Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

I'm not worked up about it. We live in a pretty litigious society. For my part, I wouldn't admit to anything like that openly. It might seem like fun, but remember that pissing off someone with a big purse is likely to hurt. Bad. And we're not as anonymous on the internet as everyone seems to think they are.

Anyone set to bring up a lawsuit over any of these posts here has way bigger problems than SR does, in my opinion. Talk about silly. Again - it's a public internet forum, people - let's keep a little perspective, eh? Why keep playing this out exactly how he anticipated? Get a chuckle, or hell, even be all miffed if ya gots to, but then just let it slide on off the front page and be done with it. People like that are a dime a dozen on the intarweb. I'm sure this wasn't the first post like this, and it won't be the last.

Or keep it rolling I guess, don't really make no nevermind to me. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm off to Entertainment section!
 
Last edited:
Seriously now, at first it was funny, then it was exasperating, now it is verging on annoying. I think it is time to stop playing footsie with Speide Bahl SylviaRox and get back to more interesting things.
 
For what it's worth, SR's explanation of his behaviour:
I had been inspired to start the thread by a video I had seen on the internet: it was a late 60s documentary on Scientology, and I was very impressed by their "always attack, never defend" tactics, and also their professed outrage at any accusations against them. I wanted to try the tactics out.
doesn't match his actual behaviour. Can you imagine a scientologist attack dog reconsidering (or pretending to reconsider) his position in the face of calls for evidence and well-argued explanations the way he did? Had he actually used "always attack, never defend" tactics in this thread it would have been way shorter. SR's 'explanation' is no more genuine than his original post.
 
I would rather be the person that bought the brooklyn bridge than the person who sold it.

Will Rogers.

I suppose SR can go back to other scams, writting computer worms, etc.

glenn

Robert: as always...you have the high ground...thanks again for being part of this forum.
 
For what it's worth, SR's explanation of his behaviour:

doesn't match his actual behaviour. Can you imagine a scientologist attack dog reconsidering (or pretending to reconsider) his position in the face of calls for evidence and well-argued explanations the way he did? Had he actually used "always attack, never defend" tactics in this thread it would have been way shorter. SR's 'explanation' is no more genuine than his original post.

It matches the initial behaviour though. The turnaround may not have been planned.

Anyway, as others have said, this is a public, anonymous internet forum. People are going to do this. There are a lot of people who have time on their hands, have maybe had a few drinks, and fancy creating a bit of chaos. The more seriously you take it, the greater their amusement will be. I know, because I was a bored student once, and I used to wind up the hippies on the legalise weed forums. I quickly grew out of it (it got old after a couple of days actually), and whoever SR is will probably do the same. There is no 'motivation' as such - it's just one of the many dumb yet kind of funny things that young people do. Like getting drunk and waking up naked, clutching a traffic cone, in a police station with some dread shouting "jailor! get me out of here!" in the next cell along.

Minus the police station bit.

And talk of lawsuits is just... ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
No, it's an assertion of ass-kicking...

Therein lies the reason for the assertion...

Hmmm. As far back as post #701, doubts were already being expressed as to the true identity and intention of the poster "SylviaRox". If not by me, at least by a few others before me, notably Conspi. Maybe we got the identity wrong, but the falsehood was already being detected at that stage.

But please! Do take the credit! Any ass-kicking of a troll is a good ass-kicking!
 
Hmmm. As far back as post #701, doubts were already being expressed as to the true identity and intention of the poster "SylviaRox". If not by me, at least by a few others before me, notably Conspi. Maybe we got the identity wrong, but the falsehood was already being detected at that stage.

But please! Do take the credit! Any ass-kicking of a troll is a good ass-kicking!

It's not the detection of the falsehood, it's my approach that kicked ass... intuiting the murky depths of the human soul... I journeyed into the heart of darkness and returned, gasping for air... but I got my man.

Like Dutch-boy from "The Shield". :D
 
Seriously now, at first it was funny, then it was exasperating, now it is verging on annoying. I think it is time to stop playing footsie with Speide Bahl SylviaRox and get back to more interesting things.
Hi H -

Gotta disagree with you here a bit.

This is NOT a trivial matter, not by a long shot. Any hashing out of this entire affair should be done right here in the thread that began it all. Anyone who feels this incident needs to be completely hashed out - c'mon in! The water's fine.

Some points:

1. This person SylviaRox is seriously lacking in humanity skills, empathy, decency and the holding of an attitude of general respect for people. He and/or she, for motives currently obscure, deliberately came to the JREF forum and decided to lie his and/or her ass off. For "amusement" and "entertainment". Let's not mince words: This is a despicable individual. A deceiver, a person who derives some kind of pleasure from conning people. Many here went out on a limb to support and defend him and/or her, and were rewarded by a swift kick to the family jewels from this disgusting person. SR took advantage of the kind and accommodating natures of valued members of the JREF forum.

2. Some JREF regulars - and I'll use myself as the example - were ridiculed and insulted by other JREF regulars simply for doing what this site should be known for: Hardnosed skepticism. That if you come to the JREF forum and float an incredulous topic, whatever it may cover: You are going to face a withering gauntlet from at least some members. I got nailed for it, and I resented that reaction quite a bit more than whatever this troll was spewing. When I saw the OP and had the usual initial reaction, I then began scrolling through the multitude of responses. I stopped when I encountered the love-in posts from member after member, directed at SR. What?!? I pasted the OP into Notepad, shut down JREF for awhile, and went through that OP with a fine-toothed comb. Then returned and posted some of my conclusions. I never expected to be attacked by JREFers but that's exactly what happened. SR had to have been laughing his and/or her depraved ass off at that.

3. The influence that a prominent JREF member can have over others here was interesting to see. I'm speaking of the esteemed RSL, of course. His insistence - oft-repeated - that SylviaRox was on the up-and-up definitely rallied many JREFers to the support of SR. And yet RSL was wrong. Classy gentleman that he is - he admitted it right here. The lesson is that anyone can be wrong. RSL. James Randi. You. Me. Most of us attempt to be less wrong as we navigate through life, but it's a treacherous route. All of us can be tripped up. So if you get an initial impression, and your follow-through research augments that impression - perhaps sticking to your guns is exactly the correct approach. Sometimes a "fresh eyes" approach to a situation may reveal one or more critical items that escaped the scrutiny of everyone else.
 
Hey, ConspiRaider, time for me to disagree with you a little bit. :)

3. The influence that a prominent JREF member can have over others here was interesting to see. I'm speaking of the esteemed RSL, of course. His insistence - oft-repeated - that SylviaRox was on the up-and-up definitely rallied many JREFers to the support of SR. And yet RSL was wrong. Classy gentleman that he is - he admitted it right here.
First, I disagree with both "classy" and "gentleman," but I'll let that pass...

But, while I'm wrong at least as often as the next guy, was I wrong here?

In my first post in the thread, I said:

Mr. Richardson:

Although I find it difficult to believe that your post is not a parody, I will take you at your word that it is not, and will respond to your points.

And in a subsequent post:

SylviaRox has stated that he is not playing a role here, and until such time that hard evidence shows otherwise, I choose to believe him.

To my way of thinking, whether his stated position was real or not has no bearing on how it should be answered. Because whether it is his true opinion or not, our response to it can help others who read the thread, and who may actually be of similar opinions themselves.

I was well aware of the high probability that trolling was going on. But I chose to treat the post as legit, both on the off-chance that it was, but more for others who would read the thread.

Was I wrong to have done so? Maybe.

And if my treatment of SR's posts as legit caused others to believe he was, my apologies.

The lesson is that anyone can be wrong. RSL. James Randi. You. Me. Most of us attempt to be less wrong as we navigate through life, but it's a treacherous route. All of us can be tripped up. So if you get an initial impression, and your follow-through research augments that impression - perhaps sticking to your guns is exactly the correct approach.
Yup. And I think that's what I did.

To be clear, I am not advocating that everyone else should have taken the approach I did. I think that your (and others') pointing out SR's inconsistencies was a necessary thing. I've done the same in other threads, on other subjects. But it was not my role here, as I saw it anyway.
 
Robert, I think a great many posters on this thread will have overlooked these important words
Although I find it difficult to believe that your post is not a parody, I will take you at your word that it is not, and will respond to your points.
If they weren't overlooked, they were quickly forgotten.
A salutary lesson to us all. I think many may have looked to your authority rather than your words.
 
I failed to see the motivation behind the OP and for that I've learned something. I couldn't see an angle but I didn't look at SR doing it solely for SR's purpose. Interesting, and hopefully a mistake I won't make again. I also just let things go with this dismissal. Why bother put my neck on the line when ConspiRaider is? Also curious and something I should learn from.

But make no mistake, I don't think these things, nor the good things about this post, turn anything SR did positive. This was a purely selfish act by a very small person. The end result did have some very nice things about it, but that doesn't say anything about SR. Also, if it has made a few people a bit more cynical, then it also has some negatives that can't be brushed off.
 
It matches the initial behaviour though. The turnaround may not have been planned.

Anyway, as others have said, this is a public, anonymous internet forum. People are going to do this. There are a lot of people who have time on their hands, have maybe had a few drinks, and fancy creating a bit of chaos. The more seriously you take it, the greater their amusement will be. I know, because I was a bored student once, and I used to wind up the hippies on the legalise weed forums. I quickly grew out of it (it got old after a couple of days actually), and whoever SR is will probably do the same. There is no 'motivation' as such - it's just one of the many dumb yet kind of funny things that young people do. Like getting drunk and waking up naked, clutching a traffic cone, in a police station with some dread shouting "jailor! get me out of here!" in the next cell along.

Minus the police station bit.

And talk of lawsuits is just... ridiculous.

Indeed, my turnaround into a skeptic was more to keep the thread alive, and to observe the resulting dynamics. L. Ron, my hero, never would have done it.

As far as all of those who are saying that I have made some people more cynical, or that I have had some sort of negative influence, I think that's just silly. No one is going to be significantly influenced in their behavior by this thread, and if they are, it will only be for a short while.

Second of all, if I honestly thought this would hurt RSL's cause I never would have done it, and I don't feel it has. He's a nice guy, but maybe if I had Scientology's resources I really could have gotten some dirt on him. I am hardly some sick monster lacking humanity.
 
It's not the detection of the falsehood, it's my approach that kicked ass... intuiting the murky depths of the human soul... I journeyed into the heart of darkness and returned, gasping for air... but I got my man.

Like Dutch-boy from "The Shield". :D

I am an appreciator of fine literature, and dogjones' had just the right tone, vocabulary usage and insight into human psychology. Bravo, sir.

And you, ConspiRaider, could have come up with nothing of the sort. You merely grunted, moaned and drooled throughout the thread, and are now sick with jealousy because you didn't get the laurel of exposing me on your head. For shame. For shame.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom