The ballad of the 911 shill

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tell everyone the exact period in which 99% of the heat transfer takes place, Tony. It's just two data points. When does it start and when does it end?

You have no case. You tried to impugn the Korol paper's use of 25 minutes for peak fire burn and did not know or believe this came from NIST itself.

Now you have to eat crow and don't like it.
 
You have no case. You tried to impugn the Korol paper's use of 25 minutes for peak fire burn and did not know or believe this came from NIST itself.

Now you have to eat crow and don't like it.

Utter failure. Why are you lying so much and making things up? You know there is no 25-30 min period in the Cardington tests in which 99% of the heat transfer occurred. You just made it up to try to win an argument. It's really odd behavior.

Also, do you honestly think figure 9-9 shows 25 min of heating? Here is is again. Everyone can see it, Tony. Who are you trying to fool? If Korol is using this fire simulation to support a 25 min temperature increase time, it shows he is either dishonest or else has no idea what he is doing.

EDIT also adding the Cardington beam temperature graphs again so and everyone you can see very clearly there is no 25-30 min period in which 99% of the heat transfer took place.

In sum--you lied about the Cardington study supporting Korol and you are now trying to lie about NIST supporting Korol (or else you are so ignorant of fire science as to really not grasp the difference between "peak burn time" and "heating time".)
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 379 9-9.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 379 9-9.jpg
    19.2 KB · Views: 2
  • Cardington Beam Temp.jpg
    Cardington Beam Temp.jpg
    20.7 KB · Views: 1
Last edited:
Utter failure. Why are you lying so much and making things up? You know there is no 25-30 min period in the Cardington tests in which 99% of the heat transfer occurred. You just made it up to try to win an argument. It's really odd behavior.

Also, do you honestly think figure 9-9 shows 25 min of heating? Here is is again. Everyone can see it, Tony. Who are you trying to fool?

EDIT also adding the Cardington beam temperature graphs again so and everyone you can see very clearly there is no 25-30 min period in which 99% of the heat transfer took place.

Now you are just being plain silly. Figure 9-9 shows several workstation clusters and the fire moving over time. Steel which is 50 to 75 feet away from a fire is not being heated in any significant way by that fire. Remember what NIST says in the text

Figure 9–9 displays hourly snapshots of the upper layer temperatures predicted by the model. The simulations indicated that the clusters of workstations burned out in about 20 min to 30 min.

I really am getting tired of your aggressiveness in light of your low level of familiarity and intent to try and prop up the Weidlinger report when there is no chance for the extreme steel temperatures they claim and on which their conclusion is entirely dependent.

When you get the Beyler analysis let me know. Until then good bye.
 
Now you are just being plain silly. Figure 9-9 shows several workstation clusters and the fire moving over time. Steel which is 50 to 75 feet away from a fire is not being heated in any significant way by that fire. Remember what NIST says in the text

Figure 9–9 displays hourly snapshots of the upper layer temperatures predicted by the model. The simulations indicated that the clusters of workstations burned out in about 20 min to 30 min.

I really am getting tired of your aggressiveness in light of your low level of familiarity and intent to try and prop up the Weidlinger report when there is no chance for the extreme steel temperatures they claim and on which their conclusion is entirely dependent.

When you get the Beyler analysis let me know. Until then good bye.

At 2 pm, the middle of the northern portion of the building shown in figure 9-9 is close to 600 C. At 3 pm it is 1000 C. You think that part of the building was only being heated for 25-30 min?

Truthers--pay attention to this chutzpah! This is the most ridiculous argument I have seen in a long time yet this is what Tony and Korol need you to believe to accept their "skepticism" of the work of actual fire science experts. Here is figure 9-9 yet again.

EDIT also adding figure 10-1 from pg 390 of the NIST WTC 7 report. This is a graph of the gas temperature at a single location on floor 12 of wtc 7. Tony wants everyone to believe that a given building element at or near that location would only experience "significant" (in some undefined sense) heat transfer for 25-30 min. Truthers---do you realize that Tony's house of cards is built on this incredibly obvious error? Can you believe he is here in this thread balding lying about graphs and figures you can see for yourself?

And Tony, frankly, if you can look at figure 10-1 and see only 25-30 min of "significant heating", what's the point of even talking about Beyler's report with you? I thought you wanted an honest discussion, but that's not the case. I've given you all the facts and figures you need and followed your citations to find only patently obvious misrepresentations. All you can do is make bald assertions without citations to actual facts and figures and claim, again without citation to figures that prove your point, that I am too ignorant about heat transfer to understand your nuance. Now that you've hung your hat on NIST's simulation as a basis for Korol's methodologies, there is plenty to discuss, even without Beyler's report. You can start by identifying the period on the graph in figure 10-1 when 99% of the heat transfer occurs. Do you think it s between 4:30 and 5:00 or something like that? Do you see the error in assuming no significant heat transfer occurs prior to 4:30? That's the exact same error that Korol makes. I've been telling you that for days now.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 379 9-9.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 379 9-9.jpg
    19.2 KB · Views: 1
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1.jpg
    16.1 KB · Views: 1
Last edited:
Now you are just being plain silly. Figure 9-9 shows several workstation clusters and the fire moving over time. Steel which is 50 to 75 feet away from a fire is not being heated in any significant way by that fire. Remember what NIST says in the text

Figure 9–9 displays hourly snapshots of the upper layer temperatures predicted by the model. The simulations indicated that the clusters of workstations burned out in about 20 min to 30 min.

I really am getting tired of your aggressiveness in light of your low level of familiarity and intent to try and prop up the Weidlinger report when there is no chance for the extreme steel temperatures they claim and on which their conclusion is entirely dependent.

When you get the Beyler analysis let me know. Until then good bye.

Over simplified theory again Tony?

How Oversimplified your ideas are as the station burned out fuel, carbon was tranfered to other areas in turbulent gas flows, once reignited it burned at exstreamly high temperatures.
 
At 2 pm, the middle of the northern portion of the building shown in figure 9-9 is close to 600 C. At 3 pm it is 1000 C. You think that part of the building was only being heated for 25-30 min?

Truthers--pay attention to this chutzpah! This is the most ridiculous argument I have seen in a long time yet this is what Tony and Korol need you to believe to accept their "skepticism" of the work of actual fire science experts. Here is figure 9-9 yet again.

That's because Tony and Korol ignore the implications of this paper from NIST.

"Soot. - National Institute of Standards and Technology
fire.nist.gov › bfrlpubs › fire93 › PDF
At flame temperatures, soot behaves not unlike a black body. emitting visible and infrared radiation following Planck's Law. A large portion (@5090 of the carbon atoms present in a hydrocarbon fire exist in the form of ..."


They don't understand the ability of carbon fuels to move in the gasious flows of fires.
 
This thread makes it clear that the best way to deal with WTC7 truthers is to force them to address the entire context.

Say, Tony, where does KSM/Flight 93/Pentagon etc etc etc fit into your ballad?

I'm guessing in the instrumental interludes?
 
I would remind everyone here that Benthamitemetric is famous for being the first to post the Aegis Insurance Co. expert reports on the collapse of WTC 7 for their negligence case against Larry Silverstein's company WTC 7 Properties. These reports are known to most as the ARUP report and Benthamitemetriic gleefully claimed that it validated the NIST conclusion that WTC 7 came down via fire.

His open glee only lasted until those of us who could fully understand got a chance to look at the ARUP report and in quick order showed that it actually invalidated the NIST failure initiation mechanism and that the ARUP report itself contained a fatal error in that it could not break through the next floor down with a falling girder from the 13th floor onto the 12th.

Now Benthamitemetric is supporting a third WTC 7 report, this one from Weidlinger Associates, that requires extreme steel temperatures on the 9th and 10th floor which are not supported by the NIST fire simulation or independent analyses of WTC 7 like that from Korol et al.

It seems Benthamitemetric had to eat crow due to his premature support of the ARUP report and is now setting himself up for another fall.

The Weidlinger report extreme steel temperatures are based on a referenced heat transfer analysis by Hughes Associates' Craig Beyler but it has not been made public. Benthamitemetric says he spoke to Beyler about this and that he is considering making the thermal analysis public. I sincerely hope this happens so we can properly scrutinize it. I am not sure if I should hold my breathe though, as it is curious that it was not made public to begin with, since it is the king pin on which the Weidlinger report conclusions depend.
 
Last edited:
I would remind everyone here that Benthamitemetric is famous for being the first to post the Aegis Insurance Co. expert reports on the collapse of WTC 7 for their negligence case against Larry Silverstein's company WTC 7 properties. These reports are known to most as the ARUP report and Benthamitemetriic gleefully claimed that it validated the NIST conclusion that WTC 7 came down via fire.

His open glee only lasted until those of us who could fully understand got a chance to look at the ARUP report and in quick order showed that it actually invalidated the NIST failure initiation mechanism and that the ARUP report itself contained a fatal error in that it could not break through the next floor down with a falling girder from the 13th floor onto the 12th.

Now Benthamitemetric is supporting a third WTC 7 report, this one from Weidlinger Associates, that requires extreme steel temperatures on the 9th and 10th floor which are not supported by the NIST fire simulation or independent analyses of WTC 7 like that from Korol et al.

It seems Benthamitemetric had to eat crow due to his premature support of the ARUP report and is now setting himself up for another fall.

The Weidlinger report extreme steel temperatures are based on a referenced heat transfer analysis by Hughes Associates Craig Beyler but it has not been made public. Benthamitemetric says he spoke to Beyler about this and that he is considering making the thermal analysis public. I sincerely hope this happens so we can properly scrutinize it. I am not sure if I should hold my breathe though, as it is curious that it was not made public to begin with, since it is the king pin on which the Weidlinger report conclusions depend.

Tony--go ahead and tell me the time period in which 99% of the heat transfer occurs in figure 10-1. It's attached again for reference. We don't need Beyler's report or anything else to see how fundamentally flawed Korol's paper is. Why can't you just admit that?

(Nice projection-filled trip down your alt-history rabbit hole, by the way, but I'm not going to let you change the subject.)
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1.jpg
    16.1 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
If anyone is misrepresenting anything it is you through not having an appreciation of how heat is transferred.


Tony, you need to understand, three major evidences for which we have for WTC 7 are:

* Uncontrolled Fires (raging for hours)

* Major Impact Damage (structural load redistribution)

* Structural Buckling (evidence of structural weakening by fire)

There is no CD evidence and having experienced the sound of explosions on many occasions, I find the conspiracy theorist claim that explosives were used to demolish the WTC buildings to be simply ludicrous, to say the least especially since they cannot offer an explanation as to what type of explosives were used or how the WTC buildings could have been rigged in total secret without structural pre-weakening.

I might add there was no reason for the government to have concocted a false flag operation involving the WTC buildings and using explosives would have left behind traceable evidence anyway. Had United 93 slammed into the Capitol Building causing it to collapse, no doubt conspiracy theorist would claim that the collapse was a CD operation.

You say that the sequence of events leading up to the collapse of WTC 7 was impossible, but what did firefighters and investigators think when they first observed the internal collapse of WTC 5 due solely to fire?

To sum it up, you should face up to the fact that the collapse of WTC 7 was due to uncontrolled fires in conjunction with impact damage.
 
Last edited:
In case you aren't aware, the 25 minutes came from NIST.
A citation please.
The Korol paper even goes to a 30 minute time, but the protected steel temperatures are still far below what is claimed in Weidlinger.
Yep, somebody got it wrong.


The 25 to 30 minute time is an effective time where significant heat transfer is possible.
The Cardington tests indicate an hour of heat transfer time.
WTC7 was much larger and fires began on the south side , preheating entire floors to 200C hours before flames even reach the NE corner area.
Not to say you are not capable of learning, but at present you do not seem to understand how temperature difference affects heat transfer rate
Yes, it is one of the very first concepts taught in thermodynamics. It has analgues in other sciences, such as capacitor charge rates. Do you really believe people don't know that?
You and Korol don't seem to realize that the NE area of concern is heating up for hours prior to flames getting to that area.
your attempt to say the Cardington tests show much more time is involved is silly on its face.

I am looking at the very same time/temp graphs and I see and hour and a quarter of heating time between fire start (20C) and cool down descending to 850C (after having reached peak temp of over 1000C)
 
Last edited:
I thought people here might have something to say about this

The ballad of the 911 shill

I help to keep the masses in the dark.
... I do it is mostly with snark. ...
A confession? You call people sheep for understanding 19 terrorists did 9/11 to cause the fires you ignore; caused the destruction you want to blame on people you can't name.

When no evidence supports the claim, project. Projection - will not help the fantasy of CD, the undefined inside job by people you can't identify.

Paranoia, part of the fantasy conspiracy theory of CD, calling everyone who knows CD is false, a shill. Simple projection.
 
Last edited:
If anyone is misrepresenting anything it is you through not having an appreciation of how heat is transferred.

You seem to think that the heat transfer rate from a 900 C gas temperature into steel is the same whether the steel is at 20 C or 800 C and it most certainly is not. As the temperature difference decreases the heat transfer rate decreases asymptotically.

In addition NIST results show burnout in 20 to 30 minutes of workstation clusters.

How about if the steel is within a upper level gas temp of over 400C for an hour before upper level gas temps reach their peak, Tony? Is the steel still at 20C?

But I get it now. I see that you and Korol are just trying to help out old Chris Sarns since that is the exact same single line from the NIST report that he used.

There is a reason that there is a subset of engineering for fire sciences. Tony, demonstrates that reason with his utterly simplistic, single variable notion of fire analysis.
 
I would remind everyone here that Benthamitemetric is famous for being the first to post the Aegis Insurance Co. expert reports on the collapse of WTC 7 for their negligence case against Larry Silverstein's company WTC 7 Properties. These reports are known to most as the ARUP report and Benthamitemetriic gleefully claimed that it validated the NIST conclusion that WTC 7 came down via fire.

Yeah odd that. For years all we got from AE911T was that NIST had to release their computer input data so that AE911T could "verify" the NIST results. Oh, no,,, it was not possible to carry out an equally comprehensive analysis of WTC7 response to impact and fire, or the progressive collapse sequence without that NIST data!
Never heard that theme again after the ARUP report came out,,, imagine that!

Also note that neither you or AE911T were the first to post, or even mention, the ARUP report.
Imagine that!

BTW, yes, that report does in fact bolster the the NIST report. It differs only in it's determination of initial failure. You know, the single least determinable event.
Same goes for the WAI report.

ALL THREE conclude that fire caused an initial failure which saw multiple floor collapses AND THAT this in turn caused column instability and buckling, AND THAT this in turn caused a progression of failures resulting in global collapse.
 
Last edited:
At 2 pm, the middle of the northern portion of the building shown in figure 9-9 is close to 600 C. At 3 pm it is 1000 C. You think that part of the building was only being heated for 25-30 min?

Truthers--pay attention to this chutzpah! This is the most ridiculous argument I have seen in a long time yet this is what Tony and Korol need you to believe to accept their "skepticism" of the work of actual fire science experts. Here is figure 9-9 yet again.

EDIT also adding figure 10-1 from pg 390 of the NIST WTC 7 report. This is a graph of the gas temperature at a single location on floor 12 of wtc 7. Tony wants everyone to believe that a given building element at or near that location would only experience "significant" (in some undefined sense) heat transfer for 25-30 min. Truthers---do you realize that Tony's house of cards is built on this incredibly obvious error? Can you believe he is here in this thread balding lying about graphs and figures you can see for yourself?

And Tony, frankly, if you can look at figure 10-1 and see only 25-30 min of "significant heating", what's the point of even talking about Beyler's report with you? I thought you wanted an honest discussion, but that's not the case. I've given you all the facts and figures you need and followed your citations to find only patently obvious misrepresentations. All you can do is make bald assertions without citations to actual facts and figures and claim, again without citation to figures that prove your point, that I am too ignorant about heat transfer to understand your nuance. Now that you've hung your hat on NIST's simulation as a basis for Korol's methodologies, there is plenty to discuss, even without Beyler's report. You can start by identifying the period on the graph in figure 10-1 when 99% of the heat transfer occurs. Do you think it s between 4:30 and 5:00 or something like that? Do you see the error in assuming no significant heat transfer occurs prior to 4:30? That's the exact same error that Korol makes. I've been telling you that for days now.
All agreed.
What is significant heating?
Well at 200C structural steel yeild strength is reduced by about 15%. ,and at 400C it is reduced by 45%. So if we look at the graph we note that gas temps were in the region of 200 to 400 for 30 minutes.
I would consider that significant.
Gas temps then spent two hours rising from 400C to 1000C.
I would consider that significant.
And, gas temps then remained over 850C for another 15 minutes.
I would consider that significant too.
So I am at a loss as to how Korol and Tony Szamboti can claim significant heating only occured over a 30 minute period.

Astounding.
 
jaydeehess:
I agree that the collapse of wtc7 was a fire induced collapse. It is funny to read the CD supporters non response to questions asked of them. It is also sad that so many of them cannot understand it was fire induced even though a report may not have identified the correct beam that failed. Personally, I doubt anyone with 100% certainty say what failed first in wtc7 collapse. There are way to many variables.

What is know is the building was damaged by falling debris and fires burned for hours before the collapse. If Tony is so sure it was CD, he should be able to point to a specific report that will lay out the evidence to back up such a claim.
 
jaydeehess:
I agree that the collapse of wtc7 was a fire induced collapse. It is funny to read the CD supporters non response to questions asked of them. It is also sad that so many of them cannot understand it was fire induced even though a report may not have identified the correct beam that failed. Personally, I doubt anyone with 100% certainty say what failed first in wtc7 collapse. There are way to many variables.
All of which has been pointed out to him many a time, I am afraid.

What is known is the building was damaged by falling debris and fires burned for hours before the collapse. If Tony is so sure it was CD, he should be able to point to a specific report that will lay out the evidence to back up such a claim.
Also well known are the infalling of the EPH, then progression to the west of rooftop visible collapse, and the formation of the 'kink' on the noth face, the loss of the SW corner column. Tony makes up stories about some of these. I personally am most amused by his fiction concerning explosives set a few floors below the roof in order to drop the EPH to lower the building's center of mass.
Second fir me, in the amusement department is the "all four corners begin dropping at the same time" when they know that there is no corner column contibuting to the support of the SW corner. The SW would have to drop if the west and south sides begin dropping. South side is already compromised east of the SW corner, so make that, the SW corner would drop with the NW corner.
 
Last edited:
All agreed.
What is significant heating?
Well at 200C structural steel yeild strength is reduced by about 15%. ,and at 400C it is reduced by 45%. So if we look at the graph we note that gas temps were in the region of 200 to 400 for 30 minutes.
I would consider that significant.
Gas temps then spent two hours rising from 400C to 1000C.
I would consider that significant.
And, gas temps then remained over 850C for another 15 minutes.
I would consider that significant too.
So I am at a loss as to how Korol and Tony Szamboti can claim significant heating only occured over a 30 minute period.

Astounding.

The reason you are at a loss is that you don't seem to know much about heat transfer.

Heat from a fire is transferred three ways.

1. By radiation from the fire.
2. By radiation from the hot gas.
3. By convection from the hot gas.

The most significant portion is by radiation from the fire and when the fire burns out that is gone because a view is needed and the fire needs to be somewhat directly under the steel in question.

Heat transfer rate is dependent on the temperature difference. The smaller the difference the lower the rate.

It also takes time for heat to transfer through the fire protection. This time is significant and causes a lag. Once the fire burns out the air in the vicinity starts to cool. If the heating is not continuously applied to the fire protection for longer than the duration of its rating in hours it will not transfer much heat from the hot gas due to radiation and convection.

Most of the heating of fire protected steel occurs by direct radiation from the fire and once it burns out that method is no longer available. This coupled with the fact that the fires directly under the steel only burn for about 20 to 30 minutes is why the steel does not get to extremely high temperatures.

Another issue is that large steel members take a lot of energy to heat up. The specific heat of steel is 500 joules/kg-degK. This means that to heat up a structural member like girder A2001 to 800 C, which weighed about 2,650 kg, would take over a billion joules. If the fire is only under the steel for 30 minutes that would require nearly 600 Kw to go directly to the girder. The heat release rate for a 32 kg/m^2 fuel load is about 340 Kw, so it can't get anywhere near 800 C. Even under very efficient transfer the girder would only get to about 500 C.

Benthamitemetric is naively sticking his neck out again, like he did with the ARUP reports, and he is going to get humiliated again. I seriously doubt they will make the Beyler analysis public because they know we will find a serious problem with it which was used to generate extreme steel temperatures in an illegitimate way (similar to the illegitimate infinite stiffness used by Nordenson). However, it can be shown that the steel structural members on the 9th and 10th floors on the east side of WTC 7 could never get to the temperatures shown in the Weidlinger report without ever seeing that analysis.
 
Last edited:
The reason you are at a loss is that you don't seem to know much about heat transfer.

Heat from a fire is transferred three ways.

1. By radiation from the fire.
2. By radiation from the hot gas.
3. By convection from the hot gas.

The most significant portion is by radiation from the fire and when the fire burns out that is gone because a view is needed and the fire needs to be somewhat directly under the steel in question.

Heat transfer rate is dependent on the temperature difference. The smaller the difference the lower the rate.

It also takes time for heat to transfer through the fire protection. This time is significant and causes a lag. Once the fire burns out the air in the vicinity starts to cool. If the heating is not continuously applied to the fire protection for longer than the duration of its rating in hours it will not transfer much heat from the hot gas due to radiation and convection.

Most of the heating of fire protected steel occurs by direct radiation from the fire and once it burns out that method is no longer available. This coupled with the fact that the fires directly under the steel only burn for about 20 to 30 minutes is why the steel does not get to extremely high temperatures.

Another issue is that large steel members take a lot of energy to heat up. The specific heat of steel is 500 joules/kg-degK. This means that to heat up a structural member like girder A2001 to 800 C, which weighed about 2,650 kg, would take over a billion joules. If the fire is only under the steel for 30 minutes that would require nearly 600 Kw to go directly to the girder. The heat release rate for a 32 kg/m^2 fuel load is about 340 Kw, so it can't get anywhere near 800 C. Even under very efficient transfer the girder would only get to about 500 C.

Benthamitemetric is sticking his neck out again, like he did with the ARUP reports. He is going to get humiliated again. I seriously doubt they will make the Beyler analysis public because they know we will find a serious problem with it which is used to generate higher steel temperatures in an ilegitimate way. However, we can show they cannot be without ever seeing that analysis.
No, Tony, that doesn't tell me anything I did not already know.
Something tells me that real fire sciences engineers know all that and more Tony.
In fact the WAI report specifically mentions preheating prior to flames reaching the area around column 79.
But you dont think that matters because you think the girder was still at 20C when that compartment began burning.

If you are using upper level gas temps to determine heating time, why do you then switch to radiative heating?
 
Last edited:
This thread makes it clear that the best way to deal with WTC7 truthers is to force them to address the entire context.

Say, Tony, where does KSM/Flight 93/Pentagon etc etc etc fit into your ballad?

I'm guessing in the instrumental interludes?
I've tried that approach.

He'll call you a nincompoop, and proudly announce you're going on ignore.

Save your keystrokes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom