• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Split Thread Students should be punished for protesting

Lukraak_Sisser said:
Yes, how dare students protest in a way that might be noticed.
First of all they should tow the government line and secondly, IF they protest they should only do so by appointment somewhere out of the way where they don't bother other people. (and still be removed from the university of course)
Click to expand...
Do you oppose sanctions and penalties for students who violate college code of conduct?
 
Last edited:
Carrot Flower King said:
Nice to know that I should have been locked up/fined/whatever for stuff like participating in an occupation of university buildings as part of a protest action agin certain government policies affecting universities back in the '70s.

How about picketing and blockading the nearest branch of Barclay's Bank over their role in supporting appartheid South Africa?

Participating in various other mass demonstrations which most definitely caused some disruption to our capital city, both when a student (university and nursing) and at other times?

Where are lines being drawn over non-violent, but disruptive, protest in a supposedly liberal democrtatic society?
Click to expand...
What's wrong with punishing students for violating school code of conduct?

What's wrong with consequences for illegals acts of civil disobedience?
 
Last edited:
Hercules56 said:
Do YOU oppose schools punishing students for violating the rules?
Click to expand...
Not if they do it even handedly. In the case of Gaza protests, pro - Palestine protestors hav had to suffer way more at the hands of their zionist fellow studenta and their henchmen than the other way around, including threats and bodily harm after being targeted.
But you oppose Jewish students suffering any consequences for that.
Did you hand out any pagers yourself?
 
The Great Zaganza said:
Not if they do it even handedly. In the case of Gaza protests, pro - Palestine protestors hav had to suffer way more at the hands of their zionist fellow studenta and their henchmen than the other way around, including threats and bodily harm after being targeted.
But you oppose Jewish students suffering any consequences for that.
Did you hand out any pagers yourself?
Click to expand...
Liar. I fully support ALL students who break the rules being treated equally, regardless of agenda.

Stop lying about my beliefs and comments.

You think JUST because I am a Jew, I support bigoted pro-Jewish policies, even though I am one of the biggest critics of Israel in this forum.
 
Last edited:
But only pro Palestine protesters were punished, so your one-sided demands for punishment are revealing.
We know of direct contacts between Jewish students and violent zionist groups targeting pro Palestinian students, and that is being okayed. i think that deserves much more outrage and punishment than making some students feel uncomfortable for being reminded of the genocide being done in their name
 
Last edited:
The Great Zaganza said:
But only pro Palestine protesters were punished, so your one-sided demands for punishment are revealing.
We know of direct contacts between Jewish students and violent zionist groups targeting pro Palestinian students, and that is being okayed m i think that deserves much more outrage and punishment than making some students feel uncomfortable for being reminded of the genocide being done in their name
Click to expand...
Are you suggesting no anti-Palestine protestors who engaged in violent acts or acts which violated school policy have been punished?

Got any evidence?
 
Hercules56 said:
Are you suggesting no anti-Palestine protestors who engaged in violent acts or acts which violated school policy have been punished?

Got any evidence?
Click to expand...


Got any evidence they were?

Otherwise, you're just asking someone to prove a negative.


-
 
Last edited:
AmyStrange said:
Got any evidence they were?

Otherwise, you're just asking someone to prove a negative.


-
Click to expand...
Its his claim, not mine.

I have no reason to believe anti-Palestine protestors are treated any better or worse.

Perhaps our friend will support his claim.
 
The Great Zaganza said:
But only pro Palestine protesters were punished, so your one-sided demands for punishment are revealing.
We know of direct contacts between Jewish students and violent zionist groups targeting pro Palestinian students, and that is being okayed.....
Click to expand...
Prove it.
 
The Great Zaganza said:
Not if they do it even handedly. In the case of Gaza protests, pro - Palestine protestors hav had to suffer way more at the hands of their zionist fellow studenta and their henchmen than the other way around, including threats and bodily harm after being targeted...
Click to expand...
Evidence of a double standard? Got any?
 
Hercules56 said:
Its his claim, not mine.

I have no reason to believe anti-Palestine protestors are treated any better or worse.

Perhaps our friend will support his claim.
Click to expand...


How can they prove a negative? How exactly would that work anyway?


-
 
Last edited:
The Great Zaganza said:
It was sanctioned by the President, so not civil disobedience, just a coup attempt
Click to expand...
As is this one, except that this time the President withdrew $400 million in grants to the university unless they stomped on the necks of student protesters. Which they did.

And as usual, the forum’s resident DINO comes out in support of MAGA totalitarianism.
 
EHocking said:
As is this one, except that this time the President withdrew $400 million in grants to the university unless they stomped on the necks of student protesters. Which they did.

And as usual, the forum’s resident DINO comes out in support of MAGA totalitarianism.
Click to expand...
You're saying students should not be punished for harassment, destruction of property, disrupting classes and club activities, vandalism, and blocking students from accessing campus property based on assumed political or religious affiliation? Why not?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom