Stundie Finals For May - Vote Now!

May Finalists

  • DYA - Shows his true colours.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • YBZ - "...a report that says the twin towers were hollow."

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • PAD - "Everyone agrees that the impact itself had no real affect on the structure."

    Votes: 6 4.9%
  • SCG - Atta, the "crazed, cocained-up, drug-smuggling" federal agent.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • LTW - "Like Rosa Parks, Simon Wiesenthal, Winston Churchill, and Nelson Mandela..."

    Votes: 25 20.3%
  • DRG - Explosives causing steel to melt.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • DrJ - Big rocks and "Hokie stone" facades.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • DJJ - Most uses of 'truth' in a nonsensical post.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • ROD - "judy wood rocks"

    Votes: 4 3.3%
  • PtG - Operation: Junkie.

    Votes: 5 4.1%
  • KvB - Kevin goes on location.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • DgH - "Because WE ARE IGNORANT OF 911 FACTS, WE DEMAND PROOF."

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • SFT - On why you don't have to pay income tax unless you are a PERSON.

    Votes: 2 1.6%
  • MJD - [i]p, q, therefore r[/i] as an argument for the demolition of WTC 7.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • FRL - On why we have to go to war occasionally.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • MaK - "You need a pointy bit on the front. No pointy bit = no entry."

    Votes: 15 12.2%
  • 28K - The "[sic] wooden poll" experiment.

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • wtb - "facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts."

    Votes: 20 16.3%
  • LUC - On the limited application of the scientific method.

    Votes: 8 6.5%
  • CAP - COnfuses a volcanic eruption with a nuclear weapons test.

    Votes: 4 3.3%

  • Total voters
    123
  • Poll closed .
The Stundies
are about lack of scientific understanding, yes. They are also about misuse of logic, logical fallacies, inability to understand basic concepts, and so on, and so on.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2485953#post2485953

The nomination is most definitely not an ad hom attack, because the stundies are not any form of refutation or counter-argument against any claims. They are a way of pointing and laughing at twoofers, and/or debunkers, for stupid comments they make.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2663746#post2663746

...now, since no one here is even remotely claiming that the arguments put forward by conspiracy theorists are false because of ironic things they have said, and since many Stundie nominations are put forward because the argument they put forward is absurd or severely flawed, I assume you'll now withdraw your accusation of ad hom?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2666089#post2666089

The Stundies are not about making an argument. The Stundies are about mocking fools in the 9/11 movement.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2666537#post2666537

To outline my thoughts on why the "Rosa Parks" nomination was included in the final: Bizarre and outlandish statements do belong in the Stundies, and this would have to be one of the most extravagent and arrogant statements yet made by a truther. No, it isn't as funny as some of the other nominations, but there is a part of me behind the rage and disgust that just says, "He can't really think that, can he?"


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2675300#post2675300

I think it may be a sign of our suppressed outrage at the twoofers outrageous nonsense becoming slightly less supressed.

The Stundies started as an effort to find some humour in the rantings of the twoofers, and in that it has been successful, but every now and then, we remember what exactly it is that these people are promoting, and our legitimate disgust with their message surfaces.

The same thing has shown up in the comic strip thread. 95% fun and jokes, but with a few reminders of the real tradgedy that is at the heart of all 9/11 discussions.

In other words, just being human. Move along, nothing to see here :)

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2682503#post2682503

See, this is another reason I think The Stundies are good. Along with the cartoon thread, they allow an outlet for people where they don't have to worry so much...a bit of humor in an otherwise humorless forum.

If people are unloading their rage a bit here by casting a vote, I think that's better overall that unloading it somewhere else in the form of an actionable flame.

I'm speechless, surely now that you have dropped any pretence that this thread is any more that a series of ad hominems for your own entertainment it must be moved to Flame Wars or AAH.
 



I'm speechless, surely now that you have dropped any pretence that this thread is any more that a series of ad hominems for your own entertainment it must be moved to Flame Wars or AAH.


Aren't we allowed to entertain ourselves?
William, was that you I saw chasing those kids out of the park for kicking a football around?
 
I'm speechless, surely now that you have dropped any pretence that this thread is any more that a series of ad hominems for your own entertainment it must be moved to Flame Wars or AAH.

Can you please stop using the term "ad hominem" so blatantly incorrectly? You know perfectly well that an ad hominem is an attempt to refute an argument based on a judgement about its proponent. The Stundies are almost the precise opposite, a judgement about the proponent based on the absurd nature of their arguments. If you want to call the Stundies personal attacks, fine; that point of view has a valid line of argument behind it, and you've presented it in considerable detail many times. But "ad hominems" are something they're not, and from many previous posts of yours you've made it clear that you know that. Are you just trying to sound clever by using a Latin phrase?

Dave
 
Probably because it is the one that has been the most contested as a nomination for the finals so far. However, I outlined my reasons for disputing the nomination at...

You think I don't get it because it's contested ? Or do you think it's contested for the same reason I don't get it ?
 
Can you please stop using the term "ad hominem" so blatantly incorrectly? You know perfectly well that an ad hominem is an attempt to refute an argument based on a judgement about its proponent. The Stundies are almost the precise opposite, a judgement about the proponent based on the absurd nature of their arguments. If you want to call the Stundies personal attacks, fine; that point of view has a valid line of argument behind it, and you've presented it in considerable detail many times. But "ad hominems" are something they're not, and from many previous posts of yours you've made it clear that you know that. Are you just trying to sound clever by using a Latin phrase?

Dave
QED
 
I'm speechless, surely now that you have dropped any pretence that this thread is any more that a series of ad hominems for your own entertainment it must be moved to Flame Wars or AAH.

Edited by Lisa Simpson: 
Inappropriate remark removed.
Please stop pretending you are the arbiter of forum manners. It's not cute.

Please do not use personal attacks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
....In contrast, comparing oneself to someone you should not be comparing yourself to is just plain old human arrogance. It's perfectly understandable how people come to this point of view. And it's a very common occurrence. People do this sort of thing all the time.

I think a good Stundie should stand on its own, entirely independent of the Stundee's views on 9/11. Imagine, for a moment, that Dylan Avery's view on 9/11 is correct, and the US government really is an evil entity taking over the world. Is his remark Stundie worthy? I don't think it is. I think it would be admirable, that he desired to follow the example of historic figures and make a stand against tyranny.

Thus the perceived stundie-ness of his remark is reliant on the fact that he is wrong about 9/11....

-Gumboot

A great post (I am intending that compliment to be sincere).

I was beginning to think that no one would ever get it.
 
Can you please stop using the term "ad hominem" so blatantly incorrectly? You know perfectly well that an ad hominem is an attempt to refute an argument based on a judgement about its proponent. The Stundies are almost the precise opposite, a judgement about the proponent based on the absurd nature of their arguments. If you want to call the Stundies personal attacks, fine; that point of view has a valid line of argument behind it, and you've presented it in considerable detail many times. But "ad hominems" are something they're not, and from many previous posts of yours you've made it clear that you know that. Are you just trying to sound clever by using a Latin phrase?

Dave

I am not using it incorrectly. See Gumboot's post above.
 
Edited by Lisa Simpson: 
Inappropriate remark removed.
Please stop pretending you are the arbiter of forum manners. It's not cute.

Please do not use personal attacks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson

I don't see how my post was inappropriate. "Anal" in the context I was using it clearly meant "fastidious" or "obsessed".
 
A great post (I am intending that compliment to be sincere).

I was beginning to think that no one would ever get it.

Yes, we get it, but the point of the stundieness of the original quote is that Rosa Parks, Winston Churchill, Nelson Mandela etc didn't just make a video cobbled together from other people's work and sell it to gullible teens in order to profit from a tragedy.

The people he is comparing himself to actually risked their lives for their ideals. The most Mr Avery is risking is credibility.
 
William, the BBC for one disagrees with you

An ad hominem argument is an attack on someone's character. <snip>

Nice way of shutting somebody up, irrespective of the arguments being proposed by the other person.

Another example of ad hominem is to point out hypocrisy on the part of the claimant. <snip>

See the bolded bit - you are wrong. The Stundies are making fun of the argument not the Truther.

PS - thanks again for bumping the thread to encourage more people to vote. Come on you Facts! - "facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts".
 
I think the full quote does a better job.
[FONT=Trebuchet MS, arial, helvetica, sans-serif][/FONT]
[FONT=Trebuchet MS, arial, helvetica, sans-serif]
Ad Hominem
[/FONT]
An ad hominem argument is an attack on someone's character. A very powerful way to convince others of the merits of your argument is to ridicule your detractors or competitors, even though this, of itself, does nothing to support your position. It's also used as a tool to distract people from you having to better substantiate your argument.
Well this law was obviously constructed because of the demands of that sanctimonious mob of weepy politically correct sops who always stick their heads above the parapet when anything even slightly critical of immigration is mentioned.​
Whatever the character of the people who introduced it, what about the merits of the law itself?
Here you go spouting off about your rights to go out at night, when you are the first person to tell everyone else to shut up when they are talking to you. You're a complete pig.​
Nice way of shutting somebody up, irrespective of the arguments being proposed by the other person.
Another example of ad hominem is to point out hypocrisy on the part of the claimant. Just because there might be an element of personal hypocrisy involved, it doesn't automatically make their claim invalid.
Mr Jennings is berating us about the evils of unregulated handgun ownership. What he didn't tell you however is that in the 1980s he had a handgun himself, and used to go out shooting on a regular basis​
​
 
Does anyone have the link for that research paper that debunks some theories? It was posted in the forums and I can't find it. It was from Northwestern and was submitted in late may. thanks.
 
I think the full quote does a better job.

[font=Trebuchet MS, arial, helvetica, sans-serif][/i][/indent]

Argumentum ad hominem (argument directed at the person). This is the error of attacking the character or motives of a person who has stated an idea, rather than the idea itself. The most obvious example of this fallacy is when one debater maligns the character of another debater (e.g, "The members of the opposition are a couple of fascists!"), but this is actually not that common. A more typical manifestation of argumentum ad hominem is attacking a source of information -- for example, responding to a quotation from Richard Nixon on the subject of free trade with China by saying, "We all know Nixon was a liar and a cheat, so why should we believe anything he says?" Argumentum ad hominem also occurs when someone's arguments are discounted merely because they stand to benefit from the policy they advocate -- such as Bill Gates arguing against antitrust, rich people arguing for lower taxes, white people arguing against affirmative action, minorities arguing for affirmative action, etc. In all of these cases, the relevant question is not who makes the argument, but whether the argument is valid. It is always bad form to use the fallacy of argumentum ad hominem. But there are some cases when it is not really a fallacy, such as when one needs to evaluate the truth of factual statements (as opposed to lines of argument or statements of value) made by interested parties. If someone has an incentive to lie about something, then it would be naive to accept his statements about that subject without question. It is also possible to restate many ad hominem arguments so as to redirect them toward ideas rather than people, such as by replacing "My opponents are fascists" with "My opponents' arguments are fascist."
http://www.csun.edu/~dgw61315/fallacies.html#Argumentum ad hominem (bolding mine)

If the "Rosa Parks" (as an example) is an ad hom, what idea are we 'debunking' fallaciously by attacking the person and not the idea?
 
I am not using it incorrectly. See Gumboot's post above.

Gumboot's post does nothing to support your erroneous usage of the term ad hominem.



Yes, let's consider Gumboot's post, shall we?


While I bow to the decisions of my peers, I have to admit I'm somewhat disappointed with the results thus far.

Delusional people comparing themselves to key historical figures is a pretty mundane, boring, and non stundie-worthy event, IMHO.

The stundies, IMHO, are for mind numbing failures of basic logic and reason, for example asserting that a fact is a fact regardless of whether it is true or false, or that a fact can change depending on what people believe.

These are like cognitive short circuits. It's unfathomable how the creator of the stundie even arrived at the mental point where making the remark seemed sensible.

In contrast, comparing oneself to someone you should not be comparing yourself to is just plain old human arrogance. It's perfectly understandable how people come to this point of view. And it's a very common occurrence. People do this sort of thing all the time.

I think a good Stundie should stand on its own, entirely independent of the Stundee's views on 9/11. Imagine, for a moment, that Dylan Avery's view on 9/11 is correct, and the US government really is an evil entity taking over the world. Is his remark Stundie worthy? I don't think it is. I think it would be admirable, that he desired to follow the example of historic figures and make a stand against tyranny.

Thus the perceived stundie-ness of his remark is reliant on the fact that he is wrong about 9/11.

If we take the first Stundie winner; Lyte Trip, with his "see-saw" comment (see my signature), the story is very different.

Regardless of what hit the Pentagon, Lyte Trip's comment that his "see-saw analogy renders all need for calculations moot" is total nonsensical. It is absurd, utterly, and in direct defiance of centuries of science and mathematics.

Likewise, the current second place position, that facts can be wrong and still be facts, is utterly absurd, entirely independent of whether water bender's version of 9/11 is true or not.

Whether the towers were demolished with explosives or not, the idea that a demolition was carried out by highly motivated drug addicts is likewise unfathomably absurd.

Just my NZ$0.02

-Gumboot



A very good post, that makes his case in a reasonable maner. However, nowhere in the post does he refer to the nominated quote as an ad hom. He does discuss it's worthiness as a Stundie quote, based on his interpretation of what distinguishes a good nominee from a bad nominee. And regardless of wheter or not you agree with his position, this is simply his opinion.

On the basis of his argument, you can agree or disagree with his opinion, but there is nothing that makes his opinion (or yours) an absolute standard of Stundie-worthiness. A person could make a counter-argument based on a slightly different conception of what the Stundies are about, or based on a different interpretation of the nominated quote.

The Stundies are a rather open-ended concept, with no rigorous definition of what a Stundie-worthy post is (despite certain posters continued attempts to insist on such a definition). They are defined solely by those who choose to participate in them. If enough people agree with Gumboot, the Stundies will change, otherwise, they won't.

And ad homs have nothing to do with it.
 
William, the BBC for one disagrees with you



See the bolded bit - you are wrong. The Stundies are making fun of the argument not the Truther.

PS - thanks again for bumping the thread to encourage more people to vote. Come on you Facts! - "facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts".

This is all immaterial. The Stundies are not about making an argument or disproving that 9/11 was in "inside job". The Stundies are quotes from people who call themselves "Truthers" that are self-evidently irrational, ironic, or just plain wrong. They exist solely for our own amusement.
 
I think the full quote does a better job.
What is it with you and stubbornly defending untenable positions (all the while declaring victory)?

The Stundies are not personal attacks standing in for arguments. They are not making any attempt whatsoever to further an argument. They are not making any attempt whatsoever to weaken an opposing argument. They are not ad hominems. Give it up. Find a more accurate and defendable classification.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom