I've read this case and it certainly is interesting. Unfortunately, it doesn't quite lay out a black-and-white rule such as you assert. The case involved another church using Scientology's teachings and methods. Scientology tried a RICO/trade secret approach. The court concluded that whatever benefit comes from the materials is of a spiritual and not an economic nature primarily because Scientology chose not to argue that it would lose money by having a competitor. The judge basically told them, "You can either pretent you're a religion out to help people or you can admit you're a business out for money. You chose option a, so you have to live with it."
The issues involved with StopSylviaBrowne.Com are far, far different. They're almost completely divergent with close to no overlap. But it was an interesting way for Scientology to go and I thank you for pointing me to the case.
Actually--there are similarities. Scientology is considered to be a malicious litigator and they paid millions in that case--and have paid out many cases since then. Moreover, slapping an injunction on someone has a way of making the information you are trying to protect--suddenly very valuable--and widely copied in digital format by those who think information should be free. Plus, posting legal "stop and desist" type letters has been a useful way for making the litigious back down--the Smoking Gun does so regularly. And if you don't want information going public, then it's not a good idea to have it in a court document. Uri Geller also has been labeled a malicious litigator or whatever they call people to bar them from bringing frivolous suits in certain Jurisdictions. Plus, I suspect Sylvia is not paying taxes on her "spiritual organization"--so, while Hay House might have copyright protection over it's for-profit ventures--the same rights are not given to non-profit organizations because are presumed to be doing some social good in return for some pretty fine tax breaks.
You are incorrect in your assumption that people cannot recover from Sylvia Browne. Although she doesn't have the deep pockets of Scientology--she does charge a $750 per 20 minute reading "donation" which she puts back into her "spiritual organization" according to her publicist. Scientology threatens to get people to shut up--just like Sylvia-- but when people don't back down--these people pay money to shut others up. Read more about the case and Scientology in regards to the law...check out Bill O'Reilly's settlement or Kobe Bryants--lots of money changes hands in order to get people to enter into agreements not to talk.
Moreover, the reading in Swift makes Sylvia ripe for suit in practicing medicine without a license. Also, most states allow recovery for negligently and wrongly informing someone that their close family member was dead--in fact, cases have been won from people wrongly told by medical personnel that they had tested positive for HIV. (It's an actionable tort in most states subject to monetary damages for severe emotional distress.) I suspect Sylvia would settle before it ever got to court upon an agreement that the victims are enjoined from commenting on the case or settlement.
Breech of contract is another possibility.
But a class action suit for fraud and/or emotional abuse is the best possibility. Look more closely at Scientology and the millions that have been recovered for similar allegations. Should anyone in the legal field be interested in taking on Sylvia Browne, I think the many recent and successful cases against Scientology can extremely useful.
Scientology cult pays $8,674,643 to ex-member to end 22-year legal battle.
May 9, 2002 9:00 AM.
http://script4u.org/cgi-bin/hell/np...t.org/letters/FACTNewsMay2002Wollersheim.html
http://script4u.org/cgi-bin/hell/np...kross.com/reference/scientology/Scien140.html
http://script4u.org/cgi-bin/hell/nph-proxy.pl/000000A/http/en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_McPherson
http://script4u.org/cgi-bin/hell/nph-proxy.pl/000000A/http/www.xenu.net/archive/CourtFiles/
You were incorrect about Scientology and I think you are incorrect in your conclusion that possible cases against Sylvia bear no similarities to cases won against Scientology (which you presumably were not even aware of.)
Because of that, I'm sure you are wrong about your assertion that Sylvia won't pay. I think there is so much fodder in Scientology briefs--that a budding and motivated lawyer shouldn't have much problems in connecting the dots. And Sylvia cannot afford the defense that Scientology can.
I'm not Psychic--but Sylvia is going down--and some people are going to profit. I hope RLS, JREF, the Hornbecks, and other victims of Sylvia will get substantial relief. You may not see the potential or legal similarities--but others will be able to see very clearly. Just watch.
Uri Geller also has some legal snafus that may be worth looking into. And I hope Larry King and Montel back off from their sycophantic behavior towards Sylvia lest they get drawn into the maelstrom.
RLS, read a little about of the links above if you have the time--and don't back down.
Oh--and I checked it over with a Tax Lawyer in regards to the Scientology case, and my summation was correct. When it all boils down--you can't claim tax free status as a religious organization on one hand, and own a for profit copyright protection on the other. State laws cannot conflict with Federal laws or federal laws trump. Tax Laws are often used to "punish" people when other legal maneuvers fail to do the job. Madame Heidi Fleiss served more time for tax evasion then for pandering.