Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Oh wait you're an officer. Sir, Darth sir!!! Sir, respectfully your fly, sir, is open sir! :)

Oooh, sheeeeeet!*zip*

Thanks. :blush:
Since (to me) there is a hinkiness to this person's intent and sincerity, then the gender and/or name given must also be subjected to hardnosed scrutiny.

This SylviaRox may not be male, that's just an assumption based, I think, on the name given. The style seems male, which is typically more challenging and confrontational than a female's style.
OK, so suspiscions aroused, but "seems to be a guy."
CR said:
The name is what drew my scrutiny, although I didn't mention earlier. Gary Richardson. GARY RICHARDSON?!? Can anyone think of a more generic male name than Gary Richardson?
Would this be argument of incredulity? When I attended the Naval Academy 12 people in my class had the last name of Smith, who graduated, and at least two Smiths quite/were tossed that I knew. Really!

So maybe I am less willing to believe that common names are commonly used absent any conspiracy to defraud. :)

DR
 
As stupid as it may be - it's not actually intended as an offensive term. Gay men actually believe that they can spot other gay men, in or out of the closet, and this is actually where it came from.This one IS offensive. As it uses gay in the derogative.
The two uses are not related - so there's no need to be offended by the former, but I agree with you with regards to the latter.
Hope that straightens things out for *you* as well.
Very cool, I learned something which is what it's all about. I still think it's a stupid word.

So apparently Lonewulf thinks I'm gay and that my "gaydar" clicked on when I saw SylviaRox's post?

Ah, youth...
 
Sorry, ConspiRaider! I tried to dadgum understand ya, ya old fogey, but I'm just a poor ol' idiot down in Texas. Yeap! Every single person down here is an udder moron! Quite wise and mature of ya to point it out!

Now, I'm gonna go spit in my spittoon, hunt myself a deer, and get me some cowpies! YEEHAW!
IIRC, you live somewhere near Corpus Christi Bay? As we all know, there is no intelligent life south of I-10. (Oh, wait, that means Los Angeles, CA, has some trouble in the intelligence department. Conspi, mah fren, you ain't so smahrt yore own seff!) :D

DR
 
Okay, this thread has been completely derailed, but if SylviaRox is still listening and he still believes in Sylvia Browne and he has some influence over her, I have a modest suggestion.

Get her to take the JREF challenge.

She won't have to deal with Randi. Randi has said Larry King can do it. It should be easy to pass. Several variants have been suggested but the simplest one goes like this: ten people sign affidavits that they are fans of Browne and believers. Sylvia phones each one of them to make a connection (her terminology). Then she does a reading. They can't actually see or hear her at this time.

All ten readings are transcribed. Everyone reads all ten, and picks the one he thinks is his own. Seven or more right is a win, then she has to do it a second time.

Can you think of any reason why Sylvia wouldn't be able to pass this test? It seems like it would be pretty easy to me. All the details are flexible.

It sounds reasonable, but if she is being dishonest as you all believe wouldn't it be doubtful she would compromise herself by being tested? If she is legit, what would be her justification for wanting to prove it, if the general public accepts her as real already?
 
It sounds reasonable, but if she is being dishonest as you all believe wouldn't it be doubtful she would compromise herself by being tested?
Exactly what she is doing. Dodging James Randi after agreeing to be tested.
If she is legit, what would be her justification for wanting to prove it, if the general public accepts her as real already?
Because she has already AGREED to be tested?

Her honesty and integrity IS in doubt.

http://www.randi.org/sylvia/index.html
[FONT=arial, helvetica]On [/FONT][FONT=arial, helvetica]Sep. 3, 2001, Sylvia Browne accepted the protocol for a definitive test for the JREF million-dollar challenge, on Larry King Live. The box shows the number of weeks since that date. And, it has been more than 322 weeks since she first agreed to be tested on March 6, 2001![/FONT]​
 
Last edited:
Let's get something straight (pun intended), shall we?

I consider the word "gaydar" to be inappropriate, offensive and quite frankly a tremendously stupid word. Guess where I categorize such a stupid word? Correct. Right along with "TomKat" and "Brangelina". Stupid words, the three of them. Furthermore, this one - "gaydar" - is something I determine to be offensive in the same sense "That's so gay" is offensive. I don't use either of those terms or phrases in conversation, or to describe anyone. It's the same reason I don't use the equally (apparently) popular "ho" to describe women. I don't even want to explore any possible subtleties that might be inherent in such a word as "ho". Not interested. I hear the word "ho", I immediately register displeasure with its usage and that's as far as it gets. Same with "gaydar" and "That's so gay".

You straight (no pun intended) on this now?
That post was so gaaaaaay.

:duck:

DR
 
It sounds reasonable, but if she is being dishonest as you all believe wouldn't it be doubtful she would compromise herself by being tested? If she is legit, what would be her justification for wanting to prove it, if the general public accepts her as real already?

A million dollars isn't enough justification? How much good would she be able to do with that money? Even if she is bringing in money hand over fist a million is still a goodly sum and she would be able to tell Randi to stuff it.


I don't understand what you mean by compromise herself. Please elaborate.




Boo
 
Oooh, sheeeeeet!*zip*

Thanks. :blush:

OK, so suspiscions aroused, but "seems to be a guy."

Would this be argument of incredulity? When I attended the Naval Academy 12 people in my class had the last name of Smith, who graduated, and at least two Smiths quite/were tossed that I knew. Really!

So maybe I am less willing to believe that common names are commonly used absent any conspiracy to defraud. :)

DR
Sir, cool sir, yes sir! Hey Darth, let's do Holy Grail on SylviaRox, shan't we? Everything in life, as we all well know, can eventually be related to Monty Python and the Holy Grail.

SylviaRox is actually John Cleese's Sir Lancelot, the Brave. When Prince Herbert shoots the arrow message outta the winda and Eric Idle "catches" it. Lancelot storms the castle, slashes most of the wedding party, stabs the bride, stabs the bride's father in the head. "Ha!" "Ah-hah!" exclaims Lancelot as he carves up the Castle That Wouldn't Sink In The Swamp.

Then he says: "Sorry! Sorry everyone! Is he all right? I just ... I just get carried away, sorry, sorry everyone..."

Textbook Lancelot, is our SylviaRox. Eh?
 
Sir, cool sir, yes sir! Hey Darth, let's do Holy Grail on SylviaRox, shan't we? Everything in life, as we all well know, can eventually be related to Monty Python and the Holy Grail.

SylviaRox is actually John Cleese's Sir Lancelot, the Brave. When Prince Herbert shoots the arrow message outta the winda and Eric Idle "catches" it. Lancelot storms the castle, slashes most of the wedding party, stabs the bride, stabs the bride's father in the head. "Ha!" "Ah-hah!" exclaims Lancelot as he carves up the Castle That Wouldn't Sink In The Swamp.

Then he says: "Sorry! Sorry everyone! Is he all right? I just ... I just get carried away, sorry, sorry everyone..."

Textbook Lancelot, is our SylviaRox. Eh?

ConspiRaider, I can't decide what is more annoying: your wannabe 'internet detective' skills or your lame, unfunny attempts at irreverence. This is the kind of smug attitude that frustrated me in the first place.
 
ConspiRaider, I can't decide what is more annoying: your wannabe 'internet detective' skills or your lame, unfunny attempts at irreverence. This is the kind of smug attitude that frustrated me in the first place.

What exactly is the smug attitude? Please explain.
 
:mad: GAYDAR DISCUSSION GO AWAY. USE GAYDAR THREAD.

(I'm not really mad, but use Gaydar thread anyhow.)

SylivaRox: Well, as others have said, that is the question. And of course forcing exactly that dilemma is one of the purposes of the million dollar challenge.

I personally believe that is why Browne will not take the test. However there are people do believe that they are actually psychic, and many of them have taken similar tests (mostly not for the million, of course).

However if YOU can persuade Browne to take the test you will become an even bigger forum legend and I'm sure James Randi himself will thank you. And if Browne passes the test, it will be world-shattering news, and you will be a part of history. So if you still believe that Browne could pass such a test, you might want to consider asking her to take it. I'd understand if you don't want to do this, but if you have inside knowledge as to what could be done to get it to happen, a lot of people would be thrilled.

I believe there has even been talk of a "finder's fee" which might go to you if Browne takes the test and wins as a direct result of your intervention. That is NOT an official statement by the JREF, but similar statements have been made in the past.
 
What exactly is the smug attitude? Please explain.

I will leave it to you to decide from his posts whether Raider has evinced a smug attitude or not.

It is also annoying to have my sexuality inferred about, especially when talking about me in the third person. Yes, I am gay. Good job, want a gold star?
 
Last edited:
I will leave it to you to decide from his posts whether Raider has evinced a smug attitude or not.

As reading emotion into an internet post is subjective, I will decline. One person's humor can be interpreted as smugness by another, and so on.
 
:mad: GAYDAR DISCUSSION GO AWAY. USE GAYDAR THREAD.

(I'm not really mad, but use Gaydar thread anyhow.)

SylivaRox: Well, as others have said, that is the question. And of course forcing exactly that dilemma is one of the purposes of the million dollar challenge.

I personally believe that is why Browne will not take the test. However there are people do believe that they are actually psychic, and many of them have taken similar tests (mostly not for the million, of course).

However if YOU can persuade Browne to take the test you will become an even bigger forum legend and I'm sure James Randi himself will thank you. And if Browne passes the test, it will be world-shattering news, and you will be a part of history. So if you still believe that Browne could pass such a test, you might want to consider asking her to take it. I'd understand if you don't want to do this, but if you have inside knowledge as to what could be done to get it to happen, a lot of people would be thrilled.

I believe there has even been talk of a "finder's fee" which might go to you if Browne takes the test and wins as a direct result of your intervention. That is NOT an official statement by the JREF, but similar statements have been made in the past.

Christine, I am sorry to disappoint but I have no direct contact with Sylvia. Some people said earlier that I am her manager, which is funny but completely untrue. I can in no way help get her to agree to the challenge or any sort of test. I would like to see the test done.
 
ConspiRaider, I can't decide what is more annoying: your wannabe 'internet detective' skills or your lame, unfunny attempts at irreverence. This is the kind of smug attitude that frustrated me in the first place.
Okay, I'll decide for you: The lame, unfunny attempts at irreverence. Know how I know that? Because you did not vote for my Hooftie The Buckling masterpiece at the May TLA awards in the Forum Community. Hey, you gotta lotta company so Welcome Aboard! Apparently nearly every JREFer also finds them attempts (and me) annoying. :)

But you're here and I no longer need to play detective, which is frustrating and fraught with inaccuracy.

So are you backing away from your support and devotion to Sylvia Browne, and moving into Skeptic City? Or at least moving into Skeptic Suburbia?

ETA: Please understand that I have zero care whether you are gay, straight, both, indifferent or whatever. As long as you're happy, I'm happy. My focus was simply on trying to determine the sincerity of your first post, and what followed.
 
Last edited:
SylviaRox, these debates tend to heat up with frustration on both sides. When the smoke clears here for you, feel free to check out the other sections of the forum and contribute.

There's more around here than just Browne to be debated. :D
 
I will leave it to you to decide from his posts whether Raider has evinced a smug attitude or not.

It is also annoying to have my sexuality inferred about, especially when talking about me in the third person. Yes, I am gay. Good job, want a gold star?

SR, the best thing to do is ignore posts such as this, and if you like, put the annoying poster on "ignore" so you won't be bothered as much. This is the nature of the internet, and while JREF is one of the most civil places I've found, it's still an internet message board.

I also do want to remind you that you began this thread with a whole lot of hostility and used some pretty harsh words against Robert. Yes, you recanted to an extent, and most of us appreciate that immensely. But you did say what you said. We are all human, we are prone to outbursts, smugness and sarcasm. You introduced yourself by showing you are not above it. I think this needs to be said for context and balance.

I am interested in forwarding the discussion with you. Nothing personal, let's just discuss the facts. Do you have any more issues with Robert's site? Would you like to discuss other aspects of psychics and/or Sylvia? Would you like to talk about cold reading?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom