StopSylviaBrowne - Emails Regarding the Excalibur Show

Robert,
How gratifying it is to actually change someone's mind using reason and rationality. I give you credit for taking the time and effort to craft such a thoughtful and lengthy response even though you had no guarantee that she would give you permission to put it up on your site.
I'm thinking that Sylvia and Kaz should get together a "Reasons I hate Lancaster" site.
Bravo again!
 
Is it just my overly suspicious imagination, or is there something about those two email links in the OP that suggest they might be from the same person, and slightly obfuscated with spelling and punctuation to hide that fact?
 
Huzzah! Those emails were wonderful to read. As I read the second one, knowing that I would get to Woman1's reply, I kept expecting her to be defensive and angry at your (polite and thorough) response. She wasn't! How satisfying in the end. :D

~ggep~
 
Robert, just a thought: did you forward these articles to the management of the Excalibur, or do you intend to do so ?
 
This. Was. Brilliant.

As I was reading Woman #1's emails, I was sure she was going to come back defensive and angry (as is human nature to be, when shown you have been made the fool.) Instead, you brought her into the light. Score one more for the good guys. Well, done, Robert. You're a hero.

And of course, the most exciting thing is, these are just two women. There's no way to know just how many of the attendees actually have visited your site (seeing as how Browne gave you the chance to plug it right there in her show). I suspect that many of them have logged on, had their eyes opened once and for all, and are now spreading the word.

Well-done!
bow.gif
 
Wow! Robert well done!

You touched so many more people than just these two email writers. I wonder about Woman2 giving the signed book to her daughter. Is she really recommending Browne to her daughter?

Why would the hotel/casino be interested in this site? I'm sure all they care about is if she brings in money or not. If the revenues drop then she will be dropped. It sound like this could be in the works.

I look forward to reading your next articles

Susan
 
Absolutely fantastic! No article you write fails to captivate me. And to know your work is effective - that must be a wonderful feeling!
 
Robert, I'm actually CRYING after reading what the second woman posted.

The thing is that people are saying to Sylvia believers, "you know that she's a fake" but really...they don't have "proof"

I say THREE CHEERS for this woman! She is so wonderful in that she IS a skeptic! She is willing to change her mind when given the evidence. I really admier her and please pass on MY admiration for her.

People say that skeptics can't even change a mind or make a difference! HA!

And I do think that next time people should just take in a good maigc show!

Though... think about it Robert...YOU were the highlight of the show! If Sylvia were smart she would hire people to get up like you do each performance. It would liven things up! I can't imagine how deadly dull it would have been without you there!
 
Though... think about it Robert...YOU were the highlight of the show! If Sylvia were smart she would hire people to get up like you do each performance. It would liven things up! I can't imagine how deadly dull it would have been without you there!


She could make them, sort of, withe in agony and then explode with the power of her mind, like in Scanners. :)
 
Excellent read! It's nice to see people review evidence and change their mind.

[Grammar Nazi mode] Why are both ladies who wrote to RSL using "coud of" and "should of" rather than "could have" and "should have"? Please don't tell me it's accepted practice nowadays...[/Grammar Nazi mode]

Accepted, no. Common, yes. Like leaving the -ed off of past tense forms of verbs ending in s, t, or d, I see it all the time.
 
Awesome!

Woman #1 deserves a lot of credit, not many people are as willing to learn something that conflicts with their existing opinion.
 
Last edited:
From the second article: "As many years as she has been in this business, why has nothing been said??? Sylvia Browne has been on tv and now has her own show in Las Vegas. Why hasn't TMZ, the gossip show or anyone else for that matter say" Sylvia Browne is full of bologna"?? I would like to know!"

My answer: Because until Robert Lancaster went to the trouble of creating the Stop Sylvia Browne web site, none of us had a voice.

Without this web site, the stories of the ex-ministers and other ex-Novus people would have had no audience outside our immediate circle of family and friends, and would not have carried much weight. Even had we found a way to be heard by a bigger audience, one or two ex-ministers somehow managing to create a blog somewhere wouldn't have meant much, and it would have been intimidating to be one voice trying to share a personal negative experience about someone as rich and famous as Sylvia has become. But there is strength in numbers. In my opinion, SB counted on us remaining powerless and voiceless; at least it would explain why she never even bothered to explain herself to the ministers when, for example, she lied in public about supporting her churches.

I'm sure it never occurred to her that someone would actually investigate her claims, much less organize it all in one very accessible place. I imagine she counts your site among her worst nightmares!

So, this is a tribute to you, RSL. I hope no one underestimates the importance of the work you are doing.
 
Have to say I'm pleasantly surprised at Woman #1's reply. As I read the article, I thought maybe that wouldn't go so well after the couple lessons skeptical reasoning. I

hope these get back to Sylvia in one way or another, but I'm glad anyway that you got them. I'm sure hearing reports that you opened someone's eyes make it all so sweet.
 
Huzzah! Those emails were wonderful to read. As I read the second one, knowing that I would get to Woman1's reply, I kept expecting her to be defensive and angry at your (polite and thorough) response. She wasn't! How satisfying in the end. :D

~ggep~


I totally agree. It is very difficult for many people to engage in a debate and when confronted with differing arguments, change their opinion. People are naturally stubborn. Which is why I love Robert's method so much. He is polite, logical and simply presents the facts to let others make up their own mind. In cases like this, the woman had enough personal integrity to admit she did not have all the facts. Good for her. This is the beauty of Stop Sylvia Browne.*

* Ughh. I just said "beauty" and "Sylvia Browne" in the same sentence.
 
From the second article: "As many years as she has been in this business, why has nothing been said??? Sylvia Browne has been on tv and now has her own show in Las Vegas. Why hasn't TMZ, the gossip show or anyone else for that matter say" Sylvia Browne is full of bologna"?? I would like to know!"

My answer: Because until Robert Lancaster went to the trouble of creating the Stop Sylvia Browne web site, none of us had a voice.

Without this web site, the stories of the ex-ministers and other ex-Novus people would have had no audience outside our immediate circle of family and friends, and would not have carried much weight. Even had we found a way to be heard by a bigger audience, one or two ex-ministers somehow managing to create a blog somewhere wouldn't have meant much, and it would have been intimidating to be one voice trying to share a personal negative experience about someone as rich and famous as Sylvia has become. But there is strength in numbers. In my opinion, SB counted on us remaining powerless and voiceless; at least it would explain why she never even bothered to explain herself to the ministers when, for example, she lied in public about supporting her churches.

I'm sure it never occurred to her that someone would actually investigate her claims, much less organize it all in one very accessible place. I imagine she counts your site among her worst nightmares!

So, this is a tribute to you, RSL. I hope no one underestimates the importance of the work you are doing.

I agree and I'd like to add that this isexactly the same situation with my cause, the homicides/ missing person's cases (as well as assorted unsolved burglaries, rapes, missing bodies and other crimes she has inserted herself into.)

None of the families have ever come forward on their own to set the record straight (allthough Shawn Hornbeck's mother and stepfather deserve a huge thank you for coming forward after the story broke, as does Misty Robbins). No journalist looks into and investigates her track record. And Montel's show obviously never follows up (except on the occassions where she was proven to get one or two things right and they retrofit the entire prediction, as with Terry Webb and Waylon Robbins.)

The silence is golden for them as it doesn't subject them to any scrutiny, allows her fans to believe that she has solved these cases and convinces the families of the missing or murdered that she can really solve these crimes.

It's angering to think that no one before Robert and me and the others had ever looked into her track record for these cases- or even seemed to think of it! Well, if my memory serves me right, James Randi did showcase one or two before SSB did.

It's inspiring to realize what a difference two or three or four people with computers can make. :)
 
Last edited:
I did want to ask you one question. About three minutes before the she came out, did you see her peeking out through the curtains? I had front row right down in front of her. And she was looking where you were sitting. Kinda like starring with a mad look on her face! i thought alot about everything last night, and i remembered that. Usually when people do a show and peek out to the crowd, they usually smile or even wave at the people that did notice them!! She just stood there with kinda a scary look on her face! One lady even said out loud, look their she is; look how beautiful she is!! Thats when i looked up, and thought ,holy moly, she looked scary!!!!

I found it interesting that she offered up this anti-Sylvia tidbit only after you'd rationally discoursed with her. It's as if only at that point was she allowing herself to remember bad parts about the session, rather than floating around in a post-Sylvia afterglow.

Kudos for the whole thing.
 
Two new articles up this morning:
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_sylviabrowneshowjune22.shtml
Email: "Sylvia Browne show on June 22"
A woman who attended the same Excalibur show that I did shares her thoughts.

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/email_lasvegasatthesylviabrowneshow.shtml
Email: "In Las Vegas at the Sylvia Browne Show"
The woman who defended Browne at the Excalibur writes.
​

I see that first woman in your article still blames you for making Sylvia be a bitch!
 
Argh, what praise to add which hasn't been said already?

What a brilliant article (two articles). This is a bazillion times better than what I was hoping for. Actual attendees of the SB farce show read your site, got back to you via e-mail, and spoke their mind. It can't (can it?) get any better than that. Kudos x2 to you, Mr Lancaster Robert. I hope I will meet you in the future, when I make it across the big pond to one of the next TAM or whatever. I just want to shake your hand, that's all. :)
 
I totally agree. It is very difficult for many people to engage in a debate and when confronted with differing arguments, change their opinion. People are naturally stubborn. Which is why I love Robert's method so much. He is polite, logical and simply presents the facts to let others make up their own mind. In cases like this, the woman had enough personal integrity to admit she did not have all the facts. Good for her. This is the beauty of Stop Sylvia Browne.*

* Ughh. I just said "beauty" and "Sylvia Browne" in the same sentence.

And our "hero" is one of the most stubborn people I've ever met. He just knows how to be polite while still being stubborn. If he were not stubborn, he'd have given up on all this long, long ago.

Congratulations, Robert. Two exceptional articles. I believe the articles are getting better and better - or is it just that a "happy ending" is in sight?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom