Stundie Finals For May - Vote Now!

May Finalists

  • DYA - Shows his true colours.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • YBZ - "...a report that says the twin towers were hollow."

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • PAD - "Everyone agrees that the impact itself had no real affect on the structure."

    Votes: 6 4.9%
  • SCG - Atta, the "crazed, cocained-up, drug-smuggling" federal agent.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • LTW - "Like Rosa Parks, Simon Wiesenthal, Winston Churchill, and Nelson Mandela..."

    Votes: 25 20.3%
  • DRG - Explosives causing steel to melt.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • DrJ - Big rocks and "Hokie stone" facades.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • DJJ - Most uses of 'truth' in a nonsensical post.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • ROD - "judy wood rocks"

    Votes: 4 3.3%
  • PtG - Operation: Junkie.

    Votes: 5 4.1%
  • KvB - Kevin goes on location.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • DgH - "Because WE ARE IGNORANT OF 911 FACTS, WE DEMAND PROOF."

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • SFT - On why you don't have to pay income tax unless you are a PERSON.

    Votes: 2 1.6%
  • MJD - [i]p, q, therefore r[/i] as an argument for the demolition of WTC 7.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • FRL - On why we have to go to war occasionally.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • MaK - "You need a pointy bit on the front. No pointy bit = no entry."

    Votes: 15 12.2%
  • 28K - The "[sic] wooden poll" experiment.

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • wtb - "facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts."

    Votes: 20 16.3%
  • LUC - On the limited application of the scientific method.

    Votes: 8 6.5%
  • CAP - COnfuses a volcanic eruption with a nuclear weapons test.

    Votes: 4 3.3%

  • Total voters
    123
  • Poll closed .
What I find amusing is that you are all making a very good argument for this thread to at least go into the Humour Forum if not the Flame Wars or AAH, and you just don't see it!

I am merely here to provide the rope with which you are willingly hanging yourself.
 
What I find amusing is that you are all making a very good argument for this thread to at least go into the Humour Forum if not the Flame Wars or AAH, and you just don't see it!

I am merely here to provide the rope with which you are willingly hanging yourself.
Stop trying to shift the goalposts. If the "Rosa Parks" (as an example) is an ad hom, what idea are we 'debunking' fallaciously by attacking the person and not the idea?
 
What I find amusing is that you are all making a very good argument for this thread to at least go into the Humour Forum if not the Flame Wars or AAH, and you just don't see it!

I am merely here to provide the rope with which you are willingly hanging yourself.
Gee whiz, you sure pulled a fast one over on us, you clever clever boy! :rolleyes:

Have you figured out what an ad hominem is, yet?
 
This is all immaterial. The Stundies are not about making an argument or disproving that 9/11 was in "inside job". The Stundies are quotes from people who call themselves "Truthers" that are self-evidently irrational, ironic, or just plain wrong. They exist solely for our own amusement.

Sorry, I'm missing your point. I said "The Stundies are making fun of the argument not the Truther". We don't generally don't even need to provide any context because, as you say, "[they] are self-evidently irrational, ironic, or just plain wrong".

I think we may well be agreeing with each other but misunderstanding each other (the Stundies are not ad hom)?
 
Last edited:
Yes, let's consider Gumboot's post, shall we?






A very good post, that makes his case in a reasonable maner. However, nowhere in the post does he refer to the nominated quote as an ad hom. He does discuss it's worthiness as a Stundie quote, based on his interpretation of what distinguishes a good nominee from a bad nominee. And regardless of wheter or not you agree with his position, this is simply his opinion.

On the basis of his argument, you can agree or disagree with his opinion, but there is nothing that makes his opinion (or yours) an absolute standard of Stundie-worthiness. A person could make a counter-argument based on a slightly different conception of what the Stundies are about, or based on a different interpretation of the nominated quote.

The Stundies are a rather open-ended concept, with no rigorous definition of what a Stundie-worthy post is (despite certain posters continued attempts to insist on such a definition). They are defined solely by those who choose to participate in them. If enough people agree with Gumboot, the Stundies will change, otherwise, they won't.

And ad homs have nothing to do with it.

Exactly. I happen to agree with Gumboot's opinion of what should be considered "Stundie-worthy" and what shouldn't, but the fact is there are no stated rules that disqualify the nomination in question. Therefore that nomination cannot be declared illegitimate without a change in the rules first. William has continually argued for the disqualification of certain Stundie nominations based entirely on his own rules and standards which exist nowhere outside of his own mind.
 
What I find amusing is that you are all making a very good argument for this thread to at least go into the Humour Forum if not the Flame Wars or AAH, and you just don't see it!

I am merely here to provide the rope with which you are willingly hanging yourself.

The "comic strip a conspiracy" thread was at one time moved by the mods to Humor based on its content, only to be moved back to Conspiracy Theories after much protest that the thread was unique to the spirit of the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum. Therefore we have precedent for its retention and your post-hoc rationalization clever little scheme is unlikely to come true. But feel free to advocate for its relocation in the Management forum.
 
Sorry, I'm missing your point. I said "The Stundies are making fun of the argument not the Truther". We don't generally don't even need to provide any context because, as you say, "[they] are self-evidently irrational, ironic, or just plain wrong".

I think we may well be agreeing with each other but misunderstanding each other (the Stundies are not ad hom)?

Well, some of the Stundie nominations, like the one with Troofers comparing themselves to Rosa Parks et al., imply a moral fault on the part of Truthers which ultimately begs the question that 9/11 Troof is intrinsically nonsense. Thus merely claiming (or insinuating) that they are full of themselves can be construed as ad hom, since the conclusion is based on largely subjective criteria. But the purpose of the Stundies is not to make sound arguments against the Truth movement as a whole, so any claim of logical fallacies categorically do not apply to the Stundies ipso facto.
 
What I find amusing is that you are all making a very good argument for this thread to at least go into the Humour Forum if not the Flame Wars or AAH, and you just don't see it!

I am merely here to provide the rope with which you are willingly hanging yourself.
Really? So why haven't you moved them there yet?
 
What I find amusing is that you are all making a very good argument for this thread to at least go into the Humour Forum if not the Flame Wars or AAH, and you just don't see it!

I am merely here to provide the rope with which you are willingly hanging yourself.

Why not just place MobySeven on ignore, select the option to hide all posts created by members on your ignore list (thus never seeing the Stundies ever again, as he compiles them), and be on your merry way?
 
Why not just place MobySeven on ignore, select the option to hide all posts created by members on your ignore list (thus never seeing the Stundies ever again, as he compiles them), and be on your merry way?
Jonny, you chased DJJ away. Now you want to chase Billy away. You don't want me to have anyone to play with, do you?
 
What I find amusing is that you are all making a very good argument for this thread to at least go into the Humour Forum if not the Flame Wars or AAH, and you just don't see it!

I am merely here to provide the rope with which you are willingly hanging yourself.



Oh, how the mighty have fallen!

So now your big complaint is that the thread is in the wrong sub-forum? If we've made such a good argument, submit it to the mods, and see if they move it.

And how exactly would moving the thread constitute us "willingly hanging ourselves"? What the heck does that even mean? Would moving the thread suddenly invalidate all the other efforts people have put into debunking 9/11 CT BS? If not, it's nothing more than housekeeping, and boring housekeeping at that!

As for your contention that AAH or Flamewars might be better, well, the purpose of AAH is:

The dumping ground for bickering and irrelevance! Generally these threads contain posts that are at best borderline inappropriate. Moved here they can at least serve some purpose: to help illustrate what is not appropriate for the JREF Forum.



As quite a few posts and threads from the CT forum have already been moved there, we must assume that, up until now, the mods haven't agreed with your suggestion to move the Stundies there.

The Flame Wars sub-forum has a less-well defined purpose, but as there is nothing in the Stundies themselves that could be classes as "flames" (except by those with notoriously thin skins), and with virtually no responses from the nominees themselves, it's hard to see how they could be described as "Wars". As such, the thread is almost certainly not Flame Wars material.

You could make a case for humour, but as was pointed out by others, as the topic is particularly CT humour, there is sufficient overlap that the choice of sub-forum is not automatically clear. And, once again, for more than three months now, the mods have seen fit to leave it where it is, even though other threads have been moved. So again, we must conclude that they are largely confortable with the current classification.
 
Oh, how the mighty have fallen!

So now your big complaint is that the thread is in the wrong sub-forum? If we've made such a good argument, submit it to the mods, and see if they move it.

And how exactly would moving the thread constitute us "willingly hanging ourselves"? What the heck does that even mean? Would moving the thread suddenly invalidate all the other efforts people have put into debunking 9/11 CT BS? If not, it's nothing more than housekeeping, and boring housekeeping at that!

As for your contention that AAH or Flamewars might be better, well, the purpose of AAH is:





As quite a few posts and threads from the CT forum have already been moved there, we must assume that, up until now, the mods haven't agreed with your suggestion to move the Stundies there.

The Flame Wars sub-forum has a less-well defined purpose, but as there is nothing in the Stundies themselves that could be classes as "flames" (except by those with notoriously thin skins), and with virtually no responses from the nominees themselves, it's hard to see how they could be described as "Wars". As such, the thread is almost certainly not Flame Wars material.

You could make a case for humour, but as was pointed out by others, as the topic is particularly CT humour, there is sufficient overlap that the choice of sub-forum is not automatically clear. And, once again, for more than three months now, the mods have seen fit to leave it where it is, even though other threads have been moved. So again, we must conclude that they are largely confortable with the current classification.
But Billy withdrew his support for the mods, so they have to do what he wants now, in order to regain his respect! Otherwise, he's going to hold his breath until the cross on his avatar turns blue!
 
But Billy withdrew his support for the mods, so they have to do what he wants now, in order to regain his respect! Otherwise, he's going to hold his breath until the cross on his avatar turns blue!



Oh, darn! I forgot about the lack of support! Now who will do all the whining and carping?

Oh, we are forsaken!




Wait. He's still whining. What was withdrawing his support supposed to entail, again?
 
Jonny, you chased DJJ away. Now you want to chase Billy away. You don't want me to have anyone to play with, do you?

Hey, it's not my fault DJJ couldn't control himself sufficiently to not get banned. To be honest, I'm surprised he lasted as long as he did. :)
 
Exactly. I happen to agree with Gumboot's opinion of what should be considered "Stundie-worthy" and what shouldn't, but the fact is there are no stated rules that disqualify the nomination in question. Therefore that nomination cannot be declared illegitimate without a change in the rules first. William has continually argued for the disqualification of certain Stundie nominations based entirely on his own rules and standards which exist nowhere outside of his own mind.

I also (mostly) agree with Gumboot.

The quote does not break any rules, and it does display an incredible level of arrogance and irony. I do not believe (still) that in any way shape or form is it not "Stundie-worthy".

However, given the benefit of 20-20 hindsight, I can see that it is possible many of the votes for it were cast out of instinctual rage rather than because people truly believed the quote to be the best of the best.

In future I shall definately consider what the ultimate implications of any quotes such as that one (shall we call them, 'rage inspiring'?) being placed into the finals. The best I can otherwise do is just to say that if when reading the Stundie finalists you feel overcome by rage, stop before you vote and drink a cup of tea. Or throw one against the wall.

Either way, it'll calm you down.
 
Yes, let's consider Gumboot's post, shall we?

<GUMBOOT'S POST>

A very good post, that makes his case in a reasonable maner. However, nowhere in the post does he refer to the nominated quote as an ad hom. He does discuss it's worthiness as a Stundie quote, based on his interpretation of what distinguishes a good nominee from a bad nominee. And regardless of wheter or not you agree with his position, this is simply his opinion.

On the basis of his argument, you can agree or disagree with his opinion, but there is nothing that makes his opinion (or yours) an absolute standard of Stundie-worthiness. A person could make a counter-argument based on a slightly different conception of what the Stundies are about, or based on a different interpretation of the nominated quote.

The Stundies are a rather open-ended concept, with no rigorous definition of what a Stundie-worthy post is (despite certain posters continued attempts to insist on such a definition). They are defined solely by those who choose to participate in them. If enough people agree with Gumboot, the Stundies will change, otherwise, they won't.

And ad homs have nothing to do with it.

Exactly. I happen to agree with Gumboot's opinion of what should be considered "Stundie-worthy" and what shouldn't, but the fact is there are no stated rules that disqualify the nomination in question. Therefore that nomination cannot be declared illegitimate without a change in the rules first. William has continually argued for the disqualification of certain Stundie nominations based entirely on his own rules and standards which exist nowhere outside of his own mind.

I also (mostly) agree with Gumboot.

The quote does not break any rules, and it does display an incredible level of arrogance and irony. I do not believe (still) that in any way shape or form is it not "Stundie-worthy".

However, given the benefit of 20-20 hindsight, I can see that it is possible many of the votes for it were cast out of instinctual rage rather than because people truly believed the quote to be the best of the best.

In future I shall definately consider what the ultimate implications of any quotes such as that one (shall we call them, 'rage inspiring'?) being placed into the finals. The best I can otherwise do is just to say that if when reading the Stundie finalists you feel overcome by rage, stop before you vote and drink a cup of tea. Or throw one against the wall.

Either way, it'll calm you down.




William Rea, please pay attention. I do not believe the Stundie in question is an Ad Hom. I have never stated that it is an Ad Hom. My comments were merely my expression of what I felt the spirit of the Stundies should be, and how I felt this particular nomination did not reflect that nomination. You believe all Stundies are inappropriate and unacceptable. Ergo, WE ARE NOT IN AGREEMENT. Do not try to use my posts to prop up your own weak stuttering arguments. No one is fooled.

I was expressing MY OPINION. Just as with your own opinion, my opinion carries no special weight, and has no special value. I was not objecting to the presence of said stundie in the nominations, per se. It did not breach the rules of the Stundies. Furthermore I am a great believer in democracy, and thus the large number of votes this nomination has received completely vindicates its nomination.

Please stop with your ridiculous and unhealthy obsession.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom