StopSylviaBrowne: Shawn Hornbeck Reading

Let's please not go in with guns blazing, guys.

I'm just reading. Leaving the writing to you :)

It's something between scary and funny to read some of the post on that forum.

Maybe sad is the word I'm looking for :cry1
 
Does Montel have any muckraking tendencies? I'd think a good strategy to reach him is 1) I'm aftraid for you, and 2) Think of the benefit to your reputation and ratings if you helped expose her as a fraud?
 
This happened just a couple miles from my house, and has been pretty much all anyone has been talking about since Friday night. I was somewhat shocked and suprised to hear about Sylvia Brown's predictions in the case on the local radio this morning, so at least the word is getting out about her around here.
 
Does Montel have any muckraking tendencies? I'd think a good strategy to reach him is 1) I'm aftraid for you, and 2) Think of the benefit to your reputation and ratings if you helped expose her as a fraud?

Montel doesn't seem to have any muckraking tendencies where Sylvia is concerned. I sent a message through his website:

http://montelshow.com/sendyourpov/

with a link to RSL's page concerning this story. I doubt it will show up on the website though. Only the Montel-is-so-wonderful messages seem to show up.
 
RSL, Just read that MySpace thread.

I must congratulate you on your patience, and fine handling of an anagonistic situation.

I wondered at first why you bothered, but your opening post was very clear, and I commend you for your fairminded approach.
 
RSL, you are simply awesome. Sylvia Browne is busted. And I am glad to hear from Minadin that the local radio in the boy's area is busting her, too.

This is good stuff.

As for your page, it is very damning. But you may want to consider that the name and circumstances are all very fresh in the minds of the public right now, but won't always be. So it should be written with that in mind. Add more detail to refresh the reader's mind a year from now. The fact the boy was found after being missing for four years, with some links to major media that won't disappear any time soon, along with a photo of the kidnapper. (ETA: Also how much money the parents spent on psychics.)

I love you and what you are doing, RSL.
 
Last edited:
From the Shawnhornbeck web site FAQs

Q: Have you contacted any psychics?

A: Yes! At this point in our search we are listening to just about anyone who feels that they know where Shawn is! We have talked to many 'gifted' people who feel that they know where Shawn. We have talked to people from all around the US and even Canada!!!

The question about contacting Sylvia Browne is non-functional.
 
This story links to your site, RSL.

2 children that disappeared 4 1/2 years and 40 miles apart have been found, alive and TOGETHER. What makes the story even better is that one of the boys was predicted dead by a television psychic. Whoops.
 
Does Montel have any muckraking tendencies? I'd think a good strategy to reach him is 1) I'm aftraid for you, and 2) Think of the benefit to your reputation and ratings if you helped expose her as a fraud?
I'm afraid I know little of Montel outisde of his SB episodes, but he evidently has no desire to look into Browne's hit/miss ratio.

I was somewhat shocked and suprised to hear about Sylvia Brown's predictions in the case on the local radio this morning, so at least the word is getting out about her around here.
That's great that her involvement is getting some coverage, if only at your local level. Thanks for the update.

I doubt it will show up on the website though. Only the Montel-is-so-wonderful messages seem to show up.
Thanks for trying, Lisa.

I must congratulate you on your patience, and fine handling of an anagonistic situation.
Thanks, CZ. I lost it a bit with that one kid, but otherwise, just bit my lip.

I wondered at first why you bothered, but your opening post was very clear, and I commend you for your fairminded approach.
Thanks. I hope it results in some input down the road.

As for your page, it is very damning. But you may want to consider that the name and circumstances are all very fresh in the minds of the public right now, but won't always be. So it should be written with that in mind.
Yes, the article was definitely written as a stop-gap thing. I wanted it out there right away.

Once I get the video of the reading, I will be writing another article with a more long-term approach, much as you describe.

I love you and what you are doing, RSL.
Thanks, Luke.
 
Another syckic who predicted the boy's demise:

10.12.02 - With few other leads to go on in the search for a missing 11-year-old eastern Missouri, Shawn Hornbeck's family has put its faith in an Illinois psychic's read on the fifth-grader's possible whereabouts. The psychic, whose name was not released, told the family through an intermediary that the boy was struck Sunday night by a vehicle off Highway 47 and was buried by the motorist, said Rodney Akers of Bourbon, Mo., the boy's uncle. While relatives were skeptical -- "I don't have any faith in psychics, but we don't have any leads to go on," Akers said - a motorist did lose control of a car Sunday night on Highway 47, the same night Shawn was reported missing. Shawn's stepfather, Craig Akers, said the car was impounded and turned out to be stolen. But Washington County Sheriff Gary Yount said that no car had been seized. Investigators searched the area where the motorist lost control of the vehicle for several hours Thursday and Friday, but they have not said what, if anything, was found. (AP)

http://quinnell.us/natural/skepticism/incidents1.html
 
Mr. Lancaster, I applaud you. In one damning article, both Browne and Van Praagh are hoist by their own petards. That is what will make a difference: making sure as many people as possible see such charlatans exposed for what they are, hanged by their own words.

I wonder if Suzan is still around: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=1660885#post1660885

I also went with the Hornbeck family (missing son: Shawn Hornbeck) at their request to the James VanPraugh show, where he brought me on stage to show me, where his visions gave clue's....to no avail no hits, and I believe he later traveled to Missouri to further torture the family.
I can't tell you the hope that is in the eyes of the families... and the sorrow that follows.
 
This story links to your site, RSL.

Unfortunately some idiot posted this without even bother to read the articles or the explanation of why this story was included on www.stopsylvia.com:

I checked out that StopSylviaBrowne website. The intro refers you to the "Articles" section, so I clicked that and scrolled down: The first item beneath the Hornbeck story reads, "A woman loses her money to someone posing as Sylvia Browne's son in a classic phony psychic scam."

What the hell? If I start prank-calling senior citizens, claiming that I am John Edward's brother and telling them to mail me $50 checks, that doesn't prove that John Edward is a fake. Now, John Edward is a fake, and so is Sylvia Browne — but if you're going to build a website to debunk her, you ought to limit yourself to presenting evidence that supports your case. Another of his "articles" consists of 2 e-mails sent by "former Sylvia Browne fans" — not victims who were scammed by her, mind you, but just a couple of people who dislike her.

It just seems like the petty rantings of some nutjob who's got an axe to grind against Browne. The fact that he happens to be right doesn't mean he's coherent or worth reading.
posted by cribcage at 1:15 AM PST on January 14

I don't really feel like spending $5 to correct this guy - anyone else have an account over there where they could address his ignorance?
 
Another excellent article, Robert. Keep up the good work. (Hopefully the details will be filled out soon, while the event is still fresh in peoples' minds?)
Sylvia and her ilk make me sick. I hope Mr. Randi puts your research to good use when he decides to go after her hard.

(In reference to your web stats - if you're interested in more in-depth reports on your visitors, Google Analytics is excellent and free; much better than the free stats that many web hosting companies provide. You just need a gmail account (also free). After copying and pasting a couple lines of code into your pages, you get all kinds of great graphs, charts, maps, etc. I use it on my site and I love it.) Geez, I sound like a Google commercial! No, I don't work for them.... :)
 
RSLancastr said:
That's great that her involvement is getting some coverage, if only at your local level. Thanks for the update.

Well, the radio station is KMOX, a clear-channel station which broadcasts to most of the contiguous US, as well as parts of southern Canada and northern Mexico. (at least at night)

Website is here: http://kmox.com/pages/2615.php

On the show, Total Information AM, this morning, they said that they got the information on a blog . . . it might have been yours, might have been here. They were talking about another TV psychic as well. I'm looking on their site to see if they have the audio or text copy up yet.

ETA: They also said that there should be more in-depth coverage of this fraudulent psychic (redundant?) on the Paul Harris Show this afternoon. It's a pretty popular radio show, which you can listen to live from their website if you like. It starts in about an hour or so (2:10pm CST)
 
Last edited:
I wonder if Suzan is still around:
I wondered the same thing.

Unfortunately some idiot posted this without even bother to read the articles or the explanation of why this story was included on www.stopsylvia.com:
Actually, it's www.StopSylviaBrowne.com, but I registered it your way as well, a couple of weeks back, and it points to the site as well! :)

I don't really feel like spending $5 to correct this guy - anyone else have an account over there where they could address his ignorance?
Thanks for pointing this out, supercorgi. But hey, you can't please all of the people all of the time. Especially when they don't bother reading what they are criticizing.

Another excellent article, Robert. Keep up the good work.
Thanks.

(In reference to your web stats - if you're interested in more in-depth reports on your visitors, Google Analytics is excellent and free;
Sounds interesting, thanks! I will probably look into it after TAM.

Well, the radio station is KMOX, a clear-channel station which broadcasts to most of the contiguous US, as well as parts of southern Canada and northern Mexico. (at least at night)
Nice!

On the show, Total Information AM, this morning, they said that they got the information on a blog . . . it might have been yours, might have been here. They were talking about another TV psychic as well. I'm looking on their site to see if they have the audio or text copy up yet.
Well, mine isn't a blog. They may well be talking about this blog. The blogger sent me the link this morning.

ETA: They also said that there should be more in-depth coverage of this fraudulent psychic (redundant?) on the Paul Harris Show this afternoon. It's a pretty popular radio show, which you can listen to live from their website if you like. It starts in about an hour or so (2:10pm CST)
Let me know what he says! With luck, he'll mention the StopSylvia site.
 
Robert, in case you need a gmail account, lemme know. I got 50 invites I need to get rid of........
Thanks The_Fire, but I guess I'm not familiar enough with the benefits of a gmail account to know why I might need one.

And speaking of email, I received one at the SSB site this morning with a subject line "I love your books", and which started "Dear Sylvia..."

:confused:

It's not the first time this has happened. Maybe they think the site name means "Stop! (It's) Sylvia Browne!" :boggled:
 
<quote>And speaking of email, I received one at the SSB site this morning with a subject line "I love your books", and which started "Dear Sylvia..."

:confused:

It's not the first time this has happened. Maybe they think the site name means "Stop! (It's) Sylvia Browne!</quote>

They probably didn't see the "Stop", all they saw was Sylvia Browne, that is sufficient to suck her believers in.
 
Well, the radio station is KMOX, a clear-channel station which broadcasts to most of the contiguous US, as well as parts of southern Canada and northern Mexico. (at least at night)

Website is here: http://kmox.com/pages/2615.php

On the show, Total Information AM, this morning, they said that they got the information on a blog . . . it might have been yours, might have been here. They were talking about another TV psychic as well. I'm looking on their site to see if they have the audio or text copy up yet.

ETA: They also said that there should be more in-depth coverage of this fraudulent psychic (redundant?) on the Paul Harris Show this afternoon. It's a pretty popular radio show, which you can listen to live from their website if you like. It starts in about an hour or so (2:10pm CST)

I've tuned in late, but I'm listening. But I have to go to lunch shortly...

The above link didn't work, but this one does: http://tuner1.dc1.sonixtream.com/SOLON/media/tuner/Tuner?aff=kmox&UseSame=true&type=IE
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom