StopSylviaBrowne: Shawn Hornbeck Reading

I noticed last night that the thread had been deleted, and the two people who had been expressing the skeptical viewpoint had been banned from posting.

I managed to see it before this and think you handled yourself extraordinarily well.

SB can't hide forever.

M.
 
Did the parents actually state this?

Not yet. But if you read Kelly's topic on Psychics and Missing People and her blog site, you can see for yourself some firsthand experiences of the hell psychics put family members through.

Where did Browne claim to be 100% accurate?

Nice try, but how come on every statement she makes that can be checked, she bats .000?

I can make claims all the live long day about what happened to missing people. And then when a rare one actually turns up and their situation doesn't match up with what I said, "Oh, well, I'm not 100 percent you know!"

What a load of crap.
 
I wouldn't say she bats .000 - after all, she did predict that Britney Spears and Keven Federline would break up.
 
Re: the myspace thread...holy moly, talk about having blinders on.

RSL, you are the most civil and polite poster I think I've ever come across.
 
Um, er, who didn't predict that Britney Spears and Keven Federline would break up?

M.


I know everyone with two brain cells to rub together saw that one coming, but to be fair, Sylvia did predict it and therefore, her batting average is not .000 .
 
Robert: I read that thread over at the other site. Masterful. Polite. Patient. You are a true gentleman.

I couldn't help but feel sad for many of those who posted against you. Not only their inability to answer questions, but their anger that anyone would -- even gently -- question their beliefs. The fact that any proofs, explainations, etc. were provided publically says volumes. IMO.

The formula seems to be. If SB is right, than she's psychic, when she's wrong, she never said she was 100%. Sad really.

I was wondering, some of the statistics thrown around in that chat... she's 85% right...she's 56% right...where do they come from?

Does SB claim a percentage?

Has anyone tried to quantify public statements?

Finally, how do you know that Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie aren't married? ;)

Bravo. You are a great man.
 
PS ... anyone know if she predicted Congress would go Democrat? Hard to see how anyone would have missed that one...she could have done it a week out and had a pretty good shot at caling it. ;0
 
That's terrific, Robert.

This particular event -- Browne's stupid guess about the boy -- would make a great press release. I hope the buzz continues to grow and eventually echo in Montel's thick skull.

M.

Actually it was a very good guess. The overwhelming majority of eleven year old boys abducted by strangers and not recovered within a few days are found dead in remote areas if they are found at all. :(
 
I was wondering, some of the statistics thrown around in that chat... she's 85% right...she's 56% right...where do they come from?

From the Twilight Zone. Or the whole cloth aisle at Wal-Mart. Or from Dr. Gary Schwartz of the University of Arizona. If you think you are psychic, just go see Gary, and he will give you a rating of 80 percent or better.
 
Actually it was a very good guess. The overwhelming majority of eleven year old boys abducted by strangers and not recovered within a few days are found dead in remote areas if they are found at all. :(

However, her guess that another kidnapped child, Opal Jo Jennings, was still alive and sold into white slavery, was completely wrong.
 
However, her guess that another kidnapped child, Opal Jo Jennings, was still alive and sold into white slavery, was completely wrong.

Now that was a stupid guess! IIRC, Opal Jo Jennings was supposedly being prostituted in Japan, where no one would notice her among all the other six year old Caucasian American children.:mad:
 
P.s. great stuff Robert. :clap:
Thanks, BB!

You were mega-patient with the people on the Sylvia MySpace forum. Perhaps it's just reading over the responses in one fell swoop rather than over a period of hours and days, but I was getting awfully discouraged for you. Does it get to you, trying to help people that don't want to be helped?
Not so far, JJ. Maybe it would, if it weren't for all the emails I get from people who feel they were helped by the site.

All I can do is put the facts (as I understand them) out there. How someone interprets them is out of my control.

I managed to see it before this and think you handled yourself extraordinarily well.
Thanks!

I was the other one posting on it.

They did delete it pretty quick.
Yeah. And, to be fair, that forum was set up to adulate her, not to be critical of her. Deleting the thread isn't very open-minded, but is well within their rights.

Re: the myspace thread...holy moly, talk about having blinders on.

RSL, you are the most civil and polite poster I think I've ever come across.
Not always, but thanks, Miss Ann.

Um, er, who didn't predict that Britney Spears and Keven Federline would break up?
Me. I just... didn't see it coming. My dreams of them doing an album of duets is now but a memory... :(

I know everyone with two brain cells to rub together saw that one coming,
:boxedin:

Robert: I read that thread over at the other site. Masterful. Polite. Patient. You are a true gentleman.
Thank you sir.

The formula seems to be. If SB is right, than she's psychic, when she's wrong, she never said she was 100%. Sad really.
Well put. I might just use that.

I was wondering, some of the statistics thrown around in that chat... she's 85% right...she's 56% right...where do they come from?
Well, Browne herself throws around an 87% figure that I've heard The 56% figure was one I read, but couldn't remember where. Later, I found out I had read it on Wikipedia, unsourced, so I will not quote that number any more until I verify that she has said it.
 
I love your conclusion on this one RL. It's just righteously indignant enough without being unnecessarily insulting...

If something can be logically extrapolated from the available facts - then it's not libelous right?

---====---

She's no more accurate than my cat. He'll do a reading for a mere $7.00.

Email, phone or in person? How many questions? 'Cause I've lost my USB memory stick... If your cat can puss-ykicly divine its location - i'll give him $7.00...
 
Well, Browne herself throws around an 87% figure that I've heard The 56% figure was one I read, but couldn't remember where. Later, I found out I had read it on Wikipedia, unsourced, so I will not quote that number any more until I verify that she has said it.

RSL, I am all over this. I have some ideas where to find exactly what you need.

I'll get back to you.
 
I heard about a couple of nice plugs for the site.

First, the on-line version of the Kansas City Star:

Psychic told parents missing boy was dead

And, in an email I received today, I was told that the site was mentioned hearing the site mentioned in their local (Kansas City) TV news.

My guess is, the site is getting some good traffic today!

Good little write up and use of your logo. Congrats!
 
RSL, I'm truly impressed with your even-handed approach to this project. Your sense of fair play is coming through loud and clear in your responses to Sylvia supporters which I am sure frustrates them.


Thanks for all your efforts and keep up the excellent work.
 
Last edited:
Not what I was looking for, but you may find this article interesting, RSL. Written in 2000 about SB's appearances on Montel for the magazine Brill's Content. Scroll down to where it says "Prophet Motive".
http://www.apologeticsindex.org/news1/an010103c.html

Not all of the Brill's Content article is shown there, but you can order from their archive.

More of the same article can be seen here: http://www.reall.org/newsletter/v09/n02/reall-news-v09-n02.pdf

Scroll down to "I see… that too few people will read
this".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom