Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

In that case, let's ratchet this up a notch.
Uh oh...
72367b567faec3e7c6be95e9f006d83d.gif
 
My God, I made it.

Now, after the warm-up, on to the rest of "175 did NOT hit the South Tower"....

Rolfe.
 
What??? When did this happen??? Why was my permission not sought??? What is this rash??? Why three question marks???

Sorry, the cult of Randi had a meeting and you were not available to skype in. We tried.

We also renamed you "CuddlesTheSpider."

You will recieve proper notice through the usual shill channels.
 
:jaw-dropp Holy crap, we started off trying to stop Robert and ended up stopping fowlsound instead. What other madness lies in store?
 
From both the post which Moufflon just quoted, and from a PM which I received from Rox, I am convinced that he no longer believes either of those things. SR apologized for his OP both in public (as was just quoted) as well as privately to me in a PM.

I appreciate the support of me implicit in your question, but this is no longer an issue for me, so I hope it is no longer an issue for anyone else.


I agree that it is hard to reconcile the OP - and SR's user name - with things he said later in the thread, but it makes sense to me given a few things:

1. As he said here, and clarified to me in a PM: his anger, which he vented in my direction, was really inspired by others. He never gave specifics, but I think it is safe to say that he felt that skeptics/cynics had in the past unfairly attacked either him or something in which he strongly believes. So when he saw the SSB site (or perhaps, read descriptions of it on SB-friendly boards), he assumed it was doing the same thing - unfairly attacking spiritual beliefs. This outraged him, and, in the heat of the moment, without actually checking out my site, he decided to do something about its supposed unfairness by making his displeasure known here.

2. Based on the first sentence in the OP, he evidently assumed his post (and probably his account) was going to be deleted soon after he started the thread, so he wanted to make as big a splash as possible before his account and his OP were erased. I think this could explain the user name, even though he later stated he wasn't particularly knowledgeable about SB. He knew it was a name that would draw attention to the thread.

Fortunately, he didn't get the treatment here that he evidently expected. His guns-a-blazing OP was met - for the most part - with calm and rational statements and requests for evidence to back up his accusations.

I think that reaction spoke volumes about the denizens of this forum.

And I think that SR's apologies, both public and private, speak volumes about him.

WEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!! I got quoted by RSL! How cool is that!!! LOL!!
Mr. Lancaster has also fully answered all the questions I asked.
This thread has been very interesting to say the least!
 
Since I read it all, I think I can make a few observations. Gary seems to have gone, which is a pity, but he did say this wasn't somewhere he wanted to spend time long term, so fair enough.

I think his OP was sincere, and I also believe him that it was banged out in a hurry. It had the feel of the indignation of someone who had only just heard about this evil slanderer and wanted to get his feelings off his chest RIGHT NOW. I don't believe he had read much of the StopSylvia web site before posting, and his opinions were mainly formed by what he'd been told by others. I also don't believe (and I think he confirmed this) that he'd looked at the StopKaz site at all, but was merely adding it into the evidence against Robert as he saw it.

His defence of Sylvia was also based almost entirely on what others had told him. She's right more often than she's wrong. She has an 85% success rate. Gary had no evidence for that at all, he was merely repeating what he'd been told.

What was very heartening was to see that he was prepared to look at evidence when he was encouraged to do so, and if he's taken anything at all from this, I hope it will be an attitude of "do I know for myself that this is true?" before spouting off on other subjects.

It was interesting that he really seemed to believe that his OP would be deleted, hence an element of "retaliate first". Woo sites of all hues seem to do this with monotonous regularity, so if he's been frequenting these, I can see how he'd get that impression. The fact that it wasn't, nor was the discussion censored, seems to have impressed him quite a lot, and I hope he thinks about that.

By the way, I heard about Claus's favourite person, Susan Blackmore, outside this forum for the first time the other day. She was being interviewed, and one thing she said which really struck me was that she'd been a woo and she'd been a sceptic, and it was very striking to her that it's the woos who send the hate mail. Sceptics don't. When she was a woo she never had a sceptic come up to her and insult her, now she's on the sceptical side, she gets hate mail all the time. Attitudes can count for a lot, so keep up the good work chaps.

What was sad was Gary's self-righteous posturing about how people were being rude to him, all the while he was being equally if not more rude to posters here, including blanket insults and insults to posters who had never been rude to him. The later, his equally self-righteous posturing about always trying to give people the benefit of the doubt and thinking the best of them - that after his appalling knee-jerk spew of false accusations against Robert! I hope he thinks about these contradictions later, when he's considering the whole issue.

I'm especially sad to hear about anyone who "believes" in something they don't necessarily think is true, just because they "need" to. Believe in God, or Christ, or Mohammed, or Buddha, because you are prepared to take the leap of faith that there is a reality behind these concepts. Because if there isn't, and you're only "believing" in a hollow way because you can't face the alternative but have no real concept of a truth in what you believe - well, I can't think of anything sadder.

I wish Gary well. He seems like basically a nice enough chap, if a bit hair-trigger and prone to believe too much nonsense just because somebody told him that. I hope he's learned something from all this, and it would be nice if he came back occasionally.

Rolfe.

PS. "Gary Richardson" is a high-profile BBC sports commentator, a regular on both TV and radio in this country. Which doesn't mean it isn't also SylviaRox's real name, just an observation.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, the cult of Randi had a meeting and you were not available to skype in. We tried.

We also renamed you "CuddlesTheSpider."

You will recieve proper notice through the usual shill channels.
The UK contingent have proposed "Boris the Spider".

(Who? You Say?)
 
For whatever it's worth -- perhaps nothing -- if you Google "Robert Lancaster," this thread shows up on the front page. No big deal, unless you consider that the title of this thread is pretty explicit: "Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne."

Let's say I were of a rather paranoid bent. I could imagine some SB acolyte starting a thread and choosing as its title an actual message intended to hurt RL and make Sylvia Browne look like the victim, in an attempt to mitigate or diminish RL's effectiveness. I can imagine the OP of that thread containing a lot of unsubstantiated attacks on RL. I can imagine the person starting that thread to keep the discussion going by arguing endlessly about extremely trivial and irrelevant points, such as what exactly it means to "speak English." After the thread has gone on for a while, I can imagine the poster eventually retracting many of his original claims, to lull the forum into a false sense of security. At the end, there would be a thread that pops up near the top of a Google search on "Robert Lancaster." In that search would be a complete, unambiguous sentence that claims RL is slandering Sylvia Browne. Following that link brings up the OP, which unchallenged is very damaging to RL's reputation.

Unless someone goes through the trouble of actually reading this very. very long thread -- and I suspect few would -- the overall result is a hatchet job on RL. And we, the members of the JREF forum, for all our politeness to Sylviarox and well-reasoned and passionate defense of RL, have helped make this thread very, very Google-visible.

I'm not saying this was all part of SR's plan. But I agree with sentiments some others have expressed, that something here just seems...I don't know, not quite right.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom