StopSylviaBrowne - Emails Regarding the Excalibur Show

RSLancastr

www.StopSylvia.com
Joined
Sep 7, 2001
Messages
17,135
Location
Salem, Oregon
It's always nice to have a "How dare you?" email followed up with one that says, "Hokey smokes!! You were right!!".
 
Fascinating article and emails.

Its really worthwhile to see people who have had their eyes opened up.

All I can really say is keep up the good work :)
 
Did you have permission to publish the full name of the lady in the second article? Usually you are careful to remove every mention of someone's name, but her full name is still mentioned a few times.
 
It's always nice to have a "How dare you?" email followed up with one that says, "Hokey smokes!! You were right!!".
:D

All I can really say is keep up the good work :)
Thanks, DF!

Did you have permission to publish the full name of the lady in the second article? Usually you are careful to remove every mention of someone's name, but her full name is still mentioned a few times.
Thanks to someone's quick PM, that has been fixed. Thanks for making sure I knew, and thanks for not using the name in your post. :)
 
That happened once before! Sylvia told a woman she'd be a teacher and she responded by saying she had no intention of the sort. It must have been at my taping allthough it's hard to remember.

Is it just me or does she throw out the same 15 predictions and answers every time?

Edit: This sounds harsh to say but when I was reading the 1st email, I thought to myself "For Pete's sake, hasn't this woman read your site? That's what every Sylvia Browne reading looks like when there is no editing involved! And what it looks like most of the time even when it is used! What is she surprised about?"

Edit 2: ..."Someone is going to get you!" (but it couldn't have been that, because I know I would have added in my mind "...and your little dog too!")...

That's what I like about you. :) You're smart, caring and funny :).

I'm now sorry I didn't ask her about her degree when I had the chance, like you wanted me to. It might have freed you to ask her about something more significant.

Edit 3: As nice as Woman 1's email was and as good as your responses to her were, I wouldn't have let this comment slide: "and he also said, when we watch phychic detectives, they help for free and you see they know what they are talking about."

I'm afraid I know too much about psychic detectives to let that go unchallenged. Way too much. :(
 
Last edited:
Nice to see someone who actually has an open mind, rather than merely demanding that skeptics should have one.
 
May I add my congratulations, Robert, for all this wonderful work.

I wonder whether there has been any major changes in the amount of "Browneing around" on your site since your interview with her?
 
Excellent read! It's nice to see people review evidence and change their mind.

[Grammar Nazi mode] Why are both ladies who wrote to RSL using "coud of" and "should of" rather than "could have" and "should have"? Please don't tell me it's accepted practice nowadays...[/Grammar Nazi mode]
 
I'm not sure how far SB's minions go to protect her from your site but these two e-mails will be certain to raise her blood pressure. I hope it will lead others to stop, read and think that if this is true about SB it may also be true about other "psychics". (yes, I know it's true about all of them.) We know the logical fallacy of because this is true for one it is true for all.

It is learning to apply what you know to be true to one to test others that is the basic tenet of skepticism and science. This is what you have given to the readers of SSB. If this is true for her then maybe I should see if this is true for others. And if this is true about psychics what about ghosts, bigfoot, aliens, crop circles, etc.?



What you do is something we all should aspire to in our daily lives. Thank you for showing us how.



Boo
 
I'm now sorry I didn't ask her about her degree when I had the chance, like you wanted me to. It might have freed you to ask her about something more significant.
Naah. You did fine.

Edit 3: As nice as Woman 1's email was and as good as your responses to her were, I wouldn't have let this comment slide: "and he also said, when we watch phychic detectives, they help for free and you see they know what they are talking about."

I'm afraid I know too much about psychic detectives to let that go unchallenged. Way too much. :(
One at a time, Eeney. But in my reply to that, I quoted my generic warning about TV psychic shows, from the SSB FAQ:

FAQ said:
Q: What about (some other psychic)?

I am asked this often, about various psychics, such as John Edward, Lisa Williams and others.

A: Again, I have seen no convincing proof of anyone having psychic abilities.

But here is a further comment, regarding TV/Celebrity psychics in general: It is important to remember that the producers of a TV show which claims to be about a "true psychic" have a financial interest in making you believe that person is psychic. Because of this, you should never assume that what you see on the show is an accurate and unbiased representation of facts and events.

Nice to see someone who actually has an open mind, rather than merely demanding that skeptics should have one.
It's always a joy!

Another proof that your site is making a difference. Bravo!
Thanks, Flo!

May I add my congratulations, Robert, for all this wonderful work.
Thanks, Macoy!

I wonder whether there has been any major changes in the amount of "Browneing around" on your site since your interview with her?
:D

Excellent read! It's nice to see people review evidence and change their mind.
Thanks, Tanja.

[Grammar Nazi mode] Why are both ladies who wrote to RSL using "coud of" and "should of" rather than "could have" and "should have"? Please don't tell me it's accepted practice nowadays...[/Grammar Nazi mode]
Accepted practice? No. But probably more common than we'd like to think. I think it's from people mishearing "could've," and "would've."

"a;ready" - you missed a key pal :)
Yeah, there were other tps in my reply. But I try not to correct emails when I publish them, and reproduce them, warts and all.

I hope it will lead others to stop, read and think that if this is true about SB it may also be true about other "psychics".
That's the hope!

What you do is something we all should aspire to in our daily lives. Thank you for showing us how.
But it's only one way, the way that seems to work for me. There are other ways.
 
I sense her downfall. Big time.

In calling you back to the microphone, Sylvia caused a scene which led to that conversation outside the building which led to a number of people contacting you and thus finding out the truth. Plus some content for a couple of juicy articles.

I bet she's kicking herself!

I love a happy ending. : >
 
I love a happy ending. : >
:D

One interesting thing: Out of the maybe 120 people there that night, there were three skeptics we know of (Claus, My Better Half and me), and by the end of the show, at least three others that we know of who highly doubted Browne's "abilities" (Women #2, 3 and 4).

Now, add Woman #1 to that, as well as (it seems) her mother. Maybe the two friends that went with her as well.

Makes me wonder A) How many others there were, and B) How little return business her show does!
 
B) How little return business her show does!
I'd have to think pretty limited, unless she changes up the show time to time what would be the point? It can't be all that exciting to see someone sit on stage, shill their books and other appearances, and then "answer" questions.
 
Last edited:
Robert, these new articles are so encouraging...you seem to really be making some inroads against Browne.

You've proven her wrong on yet another prediction? statement? - she's said previously that you were a dark entity, but she's also said that anyone who is a dark entity won't get near her or go to her shows, they can't stand all the "light." Guess you're in the clear, my friend!
 
"WOW", you have really done your homework! You blew my opionions right out of the water!! I can't believe what i read!

It's feedback like this that is just amazing! I was actually shocked to read it as it seems all too rare, but it really underscores the progress that your site is making.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom