(reposting this as it got split)
My dear lovely people,
You’ve been had. I admit I have not read the entire thread, but I think I get the gist, so on this basis I now venture my humble opinion in the form of an address.
Dear SilviaRox/Gary/Fred/whateveryournameis:
You are not a troll… more of an imp. You have been ‘lurking’ on these forums for a while. You are intelligent enough to discern the general formulas of typical rabid woo/skeptic arguments, along the lines of
1 rabid woo makes silly, unfounded claims.
2 nice serious skeps make lots of requests for evidence, other skeps make amusing comments with healthy dollops of sarcasm
3 woo ignores and gets more and more irrational,
4 skeps pick out logical flaws, mistakes, errors, falsehoods etc and continue evidence requests
5 woo ignores and gets more and more irrational
6 skeps try to give woo a crash course in logic / scientific method
7 woo ignores and gets more and more irrational,
8 skeps repeat stage (4)
9 woo either (a) insults everyone and leaves, or (b) begins at (1) again.
10 in the case of (a) - skeps rightfully declare victory but can’t shake the nagging feeling that it hasn’t made any difference and was a colossal waste of time. In the case of (b) – skeps begin at (2) again, but can’t shake the nagging feeling that it won’t make any difference and will doubtless be a colossal waste of time.
So SR, as you have a lot of spare time on your hands, you decided to tinker with the formula. Create something different! Something interesting! Something that to all intents and purposes defies the laws of physics! So you created a rabid woo character to pick a fight on an incredibly popular issue – viz, ol’ Silvia. There are a lot of threads on her, (most of which consist of people agreeing with each other), so you knew you’d get a massive reaction. So you followed the steps above for a while (and very well, too – I loved the obsessing on the German thing and other nitpicks and then these huge unfounded assertions in the same sentence, the contradictions, the complete lack of logic, the inconsistencies… it was a stellar performance!)
But… you wanted more than just a biiiig reaction, you wanted to properly [rule 8] with the skeps a bit. So, cackling with glee, you had SR actually change his mind and see reason! Now, this is something that just does NOT happen! Woos like SRs just don’t do that. It’s not in their nature. To paraphrase Robert Sheckley: it would be the equivalent of finding a palm tree growing in Antarctica, and upon examination, discovering that its fruit are not coconuts, but granny smith apples.
To put it mildly, this confused a lot of people. The thread became this great pulsating creature, with tendrils leading into various emotions and theories – “Have we succeeded?” “Has reason won out?” “Something’s wrong here…” “What’s the motivation?” “Kittens?” “Oh, good, he’s getting it, we may have a convert here” – and much, much more. (I think… cos I haven’t read it all!)
AND NOW… drunk on power and influence, you’re changing SR slowly back to rabid woo again. How many times will you manage to flip him again I wonder.
You’re a truly great man. Or boy? Or bored student? A ghastly hybrid of both perhaps? Anyway, it doesn’t matter. You’ve had something like 1300 responses so far, dogknowshowmany views, and no sign of slowing down. You’ve created a mini universe. Wonderful stuff. You have affected hundreds of lives, created a myriad of conflicting feelings, a thousand arguments. Trillions of neurons of which you normally would have no control over have responded… to you! You are the hub. You control all.
You are a God.
Cheers
D