StopSylviaBrowne: A Response to Browne's Attempt to Silence Me

Actually, I'm kinda surprised that sylvia didn't see enough into the futuer to go out there and tie-up a lot of web site names that could be used against her. For someone so precsient, one would have thought she'd have seen "SopSylviaBrowne.Com" at least a couple of months away.

The fact that robert has the domain name is but further proof that she's a liar.
 
If you live in California, why is your lawyer a 5 minute drive from me here in Rockland County, New York? Shouldn't you be using a CA attorney?
Because a California attorney was not needed to respond to this letter. As I said elsewhere in this thread, if this goes to court, another attorney will represent me.

By the way the response letter is great.
I agree!
 
Are there any unofficial Sylvia fansites that use 'Sylvia Browne' in their URL or any of her material or logos? I was unable to find any, but if there are, and they have not received similar letters, it is further proof that her intent is to suppress criticism.
 
Are there any unofficial Sylvia fansites that use 'Sylvia Browne' in their URL or any of her material or logos? I was unable to find any, but if there are, and they have not received similar letters, it is further proof that her intent is to suppress criticism.


I just did a whois search for "Sylviabrowne" domain registration - most of them give a page not found .
.
http://www.whois.net/search.cgi2?str=sylviabrowne
 
Last edited:
Nice response letter, I'm glad you got a decent lawyer to write it.

But I think it would really help your case if he referred to you as "Robert's Lancaster" a bit more. ;)
 
Just some random off the wall thoughts --

Robert, you may not just be facing Sylvia Browne's deep pockets but also Hay House, Inc.'s deep pockets. SB's attorney did say in her C&D letter to you that she:
  • was also representing them
  • "believed" the use of their trademark might also be "actionable" (a very interesting hedge)
  • noted at the bottom of her letter that she had copied them as well as the Sylvia Browne Corporation
It might be a good idea for your attorney to make Hay House, Inc. aware that they will also be named in any counter legal action unless they disassociate themselves from this matter. SB's attorney muddied up the waters by stating in her C&D letter that SB's web site was copyrighted by Hay House, Inc., which I suspect is incorrect, but is another good reason to make sure that they are directly made aware of the issues. (I strongly suspect that not all lawyers keep their clients up to date with the status of their case.)

I happened to notice that Montel Williams has published three books with Hay House, Inc. -- they were published in September and October 2000, and in June 2001. Which came first? Montel Williams association with Sylvia Browne, or his association with Hay House?

As another poster mentioned in a recent thread, Sylvia Browne is touring with Collette Baron-Reid in 2007. Hay House, Inc. sponsors these tours and Collette Baron-Reid has also published a book through them. This caught my attention because I would think if it were up to SB she would prefer to tour solo but if she were pressured into promoting someone else, she would prefer to promote her son, Chris Dufresne (who has also published through Hay House, Inc.). Obviously, I'm not in a position to know, but I think that this is a hint that SB doesn't make all of her own business decisions. My personal theory is that it's good to know with whom one is actually dealing, especially in difficult situations. Robert, you may not actually be dealing with SB, but with some "brains behind the throne" (so to speak), possibly in the Hay House, Inc. operation.

These rambling musings may not be useful, after all, it doesn’t change the law or any legal precedents, but I posted them in case you or someone else finds them useful. But as Endothermal put it, I'm always happy to STFU and go back to the cheap seats. ;)
 
Last edited:
It might be a good idea for your attorney to make Hay House, Inc. aware that they will also be named in any counter legal action unless they disassociate themselves from this matter.

The letter made it clear that the lawyer was addressing Sylvia Browne's claims as well as Hay House's. The lawyer referred to Hodgson's clients in the plural: "Your letter of January 26 has set forth no factual or legal basis as to how Mr. Lancaster is in violation of any of your clients’ rights." Since the lawyer isn't allowed to contact Hay House directly, I think the letter adequately serves to inform they that they're involved too.

In any case, I doubt Hay House and Sylvia Browne are completely distinct entities. In order to get big, they needed an infusion of capital. If I had to guess, I'd say Browne bought a chunk of the company.
 
/* 2nd attempt to post */

JSB's attorney muddied up the waters by stating in her C&D letter that SB's web site was copyrighted by Hay House, Inc., which I suspect is incorrect

Interestingly enough Hay House is the registrant for sylviabrowne.com.
However, I think someone else said in a recent thread that Sylvia Browne Corporation had trademarked "Sylvia Browne"? Regardless, as many have already pointed out, using www.stopsylviabrowne under fair use shouldn't be a problem.

Registrant:
Hay House
PO Box 5100
Carlsbad, California 92018
United States

Registered through: GoDaddy.com, Inc. (http://www.godaddy.com)
Domain Name: SYLVIABROWNE.COM
Created on: 06-Oct-02
Expires on: 06-Oct-09
Last Updated on:

Administrative Contact:
Fishell, Mike [email protected]
Hay House
PO Box 5100
Carlsbad, California 92018
United States
7604317695

Technical Contact:
Fishell, Mike [email protected]
Hay House
PO Box 5100
Carlsbad, California 92018
United States
7604317695

Rrose Selavy said:
I just did a whois search for "Sylviabrowne" domain registration - most of them give a page not found .

FWIW, I find the easiest way to do a whois search is to go to godaddy.com
I put the domain name I'm curious about into the text box that lets you know if its available. When it comes up as taken, I click on the link to the right for more information.

www.sylviabrowne.com points to www.sylvia.org
sylvia.org is registered by Sylvia Browne, Corp.
 
Last edited:
The logo was part of a simple bitmap screen capture of the homepage of her web site. I can't envision this as being different from offering a mini-browser window pointed at her web site, which could not possibly be an infringement. Anybody can offer up a browser that people can surf with, or even not surf with. (The most they could claim is that the web site has since changed, which might be the case for the text and messages, but even so, it's still an accurate repsentation at a previous time stamp.)

It's also obvious that is supposed to be an image of her web site in a browser window itself, and is not part of your web site per se.
 
The letter made it clear that the lawyer was addressing Sylvia Browne's claims as well as Hay House's. The lawyer referred to Hodgson's clients in the plural: "Your letter of January 26 has set forth no factual or legal basis as to how Mr. Lancaster is in violation of any of your clients’ rights." Since the lawyer isn't allowed to contact Hay House directly, I think the letter adequately serves to inform they that they're involved too.

I've written my share of business memos and letters. People tend to read quickly and miss the details, esp. if they are prone to poor grammar and typos as SB's attorney obviously is. One could dismiss this and say, well that's her problem, see ya in court baby. I don't know what RSL's preference is as far as that goes.

I can't do a cut and past from RSL's attorney's letter, I think he disabled the Adobe text select tool in his document. I'm not going to reytpe his sentences but he had the option to use phrases like "both of your clients" and to also refer to both SB and HH and not just SB when stating that her client has deeper pockets than his, and that would be taken into account in any anti-SLAPP suit.

Technically you are correct, but sometimes depending upon what your goals are, a little extra emphasis and even s-p-e-l-l-i-n-g it out is the way to go.

In any case, I doubt Hay House and Sylvia Browne are completely distinct entities.

I agree, I think its a safe bet that they have many close financial ties.

In order to get big, they needed an infusion of capital. If I had to guess, I'd say Browne bought a chunk of the company.

You may be right. However, I suspect that both Sylvia Brown Corp and Hay House, Inc. are private companies with long histories and that it would be a project to definitively know if and which one bankrolled the other.
 
The response is excellent--Yep...SLAPP--it would make Sylvia Browne known as a litigious individual-- and excellent reference to Sylvia's fame-- It is extremely difficult for any person of fame or notoriety to win a defamation because they are considered a "public figure" whom the public has a right to know about. The best they can aim for is a copyright violation, but Sylvia has much more to lose. I wonder if she's paying taxes or if she's writing everything off due to the "spiritual nature" of her organization as her publicist seemed to indicate (she claimed that Sylvia doesn't "profit", all the "proceeds" go back to the "spiritual foundation" or whatever the hell).

Scientology tried to sue for copyright infringement when people published their expensive secret teachings on line, but they had to withdraw in order to keep their tax free status as a "religion". The Government and Religions and charitable organizations cannot own copyrights and keep their tax exempt status. I suspect this is why the suit was brought by Hay House...rather than whatever Sylvia's publicist was referring too.

I would love for Sylvia to have to pay Robert Lancaster and/or a class action suit for Fraud. I hope the legal angle is not just used to to protect Robert, but to go after Sylvia.

If we are lucky, Sylvia will have to pay for her abuse of the public trust (and possibly practicing medicine without a license per her reading reprinted in Swift and infliction of severe emotional distress for negligently informing someone that their child was dead when their child was not.) That would send a valuable message to the public and make others less ashamed to come forward with similar tales of "spiritual" fraud.

I imagine a show like America's most wanted where the viewing public is encouraged to question these frauds. If someone is for real, why would they be afraid of being tested. I would love for people in general to know about the test very simply...the way Robert explained it on the radio and Randi did on t.v.--because the woos always pretend it's some impossible test involving trickery, and people seldom get a chance to hear how simple the tests would be--

When someone starts talking about woo, I would love for it to be a common question for people to ask--"has X applied for Randi's challenge?" I think Randi's rule revisions coupled with Sylvia's public gaffe and Roberts website can be a boon for critical thinking.
 
Scientology tried to sue for copyright infringement when people published their expensive secret teachings on line, but they had to withdraw in order to keep their tax free status as a "religion". The Government and Religions and charitable organizations cannot own copyrights and keep their tax exempt status. I suspect this is why the suit was brought by Hay House...rather than whatever Sylvia's publicist was referring too.

Well, your excitement is understandable but I don't think any of that is right. Scientology prevailed in a suit where extensive amounts of their copyright-registered documents were put online. They lost a suit where the documents were described and only quoted in small part. I don't think one's status as a religion or charitable organization changes one's ability to hold a copyright but I'd be glad to be pointed to different information.

If we are lucky, Sylvia will have to pay for her abuse of the public trust

There is no set of circumstances under which that is a possibility.
 
...I can't do a cut and past from RSL's attorney's letter, I think he disabled the Adobe text select tool in his document. I'm not going to reytpe his sentences but he had the option to use phrases like "both of your clients" and to also refer to both SB and HH and not just SB when stating that her client has deeper pockets than his, and that would be taken into account in any anti-SLAPP suit.....

You can cut and paste from the body of the page. Like I did with Point 2: " The points made above apply equally for the Hay House trademark. The trademark appeared as part of a small and indistinct picture of Sylvia Browne’s website’s homepage. There was no possibility that an unsophisticated consumer could believe that the trademark rendered as part of a picture of Ms. Browne’s homepage could indicate that Hay House produced, licensed or endorsed the content of StopSylviaBrowne.Com. Without conceding any infringement, however, Mr. Lancaster has removed Hay House’s trademark from his website."

And Point 3 in the letter: "Your claim that Mr. Lancaster has violated Hay House or Ms. Browne’s copyrights is without foundation in law. Material on which a person holds a copyright may be used without permission in a variety of cases. ".
 
You can cut and paste from the body of the page. Like I did with Point 2: " The points made above apply equally for the Hay House trademark. The trademark appeared as part of a small and indistinct picture of Sylvia Browne’s website’s homepage. There was no possibility that an unsophisticated consumer could believe that the trademark rendered as part of a picture of Ms. Browne’s homepage could indicate that Hay House produced, licensed or endorsed the content of StopSylviaBrowne.Com. Without conceding any infringement, however, Mr. Lancaster has removed Hay House’s trademark from his website."

And Point 3 in the letter: "Your claim that Mr. Lancaster has violated Hay House or Ms. Browne’s copyrights is without foundation in law. Material on which a person holds a copyright may be used without permission in a variety of cases. ".

I think Robert's lawyer focuses evenly on SB and HH when he responds that Robert is not violating trademark laws.

I think his lawyer focuses more on SB when he discusses deep pockets and that he will pursue all remedies available under California's anti-SLAPP laws. (In fact, when it comes to deep pockets he only refers to SB's wealth and resources and doesn't mention the international company Hay House, Inc. at all.) Am I nitpicking? Maybe.

My point is, that if it comes to it, I think that Hay House, Inc. should also be held fully liable.

Perhaps I have also been influenced by the title and content of this thread. Let's not forget that Hay House is also trying to shut down Robert's web site. Although they have not been the focus of TV, other media, and even our posts like SB is, HH is every bit as involved in this sordid business.

That's my main point and I don't have anything further to say.

Except if you happen to have the time, can you PM me the steps you took to cut and paste from the Adobe document? :) The Text Select Tool didn't work for me. The Graphics Select Tool sort of worked, but while I could paste it into a word document I couldn't past it into the JREF reply to topic HTML input box -- even from the word document.

TIA.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom