Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

No Lisa. That is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that the man did not speak English in the sense that he would be considered an English-speaker. In other words, he could not know whether Sylvia was right or wrong in her predictions.


You are clearly displaying your bias.

what sylvia said:

Sylvia Browne:And they were all German, and they couldn't understand one word I said. And that was a setup, as you well know.

....

Jaroff: Therefore you could elicit no information from them, for that reason.

Browne: Because they couldn't speak English. I found that afterwards They were all Germanic. That was the funniest part.

Now, theres evidence that she did speak to ONE german man, and you keep harping on it as though she did not speak to two other people who spoke english fluently and were not noticably german (no accents). This seems to be the important thing that you are missing here. Even if one person from the audience was german, and even if that guy didnt speak english (and he did speak some english, just not fluently), sylvia would still be wrong because she claimed ALL the audience members were german and could not speak english or understand her.
 
Last edited:
SylviaRox, RSL has asked many times, both on this site, his site and on other sites, for people to provide him with the best cases they have of Sylvia's successes. Perhaps you could help out by forwarding any information you have in this vein to him?

You can discuss the same cases here, if you like, but I know for a fact that RSL will publish any information he gets about Sylvia providing a correct reading. He is determined to keep his site balanced, and to allow people to draw their own conclusions, and has been generous on the side of Sylvia in some cases - which is why some of the posters here are so defensive. He could not be more fair, in many people's opinions.
 
No, he only spoke enough to say that he doesn't know how to speak English. He was exclusively a German speaker. Lancaster lied and said that he spoke English.

My sister-in-law knew about 10 words of English when she came to America, but she knew how to say she doesn't speak English well. I WOULD HARDLY HAVE SAID SHE SPOKE ENGLISH.

So, we are supposed to believe you when you say he couldn't understand her? Or believe him when he said he could understand.

And that is besides the fact that Sylvia's claim was that they were all german and none spoke a word of english.

You are grossly wrong, and even wrong on the one little nitpick you are attempting to make. Even if you were correct in your little nitpick, you would still be grossly wrong.
 
You skeptics, you people who constantly claim that you are being oppressed and assaulted by fundamentalists and new-agers, are the ones who are delusional. Robert Lancaster is a perfect example of this. The man attacks a great spiritual leader because he himself is paranoid and full of self-loathing. He distorts information at any opportunity. The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.

No one has complained except you. We have treated you very civilly.

Answer the questions.
 
He distorts information at any opportunity. The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.

Ok. Show an information he has distorted and lied about. I solemnly swear I - and, I don't doubt it, others - will hound him until he corrects or retracts his statement.

Win me to your cause! Pretty please, with sugar on top!
 
Well, this'll be a project but let's see how far I get.

I am sure an admin will delete this message because it disagrees with the stated goals of the JREF.


The stated goals of JREF are to debate issues of interest. This is an issue of interest and you are debating it. So long as you don't call someone a "cracker," your posts probably won't be deleted.


Robert S. Lancaster has made a hostile and concerted attempt to slander, libel and defame Sylvia Browne.


Sadly for you, I'm a lawyer. Please state the time, place and manner in which Mr. Lancaster slandered, libeled or defamed Ms. Browne and explain how his actions fit the definitions of these torts. Also please state which state's law you are applying and why.


as well as help to police departments


Please state the name of a single police department anywhere in the word that admits that Ms. Browne "helped" in their investigation and describe the date, the investiogation and the "help" Ms. Browne rendered. I will surrender the plural "departjments" that you used and will be satisfied with one and only one example.


Browne's success rate of 85% is ignored


Please describe how this success rate was derived. Simply relying on Ms. Browne's assertion that this is her success rate is insufficient. What cases were used? What counted as a "sucess"? What counted as a "failure"? Has the number been updated? What methodologies were used to blind the study from biases?


Mr. Lancaster, in his sham of a website


Oh, it's a real website. I've been there from multiple computers. One was even on a cruise ship.


every minor error that Browne makes in her prediction. For example: when Sylvia Browne accurately predicted the nature and appearance of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor, he pretended that she had not, and distorted her actual reading to the Hornbecks.


About Sean Hornbeck's abductor, Ms. Browne said, "The--the guy was dark-skinned, although he wasn't black. He was more Hispanic looking, had real long, dark hair. And strange enough, Hispanic, but he had dreadlocks. He was really tall and really--almost like what you think a basketball player's build would be." In fact, the guy was a dumpy, average height white man.

In what way was Ms. Browne's prediction of his appearance accurate? In what way is this direct quote a "distrotion"? And what does it mean to predict someone's "nature"? Anyone who abducts children has got to have a pretty dark nature.


Larry King even SAID that she got it mostly right, but Mr. Randi and Mr. Lancaster have tried to deny it!


I have not seen this quote. When did Larry King make such a statement? Also, why should we care about Larry King's analysis of a psychic's prediction? What special training does Larry King have in determining the truthfulness of a psychic prediction? And isn't the real measure of the value of Ms. Browne's prediction the fact that it in no way aided anyone in actually locating Sean Hornbeck? If psychics can only tell us after the fact how they really were right, what is the value of their readings?


Lancaster's main argument seems to be that because Browne is occasionally un-eloquent in her speech, this means that she somehow had faked a master's degree in literature.


Mr. Lancaster's main argument is that there is no evidence that Ms. Browne has a Master's Degree in Literature. I have a Masters Degree and could have a transcript produced in about three days for about ten dollars. Ms. Browne has not produced such a transcript and the school she says she attended does not appear to exist. If she would like to provide proof of her degree, I swear on my life that Mr. Lancaster will retract his statements and issue an appology.


[QOTE]His other arguments are that because Browne occasionally misses a minor fact (like the hair color of a missing person), she is somehow a fake.[/QUOTE]


Forget minor facts. Please provide one single case of a missing person in which Browne's predictions actually helped solve the case. Just one.


There are thousands of positive testimonials in favor of Browne


I imagine that a dilligent reasercher could collect thousands of testimonials that pedophelia is perfectly normal if he surveyed the right people. How does popularity indicate that a person is correct?


and it is clear from a simple reading of Amazon.com reviews of her books that she has helped INNUMERABLE people.


That some have felt like they've been helped? Yes. I agree that some people believe Browne has helped them. However, why does feeling that one has been helped necessarily mean that one actually has been helped?



Mr. Lancaster has always engaged in a vigorous campaign to attack GoSylviaBrowne.com, a completely innocuous fan website.


Well, it's not a fan website entirely, is it? It is maintained by Syvia's organization.

Lancaster is also a vigorous copyright abuser (posting both clips of Montel's show, transcripts, images of Sylvia, quotes from her books, and the Hay House logo), as noted by Browne's lawyers. Let's hope they pursue this case to the fullest extent of the law and stop Robert S. Lancaster's campaign of terror.


Actually, after some posturing, they retreated into silence. They did so because their position had no merit.


Gary Richardson, admirer of Sylvia Browne


Yeesh. You should look for another hobby.
 
I think your temper may be getting away from you. Perhaps now is a good time to take a breather, and come back to reread what was posted later.

THIS, from fowl?!!!?

*hcmom waits for hell to now freeze over...

 
You skeptics, you people who constantly claim that you are being oppressed and assaulted by fundamentalists and new-agers, are the ones who are delusional. Robert Lancaster is a perfect example of this. The man attacks a great spiritual leader because he himself is paranoid and full of self-loathing. He distorts information at any opportunity. The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.

I know Robert personally, and I can tell you he is not self loathing or paranoid in the least. The fact that he uses his real name on both the stopkaz and ssb site should be enough to show he's not all that paranoid.


Do you have anything other than personal attacks, which you seem to be so fond of claiming we are persecuting you with?
 
Oh please. All you 'skeptics' have done so far is personally attack me and harp on this 85% success rate issue, which has nothing to do with this thread.



More misrepresentation. There are several people who have debunked your claims in detail, with no "personal attacks". And only some of us in this thread are harping on the 85% success rate, one of whom is you.
 
No, he only spoke enough to say that he doesn't know how to speak English. He was exclusively a German speaker. Lancaster lied and said that he spoke English.

My sister-in-law knew about 10 words of English when she came to America, but she knew how to say she doesn't speak English well. I WOULD HARDLY HAVE SAID SHE SPOKE ENGLISH.


Is Robert's statement factually incorrect? Did the man not speak English? Yes or no? Did he only speak German? Yes or no.
 
You skeptics, you people who constantly claim that you are being oppressed and assaulted by fundamentalists and new-agers, are the ones who are delusional. Robert Lancaster is a perfect example of this. The man attacks a great spiritual leader because he himself is paranoid and full of self-loathing. He distorts information at any opportunity. The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.

I see. So, when you cannot provide the tiniest bit of evidence to support your claim, we are all delusional, paranoid, and full of self-loathing?

Beyond pitiful.
 
The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.

You really, really are a funny guy. I don't know how long I could keep up this kind of parody myself.
 
Can someone who speaks German watch that video? At about 3:23 into it, the man says:

I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words.

Can anyone guess the [unintelligible] word?
 
You skeptics, you people who constantly claim that you are being oppressed and assaulted by fundamentalists and new-agers, are the ones who are delusional. Robert Lancaster is a perfect example of this. The man attacks a great spiritual leader because he himself is paranoid and full of self-loathing. He distorts information at any opportunity. The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.

You haven't provided a single piece of evidence that RSL has misrepresented SB. You have demonstrated that you have SB's gift for misdirection.

You stated that SB was 85% right. Prove it.

You stated that SB has helped police departments. Prove it.

You stated that SB described the nature of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor. Prove it.

For example SB clearly said that Shawn Hornbeck was dead. He was not. Is that a) 100% b) 85% or c) 0% correct?
 
You skeptics, you people who constantly claim that you are being oppressed and assaulted by fundamentalists and new-agers, are the ones who are delusional. Robert Lancaster is a perfect example of this. The man attacks a great spiritual leader because he himself is paranoid and full of self-loathing. He distorts information at any opportunity. The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.

I really must take exception with this statement. I've met Robert Lancaster and found him to be full of good humour, compassion and concern for his fellow man. For you to suggest otherwise suggests to me you a talking out of your hat.
 
That really doesn't prove much. I have several friends who read and understands English perfectly, but if you heard them speak English you would not think so. You may have a problem making your lips pronouce the words correctly, which in turn could make you shy to speak at all (especially with a TV camera on you, and a weird woman asking you weird things) doesn't mean you don't understand English well.

Fran
Who doesn't speak English as a first language

Woah -Fran-, I did not make that quote you attribute to me, I merely quoted SilviaRox. I hope it's a mistake that it's attributed to me.
 
Is Robert's statement factually incorrect? Did the man not speak English? Yes or no? Did he only speak German? Yes or no.

The man only spoke a few words, in an attempt to say he couldn't speak the language. So Mr. Lancaster is lying when he says the man spoke English. I cannot get any clearer Lisa. I can say "I cannot speak French" in French (je ne peux pas parler français), but this does NOT mean I can SPEAK FRENCH.
 
I too, have met Robert Lancaster. I would hardly say he is paranoid or full of self-loathing. He's a genuinely nice man.
 
The man only spoke a few words, in an attempt to say he couldn't speak the language. So Mr. Lancaster is lying when he says the man spoke English. I cannot get any clearer Lisa. I can say "I cannot speak French" in French (je ne peux pas parler français), but this does NOT mean I can SPEAK FRENCH.

Did he speak any words in English? YES OR NO?

ETA: Robert did not say "Everyone was a fluent English-speaker." He said that everyone spoke English. There is a difference.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom