Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Sylvia: "They [the studio audience] were all Germans! And they couldn't understand a word I said! That was a setup, as you well know.... because they couldn't speak English. I found that out after, they were all Germanic!"

I never even noticed before. She actually said "Germanic" instead of "German"?

Well, then technically, I suppose she was probably right, since English is a Germanic language. ;)

Guess that Master's in English isn't doing her much good.
 
Christine, I am sorry to disappoint but I have no direct contact with Sylvia. Some people said earlier that I am her manager, which is funny but completely untrue. I can in no way help get her to agree to the challenge or any sort of test. I would like to see the test done.

Fair enough. If nothing else the fact that she refuses to provide documentation for her claimed success rate or to take these sorts of tests should be food for thought.

I'd also like to point out that even finding ONE lost child, alive or dead, is worthy, and if she did that it wouldn't matter to me if her success rate was once in a lifetime. If she has in fact found a missing person or solved a crime, everyone here would like to see the evidence, and Robert has said many times that he will put it on his website.
 
I never even noticed before. She actually said "Germanic" instead of "German"?

Well, then technically, I suppose she was probably right, since English is a Germanic language. ;)

Guess that Master's in English isn't doing her much good.

Ooh, good catch!
 
SylviaRox has retracted all of his original statements, except for a minor squibble regarding the German man on the TV show.

Even that part where he says, "I am sure an admin will delete this message because it disagrees with the stated goals of the JREF."?

Wow.
 
The argument that SB has nothing to prove if she accepts the test has a serious problem, the money prize and the huge influx of people to her business were she to complete the test. SB has millions no doubt, but 1 million for a single week's time spent doing easy work is way more than she makes, unless you believe that she makes $52 million per year doing $700 per 30 min phone calls. This rate is a pittance btw to what she could charge were she to be verified as a genuine psychic. If she is genuine and believes in what she teaches, she would take the test. It would expand NS by a huge amount and would bring her work to almost every person on the planet. She does not take the test because she is a fake, and the test would ruin her far beyond what her not taking it has already done to her business.
 
Some people said earlier that I am her manager, which is funny but completely untrue.

SR, I am going to have to call you on this. "Some people" in this thread? Name two, please. The thread is here for all to read. I'm sure you're referring to the indirect allegation made by Ground Beast Samwich (presumably referring to you as "Linda"), which was explained in post #503 by SeekingTruth. A search in this thread on the term "manager" only brings up one use unrelated to said allegation, then SeekingTruth's comments (and a string of quotes of that comment), then your statement. When I read through this, I didn't see any support for Ground Beast's allegation (except possibly one who thinks it might be possible that you are involved with SB's organization). I read instead several people who dismissed the notion and pointed out that it's irrelevant.

I know it's a trivial point, but it highlights a problem with your thinking. One indirect allegation by one individual is not at all the same as "some people said earlier that I am her manager". Just like one lucky hit on a first name (the "Michael" thing again) is no proof at all that Sylvia uses psychic abilities to help police solve missing person cases.
 
Ground Beast Sammich (a poster of questionable sincerity) referred to SylviaRox as "Linda." Someone else said "NotaRepublican" also referred to him as "Linda," but I think that person was confusing NotaRepublican with Ground Beast Sammich.

However several people have suggested that this whole thread was some sort of setup by a friend of Sylvia Browne, although it isn't clear what we were being set up for.

I think the suspicion was that SylviaRox is going to present us with personal testimony of some undeniable psychic prediction Browne has made, i.e. "Sylvia told me yesterday that today's lotto numbers would be 1, 2, 5, 21, 40 and she was right!" Of course we would all call him a liar, and then we'd look like a bunch of fools and cynics at the same time.
 
Ground Beast Sammich (a poster of questionable sincerity) referred to SylviaRox as "Linda." Someone else said "NotaRepublican" also referred to him as "Linda," but I think that person was confusing NotaRepublican with Ground Beast Sammich.

However several people have suggested that this whole thread was some sort of setup by a friend of Sylvia Browne, although it isn't clear what we were being set up for.

I think the suspicion was that SylviaRox is going to present us with personal testimony of some undeniable psychic prediction Browne has made, i.e. "Sylvia told me yesterday that today's lotto numbers would be 1, 2, 5, 21, 40 and she was right!" Of course we would all call him a liar, and then we'd look like a bunch of fools and cynics at the same time.

I agree. I fail to see what we were being set up for. This thread makes JREF look way better than SB her followers. If anyone has any ideas on what that other foot would be then let me know.
 
(Usually after they sober up.)


In that case, you're talking beer goggles falling from your eyes, not scales. And when they fall off, in the clear morning light as you awaken and gaze over at the stanger next to you, look out.
 
<<Mr. Lancaster has apparently also started a campaign against Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen, a 9/11 survivor and inspirational speaker, and a descendant of famous film director Cecil B. Demille.>>

This statement sounds so odd. How could someone read the Kaz site and come up with this? It sounds like someone is trying to start a fight. Someone who is a big supporter of Sylvia Browne (like SilviaRox) wouldn't tack on this Kaz person also, would they? Why support Kaz, she is a no body, and has been completely debunked. I mean the DeMille link to Kaz is so over, the DeMille family is out to sue Kaz for her use of the name. The 9-11 link is also a mess.

Maybe I'm too new to forums. But I have read all the posts and wonder is it common for people to beat the same old horse to death over and over (the German man) (Michael) and now this new reference to Gaydar, who cares. It seems to me that we are running around in circles when SylviaRox made specific charges that have not been addressed. I'm still very skeptical of SylviaRox's change of mind (which seems very odd to me, coming from such a angry first post at the beginning).

I said from the first that this thread makes me unsure of the why of it all. How can you be such a big believer and then suddenly change your mind. If SylviaRox is a big believer and supporter (I mean look at the name) then why hasn't SylviaRox not told us about how much Sylvia Browne has helped them, and how even though we and the SSB site makes good points against Browne, why hasn't SylviaRox said that Browne is really a good person and all that stuff everyone says when their hero is falling?

My idea was that possibly SylviaRox started this thread so that everyone would gather around Robert and show him how much he is supported. I mean that is exactly what happened isn't it. And the timing couldn't be much better considering that he was off getting married and the like. If I had a support group like this one, I think I could do anything, what a great feeling it must be.

Anyway, just my take on the whole thing

Susan
 
If she is legit, what would be her justification for wanting to prove it, if the general public accepts her as real already?
For one thing, it would shut up that annoying Bob Lancaster guy!
 
Susan,

If you read any of the 911 conspiracy threads, you will see it is very common to hone into minutia and beat it to death.

It is interesting you brought back the quote about Kaz. That's a good point.

Sometimes people do a quick turn around, when they are ready. One poster was against gay marriage recently, but invited logical arguments. This person reversed their opinion, and if I may paraphrase a PM I shared with this person, it was because for once they decided to think for themselves and allow themselves to analyze where opinions were rooted. (If that poster reads this here and I have paraphrased in a way that is not true to the spirit of the conversation, feel free to correct me). Though in this case it was someone who had already waded into the waters of skepticism, thus arrived here at a turning point in their own journey.

SR, in my opinion, did not come here to learn, but rather grind an axe. However, this person has made admissions. I'll take him at face value presently in hopes that regardless of original intent, he is willing to hold a productive discussion. Though as of this writing I am not seeing any responses to my requests that he move forward in that direction. But I'm not giving up just yet.
 
All the crap about "not needing money" or "contempt for psychics", etc, are just excuses from people who are too afraid to actually undergo a verifiable, controlled testing process. We all know that. What's sad is that such pathetic excuses ring true with the believers. It really boggles the mind. Anyone who puts their mind to it, honestly, will realize that to be able to prove, conclusively and scientifically that a psychic power exists would change the entire world, and bring immeasurable wealth and notoriety to the person in question. To go down in history as the first real, verifiable psychic? The million dollars is a pittance in comparison to what is to gain.

It just goes to show that when people want to believe something, their is nothing that will stop them believing it. The liars will keep on lying as long as people are gullible and accept it and fork over the cash in large amounts.
 
Last edited:
I will leave it to you to decide from his posts whether Raider has evinced a smug attitude or not.

It is also annoying to have my sexuality inferred about, especially when talking about me in the third person.

SR, you need to either develop a thicker skin or learn to ignore some posters. Try not to assume evil motivation as, usually, it's usually ignorance or stupidity. There's a well-known internet "law" that states such but it's title escapes me now.

Yes, I am gay. Good job, want a gold star?

That's no one's business but your own. Let me say that I'm glad you stuck around anyway. Don't let the fistfights drive you away.
 
My idea was that possibly SylviaRox started this thread so that everyone would gather around Robert and show him how much he is supported. I mean that is exactly what happened isn't it. And the timing couldn't be much better considering that he was off getting married and the like. If I had a support group like this one, I think I could do anything, what a great feeling it must be.

Anyway, just my take on the whole thing

Susan
Except around here, to show someone how much they are supported, especially someone like RSL, a thread would just be started that was all about supporting him, without the facade of being anything else.
 
<<Mr. Lancaster has apparently also started a campaign against Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen, a 9/11 survivor and inspirational speaker, and a descendant of famous film director Cecil B. Demille.>>

This statement sounds so odd. How could someone read the Kaz site and come up with this? It sounds like someone is trying to start a fight. Someone who is a big supporter of Sylvia Browne (like SilviaRox) wouldn't tack on this Kaz person also, would they? Why support Kaz, she is a no body, and has been completely debunked. I mean the DeMille link to Kaz is so over, the DeMille family is out to sue Kaz for her use of the name. The 9-11 link is also a mess.

Maybe I'm too new to forums. But I have read all the posts and wonder is it common for people to beat the same old horse to death over and over (the German man) (Michael) and now this new reference to Gaydar, who cares. It seems to me that we are running around in circles when SylviaRox made specific charges that have not been addressed. I'm still very skeptical of SylviaRox's change of mind (which seems very odd to me, coming from such a angry first post at the beginning).

I said from the first that this thread makes me unsure of the why of it all. How can you be such a big believer and then suddenly change your mind. If SylviaRox is a big believer and supporter (I mean look at the name) then why hasn't SylviaRox not told us about how much Sylvia Browne has helped them, and how even though we and the SSB site makes good points against Browne, why hasn't SylviaRox said that Browne is really a good person and all that stuff everyone says when their hero is falling?

My idea was that possibly SylviaRox started this thread so that everyone would gather around Robert and show him how much he is supported. I mean that is exactly what happened isn't it. And the timing couldn't be much better considering that he was off getting married and the like. If I had a support group like this one, I think I could do anything, what a great feeling it must be.

Anyway, just my take on the whole thing

Susan
Susan I like the way you think. I was mulling over that yesterday - the "coincidence" of the esteemed RSL getting married, and what a great marriage present from JREF something like this would be.

Susan the Skeptic. Excellent!
 
I'm still very skeptical of SylviaRox's change of mind (which seems very odd to me, coming from such a angry first post at the beginning).
SylviaRox has stated that he is not playing a role here, and until such time that hard evidence shows otherwise, I choose to believe him.

To my way of thinking, whether his stated position was real or not has no bearing on how it should be answered. Because whether it is his true opinion or not, our response to it can help others who read the thread, and who may actually be of similar opinions themselves.

How can you be such a big believer and then suddenly change your mind.
Well, he stated in the thread that he wasn't that much of a Browne supporter, and seemed to be more of an opponent of overly-aggressive criticism of spiritual topics, which is how he evidently viewed my site. The fact that I had a second such site probably fueled that opinion.

As for quick changes in opinion, I have seen many examples of this through the course of my email correspondence on both the Kaz and Sylvia sites. There have been many times when I have received very angry, sometimes obscenity-laced emails from a person asking why I would dare to have a site criticizing such a wonderful, spiritual person.

I try to reply to these emails with calm, reasoned replies (I don't always. Sometimes they catch me in a bad mood), asking the person if they have read this or that article (such as the Opal Jo Jennings one). There have been many, many instances where the very next email I receive from that person is one where their opinion of Browne (or Kaz) has undergone a dramatic change.

So, it does happen. Did it really happen this time? Nobody truly knows but SylviaRox, and i think that's the only person for whom it should really matter.

My idea was that possibly SylviaRox started this thread so that everyone would gather around Robert and show him how much he is supported. I mean that is exactly what happened isn't it. And the timing couldn't be much better considering that he was off getting married and the like. If I had a support group like this one, I think I could do anything, what a great feeling it must be.
So, you think this whole thread might have been SylviaRox's wedding present to my wife and me?

Well, it's an interesting thought. And whether it was or not, yes, reading all of the posts defending the article, the site, and myself was a very good feeling. Thanks again to everyone.

For one thing, it would shut up that annoying Bob Lancaster guy!
:mad:

And that annoying Randi guy!
:rm:
 
SylviaRox has stated that he is not playing a role here, and until such time that hard evidence shows otherwise, I choose to believe him.

To my way of thinking, whether his stated position was real or not has no bearing on how it should be answered. Because whether it is his true opinion or not, our response to it can help others who read the thread, and who may actually be of similar opinions themselves.

Well, he stated in the thread that he wasn't that much of a Browne supporter, and seemed to be more of an opponent of overly-aggressive criticism of spiritual topics, which is how he evidently viewed my site. The fact that I had a second such site probably fueled that opinion.

As for quick changes in opinion, I have seen many examples of this through the course of my email correspondence on both the Kaz and Sylvia sites. There have been many times when I have received very angry, sometimes obscenity-laced emails from a person asking why I would dare to have a site criticizing such a wonderful, spiritual person.

I try to reply to these emails with calm, reasoned replies (I don't always. Sometimes they catch me in a bad mood), asking the person if they have read this or that article (such as the Opal Jo Jennings one). There have been many, many instances where the very next email I receive from that person is one where their opinion of Browne (or Kaz) has undergone a dramatic change.

So, it does happen. Did it really happen this time? Nobody truly knows but SylviaRox, and i think that's the only person for whom it should really matter.

So, you think this whole thread might have been SylviaRox's wedding present to my wife and me?

Well, it's an interesting thought. And whether it was or not, yes, reading all of the posts defending the article, the site, and myself was a very good feeling. Thanks again to everyone.
Nothing like a bit of righteous indignation (like from me when I read that opening post) to kick-start some enthusiastic support for the esteemed RSL...:)

Congrats on your marriage! Don't forget to love and obey! ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom