Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Now that this thread appears to be done, I would just like to invest my 2 cents.
I have read this entire thread. I have come to the conclusion that either this SR person is a super troll or has no idea which way is up.
First off "he" comes storming through the door making very hateful, very specific charges against RSL. "He" then spouts off all kinds of very specific things defending Sylvia Browne. Going as far as naming "himself" Sylviarox.

"He" then states "he" never really believed in Sylvia Browne to begin with and said all those things about RSL because "he" thought RSL was saying something with his SSB site he really wasn't.
That doesn't make any sense at all!
How could someone come in and start an OP like that without really believing anything that the OP stated?
Now there have been pages of this thread devoted to praising SR for "his" turn around of "his" beliefs. But how can you turn around in your beliefs you never really had to begin with?
Again doesn't make any sense.
SR has never bothered to even read the SSB site. Other than one part of one article about a 30 sec "reading" Sylvia gave some German guy in 1989.
Now many here will state the OP no longer merits mentioning because SR as recanted that statement. But how can you recant a statement you never really meant or believed in in the first place?
The only conclusion I can reach from that is SR wanted to attack something that "he" knew would draw lots of people into the thread. Why?
Doesn't make any sense.
After SR had pulled said people into the thread "he" then began to dictate what would and would not be a subject for discussion. How people were to address their questions to "him" and if said questions were not addressed to "his" standards then "he" would no longer discuss anything with that poster. Once again why?
Doesn't make any sense at all.
If this person was not a super troll then they wanted needed or something the attention of as many people "he" could gather all focused on "him".
Why?
One very positive aspect of this thread has been that not one other poster out of 32 pages of post came in to say anything negative about RSL or his SSB site. But then again that would be like complaining about the sky being blue or grass being green. Which brings home my entire point. Why come in swinging when you know from the get go that there is nothing to swing at?
Doesn't make any sense at all!
 
That's fair enough, Brattus. But two things:

Firstly, does it matter entirely what SyviaRox's intentions were? The thread stands as it does. Slander was met with evidence; bad faith with empirical documentation. I cherish the moment that it was revealed that RSL actually helped Heather on beating the spam on her site! Priceless. And SR retracted his claims, without qualification. This thread did not ramble or degenerate into name calling.

Secondly, and colour me naive if you like, but people do change, and their beliefs change. Otherwise, what is this JREF forum for? What is RSL's site for? Not wholly or even primarily for people who already know that SB is a fraud, surely. And the sort of quick change in chinking makes good cognitive sense to me; RSL had provided evidence of it from his own correspondence. It does happen. Occassionally. Isn't that why PastBrowneFan, TBT, SK, angrybeliever are here?

Perhaps -- perhaps -- SylviaRox will re-emerge as SylviaSux. Who knows?

I still think this thread should be on some sort of plinth. It's mainly why I stopped lurking and learned to love the post.

Cheers,
Moufflon
 
Firstly, does it matter entirely what SyviaRox's intentions were? The thread stands as it does. Slander was met with evidence; bad faith with empirical documentation. I cherish the moment that it was revealed that RSL actually helped Heather on beating the spam on her site! Priceless. And SR retracted his claims, without qualification.

Did he? Although he retracted some specific accusations, I don't ever recall him retracting the actual subject of the thread: Robert Lancaster is slandering Syliva Browne and should be stopped.

At one point, he basically stated he wouldn't comment on that (undecided or something like that). So, although I agree that his positions seemed to have changed at least in regards to certain specifics, I have never seen a retraction of the original general accusation that was the subject of the thread.

My question remains: Does SR think that RSL is slandering Sylvia Browne and that he should be stopped?
 
This is what SyviaRox said:

1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.


Note no. 7 - RSL's "investigations", not "slanderous accusations". I think that's pretty darn close, IMHO.
 
Last edited:
And SR retracted his claims, without qualification.

That is not so.

His retraction was very qualified (no apologies), and even included several points on which he wasn't willing to budge. After being presented with the evidence against even those remaining points, SR basically moved on and refused to engage in further debate those points (notably, RL's statement that everyone in the audience spoke English).

I didn't push the issue of a public apology to RL, but I do think that would have been entirely appropriate. My main reason for letting that alone was that RL mentioned that he and SR had exchanged private messages, so I assume that part was worked out. Still, the wild accusations of the OP were public, so I do believe it is an entirely public matter.
 
That is not so.

His retraction was very qualified (no apologies)

Eh?

1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

I agree that Sr could have grovelled some more, given the absolute virulence of his OP. I take the existence of some apologies, at any rate, as something fairly positive, and quite rare.

ETA: "without qualification" is probably too strong, I agree. Retractions in general are pretty unusual, though, wouldn't you say?
 
Last edited:
My question remains: Does SR think that RSL is slandering Sylvia Browne and that he should be stopped?

From both the post which Moufflon just quoted, and from a PM which I received from Rox, I am convinced that he no longer believes either of those things. SR apologized for his OP both in public (as was just quoted) as well as privately to me in a PM.

I appreciate the support of me implicit in your question, but this is no longer an issue for me, so I hope it is no longer an issue for anyone else.

How could someone come in and start an OP like that without really believing anything that the OP stated?
I agree that it is hard to reconcile the OP - and SR's user name - with things he said later in the thread, but it makes sense to me given a few things:

1. As he said here, and clarified to me in a PM: his anger, which he vented in my direction, was really inspired by others. He never gave specifics, but I think it is safe to say that he felt that skeptics/cynics had in the past unfairly attacked either him or something in which he strongly believes. So when he saw the SSB site (or perhaps, read descriptions of it on SB-friendly boards), he assumed it was doing the same thing - unfairly attacking spiritual beliefs. This outraged him, and, in the heat of the moment, without actually checking out my site, he decided to do something about its supposed unfairness by making his displeasure known here.

2. Based on the first sentence in the OP, he evidently assumed his post (and probably his account) was going to be deleted soon after he started the thread, so he wanted to make as big a splash as possible before his account and his OP were erased. I think this could explain the user name, even though he later stated he wasn't particularly knowledgeable about SB. He knew it was a name that would draw attention to the thread.

Fortunately, he didn't get the treatment here that he evidently expected. His guns-a-blazing OP was met - for the most part - with calm and rational statements and requests for evidence to back up his accusations.

I think that reaction spoke volumes about the denizens of this forum.

And I think that SR's apologies, both public and private, speak volumes about him.
 
From both the post which Moufflon just quoted, and from a PM which I received from Rox, I am convinced that he no longer believes either of those things. SR apologized for his OP both in public (as was just quoted) as well as privately to me in a PM.

I appreciate the support of me implicit in your question, but this is no longer an issue for me, so I hope it is no longer an issue for anyone else.

1. As he said here, and clarified to me in a PM: his anger, which he vented in my direction, was really inspired by others.
======
2. Based on the first sentence in the OP, he evidently assumed his post (and probably his account) was going to be deleted soon after he started the thread, so he wanted to make as big a splash as possible before his account and his OP were erased.
======
I think that reaction spoke volumes about the denizens of this forum.

And I think that SR's apologies, both public and private, speak volumes about him.
Well played, RSL. :) *claps*

For a mega thread, there was much goodness to be had here, for both participants and lurkers.

I am reminded of a variation on an old saying:

"The thread has ended, go in peace."

Or, maybe it was

"The thread has ended, go get a pizza!"

I forget. Blame it on Rio.

DR
 
I think the thread should be placed in the repository for the reasons DR stated.

Lisa..... is it possible?



Boo
 
I'd love for Sylvia Browne to visit this forum. We know that she never will.M.

While we know she will never be here - her nails wouldn't let herclose enough to the keyboard to type - we are sure that her cronnies are in here daily - probably several times a day - and are not only reading but copying every post that has anything to do with SB and SNS. So SB is fully aware of what's being said - and what information is being made public. They wouldn't dare NOT tell her.

ST
 
I made it!

Yesss!!!! I made it!! :yahoo

I finally caught up with this thread, after having read 1291 posts.....!!

Now, where can I collect the t-shirt with "I survived reading the entire Stop RL Slanderer of SB thread!"?

.... hey, that's funny... my monitor is falling sideways.... :faint:
 
While we know she will never be here - her nails wouldn't let herclose enough to the keyboard to type - we are sure that her cronnies are in here daily - probably several times a day - and are not only reading but copying every post that has anything to do with SB and SNS. So SB is fully aware of what's being said - and what information is being made public. They wouldn't dare NOT tell her.

ST

In that case, let's ratchet this up a notch.


It is my opinion that Sylvia Browne is cowardly, slimy and morally bankrupt. Also, I believe she is guilty of plagiarizing from Joe Nickell of CSICOP. I think she has never had an original thought in her life, and has stolen whatever she wishes from every aspect of new age philosophies, and doesn't care one bit about who she hurts with her scam.

I believe she should be charged with fraud in any instance where she has charged for a phone reading. I believe she should be charged with practicing medicine without a license every time she gives bogus medical advice, and I believe she has the appearance, demeanor and ethics of the worst kind of double-wide trailer trash whore -- and I would pay the double-wide trailer trash whore more money to lick my feces from the floor than I would for Sylvia to do so.

I think Sylvia is an affront to every grieving parent with a missing child, every grieving family with a missing family member, and any law enforcement officer with even minimal brain function. I believe the next time she throws out bogus medical advice she should be taken to the nearest hospital and have her tongue surgically removed from her mouth, and grafted to her anus.

All of this is my opinion, not the JREF's, nor do I represent the JREF in any way.

Come get me, Sylvia. You cowardly slimeball of a sloth. My name is David Federlein, and I am not afraid of a two bit hack with a voice like a chainsaw and the brainpower of a dripping paper bag full of dogpoop.

Bring it on, you cow.
 
In that case, let's ratchet this up a notch.


It is my opinion that Sylvia Browne is cowardly, slimy and morally bankrupt. Also, I believe she is guilty of plagiarizing from Joe Nickell of CSICOP. I think she has never had an original thought in her life, and has stolen whatever she wishes from every aspect of new age philosophies, and doesn't care one bit about who she hurts with her scam.

I believe she should be charged with fraud in any instance where she has charged for a phone reading. I believe she should be charged with practicing medicine without a license every time she gives bogus medical advice, and I believe she has the appearance, demeanor and ethics of the worst kind of double-wide trailer trash whore -- and I would pay the double-wide trailer trash whore more money to lick my feces from the floor than I would for Sylvia to do so.

I think Sylvia is an affront to every grieving parent with a missing child, every grieving family with a missing family member, and any law enforcement officer with even minimal brain function. I believe the next time she throws out bogus medical advice she should be taken to the nearest hospital and have her tongue surgically removed from her mouth, and grafted to her anus.

All of this is my opinion, not the JREF's, nor do I represent the JREF in any way.

Come get me, Sylvia. You cowardly slimeball of a sloth. My name is David Federlein, and I am not afraid of a two bit hack with a voice like a chainsaw and the brainpower of a dripping paper bag full of dogpoop.

Bring it on, you cow.
how did you ever manage to contain yourself so
 
Just to be clear:

Doublewide trailer trash whores at least deliver on the deal when you pay them. Sylvia does not. This would make them more ethical than sylvia.

I may have been hasty in my charactarization of doublewide trailer trash whores in my rant. Comparing them to Sylvia may have been insulting to them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom