StopSylviaBrowne: Shawn Hornbeck Reading

Wow, such ignorance and hate from folks that are filled with Sylvia's great love.

Barf.....


As for some of those posters (CC, Kyle), its obvious that the public school system was a complete failure and waste of their time.

U NO WAT I MENE?
 
Wow, such ignorance and hate from folks that are filled with Sylvia's great love.

Barf.....


As for some of those posters (CC, Kyle), its obvious that the public school system was a complete failure and waste of their time.

U NO WAT I MENE?

Could you try to post this again, in some language that someone can understand?
 
If you think that such an image did not cause them anguish, you are most likely not a parent.

It is not about what I think or don't think, or what you think or don't think.

You wrote

Once again, Browne's totally incorrect "psychic visions" added anguish and horrible mental images to the burden already being carried by the parents of a missing child,

Now, do you know if the parents actually stated that Browne's stuff caused them anguish and horrible mental images?
 
, it looks as though you're just here to play devil's advocate, to "ask questions" like the twoofers. Don't you get tired of just asking questions?

"juryjone", I'm not sure what your point is. If you don't like questions, you're probably in the wrong place.

I'm pointing out the obvious, that empty criticism ('It is damning that Sylvia was wrong even though she doesn't claim to be right' and 'I believe Sylvia added anguish even though I don't have evidence of that' and 'the man hours were wasted, even if they helped eliminate a possibility') really falls flat. It is good emotional criticism though, the type of stuff a lot of pseudoskeptics eat up like a buffet and keep going back for more.

Eat up. :)
 
The Sylvia supporters are a cult now. Unwilling to entertain any information contrary to what has been programmed into them.
 
Now, do you know if the parents actually stated that Browne's stuff caused them anguish and horrible mental images?

From what I understand those parents were on the show to speak with Sylvia about their missing son. So that means that part of them was ready to believe her, they wouldn't go just for fun. So this is what happened afterwards:

They were thinking: OMG is she right? she seems so sure of herself. It left an image in their head of their dead son, and the scary thought that they would never see him again. They could actually see an image of him being kidnapped by a person in a wooded area. I know, because that's the first image I got when I read the article about the reading. After that, some people told them that they shouldn't take it too seriously because psychics sometimes can be wrong. But this possibility that Sylvia could be right would not leave them for a long time, maybe even until a few days ago when they found the truth.

I didn't talk to the child's parents even once, but I can guarantee you that's what they felt. I don't need to ask them.
 
Last edited:
Hey Lancaster-

Haven't read the entire thread, so sorry if you've answered this, but how goes the search for video of this?

I'd love to see that on YouTube.

(Wouldn't make a difference to the people that need to believe, but it would be compelling for many sane, reasonable folks.)
 
Originally Posted by T'ai Chi
Now, do you know if the parents actually stated that Browne's stuff caused them anguish and horrible mental images?




Here's the thing...is there realy any proof that the boy is alive? I mean, they could still find him burried in the woods, right? Yes, he looks alive on TV, but they faked that whole moon walk thing...so it is possible that it is all some sort of consiracy to undermine SB's credibility.

And, we don't know that the parents were "anguished." In fact, they may have been delighted to know that SB thought there son was murdered and burried in the woods? What parent doesn't want the best for their children and proudly aspire to learning that their son has been killed?

Besides, the fact is that SB being wrong here probably made the news that the boy was alive (if he is alive and this is not a conspriacy) that much better...unless, of course, as said, the original prediction of his demise didn't cause them any anguish in the first place.....
 
Headscratcher4

So what you're saying is that NASA killed the boy?

Then arranged to parade him around to prove that he's still alive?

I'm not sure how 9/11 comes into this, but I'm sure by tomorrow - if not already - somebody's got a theory for that as well.

Dam' ebil gubmint!

I don't know about you, but I'm convinced.....

Ooops - fergot the smilies - :) :) :) :) :(



YBW
 
Last edited:
"juryjone", I'm not sure what your point is. If you don't like questions, you're probably in the wrong place.

No, no, you got it all wrong. The correct answer to "Don't you get tired of just asking questions?" is "Do I?"

I'm pointing out the obvious, that empty criticism ('It is damning that Sylvia was wrong even though she doesn't claim to be right' and 'I believe Sylvia added anguish even though I don't have evidence of that' and 'the man hours were wasted, even if they helped eliminate a possibility') really falls flat. It is good emotional criticism though, the type of stuff a lot of pseudoskeptics eat up like a buffet and keep going back for more.

Eat up. :)

Thank you for implying that I'm a "pseudoskeptic". It's a favorite term for those who are trying to peddle some kind of woo, like Ian used to do. I suppose we should take Sylvia's claims at face value. If she was wrong, this is just one of the 14 out of 100 times that she is wrong.

You didn't respond to the question I had about WHEN she talks about being wrong sometimes. Is it before she gives the reading or after she's been caught being wrong? Every time I've seen her on Montel she doesn't talk about being wrong, she just gives grand pronouncements. Don't you think she should add a qualifier, such as "it seems to me..." or "I may be wrong, but..."

By the way, could you please respond to my other questions about the statistics? Is there a chance that Sylvia's 86 or 87 percent figure is backed by strong data, or is it more likely that she lied about that just as she does everything else?
 
Now, do you know if the parents actually stated that Browne's stuff caused them anguish and horrible mental images?

T'ai Chi, you have to be nearly sociopathic to think that Sylvia Browne's bogus death proclamations to the parents of a missing child don't cause pain and suffering. You have to be completely disconnected from all of humanity to not get it.

But let me help you by quoting two parents of missing children:

I have very strong feelings about psychics. They're part of a second wave of predators. The first wave is the person who takes the child. The second is the ambulance-chasing lawyers, the exploitation journalists and psychics. They're off the mark, every last one of them.

That's Mark Klass, whose daughter was abducted and murdered.

And then there is Kelly, a member of this forum:

I don't know if you have children or not, and even if you don't, why don’t you imagine the person you love most in the world? Imagine that he/she is gone, and you have no idea what has happened to them. Dozens, and perhaps even hundreds of people come forward, offering their "help". They tell you all sorts of things, none of them the same as the others, and none of them ever results in finding the missing loved one. Regardless, you MUST listen to all of it, over and over again, lest you be accused of not wanting to find the missing loved one. You must listen to them tell you the most horrid things you can imagine being done to a person by another. You must listen to them telling you that your missing loved one was stabbed, beaten, and then their head was bashed in. You must listen as they tell you that your missing loved one was still alive, wimpering and asking for help as he/she drew their last breath, and no one was listening. He/she was all alone, and then the end came.

All of these people who come to you offering help want you to go through something like that. How did you feel reading that? How many times would you want to hear stories like that? What do you think that does to a person? Do you think it's healthy? How is it that it is called "helping"? Nothing has ever come of it except for pain. Is pain helpful? Does pain find the missing person?

Granted, this is the worst of this type of thing, but people who are not in this position have no idea of the roller coaster ride of emotions that we ride daily. We live with an ongoing trauma. Anyone in the medical field can understand what trauma does to a person mentally and physically. To add to that trauma needlessly is not a good idea. Needlessly refers to the fact that persons using paranormal means have not proven themselves useful in finding the missing person. I just don't know how much clearer I can make this. And in regards to caring, I care a great deal. If I didn’t, I wouldn't do this work while dealing with my own loss. Anyone who knows the work I have done cannnot dispute that I care. The fact that you do not understand how I can disagree with your opinion does not negate my caring.

Sylvia Browne is a bloodsucking, evil, turd. I will happily turn in my skeptic credentials, if that will satisfy you, T'ai Chi. There comes a point when one has to say, "No more". And the exploitation of the families and friends of missing people by Sylvia Browne, Montel, John Edward, and others of their ilk, is that time.

If people like you can't see the pain and anguish these scum cause, then it is time for someone like me to step down from the objective observer seat, and give you a shake.
 
T'ai Chi. Read Kelly's post that I quoted above again carefully. And then re-read this quote again from the FAQs on the Hornbeck site:

Q: Have you contacted any psychics?

A: Yes! At this point in our search we are listening to just about anyone who feels that they know where Shawn is! We have talked to many 'gifted' people who feel that they know where Shawn. We have talked to people from all around the US and even Canada!!!

Pure evil exploitation.
 
Agrees with Luke T.
When I was a kid, 6 years old at the time, I managed to get past a locked gate at my paternal grandparents and out into a heavily trafficked part of the city. Got picked up by the police and were returned to my parents unharmed. My mother later told me that those two hours I was missing were the most nerve wracking, frightening time in her life. Now add to that fear a moron of a psychic telling you that your kid is dead.
Sylvia Brown and her ilk makes me want to hurl.
 
You didn't respond to the question I had about WHEN she talks about being wrong sometimes. Is it before she gives the reading or after she's been caught being wrong? Every time I've seen her on Montel she doesn't talk about being wrong, she just gives grand pronouncements. Don't you think she should add a qualifier, such as "it seems to me..." or "I may be wrong, but..."

By the way, could you please respond to my other questions about the statistics? Is there a chance that Sylvia's 86 or 87 percent figure is backed by strong data, or is it more likely that she lied about that just as she does everything else?


Indeed....here's a critical question: when she is "right" (and keep in mind that means there is some semblance of accuracy in her predicition, for example someone she predicts will die, dies), how is it distinguishable from a guess?

Becasue she says: "I see it..."?

But, without putting her accuracy to any kind of a test, it looks like a guess...and even good, or educated guesses are still just guesses unless you can indeed show accuracy above mere chance.
 
Actually it was a very good guess. The overwhelming majority of eleven year old boys abducted by strangers and not recovered within a few days are found dead in remote areas if they are found at all. :(

It was a stupid guess in light of the fact she had no evidence, and for distressing the boy's family. But stupid, as we all know, is what she does best.

M.
 
Don't know if this is good enough for you, RSL, but here is a secondhand claim about SB's accuracy rate:

Celebrity psychic Sylvia Browne now offers her equally inspiring and forbidding prophecies in this discussion about the future of humanity. Browne pays homage to many famous prophets, including Nostradamus, Madame Helena Blavatsky, and Edgar Cayce. She then explains how prophets glean information about the future. Not all prophets should be trusted, she warns. Browne lists ways to recognize a "false prophet," such as recognizing that "any prophet who claims to be infallible is a false prophet." On this front, Browne claims that her own accuracy rate is 87 to 90 percent. "Only God can truthfully claim 100 percent."

http://www.amazon.com/Prophecy-What-Future-Holds-You/dp/0525948228

Perhaps you can find an accuracy claim in her own words in the book being sold in that link.
 
I find T'ai Chi's comments about not knowing that SB's comments caused anguish to be laughable.

I know several people injured in Iraq. I know of one who lost the use of his arm.

Since he never told me it bothered him, I suppose it would be unfair of me to assume that it bothered him.
 
Thanks Luke, and how does she quantify that accuracy claim? Makes the head reel.

The cynical part of me thinks she just calculates how much of her bullcrap will be actually proven to be bullcrap. It isn't really an 87 to 90 percent accuracy rating. It's a 10 to 13 percent "caught/busted" rating. Which, considering the amount of bullcrap she shovels on a daily basis, is an extremely liberal buffer she's given herself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom