Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Ah, well. Color me disappointed, though not particularly surprised.

Many of us said that the OP sounded like satire, but I decided to treat it as a serious post, on the off chance that it was.

Sorry that everyone spent so much time and energy defending me and the site from what turned out to be a pretend attack. I said in a previous post that the general civility with which the thread was conducted speaks volumes about the people here. Rox's confession does nothing to change that.
 
Several former members of Browne's church, parents of missing children, and others who have been abused by Browne's claims have posted here in hopes of helping what they assumed was a sincere person.

Such as:

well sylviarox wanted to hear my story.

I'll give a brief version, very brief.

My friend had her son die. Very tragic, and unexpected.

She is grieving and decides to seek the advice of a psychic. A well known one, but not Sylvia Browne. But I can not but imagine she works the same way.

You get a hint, just a bit, but not anymore than those several really good hits. You forget the misses, the "not quite rights" or "almost right" or "totally wrongs" in the happiness that with those few hits - you may have contacted YOUR CHILD.

sure it costs money, after all the psychic has to EAT.

And sure you have to go back again and again, because she can't be expected to get through clearly and with all the information you want, and you want to share with your dead CHILD in one session. It's very exhausting, and you know you do pay a physician. Sure they get paid less per hour, but this is MORE than an operation. This is talking to and contact with YOUR DEAD CHILD.

One day, you run out of money, or your family cuts you off.

what to do?

$30,000 later, but with nothing left in the bank account, sorry, no more talking to YOUR DEAD CHILD.

Now a psychic would say, "you would gladly pay $100,000 to have your child with you again, even a million would be a bargain" (and yes, they do say this stuff). And gosh knows that psychic HAS TO EAT. She is a PROFESSIONAL.

But we are talking A DEAD CHILD.

what parent wouldn't sell everything, give up everything, just to talk with her child again, and then again. As long as you give that psychic money it's like your child is still with you. Until the money runs out.

If you can talk to the dead, you had better make sure you are getting a clear signal. You had better really weigh everything that comes out of your mouth. If you REALLY believe you are talking with a DEAD CHILD and you charge for it and then refuse to "contact" this child anymore because mommy has run out of money... what kind of immoral monster are you? Does the DEAD CHILD shut up because mommy isn't paying the psychic?

Seriously, don't DEAD CHILDREN just yell in Sylvia's ear 24 hours a day, desperate to reassure their parents that they are fine? She should be out knocking on doors, talking to people, giving the the word from heaven. Doesn't God get pissed that she CHARGES, for what she claims is a heaven sent gift? Did Jesus charge for the fish and loaves? Or "hey I healed your blindness, that will be $300?" She claims to be like Jesus. Heck she wrote a book about Jesus.

She can't believe in Jesus, because if she did she would so fear dying and going to heaven. He would SO be there at the gate waiting for her with a few questions (to say the least).

However, you were simply playing with these people:

Ding, ding, ding! We have a winner. I appreciate your sarcasm, but I do hope that at the very least some of your admiration is sincere, dogjones. :)

I have lost my passion for this thread, and shall admit the truth: I am not a woo, and have never believed in Sylvia Browne. "Bored student", indeed. It was the fine poetic quality of your post that finally allowed me to admit it, unlike the inane ramblings of ConspiRaider, my mortal enemy, and his ilk. As a matter of fact, it was specifically his accusations which prevented me from admitting it sooner.

I have nothing left to gain from continuing this charade. I am not a skeptic, but I am fairly well versed in the tactics used by them, and have enjoyed reading Mr. Lancaster's column since its inception. I had been inspired to start the thread by a video I had seen on the internet: it was a late 60s documentary on Scientology, and I was very impressed by their "always attack, never defend" tactics, and also their professed outrage at any accusations against them. I wanted to try the tactics out.

Do not think that the effort you fine people have put into this thread has gone to waste, it provided me with a good deal of amusement and pleasure.

The gaps in your explanation and refusal to answer questions were evidence of a troll. However, more kind people overlooked that (such as Robert, kittynh, and others). For their kindness they were taken in by you. You should be ashamed of yourself.

Regarding your last sentence, did kittynh's post provide you with "amusement and pleasure"?
 
Last edited:
Agh, I had written a post in reponse to ConspiRaider, deleted it when SR replied, and now it looks like I should have left it standing.

People, please let it go. Any indignation, while justified, only encourages SR to try and get everyone worked up again. Life is too short for this. There was a great deal of value generated in this thread, 4 or 5 TLA's alone! If SR wants to remain in this thread and attempt to generate additional friction, that it his/her problem, not ours.

Raidey, come on over to Community and help me convince slingblade to give me a house in Randiville. :)
 
So it was all a parody, I see. If so, I have somewhat mixed feelings about this. On one hand, I've always enjoyed a good, clever practical joke, especially if it is on me. And I guess I'd have to rate this as at least somewhat competently done, despite some rather contrived transitions (which were so obviously stitched together that many people never quite accepted that everything about you was 100% genuine -- I think this thread went on as long as it did more out of the respect and restraint shown by forum members, rather than any overarching cleverness or creativity).

On the other hand, if you Google "'robert lancaster' 'sylvia browne'" you'll see not one, but two references to this thread immediately under the stopsylviabrown site itself. I know that doesn't appear to bother RL much, but I don't know. It continues to cause me a bit of indigestion to think that SB now has what appears to be a response to RL's site, and it didn't cost her a penny -- indeed, JREF is actually paying for it. (Kind of like hijacking your enemy's airliners and using them to attack your enemy -- my God, I sound like a 9/11 CTer!!)

So in the end, I'm not sure I can consider this thread a net positive. For what it's worth, I personally don't feel that anyone owes me any apology (not that one was ever offered). As to those who put more faith in you -- indeed, took time and effort to defend you and offer congratulations for your faux "conversion" -- I'll leave it for others to decide whether apologies would be warranted.
 
I mentioned the syndrome earlier in the thread, and I think it's worth repeating.
Skeptics, make sure your confirmation bias detector is switched on and calibrated at all times.
Yeah, the thread's been funny at times, tedious at others, but I really don't think, as was pointed out by QG, kittynh is likely to see it that way.
SR, there really are some posters who deserve a grovelling apology:mad:
 
Last edited:
Ooops, there you go!

I haven't been here in a while and was catching up on this thread. Quite an interesting turn of things...

Ah, well....
 
Again, this was expected in some form or another. If you have been here long enough you know that such turn arounds never happen. Again, who cares? I don't think SB got a response to RSL given how poorly this thread reflects on it all. If I were an SB supporter I would not want one of my marks to wander into this thread.

All in all, it is probably the best to take people at face value online, unless they are obviously a pdoh sock puppet.
 
You knowingly and intentionally accused an upstanding man of crimes he didn't commit? In public? For entertainment purposes? Right before making hundreds of people angry? In America?

You're not very smart, are you?
 
I've only been lurking, but this confession bothers me. Why, yes; I'd be happy to tell you why. :D

I've been at JREF forums long enough to have seen how some people react to skepticism, critical thinking, and logical argument. I've seen it bandied about, in No True Scotsman style, that "we" aren't skeptics; we're cynics. It's not that we question our assumptions, so much as we simply refuse to believe in much of anything.

I'm a skeptic because I'm tired of my own gullibility. I'm tired of belief making me a fool, easily suckered into any old thing that comes down the pike. I don't necessarily want to ruin anyone else's fun, or drag them down into some hopeless, depressing abyss. I simply want to see the world, and all that's in it, with as much clarity as I can manage.

I spent most of my life mired in belief, and it served me poorly, if at all.
Now I have swung to the side of knowledge, and it serves me very well; so well, in fact, that I am eager for as much of it as I can get. I would much rather know a thing than believe a thing.

Yet, I still have certain beliefs to which I tenaciously cling, in spite of the fact that they've been disproven and debunked over and over again.

This whole thread is indicative of that very phenomenon: I tend to trust strangers to tell me the truth. I tend to trust in honesty, even before honesty has been displayed. Put like that, it sounds pretty wooish, doesn't it? Why would I do that?

You know, I don't really know why. <critical-thinking cap is now engaged>

I do know, however, that every time my trust in someone's honesty is "rewarded" as it has been in this thread, it moves me a little closer towards rejection of the notion of trust. When I act on this rejection, it will only make me seem even more cynical, rather than skeptical.

Regardless, the next time I see a new thread with an opening post in a similar vein to this one, I'm not going to bite. I'm going to question the poster as to his sincerity, and point to this thread as the reason why. I'm going to carefully explain that secretly pretending to take a certain position, for the sake of inciting argument, automatically brings an appeal to emotion into the argument that need not be there, and will end up spoiling it, in the end.

"I really respect Person X, and believe in what s/he does. Person P's site against Person X is nothing more than slander, libel, and defamation! I am offended that you would use such base tactics to attack someone who is doing so much good!"

See all the emotional appeals in there? And so many fronts to defend at once! Instead, in my opinion, we could have had just as meaningful and interesting a discussion (if not more so) had the OP rather said: "I have seen your SB site, and am curious as to how you defend your position when attacked by 'the faithful.' I propose a mock-debate, therefore, and will take the position of the SB Believer, so we can see this play out."

Man, I would have been on that like white on rice!

Now I just feel stupid, and lied-to. And gee....maybe even a bit more cynical.
Maybe, as it did play out, this was a good exercise. Maybe I needed that extra cynicism. I think I've just discovered that a certain amount of cynicism is necessary to the skeptic, and is not a particularly bad thing.

So, I think the next time someone bleats about how cynical I am (or we are), I'll just smile, knowingly. Thanks. :cool:
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, but anyone that plays a practical joke and spins it on and on despite being repeatedly called on it, is a total and utter cock.
 
You knowingly and intentionally accused an upstanding man of crimes he didn't commit? In public? For entertainment purposes? Right before making hundreds of people angry? In America?

You're not very smart, are you?

Let's try to remember that this is a public internet forum. This should be a nice wake up call for some people, myself included.

We shouldn't feel 'stupid' and 'lied to', we should feel a smidge silly for letting a random internet post get us all worked up in the first place. Nobody needs an apology from some random internet guy gettin' his jollies in a single forum post. It's not that big of a deal. Anyways, that's just how I look at it.
 
Let's try to remember that this is a public internet forum. This should be a nice wake up call for some people, myself included.

We shouldn't feel 'stupid' and 'lied to', we should feel a smidge silly for letting a random internet post get us all worked up in the first place. Nobody needs an apology from some random internet guy gettin' his jollies in a single forum post. It's not that big of a deal. Anyways, that's just how I look at it.
I'm not worked up about it. We live in a pretty litigious society. For my part, I wouldn't admit to anything like that openly. It might seem like fun, but remember that pissing off someone with a big purse is likely to hurt. Bad. And we're not as anonymous on the internet as everyone seems to think they are.
 
I've known enough people like SR to feel very badly for him. This stunt really speaks more to his lack of character than any sterling quality he might be trying to find in himself. I believe that the Forum has shown itself to be what it is, a marvelous place to discuss all ideas.

Leave SR to wax in his insignificance. There's (at least) one in every crowd. Sucks to be him, really.
 
There's nothing to feel bad about. People posted in this thread for many reasons. I became a part of it because someone I believe in was being mistreated.

I've said this in another thread, but let's help everyone, let's defend ourselves and our friends, let's educate regardless of our perception of the situation. This time, it turned out to be a hoax. Honestly that doesn't injure me at all that some kid is getting a laugh out of all this.

I'm going to keep on helping, doing my small part. I will have (and do have) a fulfilling life in no small part because of what I learn and what I can contribute here. If someone wants to get a laugh at my expense, if that really makes them feel good for a while, it doesn't matter to me - they don't matter to me. I'll keep on helping and they can go right on being a douche.

Again, don't feel bad. People pull these stunts to make us think twice about helping people. They only win if we stop. I can't hear him laughing. Can you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom