StopSylviaBrowne - Emails Regarding the Excalibur Show

Great article, and I will get back to reading them in a moment...

Another oops on the first article:
"I had read your blog and almost didn't get tickets but I like to tell myself that there are really people out there that are physic and I had seen Sylvia on Montel several times."

ETA: Yeah, I know... It was her (possible) typo rather than RSL's. I was just in a rush to get back to two amazing articles...
 
Last edited:
Good stuff as always, Robert.

I wish I was as confident as others on this board that your web site was going to cause her downfall, cause I don't see it in Sylvia's case (thought one can always hope!)

That comment is in no way meant to discourage you however. Stop Kaz and Stop SB are good examples of what just one individual can do, and I admire you for that.
 
I appreciate the posting of what happened at the Excalibur. There are more than a handful of people that I have come in contact with that are assured of her position as a spiritual leader. The place I used to work at wanted to book her as a speaker, glad that they didn't.
 
Great article, and I will get back to reading them in a moment...

Another oops on the first article:
"I had read your blog and almost didn't get tickets but I like to tell myself that there are really people out there that are physic and I had seen Sylvia on Montel several times."

I think he's just quoting what she actually wrote. I used to work for a newspaper, and that was the way they did it... they did not want to change what the person had actually said, so when they quoted someone, they wrote down exactly what they said, even if the person started out by saying "We was...".

Great reading, grammar and spelling aside... and Hooray for Woman #1! She's a class act. I admire someone like her who can learn new facts, and then change their mind based on facts. That can be hard!
 
There's something so beautiful about seeing someone think things through and admit they were wrong about something. It happens so rarely.

Dare we hope that any of those other emails you mentioned might have similarly happy endings?
 
I'm sure it never occurred to her that someone would actually investigate her claims, much less organize it all in one very accessible place. I imagine she counts your site among her worst nightmares!

I guess it is understandable that she didn't visualize the Internet, Personal Websites, and RSL. Oh wait, isn't she psychic? Musta been those nasty sunspots!

Susan
 
And our "hero" is one of the most stubborn people I've ever met. He just knows how to be polite while still being stubborn. If he were not stubborn, he'd have given up on all this long, long ago.

Congratulations, Robert. Two exceptional articles. I believe the articles are getting better and better - or is it just that a "happy ending" is in sight?

Well, I don't know if Robert is stubborn or not but putting an enormous amount of work into a long-running project is what I'd rather call "determined" or "committed". :)

Actually, I enjoyed almost all of the articles, even the ones I've had problems with, and I don't think they really vary in quality. If I had to pick a favorite, it would probably be her "Scorecard" for missing people and homicides but that's probably just because of personal bias. If I had to pick a favorite among emails, it would probably be "My Experiences in the Early 70s With Sylvia Browne".
 
Is it just my overly suspicious imagination, or is there something about those two email links in the OP that suggest they might be from the same person, and slightly obfuscated with spelling and punctuation to hide that fact?

I have to admit I thought the same thing. It's probably the use of "could of" instead of "could have" that stands out the most. But this is a pretty common mistake. Although you don't see it used here much (because of the superior intelligence of the forum members:D) you do see it a lot elsewhere.

Megakudos, Robert. I'm sure that woman who changed her mind wasn't the only one who did.

BTW, I want Randi's million. In post #129 of the I Speak with Sylvia Browne thread, I wrote "I'm sure you'll be getting e-mails from people who were there and had their eyes opened by your site." Proof of my all-powerful abilities. Small unmarked bills will suffice.

Steve S.
 
Last edited:
On the positive e-mail intro:
"Since then, I have since received emails"
Either since is superfluous.

As for Sylvia knowing who your wife is, didn't she have a PI run your background? She likely knew but didn't care to recognize her.
 
A large and warty woman sits at her desk, a banker's desklamp provides a small circle of light around her. The smudgy glow of the lamp is filled with cigarette smoke; it wreathes her head and then drifts off to find better company. She combs her straw-like, blonde hair back from her face with her fingernails; claws on a gargoyles hand. Joining the lamplight is the faint brilliance of a computer screen, highlighting her oddly patched up features and creating menacing shadows on her countenance. Her expression is furious, her jaw works silently as if she is chewing on her anger. She grabs the phone on her desk, and her office is filled with the sound of a dog's nails on a hardwood floor - a faint clicking as her monstrous claws dial the numbers. The toad screams into the phone, threats and half-formed vitriol rasps out of her mouth, demanding if the poor unfortunate on the other end of the line has seen the new article on the "nasty man's blog", demanding that they fix this problem for good, commanding that her base be shored up by writing blogs and posts on her fan forum. With one last thunderous croak, she slams down the phone and turns off the lamp. The soft flame from her lighter erupts suddenly in the darkness, a glowing red eye at the end of a cigarette flares quickly to life; she draws deeply, settling back with a grunt and mumbling to herself about revenge and how to milk more out of the people she has left.

***Please forgive any grammatical errors. I've only had one cup of coffee, drove 20 hours in the last two days, and bloodied my toe yesterday on a wii fit - I'm a little off my game.***
 
Last edited:
Two more satisfied customers (of RSLs website); excellent!
Thanks, Locknar!

Robert, these new articles are so encouraging...you seem to really be making some inroads against Browne.
Thanks, Hawthorne. I find them encouraging as well.

You've proven her wrong on yet another prediction? statement? - she's said previously that you were a dark entity, but she's also said that anyone who is a dark entity won't get near her or go to her shows, they can't stand all the "light." Guess you're in the clear, my friend!
Do you recall where she said that? I would like to get ahold of that quote!

Susan and I had intended to get a pair of t-shirts to wear at TAM. Mine would say:

DARK ENTITY​

...and hers would say

I'M WITH
DARK ENTITY
<-----
​

We never got around to having them made, but they would probably not have gone over well at the Ecxalibur...

It's feedback like this that is just amazing!
It's always nice to read, that's for certain.

The lady that didn't have a question would have done better just by cracking open a fortune cookie.
...and she could have bought quite a few for $137.50.

How gratifying it is to actually change someone's mind using reason and rationality.
Yup. By the way, I wish we had been able to visit more at TAM6, as we did at TAM5.5. Next year!

Bravo again!
Thanks, Ed!

Is it just my overly suspicious imagination, or is there something about those two email links in the OP that suggest they might be from the same person, and slightly obfuscated with spelling and punctuation to hide that fact?
I had considered this. Both had the "could of" quirk, and similar approaches to paragraphing. However, the email headers didn't support this (which can be gotten around), and more importantly, there were details in the subsequent emails which convinced me that they were not the same person. I could be wrong, but I do not think so.

Huzzah! Those emails were wonderful to read. As I read the second one, knowing that I would get to Woman1's reply, I kept expecting her to be defensive and angry at your (polite and thorough) response. She wasn't! How satisfying in the end. :D
Yes, it was!

Robert, just a thought: did you forward these articles to the management of the Excalibur, or do you intend to do so ?
I hadn't considered it. Personally, I doubt they would care, so long as she is selling a sufficient number of tickets.

This. Was. Brilliant.
:D

As I was reading Woman #1's emails, I was sure she was going to come back defensive and angry (as is human nature to be, when shown you have been made the fool.)
Although I was surprised that she changed her mind after only one email, I was not surprised at her change in opinion. When she had approached us outside the theater and started asking questions, it was obvious that she was genuinely interested in our responses, genuinely curious as to our point of view. I think that, had we the opportunity to sit and talk that day, she would have been well on her way to changing her mind even then. Unfortunately, time (and security guards) did not allow for that, so I am glad that she looked the site up and contacted me later.

Well-done!
Thanks!

Wow! Robert well done!
Thanks Susan!

You touched so many more people than just these two email writers. I wonder about Woman2 giving the signed book to her daughter. Is she really recommending Browne to her daughter?
Good question. And, by the way, she was not Woman #2 in the article. She did not approach me after the show.

Absolutely fantastic! No article you write fails to captivate me.
Thanks, Kate!

I say THREE CHEERS for this woman! She is so wonderful in that she IS a skeptic! She is willing to change her mind when given the evidence. I really admier her and please pass on MY admiration for her.
Agreed, and will do.

Though... think about it Robert...YOU were the highlight of the show! If Sylvia were smart she would hire people to get up like you do each performance. It would liven things up!
:D

She could make them, sort of, withe in agony and then explode with the power of her mind, like in Scanners. :)
Yikes!

Woman #1 deserves a lot of credit, not many people are as willing to learn something that conflicts with their existing opinion.
Agreed.

Well done Robert I eagerly await more! :clap:
Thanks, db!

I'm sure it never occurred to her that someone would actually investigate her claims, much less organize it all in one very accessible place. I imagine she counts your site among her worst nightmares!
The Internet has really opened up a whole new avenue for exposing frauds and con-artists. I learned that with the StopKaz site. I would imagine that there are many such individuals who have had to change their way of operating, thanks to blogs, YouTube and the immediate, world-wide access these sites bring to the table.

So, this is a tribute to you, RSL. I hope no one underestimates the importance of the work you are doing.
Thanks Ex-M, you're very kind.

I hope these get back to Sylvia in one way or another, but I'm glad anyway that you got them. I'm sure hearing reports that you opened someone's eyes make it all so sweet.
They do, KT. :)

In cases like this, the woman had enough personal integrity to admit she did not have all the facts. Good for her.
Well said.

It's as if only at that point was she allowing herself to remember bad parts about the session, rather than floating around in a post-Sylvia afterglow.
I often hear from people who say "Now that I've read your web site, I can see how rude and abrupt she is with people on the Montel Williams sho. Why didn't I ever notice this before?"

Our expectations color our perceptions.

Kudos for the whole thing.
Thanks, Nurse!

I see that first woman in your article still blames you for making Sylvia be a bitch!
Not sure I follow you there, Tiger. What do you mean?

Kudos x2 to you, Mr Lancaster Robert. I hope I will meet you in the future, when I make it across the big pond to one of the next TAM or whatever. I just want to shake your hand, that's all. :)
Thanks, Warheit. I look forward to it!

Congratulations, Robert. Two exceptional articles.
Thanks, hon!

Great article, and I will get back to reading them in a moment...
Thanks, BB, and thanks for trying to point out a typo, but as you later discovered, I publish emails warts and all (even my own emails).

Good stuff as always, Robert.
Thanks, Mr. S!

I wish I was as confident as others on this board that your web site was going to cause her downfall, cause I don't see it in Sylvia's case (thought one can always hope!)
Time will tell!

That comment is in no way meant to discourage you however. Stop Kaz and Stop SB are good examples of what just one individual can do, and I admire you for that.
Thanks!

I appreciate the posting of what happened at the Excalibur. There are more than a handful of people that I have come in contact with that are assured of her position as a spiritual leader. The place I used to work at wanted to book her as a speaker, glad that they didn't.
Thanks, rose. If I may ask, what sort of place was it that you worked?

Great reading, grammar and spelling aside... and Hooray for Woman #1! She's a class act. I admire someone like her who can learn new facts, and then change their mind based on facts. That can be hard!
Agreed.

There's something so beautiful about seeing someone think things through and admit they were wrong about something. It happens so rarely.
:)

Dare we hope that any of those other emails you mentioned might have similarly happy endings?
Only one other person who was there that afternoon has contacted me (that I know of). He described himself as someone who loves Browne, and had a comment about something in the article he disagreed with. When I explained it to him (I can't go into details here), he thanked me for the clarification. I asked permission to publish his email, in case anyone else who was there that day had the same question, but he requested that I not do so. I also asked him if my article was accurate, in so far as events he witnessed, and he agreed that it was. He made no indication that the article, or the events of that afternoon, had made him any less a believer in Browne. But I'd like to hope that some seeds of questioning were planted.

Megakudos, Robert. I'm sure that woman who changed her mind wasn't the only one who did.
Thanks, Steve. And let us know how it goes, collecting on the MDC. :D

Either since is superfluous.
Yeah, as were several instances of "And then she said.." I would probably have caught them had I done what I usually do, and read the article aloud before putting it up on the site, but I didn't. But the article is what it is, and at this point, I won't try to polish it. But thanks for pointing it out.

As for Sylvia knowing who your wife is, didn't she have a PI run your background? She likely knew but didn't care to recognize her.
May well be.

A large and warty woman sits at her desk, a banker's desklamp provides a small circle of light around her.
Nicely written!
 
Robert, I could swear I just saw that dark entity quote yesterday in a document I was looking at on dark entities/lucifer that I had compiled for you many months back. I have a copy of that one but don't have access to my home computer right now. If you find that document, you may find that quote. Otherwise, I'll try to locate it later today or tomorrow.
 
Wow! Robert well done!

You touched so many more people than just these two email writers. I wonder about Woman2 giving the signed book to her daughter. Is she really recommending Browne to her daughter?

Why would the hotel/casino be interested in this site? I'm sure all they care about is if she brings in money or not. If the revenues drop then she will be dropped. It sound like this could be in the works.

I look forward to reading your next articles

Susan


I respectfully disagree with you and (dare I say?) RSL on this point. If the casino sees that there is a growing backlash against SB and a possibility of unwelcome publicity, maybe in the form of Anderson Cooper showing up with a camera crew in tow, they might choose to rethink their position. After all, I think a case could be made that Montel's poor showing could be linked to his association with her.

All it takes is an email or two to bring it to their attention. What would anyone have to lose but a few minutes of time?
 
Robert, from your reply in the second link:

[[ I think you knew what you were doing when you walked up to ask your question. ]]

Well, I'm not sure what you mean by that. I knew the question that I was going to ask, and I knew that if Browne didn't a;ready know who I was, she would after I asked my question. But, given the strangeness with my ticket stub, and the fact that I was called last, I was fairly certain (and am still of the opinion) that she knew full well who I was before the show even started. Why else would she even call out every single number from the Preferred sectionif

Two errors: a;ready instead of already and sectionif instead of section if.
 
Thanks, rose. If I may ask, what sort of place was it that you worked?

Hey Robert,

I worked at a yoga an qigong center that was trying to put in an apiary to capitalize on their sourwood trees. Since I know about bees, business and worked in the New Age community of Asheville at the time, they invited me in. One of our lead instructors Tina was actually on P&T's episode called Self Helpless (I didn't know that until this past month and we weren't told about it.) I myself wasn't an instructor, but had been dealing with setting up an apiary on the land and looked after the land during the winter. We were looking to book Dannion Brinkley (Saved By the Light), Vincent Bridges (History Channel Nostradomus person) - who was a friend of the one of the fellows that ran the place and several Qigong and TM folks. That was the kind of lineup that the non-land oriented side dealt with.

The lady that owns the place was a follower (still is I believe) of Browne and was trying to book her to speak there at the center. The center is about 45 acres of mountain outside of Asheville and is pretty typical of the New Age facilities in the area. She did try to get me to read Sylvia's books, but I declined because of the real life workload I already had. I was lead to believe they had met at one of the New Age gatherings they have for the professional sorts.

Don't want to tie up too much of this thread - most of the background info I posted on my initial hello on the Welcome forum.
 
I often hear from people who say "Now that I've read your web site, I can see how rude and abrupt she is with people on the Montel Williams show. Why didn't I ever notice this before?"

Our expectations color our perceptions.

This something that has always baffled me. Her (and Montel's) behavior has offended and angered me very much (not that what she does would be any better if she were mannered and polite. Not at all. In fact, someone doing what she does and pretending to be your friend would- in some ways- make it worse.)

However, I can kinda sorta see why other people have described her as nice or warm and not unpleasant or mean-spirited at all. And why people are drawn to her personality and find it appealing. Allthough I still say she has no charisma or TV presence whatsoever. It's a funny thing but I can see why she rubs some people the right way.

The only other person I can think of who inspires similar reactions is, oddly enough, President George W. Bush. Journalists, staffers, politicians, Washington insiders and others who know him on a professional and personal basis have described him as cold, snarky, snappish and impatient. They say he lacks charisma, personability and social skills and comes off as a truly "mean" and very arrogant person. They interpret his smiles as nasty "smirks" and say he stands criticism very badly and has little sense of humor.

However, a myriad of other people, from activists to journalists to pundits to voters to staffers, both Republican and Democrat, call him charming, pleasant and personable and say that, whatever else you may say about him, he's a kind and generous man as a person. Even Jacob Weisberg has accused him of coasting by on good looks and personability. And the general consensus among the public and votes does seem to be that's he's well-meaning, good-humored and very "likable".

What is it that makes different people paint such different portraits of the same exact person? :confused: It's not just a matter of different interpretations of actions and remarks; this is a case of "are we talking about the same person?!".
 
Last edited:
Robert, I could swear I just saw that dark entity quote yesterday in a document I was looking at on dark entities/lucifer that I had compiled for you many months back. I have a copy of that one but don't have access to my home computer right now. If you find that document, you may find that quote. Otherwise, I'll try to locate it later today or tomorrow.

I hope you find it! I know she said it at one of her lectures that I attended, and all her followers on the GSB site have said that as well - I know that for sure.
By the way, Robert, did you ever get that t-shirt they promised you? The one that says something like "Sylvia doesn't prey on me, she prays for me"?
 
I hope you find it! I know she said it at one of her lectures that I attended, and all her followers on the GSB site have said that as well - I know that for sure.
By the way, Robert, did you ever get that t-shirt they promised you? The one that says something like "Sylvia doesn't prey on me, she prays for me"?


I know, and the taped version I have is one from the 1980s and I think it was supposedly Francine saying it. It still bugs me every time I hear it. Even though it may be a bit off the Excalibur topic, here are a few anecdotes about Sylvia and dark entities from my own past:

First, I recall a woman who'd been attending trance classes regularly for many months (years?), who suddenly stopped coming. This woman was somewhat outspoken and in the habit of asking intelligent questions, which sounded confrontational to the rest of us and seemed to annoy Francine/Sylvia. The night she failed to show for class, Francine explained to the group that she'd been a dark entity. People all exchanged knowing glances and seemed to agree, but all I could think was: "What happened to dark entities wouldn't come here, and if they did, wouldn't be able to stay?"

Second, a year or two later, Sylvia and Dal were brought up on charges, they separated almost immediately and Sylvia/Francine announced to the ongoing trance class (there were always ongoing trance classes back then) that it had all been Dal's fault and that he'd turned into a dark entity. According to Francine, when he turned dark, his spirit guide (Raheim) defected over to Sylvia. So this man, Dal, who'd been a fixture for years, who we all knew, who was very warm and friendly and approachable, and who many of us really liked, was supposedly, instantly, a dark entity? One moment he's at the church and everything is fine, the next he's dark and we never see him again. (I haven't been able to find that trance tape, though I'm fairly certain I must have it)

Third, a good friend of mine was a minister-in-training back then, devastated when Sylvia suddenly decided she was a dark entity.

Next, I had the bizarre experience back then of having one friend call me to tell me that Sylvia had just told her in a reading that another friend, also to me a very kind person who went to church with us and attended trance classes, was a dark entity. This person in later years went on to become a minister for Sylvia's church! A dark entity no less. Ha.

So I have some bitter memories of Sylvia's misuse of the term dark entity. And there are more stories, some even worse, that I can't tell because they involve people in my family and people who want their stories kept private.

Some more insight from an ex-minister who knows a bit about this: I suppose whether or not a person has charisma is a matter of opinion, but in my opinion she does (or did) have the kind of charisma that would move her into celebrity status, and she is a strong personality. Twenty years ago she was the kind of passionate speaker who could make you laugh at the goofy things people do and say in the guise of religion and psychology, who seemed to be promoting a view of life and the afterlife that was empowering and hopeful, and who could move you to tears. She didn't get where she is by NOT having charisma. Her blunt humor came across as confidence and "telling it like it is." Back then, she actually had no money, and she spoke with passion to her relatively small group of ministers and followers (us) about her dreams, once she had money, of one day building old folks homes and children's centers and how we would all be on the cutting edge of a religion that could help usher in a more peaceful, tolerant world. I still have many of those old lectures on tape and even now when my husband and I hear the excitement and apparent sincerity in her voice back then, it makes us wonder whether at one time she WAS sincere in desiring those things. Did money corrupt her? Is she a narcissitic personality who is partly deluded and partly corrupted now? Or was she corrupt all along and we were just too naive to see it?

But IMO, she has changed with age. She now seems caustic and impatient, her humor can seem cruel, and she seems not to "bother" much in lectures anymore - it seems more of a canned routine, and not the heartfelt, passionate lectures she did in the days before she hit it big on Montel. In person, she could be extraordinarily kind and compassionate. She could be generous and helpful, and I have seen her moved to tears when face to face with me, as when talking about her son Chris or about her dad. So just know that the side you all see is not the only side there is. Her behavior is inexcusable, but just know that she doesn't conveniently act the part of the cold, calculating person one suspects her to be based on her actions. All of this helped confuse the issues for me for a long time, at any rate, so I share it with all of you for what it's worth.

(OK, end of latest rant and I will now climb down off soapbox.) :)
 
P.S. Robert, I wonder if you read that and couldn't help but think that the trance tapes are anything but what I described in my previous post (heartfelt, etc). If so, I agree they are agonizing to listen to. When I was there, when Sylvia pretended to be Francine, she slowed her voice down and apparently tried to talk more seriously (at least that's the way they tried to portray Francine, as more serious and literal than sylvia herself - listening to the tapes, it becomes pretty evident that Francine sounds just like Sylvia but slowed down and more serious). One day I'll copy and send some of the old lectures so you can see what I mean. They probably aren't useful for research for your web site, which is why I haven't done it yet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom