I've only been lurking, but this confession bothers me. Why, yes; I'd be happy to tell you why.
I've been at JREF forums long enough to have seen how some people react to skepticism, critical thinking, and logical argument. I've seen it bandied about, in No True Scotsman style, that "we" aren't skeptics; we're cynics. It's not that we question our assumptions, so much as we simply refuse to believe in much of anything.
I'm a skeptic because I'm tired of my own gullibility. I'm tired of belief making me a fool, easily suckered into any old thing that comes down the pike. I don't necessarily want to ruin anyone else's fun, or drag them down into some hopeless, depressing abyss. I simply want to see the world, and all that's in it, with as much clarity as I can manage.
I spent most of my life mired in belief, and it served me poorly, if at all.
Now I have swung to the side of knowledge, and it serves me very well; so well, in fact, that I am eager for as much of it as I can get. I would much rather know a thing than believe a thing.
Yet, I still have certain beliefs to which I tenaciously cling, in spite of the fact that they've been disproven and debunked over and over again.
This whole thread is indicative of that very phenomenon: I tend to trust strangers to tell me the truth. I tend to trust in honesty, even before honesty has been displayed. Put like that, it sounds pretty wooish, doesn't it? Why would I do that?
You know, I don't really know why. <critical-thinking cap is now engaged>
I do know, however, that every time my trust in someone's honesty is "rewarded" as it has been in this thread, it moves me a little closer towards rejection of the notion of trust. When I act on this rejection, it will only make me seem even more cynical, rather than skeptical.
Regardless, the next time I see a new thread with an opening post in a similar vein to this one, I'm not going to bite. I'm going to question the poster as to his sincerity, and point to this thread as the reason why. I'm going to carefully explain that secretly pretending to take a certain position, for the sake of inciting argument, automatically brings an appeal to emotion into the argument that need not be there, and will end up spoiling it, in the end.
"I really
respect Person X, and
believe in what s/he does. Person P's site against Person X is nothing more than slander, libel, and defamation! I am
offended that you would use such
base tactics to
attack someone who is doing so much
good!"
See all the emotional appeals in there? And so many fronts to defend at once! Instead, in my opinion, we could have had just as meaningful and interesting a discussion (if not more so) had the OP rather said: "I have seen your SB site, and am curious as to how you defend your position when attacked by 'the faithful.' I propose a mock-debate, therefore, and will take the position of the SB Believer, so we can see this play out."
Man, I would have been on that like white on rice!
Now I just feel stupid, and lied-to. And gee....maybe even a bit more cynical.
Maybe, as it did play out, this
was a good exercise. Maybe I needed that extra cynicism. I think I've just discovered that a certain amount of cynicism is necessary to the skeptic, and is not a particularly bad thing.
So, I think the next time someone bleats about how cynical I am (or we are), I'll just smile, knowingly. Thanks.
