Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Again, this thread is NOT about Sylvia Browne's success rate, it is about Lancaster's consistent misinformation campaign[/B against Sylvia Browne.


Unless you can give some hard evidence of Slyvia's success rate, you have no basis for claiming that Robert is misrepresenting her success rate.
 
Yes, I edited my post to make myself more clear.

You are stating that the man from Germany did not speak English at all? If I go watch the video, he will not have said one word in English. Is this your statement?

No Lisa. That is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that the man did not speak English in the sense that he would be considered an English-speaker. In other words, he could not know whether Sylvia was right or wrong in her predictions.
 
No Lisa. That is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that the man did not speak English in the sense that he would be considered an English-speaker. In other words, he could not know whether Sylvia was right or wrong in her predictions.

Do you have evidence he did not understand English?
 
This thread is NOT about Sylvia's legitimacy. It is about Robert Lancaster, and how he distorts information. Mr. Lancaster only just recently posted a video of Browne on a television show. On this show, Browne was asked to do a reading for a German man. This man knew practically NO English. Browne did her best to do the reading. It was impossible to verify whether Browne got her answers right or not. But Mr. Lancaster claims that "All of them spoke English." This is simply not true. Watch the clip. The man only knows how to say he doesn't speak English, but Mr. Lancaster counts this against Browne!?
Found the link. http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml .

You're wrong.

Robert's assessment is both fair and correct.
 
Last edited:
No Lisa. That is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that the man did not speak English in the sense that he would be considered an English-speaker. In other words, he could not know whether Sylvia was right or wrong in her predictions.

Of course he could not, because she told him about something that would happen in the future.. even an American would not be able to say if she was right or wrong.
 
No Lisa. That is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that the man did not speak English in the sense that he would be considered an English-speaker. In other words, he could not know whether Sylvia was right or wrong in her predictions.


No.

You said that Robert is a liar because he said they all spoke English when they did not. Now you must prove that Robert's statement is a lie. No moving the goalposts, please. It is not a question of whether or not the man was an "English-speaker". HE SPOKE ENGLISH. Therefore, Robert's statement was factually true.
 
This thread is NOT about Sylvia's legitimacy. It is about Robert Lancaster, and how he distorts information. Mr. Lancaster only just recently posted a video of Browne on a television show. On this show, Browne was asked to do a reading for a German man. This man knew practically NO English. Browne did her best to do the reading. It was impossible to verify whether Browne got her answers right or not. But Mr. Lancaster claims that "All of them spoke English." This is simply not true. Watch the clip. The man only knows how to say he doesn't speak English, but Mr. Lancaster counts this against Browne!?


You obviously havent actually read the website. lol.

heres the link:

http://stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml

the break down is basically like this-

Sylvia browne: that show was a set up! all the audience members were from germany and spoke almost not english!

RSL then goes on to PROVIDE VIDEO CLIPS FROM THE SHOW illustrating that there was one man she talked to on camera who had trouble with english, there is video footage showing her talking to two other people who speak english just fine without any sort of accent.

and NO WHERE does rsl assert everyone spoke english just fine, in fact he notes specifically that they cannot know how much of the audience was german or english speaking outside of the minority of audience members who got to speak on camera.

in conclusion, you really couldnt be MORE WRONG about this one.
 
The 'german' man even says these exact words, "....and I understand your words."

Sounds like he is saying, while he might not be the greatest with english, he did understand, despite it.
 
Glad to help! Here is Robert's article:

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml

Here is Robert's analysis:

"...they couldn't speak English." All of them spoke English. Wrong

And here is what the German gentleman had to say about himself:

Man #1: I understand you not so good, I am a German.


Man #1: I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words.

He spoke English. He spoke English to Sylvia. He spoke English poorly. Ms. Brown had to repeat herself in simpler terms.

I can't speak for others, but I do not find myself to be terribly put upon when I am required to repeat myself in simpler terms for the benefit of non-native speakers.
 
This thread is NOT about Sylvia's legitimacy. It is about Robert Lancaster, and how he distorts information. Mr. Lancaster only just recently posted a video of Browne on a television show. On this show, Browne was asked to do a reading for a German man. This man knew practically NO English. Browne did her best to do the reading. It was impossible to verify whether Browne got her answers right or not. But Mr. Lancaster claims that "All of them spoke English." This is simply not true. Watch the clip. The man only knows how to say he doesn't speak English, but Mr. Lancaster counts this against Browne!?

Again, this thread is NOT about Sylvia Browne's success rate, it is about Lancaster's consistent misinformation campaign[/B against Sylvia Browne.




Actually, it is about your unsupported accusations that RSL is engaging in a consistent misinformation campaign.

So far, you have been spectacularly unsuccessful at presenting any evidence for your accusations. For instance, could you link to the above referenced analysis? I can't find it on his site, and we can't evaluate your accusations without seeing it.

You do have a link, don't you? You wouldn't just make something up, right?

As you don't have 15 posts yet, just provide the link without the "http:" part, and we'll figure it out.
 
No Lisa. That is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that the man did not speak English in the sense that he would be considered an English-speaker. In other words, he could not know whether Sylvia was right or wrong in her predictions.

Prove it.
 
No Lisa. That is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that the man did not speak English in the sense that he would be considered an English-speaker. In other words, he could not know whether Sylvia was right or wrong in her predictions.

Considering how many forum members don't have English as their first language, this comes pretty close to sounding insulting....

Oh please. All you 'skeptics' have done so far is personally attack me and harp on this 85% success rate issue, which has nothing to do with this thread.

Damn selective reading you're doing, huh?



 
Again, this thread is NOT about Sylvia Browne's success rate, it is about Lancaster's consistent misinformation campaign[/B against Sylvia Browne.


The claim of 85% accuracy has been made.

Evidence to support this claim has been called for.
 
Oh please. All you 'skeptics' have done so far is personally attack me and harp on this 85% success rate issue, which has nothing to do with this thread.

OK, I dispute Sylvia even has a 1% success rate. Prove me wrong. Show me even one verifiable success. One, just one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom