StopSylviaBrowne: A Response to Browne's Attempt to Silence Me

This Davis fellow might be a good attorney, but you should have hired Rabinowitz, Rabinowitz and Rabinowitz, seven savage Jews who wouldn't leave a scrap of meat on Sylvia's bones. :D
 
Last edited:
Hey Robert!

In that letter's last paragraph there is a mention of Sylvia's people having contacted "Domains by Proxy" which I understand is the company through which you've registered "StopySylviaBrowne.com". Have you had any inquiries from them (Domains by Proxy/GoDaddy) that you can talk about?
 
Her lawyers, being lawyers, must know their case has no legal standing...While her lawyers are raking in the money, it is people like them who give all lawyers a bad name.

It could also be possible that her lawyers are saying things such as, "Look, this is a really bad idea, but if you really want then we'll give it a go."
 
Hey Robert!

In that letter's last paragraph there is a mention of Sylvia's people having contacted "Domains by Proxy" which I understand is the company through which you've registered "StopySylviaBrowne.com". Have you had any inquiries from them (Domains by Proxy/GoDaddy) that you can talk about?

I was wondering that myself. What information could they possibly get from Domains by Proxy that isn't publicly available on stopsylviabrowne itself? It's not like RSL is hiding his name.

ETA: Domains by Proxy hides your whois information. I use it for skepticsrock.com.
 
Her lawyers, being lawyers, must know ...

Indeed. Her lawyers being lawyers found a way to charge her. At this stage the fact that the claims may have no merrit is meaningless to the lawyers...it is about charging fees AND intimidation. Methinks they were hoping that a shot across the bow would scare Robert off and that he wouldn't seek competent legal opinion.

Bravo Robert. Good response. No one has won here, but her lawyers have to know now that you won't be chased away.

Another thing to think about...perhaps a way to take on Montell as well...I wonder if he is in favor of trying to repress information...I mean he has a talk show, I wonder how he would feel if her lawyers tried that crap on him...or someone else tried to keep him from discussing a topic with this kind of legal gobildy gook.

In short, this letter should be used to sober Montell up on this topic...
 
Y'know, somehow I really, really doubt that Sylvia wants to wind up in a courtroom where, under oath, she can be questioned about her abilities and past behavior. Rock on, RS!
 
The business of the anti-SLAPP statute is hardly an empty threat.

Even if the statute were not applicable, federal courts look very harshly upon lawsuits unsupported by fact and law.

As I discussed in this thread, our illustrious President Bush had his noble head up his pompous ass when he urged that frivolous lawsuits ought to be prohibited. Frivolous lawsuits had been prohibited in federal courts for decades before Bush expressed his lame-brained outrage, and the federal courts had been largely diligent in enforcing this prohibition.

If you really want to get a federal judge mad at you, I mean really mad at you, then present that judge with a lawsuit that wastes his/her valuable time. And then get out your checkbook, bub, because the judge is about to express his/her degree of displeasure.

On top of all that, there are other techniques (which I will not discuss at this point) for making life difficult--in a perfectly legal way--for someone who files a harassing lawsuit unsupported by fact and law.
 
I was wondering that myself. What information could they possibly get from Domains by Proxy that isn't publicly available on stopsylviabrowne itself? It's not like RSL is hiding his name.

ETA: Domains by Proxy hides your whois information. I use it for skepticsrock.com.

My guess is they are trying to take ownership of the domain through proxy. For example with domain name conflict resolution, there is stipulation that if you are the rightful trademark owner used in a domain name by someone else you can have the ownership of that domain transferred to you without the real owner's permission or control. Mind you there are many steps involved and there are mitgating techniques as well. When I read the letter from her lawyer and it mentioned the trade mark first and foremost, that's the angle that popped into my mind. This letter might serve solely as a "told you so" if she is successul in having the domain transferred. This came about to thwart cyber squatters but big companies are using it to shut down critical sites.

Robert a bit of advice; keep your registration payments up to date and your ISP & registrar very happy otherwise, SB can use many techniques to try and steal the domain from you. If your payments are late or slow to come someone from SB's camp can make the payment before you and have a chance of domain ownership. (This would only be a problem when the domain name is due for renewal) . Also make sure your lawyers are aware of this as a possible threat vector.

ps. if i'm preaching to the choir just tell me to STFU, i can go back to the cheap seats.
 
Last edited:
The business of the anti-SLAPP statute is hardly an empty threat.

Even if the statute were not applicable, federal courts look very harshly upon lawsuits unsupported by fact and law.

As I discussed in this thread, our illustrious President Bush had his noble head up his pompous ass when he urged that frivolous lawsuits ought to be prohibited. Frivolous lawsuits had been prohibited in federal courts for decades before Bush expressed his lame-brained outrage, and the federal courts had been largely diligent in enforcing this prohibition.

If you really want to get a federal judge mad at you, I mean really mad at you, then present that judge with a lawsuit that wastes his/her valuable time. And then get out your checkbook, bub, because the judge is about to express his/her degree of displeasure.

On top of all that, there are other techniques (which I will not discuss at this point) for making life difficult--in a perfectly legal way--for someone who files a harassing lawsuit unsupported by fact and law.

While they do indeed view harshly lawsuits without merit, that does not remove the fact that the defendant has to
1. Hire representation--Lawyers insist onpayment in advance for defendants, thank you very much
2. Take time away from work/place of business to defend
3. Suffer mental anguish ecause of the financial squeeze
4. face default judgement if he/she does none of the above.
Which basically makes blackmail legal. Just file the suit--it will cost money to the other side.
 
The business of the anti-SLAPP statute is hardly an empty threat.

Even if the statute were not applicable, federal courts look very harshly upon lawsuits unsupported by fact and law.

As I discussed in this thread, our illustrious President Bush had his noble head up his pompous ass when he urged that frivolous lawsuits ought to be prohibited. Frivolous lawsuits had been prohibited in federal courts for decades before Bush expressed his lame-brained outrage, and the federal courts had been largely diligent in enforcing this prohibition.

If you really want to get a federal judge mad at you, I mean really mad at you, then present that judge with a lawsuit that wastes his/her valuable time. And then get out your checkbook, bub, because the judge is about to express his/her degree of displeasure.

On top of all that, there are other techniques (which I will not discuss at this point) for making life difficult--in a perfectly legal way--for someone who files a harassing lawsuit unsupported by fact and law.


Indeed. Sylvia's lawyers have very hard row to hoe here. First, given the nature of what Robert is trying to do (and the fact that SB is by here own making a public figure), the law is inclined to protect him and his right of free speech above any commercial right SB migh have.

In addition, SB's next move after receiving Roberts letter -- had she any ground to stand on -- would be to go for a preliminary injunction. However, such a move would expose her claims for the nuciance not substance they contain...and this would be where a Judge would start going nuts on her legal advisors.

No, in some ways she's shot her best shot...save for her financial advantage. But this is expensive litigation to persue not just defend...and if a judge starts assessing fees...it could get very expensive very fast...also, it turns a matter between her and Robert into a public affair...i.e. SB tries to legally repress criticism, not based on libel or slander ('cause a psychich has no case if someone says "she's a liar, she's no psychic" and even less if they are a public figure) but on commercial/copyright infringement grounds.

One wonders, wouldn't some of her believers wonder why she's not going after Robert for slander or libel? They might be disapointed to see that she has no public defence in a court of law.
 
While they do indeed view harshly lawsuits without merit, that does not remove the fact that the defendant has to
1. Hire representation--Lawyers insist onpayment in advance for defendants, thank you very much
2. Take time away from work/place of business to defend
3. Suffer mental anguish ecause of the financial squeeze
4. face default judgement if he/she does none of the above.
Which basically makes blackmail legal. Just file the suit--it will cost money to the other side.
First of all, don't default! RSLancaster has legal representation and is not at risk in that area.

As for the mental anguish, sorry, no one (except for certain special interests) has any right not to be sued. RSLancaster has so far demonstrated a mental toughness associated with standing his ground, even if it would be cheaper to surrender.

Hiring representation, while not cheap, is often not as expensive as is often believed, especially for pre-litigation posturing. Here again, RSLancaster has his bets covered.

The bulk of time and expense associated with litigation is in the discovery process. Even then, this often doesn't cost the client much time (although it is expensive).

One of the nice things about discovery is that it works both ways. They want to depose Lancaster? Fine. Then Lancaster's attorney gets to depose Browne. And it's a safe bet that Browne wants to avoid that. (I can think of a few attorneys who would represent RSLancaster for free if they could get the opportunity to grill Sylvia Browne under oath!) Just imagine. Every prediction, every testimonial, every fee, every goof-up, every tax dodge, every brush with the law, every potential bit of con artistry can become the subject of questioning.

Hey, if Sylvia sues to protect her "good name," it's open season on the dirty laundry!!
 
Your lawyer wrote a great letter and really seems to know his stuff! :)

However, I couldn't help but notice that trademarks and SLAPP laws are not listed among his law firm's practice areas and that they are also located in New York and not California -- and there is no mention of what other states they are able to practice law in.

So, if it becomes necessary, I hope you will be able to bring in another lawyer or law firm.

However, I'm not too concerned about it, you seem to have all your ducks lined up in a row. Just be on the lookout for surprise ducks too…:)

Let us know if you decide to start collecting for legal fees -- like others have mentioned, I can contribute at least the equivalent of a couple of beers. ;)
 
Hey, if Sylvia sues to protect her "good name," it's open season on the dirty laundry!!


This is the point I was trying to make. She isn't suing to protect her good name. SHE HAS NO CASE. She is a public figure and unless Robert KNOWINGLY perpetuates a lie against her and intends to perpetuate that lie, she has no case for libel or slander.

She is suing to protect a commercial interest. The questions will not be whether she is psychic or telling the truth or what her history is, the questions will be whether this is an infringement on her copyright under the law, and if so is she harmed by it. In short it is a trademark/copyright issue ... a commercial issue.

BUT, here again, Robert is in pretty good shape. She doesn't want this to go to court, to seek an injunction, etc. because she is on weak ground. Free speech here also trumps her commercial rights...especially as Robert is a critic, not holding her up for commercial blackmail, not making money off her mark, etc.

In any event, she will never go to court to sue anyone for slander or libel. She could have sued Randi dozens of times over by now...but it is a complete loser. She can't prove she's psychic -- at least not to the satisfaction of a court of law -- so she has to stay away from anything dealing with her person or claims.

All she is left with is a bogus commercial claim and using it to intimidate. Robert has very ably hit that ball back over the net.
 
Last edited:
Robert, maybe you should start a new section on your site about the legal issues?
Yes, that is the plan. When I will have time to execute that plan is another thing entirely.

Does anyone have any data on how effective the anti-SLAPP stuff actually is?
I am reading good things about it. Visit the site I link to in the article, and the sites linked to from that site.

That's a kickass letter your lawyer wrote.
Indeed. I resisted using that very phrase ("kickass letter") in the article.

I especially like the part where he informs SB's lawyers they are acting unethically and will also be held accountable.
Yes, that was one of my favorite parts as well. :)

While her lawyers are raking in the money, it is people like them who give all lawyers a bad name.
Not neccessarily. As has been said elsewhere in this thread, it was worth a shot. I would think that an attorney might tell Browne "We have no way of winning this, but let's see if Lancaster knows that. Who knows, he might fold, and all it will cost you is the one letter."

Prepare for the dirty battle.
That is a likely outcome.

I just hope your site doesn't get all bogged down with this crap, RSL. She wins that way, too.
Yup. It will be separate at some point. And there will be other new articles up which wil not relate to the legal wranglings.[/QUOTE]

Yeah. Nice job, RS -- and your lawyers rock, too.
Thanks!

His comment to me at the time was "That was a mistake. I don't pay my lawyers to write letters; I pay them to bitch-slap other lawyers around."
An interesting perspective! :)

In that letter's last paragraph there is a mention of Sylvia's people having contacted "Domains by Proxy" which I understand is the company through which you've registered "StopySylviaBrowne.com". Have you had any inquiries from them (Domains by Proxy/GoDaddy) that you can talk about?

Y'know, somehow I really, really doubt that Sylvia wants to wind up in a courtroom where, under oath, she can be questioned about her abilities and past behavior. Rock on, RS!
Thanks!

The business of the anti-SLAPP statute is hardly an empty threat.
No, it most definitely is not.

My guess is they are trying to take ownership of the domain through proxy.
While this may or may not be true, it would have nothing to do with Domains By Proxy.

As Lisa Simpson has already said, Domains By Proxy is a company which you can use in order to keep your contact information from showing on a WHOIS search of your domain name.

Browne's attorney contacted Domains By Proxy and requested my personal contact information.

ps. if i'm preaching to the choir just tell me to STFU, i can go back to the cheap seats.
No, better to tell me something I already know than to not tell me and find out that I don't know.

Your lawyer wrote a great letter and really seems to know his stuff! :)
Yes he does, thanks!

So, if it becomes necessary, I hope you will be able to bring in another lawyer or law firm.
Yes, if it goes to court, another attorney will represent me.

Let us know if you decide to start collecting for legal fees -- like others have mentioned, I can contribute at least the equivalent of a couple of beers. ;)
I appreciate that, thanks!
 
All the lawyers on the planet can't make Sylvia Browne see one nanosecond into the future.
 
While this may or may not be true, it would have nothing to do with Domains By Proxy.

As Lisa Simpson has already said, Domains By Proxy is a company which you can use in order to keep your contact information from showing on a WHOIS search of your domain name.

Browne's attorney contacted Domains By Proxy and requested my personal contact information.

No, better to tell me something I already know than to not tell me and find out that I don't know.

you're right about the domains by proxy and their purpose, I shouldn't have quoted that original comment when I was posting my comment. The technique used to grab the domain back that I was talking about is usually labeled "transfer of ownership through proxy" The last company I worked at was successful taking ownsership of a domain through this approach. cheers
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom