Stundie Finals For May - Vote Now!

May Finalists

  • DYA - Shows his true colours.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • YBZ - "...a report that says the twin towers were hollow."

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • PAD - "Everyone agrees that the impact itself had no real affect on the structure."

    Votes: 6 4.9%
  • SCG - Atta, the "crazed, cocained-up, drug-smuggling" federal agent.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • LTW - "Like Rosa Parks, Simon Wiesenthal, Winston Churchill, and Nelson Mandela..."

    Votes: 25 20.3%
  • DRG - Explosives causing steel to melt.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • DrJ - Big rocks and "Hokie stone" facades.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • DJJ - Most uses of 'truth' in a nonsensical post.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • ROD - "judy wood rocks"

    Votes: 4 3.3%
  • PtG - Operation: Junkie.

    Votes: 5 4.1%
  • KvB - Kevin goes on location.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • DgH - "Because WE ARE IGNORANT OF 911 FACTS, WE DEMAND PROOF."

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • SFT - On why you don't have to pay income tax unless you are a PERSON.

    Votes: 2 1.6%
  • MJD - [i]p, q, therefore r[/i] as an argument for the demolition of WTC 7.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • FRL - On why we have to go to war occasionally.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • MaK - "You need a pointy bit on the front. No pointy bit = no entry."

    Votes: 15 12.2%
  • 28K - The "[sic] wooden poll" experiment.

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • wtb - "facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts."

    Votes: 20 16.3%
  • LUC - On the limited application of the scientific method.

    Votes: 8 6.5%
  • CAP - COnfuses a volcanic eruption with a nuclear weapons test.

    Votes: 4 3.3%

  • Total voters
    123
  • Poll closed .
Seriously, I don't get why the "Rosa parks" one gets so many votes.

I had cast my vote on "On the limited application of the scientific method."

Damn you all! <sulk>
I suspect it gets so may votes not because it is especialy Stundie-worth but because of the quality of Redtail's TLA-nominated post commenting on it.
I don't either. I know it illustrates a painful amount of vaingloriousness on the part of troofers, but it's really more disgusting than funny. The Stundies should shoot for funny more than anything else, I feel.

For what it's worth Belz..., I agree with you (and my vote went the same way).

To outline my thoughts on why the "Rosa Parks" nomination was included in the final: Bizarre and outlandish statements do belong in the Stundies, and this would have to be one of the most extravagent and arrogant statements yet made by a truther. No, it isn't as funny as some of the other nominations, but there is a part of me behind the rage and disgust that just says, "He can't really think that, can he?"

No, it isn't laugh out loud funny, but once the rage settles it is at least amusing to a degree that the LTW crew think that they are really that important.

But then again, the way the votes turn out constantly surprises me. For example, I thought the DRG quote from a few months ago was a shoo in for either win, place or show. But it barely made a blip on the radar.

I guess I'm just too much of a geek sometimes! :p

Probably because it is the one that has been the most contested as a nomination for the finals so far. However, I outlined my reasons for disputing the nomination at...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2655046#post2655046

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2663616#post2663616

It is probably one of the poorest nominations to date. Ironically I got a June nomination for contesting it!

It certainly is curious that you refuse to reply to my rather lengthy post where I outline the reasons that the finalists you are disputing made it through then.

I think Chipmunk Stew said it best though:

If that were the case, then the nominations that you previously contested should have received a large share of votes.

How many votes did DRG's vertical energy receive, William?

Correlation =/= Causation

Emphasis mine.
 
I'm tempted to say "projection", but that's usually ascribing your own bad faults to others while ignoring them in yourself. I'm not sure if there's a word for thinking everyone is just like you though - except maybe "provincial", but that doesn't quite fit either.

Let's just stick with "dumb".


P.S., OMG! I edited out some bits of your post! Please don't report me!!!! :rolleyes:
OMG, you improved my post! I will report that, you fiend. Projection sounds good, but I forgot what was being projected. Dumb could fit.
 
Seriously, I don't get why the "Rosa parks" one gets so many votes.

I had cast my vote on "On the limited application of the scientific method."

Damn you all! <sulk>

Great minds think alike!

The "Rosa Parks" one isn't so much funny as it is just plain insulting to people who have actually stood up for their beliefs.

The "scientific method" is just hilarious!
 
Great minds think alike!

The "Rosa Parks" one isn't so much funny as it is just plain insulting to people who have actually stood up for their beliefs.

The "scientific method" is just hilarious!

Garnos, however wrong they may be they are at least standing up for their beliefs, I don't think you can accuse them of not truly believing in their cause so I am surprised at that comment.

However, addressing the accusation of arrogance (as opposed to their argument) that seems to be the common problem...

The quote singles out certain characteristics of Rosa Parks etc such as being outspoken and not veering from their chosen path. Paraphrasing John Lennon, it doesn't say they are greater or better than these people. In fact in many ways it has the sound of a rallying call or an aspiration not to veer from the path.

As an example, if I was to say "Like Charles Dickens I will be a great writer" am I saying that I am as great or better or is it an aspiration?

The interpretation of the statement used for the nomination is very much based upon pre-conceived notions of the people so the nomination is a straight ad hominem attack. It is based upon disliking these people for their beliefs and not based on any specific argument.
 
Last edited:
The interpretation of the statement used for the nomination is very much based upon pre-conceived notions of the people so the nomination is a straight ad hominem attack. It is based upon disliking these people for their beliefs and not based on any specific argument.

Ugh...I'm going to say this as simply as I can.

The nomination was not based upon 'pre-conceived notions' of the LTW crew, it was based upon a basic knowledge of the LTW crew and a knowledge and understanding of their history.

No one here is saying, "Dylan Avery is arrogant and therefore 9/11 was not an inside job."

What is being said is, "Dylan Avery (and the LTW crew) are demonstrably wrong about 9/11 being an inside job. They have often and repeatedly been told this, and had explained to them exactly why they are incorrect and where the 'documentary' Loose Change was incorrect, as well as why other claims made by conspiracy fantasists are incorrect. Despite all this, they not only continue to profit from the tragedy that was 9/11, but they are comparing themselves to figures who stood against real hardships and fought for what they believed in, as opposed to some non-existant NWO boogeyman. That is disgusting and arrogant of them...they can't really believe that they can compare themselves to those historical figures, can they?

I assume that clears matters up for you then?
 
Garnos, however wrong they may be they are at least standing up for their beliefs, I don't think you can accuse them of not truly believing in their cause so I am surprised at that comment.

I think most of the "followers" truly believe in their cause. Whether this is true of the leaders is questionable - some seem to be more interested in dollar signs.

As for "standing up for their beliefs" - that depends how you define "standing up for".

However, addressing the accusation of arrogance (as opposed to their argument) that seems to be the common problem...

Their arguments have been addressed many times.

The quote singles out certain characteristics of Rosa Parks etc such as being outspoken and not veering from their chosen path. Paraphrasing John Lennon, it doesn't say they are greater or better than these people. In fact in many ways it has the sound of a rallying call or an aspiration not to veer from the path.

As an example, if I was to say "Like Charles Dickens I will be a great writer" am I saying that I am as great or better or is it an aspiration?

An interesting analogy, but I think it lacks one thing: emotion.

Rosa Parks, Simon Wiesenthal, Winston Churchill and Nelson Mandela are all people who's names invoke great emotion. In my opinion, the Loose Change Blog post was a load of rhetoric with the message: "follow us, and you will be like these people".

The interpretation of the statement used for the nomination is very much based upon pre-conceived notions of the people so the nomination is a straight ad hominem attack. It is based upon disliking these people for their beliefs and not based on any specific argument.

I've been thinking this one over for the last fifteen minutes and I find that I somewhat agree with you on this one.

The post certainly doesn't address a specific argument; I don't think anyone ever claimed that it did.

The question of ad-hominem is tricky, and there are two ways of looking at it. If the post is nominated because of what we (skeptics) see as being the clearly delusional remarks of Louder Than Words, that would definitely be ad-hom ("hey guys, look how delusional they are!")

On the other hand, if you believe LTW are exploiting the movement, the post could be used as an example of LTW deliberately misleading their followers through use of emotionally charged rhetoric.

My head hurts.
 
Last edited:
Garnos, however wrong they may be they are at least standing up for their beliefs, I don't think you can accuse them of not truly believing in their cause so I am surprised at that comment.

However, addressing the accusation of arrogance (as opposed to their argument) that seems to be the common problem...

The quote singles out certain characteristics of Rosa Parks etc such as being outspoken and not veering from their chosen path. Paraphrasing John Lennon, it doesn't say they are greater or better than these people. In fact in many ways it has the sound of a rallying call or an aspiration not to veer from the path.

As an example, if I was to say "Like Charles Dickens I will be a great writer" am I saying that I am as great or better or is it an aspiration?

The interpretation of the statement used for the nomination is very much based upon pre-conceived notions of the people so the nomination is a straight ad hominem attack. It is based upon disliking these people for their beliefs and not based on any specific argument.
It is not an ad hominem logical fallacy because it is not being used as part of an argument, as a counter-argument, in a debate, or even in a discussion.

Your continued attempts to paint the Stundies as being something they are not is, however, a strawman logical fallacy. And your continued ignoring of answers and critiques against your claims is intellectual dishonesty.
 
It is not an ad hominem logical fallacy because it is not being used as part of an argument, as a counter-argument, in a debate, or even in a discussion.

Your continued attempts to paint the Stundies as being something they are not is, however, a strawman logical fallacy. And your continued ignoring of answers and critiques against your claims is intellectual dishonesty.

I'll continue with my devil's advocate approach for a moment...

The Stundies are supposed to be about making fun of the truthers arguments, rather than the thruthers themselves, correct?

As you say, the Rosa Parks quote is not addressing an argument of any kind, so I interpret it as essentially stating, "hey look at these delusional/arrogant idiots - they think they're like Nelson Mandela", which is making fun of the truther, rather than an argument.
 
I'll continue with my devil's advocate approach for a moment...

The Stundies are supposed to be about making fun of the truthers arguments, rather than the thruthers themselves, correct?

As you say, the Rosa Parks quote is not addressing an argument of any kind, so I interpret it as essentially stating, "hey look at these delusional/arrogant idiots - they think they're like Nelson Mandela", which is making fun of the truther, rather than an argument.
Whether they are focusing on the truther, or their argument is moot. The Stundies are essentially a way of going:
24818BP~The-Simpsons-Nelson-Haha-Posters.jpg


Since no one is claiming their arguments, claims, etc are false because they (the person) has been nominated for a Stundie or they (the argument) has been nominated, no ad hom is occurring.
 
Whether they are focusing on the truther, or their argument is moot. The Stundies are essentially a way of going:
[qimg]http://imagecache2.allposters.com/images/pic/ATA/24818BP~The-Simpsons-Nelson-Haha-Posters.jpg[/qimg]

Since no one is claiming their arguments, claims, etc are false because they (the person) has been nominated for a Stundie or they (the argument) has been nominated, no ad hom is occurring.

I understand and agree with this. My concern was that Teh Stundies, as I understand it, are supposed to be about us going "ha ha" at their arguments/reasoning etc, rather than at them as people.

The Rosa Parks nomination was about how disgusting and arrogant that statement was, hence it's Stundie status being questionable. In any case - I certainly wasn't laughing at them as much as I was trying not to vomit.
 
I'll continue with my devil's advocate approach for a moment...

The Stundies are supposed to be about making fun of the truthers arguments, rather than the thruthers themselves, correct?

As you say, the Rosa Parks quote is not addressing an argument of any kind, so I interpret it as essentially stating, "hey look at these delusional/arrogant idiots - they think they're like Nelson Mandela", which is making fun of the truther, rather than an argument.

Not exactly. They aren't considered delusional or arrogant just because they compared themselves to Nelson Mandela, Rosa Parks, et al. Anyone with a knowledge of the LTW crew prior to this statement already knew that they were arrogant and delusional.

This quote did not occur in a vacuum.

And to echo Arkan - The Stundies aren't about arguing with truthers, they're about pointing out illogical, absurd, ironic (and so on) arguments, claims, statements, experiments, etc.

As I said previously:

Mobyseven said:
No one here is saying, "Dylan Avery is arrogant and therefore 9/11 was not an inside job."

What is being said is, "Dylan Avery (and the LTW crew) are demonstrably wrong about 9/11 being an inside job. They have often and repeatedly been told this, and had explained to them exactly why they are incorrect and where the 'documentary' Loose Change was incorrect, as well as why other claims made by conspiracy fantasists are incorrect. Despite all this, they not only continue to profit from the tragedy that was 9/11, but they are comparing themselves to figures who stood against real hardships and fought for what they believed in, as opposed to some non-existant NWO boogeyman. That is disgusting and arrogant of them...they can't really believe that they can compare themselves to those historical figures, can they?"

See how important and relevant the history of the group is?
 
I understand and agree with this. My concern was that Teh Stundies, as I understand it, are supposed to be about us going "ha ha" at their arguments/reasoning etc, rather than at them as people.

The Rosa Parks nomination was about how disgusting and arrogant that statement was, hence it's Stundie status being questionable. In any case - I certainly wasn't laughing at them as much as I was trying not to vomit.

I would say that LTW claim that they are like the figures they mention shows faulty reasoning on their part, as well as unreserved arrogance. My first reaction was rage, then disgust, then ragust (a new word I made up to describe the feeling) and then bemusement that they couldn't really think that they were like those people, could they?

Yes, it ultimately reflects poorly on the LTW crew. But only because of the claim that they made.
 
While I bow to the decisions of my peers, I have to admit I'm somewhat disappointed with the results thus far.

Delusional people comparing themselves to key historical figures is a pretty mundane, boring, and non stundie-worthy event, IMHO.

The stundies, IMHO, are for mind numbing failures of basic logic and reason, for example asserting that a fact is a fact regardless of whether it is true or false, or that a fact can change depending on what people believe.

These are like cognitive short circuits. It's unfathomable how the creator of the stundie even arrived at the mental point where making the remark seemed sensible.

In contrast, comparing oneself to someone you should not be comparing yourself to is just plain old human arrogance. It's perfectly understandable how people come to this point of view. And it's a very common occurrence. People do this sort of thing all the time.

I think a good Stundie should stand on its own, entirely independent of the Stundee's views on 9/11. Imagine, for a moment, that Dylan Avery's view on 9/11 is correct, and the US government really is an evil entity taking over the world. Is his remark Stundie worthy? I don't think it is. I think it would be admirable, that he desired to follow the example of historic figures and make a stand against tyranny.

Thus the perceived stundie-ness of his remark is reliant on the fact that he is wrong about 9/11.

If we take the first Stundie winner; Lyte Trip, with his "see-saw" comment (see my signature), the story is very different.

Regardless of what hit the Pentagon, Lyte Trip's comment that his "see-saw analogy renders all need for calculations moot" is total nonsensical. It is absurd, utterly, and in direct defiance of centuries of science and mathematics.

Likewise, the current second place position, that facts can be wrong and still be facts, is utterly absurd, entirely independent of whether water bender's version of 9/11 is true or not.

Whether the towers were demolished with explosives or not, the idea that a demolition was carried out by highly motivated drug addicts is likewise unfathomably absurd.

Just my NZ$0.02

-Gumboot
 
Although I'm glad to see one of my nominations doing so well I am more partial to DRG's ideas about how controlled demolitions work.
 
Bad epistemology ("facts can be wrong...") vs. bad sociology ("...like Rosa Parks...")? Not a dilemma pour moi. In my version of Stundieland, they both go down to defeat against a quote which, though wrong enough in itself, derives most of its Stundieworthiness from lending itself to sophomoric sexual double-entendre interpretation. [Beavis]"He said 'pointy bits' and 'penetration.' Heh-heh heh heh heh-heh."[/Beavis]

Which is currently in third place, so apparently I'm not alone in this viewpoint. It's a humor contest, after all.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
2. The bumps keep the stupidity of the Stundies in view for lurkers and decent forum members.

As a lurker and a decent member of the forum, I thank you for allowing me to get in on the Stundie voting. I might have missed the fun if it wasn't bumped.

It is a good reflection on the hardcore of this forum.

I believe hardcore is against the rules of the forum. However, I'd be glad to look at any instances of it you may find.


(Uh-oh. I split the quote and assigned a different meaning than what was intended! I'm going to hell for sure!)

Up to 100 votes so far...interesting that only one finalist has not received a single vote yet...more interesting to see which finalist!

Although I was tempted to vote for the delightful doctor, I could nat figure out WTF she was talking about. To me, it's funnier if the post has some grounding in reality. This was just some absurdist rant that could just as well be talking about cream pies and steamrollers.

Seriously, I don't get why the "Rosa parks" one gets so many votes.

I had cast my vote on "On the limited application of the scientific method."

Damn you all! <sulk>

Just like Belz... and qarnos, I voted for the scientific method post. It really sums up the whole troofer experience: Science is only worthwhile if it agrees with my delusions.
 
Although I was tempted to vote for the delightful doctor, I could not figure out WTF she was talking about. To me, it's funnier if the post has some grounding in reality. This was just some absurdist rant that could just as well be talking about cream pies and steamrollers.



In retrospect, I think the Judy Wood quote relies a bit too much on the context to really get it's full effect. The quote, combined with the pictures she's discussing, leads one to realize she's pretty much just seeing things in her own mind, rather than in the photos she claims to be analysing. That, combined with the rest of her rantings, and the repetition of the same stock phrases, like some sort of scientific Tourettes's syndrome, adds up to a whole package of Stundie-level insanity. But that's all a bit too much to get just from the one quote.

It may be Judy Wood has transcended mere Stundieisms, and has become something more powerful insane than we can possibly imagine....
 
Bad epistemology ("facts can be wrong...") vs. bad sociology ("...like Rosa Parks...")? Not a dilemma pour moi. In my version of Stundieland, they both go down to defeat against a quote which, though wrong enough in itself, derives most of its Stundieworthiness from lending itself to sophomoric sexual double-entendre interpretation. [Beavis]"He said 'pointy bits' and 'penetration.' Heh-heh heh heh heh-heh."[/Beavis]

Which is currently in third place, so apparently I'm not alone in this viewpoint. It's a humor contest, after all.

Respectfully,
Myriad

I agree with Myriad here - I feel that including the "Rosa Parks" quote in the finals was not a mistake...however at no point did I think it would actually win.

To me, the confusing thing is why this nomination received so many votes...I for one mark myself among the ranks of qarnos and Belz... who voted for LUCAS (something I find more 'Stundie-worthy' myself).

This doesn't mean I think that I was incorrect for including the LTW quote, I stand by my reasons for including it, and I will endeavour to take all of the comments posted here into account - especially Gumboot's comment that, "These are like cognitive short circuits. It's unfathomable how the creator of the stundie even arrived at the mental point where making the remark seemed sensible."

However, I also have to take the voting into account, and it seems that many people would disagree with me over what the Stundiest finalist was...it does put me in somewhat of a dilemma. Be assured that next month I'll have all of the comments made this month in mind when I sort out the finalists.

But I agree that I'm a little bit curious as to this month's voting. Call me a slightly disappointed tyrant, I suppose.

Mobyseven

Slightly disappointed Democratically Elected Tyrant
​
 
To me, the confusing thing is why this nomination received so many votes...I for one mark myself among the ranks of qarnos and Belz... who voted for LUCAS (something I find more 'Stundie-worthy' myself).



I think it may be a sign of our suppressed outrage at the twoofers outrageous nonsense becoming slightly less supressed.

The Stundies started as an effort to find some humour in the rantings of the twoofers, and in that it has been successful, but every now and then, we remember what exactly it is that these people are promoting, and our legitimate disgust with their message surfaces.

The same thing has shown up in the comic strip thread. 95% fun and jokes, but with a few reminders of the real tradgedy that is at the heart of all 9/11 discussions.

In other words, just being human. Move along, nothing to see here :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom