Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

No.

You said that Robert is a liar because he said they all spoke English when they did not. Now you must prove that Robert's statement is a lie. No moving the goalposts, please. It is not a question of whether or not the man was an "English-speaker". HE SPOKE ENGLISH. Therefore, Robert's statement was factually true.

Saying someone speaks English implies they are fluent enough in the language to communicate in a basic conversation. It also implies they are able to confirm or deny the predictions made in a psychic reading. Mr. Lancaster said that everyone spoke English. The German man did not and this is clear from the clip (watch the clip, everyone). He knew only enough words to say that he doesn't speak English (almost everyone knows that).
 
Do we have anyone here experienced in cult deprogramming? :rolleyes:

It would appear that "Gary Richardson" is into it so deeply that it will be impossible to get him to rationally view the material presented.
 
Oh please. All you 'skeptics' have done so far is personally attack me and harp on this 85% success rate issue, which has nothing to do with this thread.

Actually, we've done more than that. We've pointed out that the "misrepresentations" that you accuse RSL of doing are not misrepresentations. We've pointed out that Larry King is wrong in his assessment of Sylvia's description of the kidnapper. We've shown that the german did speak english, enough to understand the reading. We've waited for you to come up with good evidence to support your accusations.
 
{Mr. Lancaster, in his sham of a website, obsessively harps on every minor error that Browne makes in her prediction.}



Please forgive me SylviaRox, but some of Sylvia's errors are far from minor. I understand why you are doing this, but, truthfully, until SYLVIA BROWNE, gathers enough courage to answer for herself, there will be no respect at all for her.

These new threads and blogs that are appearing, are a wonderful example of how Sylvia Browne tries to use the Scientology approach to answering her critics. She fails miserably. Don't you think that it has been difficult for those of us who have left NS? Kid yourself not! It was painful!

What is even more painful is reading a lot of the documents, both submitted on Mr. Lancaster's site, and subsequently found on the internet, and inwardly shudder at the horrendous lack of care, consideration and accountability that has, and continues to happen with Sylvia and NS.

Please do not bother to come back and attack this post. I have had well over 15 yrs with NS, and have at least 49 yrs research experience during my spiritual journey.

All things happen for a reason. While we may not know why, understand why or even care why...they happen for a reason.

I wish you well, and leave you with this thought. Please be kind to yourself when you finally do discover the truth. There will be a period of time where you may beat yourself up for not being able to see what was right in front of you.

There are TOO MANY instances, SR for any of us to hide our heads in the sand. Luwanna Miller weighs on my heart every night, since I read about it.
 
Again, this thread is NOT about Sylvia Browne's success rate, it is about Lancaster's consistent misinformation campaign[/B against Sylvia Browne.


So far you have not produced any evidence that Rob Lancaster has misrepresent Sylvia Browne in respect of any statement on his website.

Your claims:

Robert S. Lancaster has made a hostile and concerted attempt to slander, libel and defame Sylvia Browne. Browne, a woman who has brought an immeasurable amount of comfort and assistance to men and women across the country, as well as help to police departments, has been treated in a fashion completely and utterly shocking to any civilized person. Browne's success rate of 85% is ignored, Mr. Lancaster, in his sham of a website, obsessively harps on every minor error that Browne makes in her prediction. For example: when Sylvia Browne accurately predicted the nature and appearance of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor, he pretended that she had not, and distorted her actual reading to the Hornbecks. Larry King even SAID that she got it mostly right, but Mr. Randi and Mr. Lancaster have tried to deny it!

You stated that SB was 85% right. Prove it.

You stated that SB has helped police departments. Prove it.

You stated that SB described the nature of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor. Prove it.

I should warn you that accepting SB's word for everything without evidence while quibbling every documented lie by SB is a good working definition of delusional.

For example SB clearly said that Shawn Hornbeck was dead. He was not. Is that a) 100% b) 85% or c) 0% correct?
 
Saying someone speaks English implies they are fluent enough in the language to communicate in a basic conversation. It also implies they are able to confirm or deny the predictions made in a psychic reading. Mr. Lancaster said that everyone spoke English. The German man did not and this is clear from the clip (watch the clip, everyone). He knew only enough words to say that he doesn't speak English (almost everyone knows that).

You said:

But Mr. Lancaster claims that "All of them spoke English."

Did the man from Germany speak English? Yes or no? Ja or nein?
 
Saying someone speaks English implies they are fluent enough in the language to communicate in a basic conversation. It also implies they are able to confirm or deny the predictions made in a psychic reading. Mr. Lancaster said that everyone spoke English. The German man did not and this is clear from the clip (watch the clip, everyone). He knew only enough words to say that he doesn't speak English (almost everyone knows that).

Except that isn't what he said. He said the he DID understand.
 
Saying someone speaks English implies they are fluent enough in the language to communicate in a basic conversation.
Aye.
It also implies they are able to confirm or deny the predictions made in a psychic reading.
Aye.
Mr. Lancaster said that everyone spoke English.
Where?
The German man did not
Yes he did.
and this is clear from the clip (watch the clip, everyone). He knew only enough words to say that he doesn't speak English (almost everyone knows that).
Have you read the transcript?
 
He knew only enough words to say that he doesn't speak English (almost everyone knows that).

Rubbish. The man understood and spoke enough English to answer yes and not questions and to even say "I understand."
 
You said:



Did the man from Germany speak English? Yes or no? Ja or nein?

No, he only spoke enough to say that he doesn't know how to speak English. He was exclusively a German speaker. Lancaster lied and said that he spoke English.

My sister-in-law knew about 10 words of English when she came to America, but she knew how to say she doesn't speak English well. I WOULD HARDLY HAVE SAID SHE SPOKE ENGLISH.
 
(Sylvia) Browne: And they were all German, and they couldn't understand one word I said. And that was a setup, as you well know.

Reality, 4 native english speakers and one german with limited but functional english.
 
- Gary Richardson, admirer of Sylvia Browne
Okay, let's take your points one at a time.

Robert S. Lancaster has actually made a concerted effort to present facts about Sylvia Browne. A fact, according to Webster Online, is "something that has actual existence." If Ms. Browne's success rate of 85% had actual existence, there would be evidence to back it up, and Mr. Lancaster would provide room for that evidence on his site.

While it is possible that Ms. Browne has brought short-term comfort to people across the country, that's simply not enough to dismiss the facts about what she has said, nor is it enough to dismiss the great pain she has put some people, such as Shawn Hornbeck's parents, through.

Mr. Lancaster documents Ms. Browne's errors because, frankly, that's all that there is documentation for. Her successes don't seem to get filmed or verified after the fact for some reason.

Ms. Browne did not accurately describe Michael J. Devlin, except by calling him "Michael", one of the most common men's names ever. This is all public record, and all spelled out here. Mr. Lancaster even provides links to the source of his data so you can analyze them yourself and come to your own conclusions.

I'm sure that to a follower of Ms. Browne such as yourself, data that contradicts the belief you have may seem "frenzied" as more of it is revealed to you. That's normal. What you have to ask yourself, though, is not "how can Mr. Lancaster do this?" but "is any of this data true?"

Mr. Lancaster's main argument against Ms. Browne not having a masters' degree in literature is not that she is ineloquent, but that there is no evidence of her earning a masters' degree in literature.

Your assumption that Mr. Lancaster had us skeptics ambush the gosylviabrowne guest book shows a profound misunderstanding of both Mr. Lancaster's intentions and the way spammers operate, and need not be discussed here.

And finally, it was Mr. Lancaster's success with the StopKaz.com Web site that prompted him to start StopSylviaBrowne.com, not the other way around. Facts -- things that have actual existence, remember -- brought Kaz's money-making scheme to a stop. Time will tell if Ms. Browne's scheme can withstand the same force. If she's been telling the truth, the facts shouldn't scare her one bit.
 
Again, this thread is NOT about Sylvia Browne's success rate, it is about Lancaster's consistent misinformation campaign against Sylvia Browne.
And yet, you haven't found a single incident where Mr. Lancaster was giving misinformation. Every anti-Lancaster point you have brought up has been shown to be incorrect. What is your success rate, Rox?
 
No, he only spoke enough to say that he doesn't know how to speak English. He was exclusively a German speaker. Lancaster lied and said that he spoke English.

My sister-in-law knew about 10 words of English when she came to America, but she knew how to say she doesn't speak English well. I WOULD HARDLY HAVE SAID SHE SPOKE ENGLISH.

I think your temper may be getting away from you. Perhaps now is a good time to take a breather, and come back to reread what was posted later.
 
This thread is NOT about Sylvia's legitimacy. It is about Robert Lancaster, and how he distorts information. Mr. Lancaster only just recently posted a video of Browne on a television show. On this show, Browne was asked to do a reading for a German man. This man knew practically NO English. Browne did her best to do the reading. It was impossible to verify whether Browne got her answers right or not. But Mr. Lancaster claims that "All of them spoke English." This is simply not true. Watch the clip. The man only knows how to say he doesn't speak English, but Mr. Lancaster counts this against Browne!?

As you well know Lisa (being an admin), I cannot post links.

Please visit the article on Exploring Psychic Powers Live (the newest article) on Mr. Lancaster's website. Go to the analysis section. You will see the following words: "All of them spoke English." It's there, I am no liar.



Okay, I've found this link. However, contrary to your assertion that the German fellow "knew practically NO English", it's clear that he did speak english. RSL also quotes Randi:


Robert: re the Bixby/Browne video, it should be said that I mixed with that section of our audience following the incident, and as far as I could tell, all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

James Randi.


When you consider that SB alleged the entire audience were German, and she was "set up", you'll excuse me for thinking Randi is a more reliable source of information on the subject.


You'll also note, the German fellow says:

I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words.


So, wrong again.
 
So far you have not produced any evidence that Rob Lancaster has misrepresent Sylvia Browne in respect of any statement on his website.

Your claims:



You stated that SB was 85% right. Prove it.

You stated that SB has helped police departments. Prove it.

You stated that SB described the nature of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor. Prove it.

I should warn you that accepting SB's word for everything without evidence while quibbling every documented lie by SB is a good working definition of delusional.

For example SB clearly said that Shawn Hornbeck was dead. He was not. Is that a) 100% b) 85% or c) 0% correct?

You skeptics, you people who constantly claim that you are being oppressed and assaulted by fundamentalists and new-agers, are the ones who are delusional. Robert Lancaster is a perfect example of this. The man attacks a great spiritual leader because he himself is paranoid and full of self-loathing. He distorts information at any opportunity. The amount of intellectual effort it takes for Mr. Lancaster to craft and present his bold-faced lies to the public must be astonishing.
 
and this is clear from the clip (watch the clip, everyone). He knew only enough words to say that he doesn't speak English (almost everyone knows that).

That really doesn't prove much. I have several friends who read and understands English perfectly, but if you heard them speak English you would not think so. You may have a problem making your lips pronouce the words correctly, which in turn could make you shy to speak at all (especially with a TV camera on you, and a weird woman asking you weird things) doesn't mean you don't understand English well.

Fran
Who doesn't speak English as a first language
 
Last edited:
Rubbish. The man understood and spoke enough English to answer yes and not questions and to even say "I understand."

I work daily with people who have a relatively poor grasp of French as a second language. One thing I've noticed (and also noticed when I was learning English as a second language) is that understanding a language comes *much* sooner than being able to respond in that same language. I'm not an expert, but from my personnal experience, the answers this man provided point to him knowing enough English to be able to sustain a simple conversation.

And as others have pointed out, no matter your first language, it's impossible for anybody to agree/disagree with a statement about something supposed to happen in the future.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom