ0

Tony do you actually realize how Stupid the claims you are making are?

Oh since I am a ghost having burned up alive, it is hard for me to find time to edit videos, and load them to YouTube. Too much Haunting of idiots to do!
 
Last edited:
20141002_183417-1_zpsdkng7kjx.jpg


Hey Tony how many times do you want to make a fool of yourself?

The many of the stumps in that pile were trees 4 foot in diameter.
benthamitemetric. Come on down, I have a small brush pile ready to burn, about 200 Tons or so of stumps and brush, we can light it with a leaf blower and 20 gallons of Biodiesel, and just vaporize
Ourselves to prove Tony right!

Truther, Lurkers take note, Boy Scouts die every day roasting marsh mellows to make smores over campfires! Your best and brightest says so, so it must be true!

Tony go get help, you really need it!
 
Last edited:
As an engieer half trained in law I would love to see "them" get the "New investigation" with "subpoena powers" AKA para judicial powers.

The Gage, Jones, Szamboti nonsense would not last the first minutes of cross examination.

I recommend to anyone who is interested that they read the transcript of Behe, M cross examination in Kitzmiller v Dover - one of the classic "creationists v evolutionary biology" cases.

He was committed to lie for his version of God and was carved to shreds. The same would happen for any 9/11 truthers who ever got before a para-judicial empowered investigation.

I was only in that situation once - the lawyers deliberately excluded me from their discussions to leave open the option of me being an expert witness. As I understand our AU legal system in common with UK is no where near as testing on quals as "expert witness" as the US courts...acceptance is easier than US.

But forget "expert witness" and all the extra rules. Just as a witness for one side the truther "leaders" would not last through the first session.
I worded my post rather badly--
The case i told of was not me being an Expert Witness (I was involved and therefore couldn't be) but the advice of the lawyer during the discussions was that my attitude makes me a bad witness, and while at the time I had the credentials, I should not ever try to be an expert witness. Which is why they chose a colleague of mine to present. As I said, it never got to the point of actual testimony.
Even being right doesn't make one a good witness in court...
 
What I found funny was when AE911T tried to get a High Rise safety initiative passed in NY. It was a way to get a new WTC7 investigation approved and funded.

Now that said, if they are so sure it was CD. What building design changes would come out of such an investigation to prevent future High Rise buildings from collapsing due to controlled demolition? The initiative failed, for good reasons.
 
It wouldn't be a goofball situation like an argument on a silly forum like this. You won't even discuss this issue with me by e-mail. You obviously have to stay in a place like this to confuse the situation. You are not discussing things in a legitimate way and you know it.

The first two WTC 7 reports (NIST and ARUP) have been shown to have huge invalidating issues.

Your last hope is the WAI report and it too seems to have big problems with its extreme steel temperature claims. Interestingly, the heat transfer analysis it depends on is not publicly available.

The reality you want to evade in your defense of the WAI report is that direct radiation is the dominant method of heat transfer into protected steel, which that in WTC 7 was. Direct radiation needs to see the item to heat it and that means the fires would have to be under the steel to heat it in any significant way. Unfortunately for you, the fires can be shown to have lasted in a given area for only about 30 minutes. The fire protection with its low thermal conductivity would severely limit heating of the steel for much longer than that, and the temperatures of the steel framing would not reach anywhere near the extreme temperatures the WAI report claims.

You cannot say the WAI report is valid, as there is no way to substantiate its extreme steel temperature claims publicly. They are nothing more than unsupported assertions at the moment. I would bet the Beyler analysis will not be released to the public because it probably uses assumptions which can't be supported and can be shown to be erroneous.

You are trying to defend the indefensible. Simply put there is currently no valid analysis showing WTC 7 came down due to fire that is publicly available.

Just going to pretend we weren't talking about Korol's paper for 3 whole pages before you decided to switch the subject after I proved you to be 400 C wrong on pre-heating, eh?

The forum isn't the problem, Tony. You are the problem. You can't be intellectually honest if it means admitting that you or your fellow travelers could be mistaken, and, when you don't know what you're talking about, you just blatantly make stuff up and lie to try to win an argument. It's a sad spectacle and everyone can see exactly what happened in this thread and exactly when you tried to change the subject.

You know Korol's methodology is indefensible. If not, you'd actually try to defend it. You're still welcome to try and prove me wrong, Tony. You've had plenty of time to "coagulate" your thoughts offline.

I'm re-attaching the graph and chart we were discussing. Please tell me the 25-30 min in which you believe 99% of the heat transfer occurs or else admit you were wrong. If you can bring yourself to admit you were wrong, then you understand why Korol's approach is wrong. Everyone else in this thread already understands it, Tony. Just look at all the pre-heating you are missing on the floor 12 graph and look how hot the floor 13 beams actually were at 4:30 pm in the simulation. Korol missed all of that heating because he conflated the peak burn time in a particular area of a compartmental fire with the heating time in a compartmental fire or a traveling fire. Just acknowledge it and we can move on and discuss whatever you want.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    34.1 KB · Views: 0
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 0
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 379 9-9.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 379 9-9.jpg
    19.2 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
Just going to pretend we weren't talking about Korol's paper for 3 whole pages before you decided to switch the subject after I proved you to be 400 C wrong on pre-heating, eh?

The forum isn't the problem, Tony. You are the problem. You can't be intellectually honest if it means admitting that you or your fellow travelers could be mistaken. It's a sad spectacle and everyone can see exactly what happened in this thread and exactly when you tried to change the subject.

You didn't prove anyone wrong. Most of the heating of fire protected structural steel that could take place would be by direct radiation and that can only happen when the fire can see the item. Convection won't do much in the case of insulated structural steel so there won't be much preheating.

NIST's fire simulation temperatures are on the high side with preheating exaggerated, although apparently not nearly as much as the analysis by Beyler must be.

Anyone who has some idea about heat transfer and fire protection of structural steel will understand what I am saying above and it can be shown mathematically, so you really can't win.
 
Last edited:
I thought people here might have something to say about this

The ballad of the 911 shill

I help to keep the masses in the dark.
The way I do it is mostly with snark.
To keep the masses as sheep they must not know
how they are moved to and fro.
We are the ones who can proudly say
we perform this mission to minimize the fray.

Work on your meter - it's atrocious!! :covereyes
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom