Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Sylvia's predictions for them may have been wrong, but she is right most of the other times.
Don't you think that it is absolutly dispicable that she would make claism about those peopel without beign certian? Multiplyign eth rgeif felt by theri famalies? How many "correct" claims wipe out eth misery casued by tellign aprents that their missing daughter is being repetaedly raped?
or that theri missing son is dead?

Why do you think so many people seek her out as an authority?
because she is very convincing to those that don't examine her claims critically.

Why do you think she is called back time and time again by Montel Williams?
becasue she gets ratings- peopel like to wallow in the greif of otehrs.

Why do you think she has become so successful as a writer, a spiritual leader and a psychic?
see above.

BECAUSE SHE GETS THINGS RIGHT! That's why.
please demonstrate this.
 
When we ask for evidence of her success, and you can't find any, does it bother you? Why or why not?
 
I'm still waiting to be shown where I have been "extremely curt and full of vitriol".
 
Sylvia's predictions for them may have been wrong, but she is right most of the other times. Why do you think so many people seek her out as an authority? Why do you think she is called back time and time again by Montel Williams? Why do you think she has become so successful as a writer, a spiritual leader and a psychic? BECAUSE SHE GETS THINGS RIGHT! That's why. That's what puts her ahead of all of the other psychics. That's why she's Sylvia.
Can you provide us some examples of unambiguous cases where Sylvia "got things right" in a criminal case? I see a lot of claims, but no evidence. Please, no anecdotes. Cold, hard evidence, please. Every single piece of real evidence I've seen so far indicates that she is wrong far more often than she is right. But I am willing to be convinced otherwise if you will provide the evidence.
 
Please present your evidence of what she gets right.

Once again, answer the questions.

I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.

Please refer to my comments regarding Mr. Lancaster's deliberate lie about the German man in the Exploring clip being an English speaker as one example.

Mr. Lancaster, in regards to your extremism, I pull this very typical quote from your front page regarding Browne, calling her "a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved".
 
Another example of extreme rudeness. I cannot imagine anything more hurtful or condescending than implying: "your opinion is so stupid that you couldn't possibly hold it". I imagine that you use this same style of debating against Christians. "You believe in God? Wow, no one could really believe that. You must be kidding."

Im sorry other members were rude to you. People have been rude to me here too on occassion. My regular response is to critically examine the veiw that got me insulted, and if I still draw the same conclusion the insult or insults do not bother me after that. I think its important to do something constructive when challenged rather than to retreat into a victim role, but thats just my take on it.


If you disagree with my take- What you can do is decide not to respond to them, and talk to the people who have not been rude to you. There are plenty of people respectfully disagreeing with you in this thread.
 
When we ask for evidence of her success, and you can't find any, does it bother you? Why or why not?

Prewitt, I will state AGAIN that it is NOT my duty to DEFEND BROWNE'S track record. This thread is about LANCASTER, it is NOT another "let's attack Sylvia Browne and her followers" thread like the hundreds of others you people revel in.
 
Sylvia's predictions for them may have been wrong, but she is right most of the other times.
Show me.
Why do you think so many people seek her out as an authority?
You know I wonder that myself.
Why do you think she is called back time and time again by Montel Williams?
Ratings.
Why do you think she has become so successful as a writer, a spiritual leader and a psychic?
Again, I wonder that myself.
BECAUSE SHE GETS THINGS RIGHT!
Show me.
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.

Please refer to my comments regarding Mr. Lancaster's deliberate lie about the German man in the Exploring clip being an English speaker as one example.

Mr. Lancaster, in regards to your extremism, I pull this very typical quote from your front page regarding Browne, calling her "a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved".


Again, show us the evidence Mr. Lancaster has lied.

Again, answer my questions.

If you cannot, I can only assume you have no evidence at all.
 
Prewitt, I will state AGAIN that it is NOT my duty to DEFEND BROWNE'S track record. This thread is about LANCASTER, it is NOT another "let's attack Sylvia Browne and her followers" thread like the hundreds of others you people revel in.

This has been addressed. If Robert's website is accurate, then the problem is Sylvia. If his website is inaccurate, then you score a point. Let's see you score a point. What about his site is inaccurate?


Are you even going to reply to Robert's direct response to you?
 
SylviaRox, doesn't it bother you that Sylvia was lying when she said the entire audience was German?

I know you just want to talk about Robert's site in this thread.. but just curious about this issue.
 
It sounds to me like "I must in my ??? speak English, and I understand your words."

A logical fit would be something like "in my school" or "in my youth" but I don't hear it.

All the words in that sentence (that I can make out) are cognate to English words, i.e. "sprechen Englisch" = "speak English."
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.

Please refer to my comments regarding Mr. Lancaster's deliberate lie about the German man in the Exploring clip being an English speaker as one example.

Mr. Lancaster, in regards to your extremism, I pull this very typical quote from your front page regarding Browne, calling her "a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved".

You cannot show that RSL lied about it, unless you first show that Sylvia has a proven track records. Why is his comment extreme IF IT IS TRUE? If it is not true, then show that it is not true, that she IS very accurate. I may be misunderstanding this, but it seems to me that you are upset that Browne is being criticized, but you do not show that the criticism is incorrect.

If the entire German-speaking incident is as you say, is that not just ONE case of hundreds? You want to claim for SB that 85% is good enough (although you haven't show evidence for that yet), but expect 100% accuracy from everyone else?

If Sylvia has these abilities, given by God, why isn't she able to figure out the German? Can't God (or whoever is in the spirit world giving her information) speak German?
 
Prewitt, I will state AGAIN that it is NOT my duty to DEFEND BROWNE'S track record. This thread is about LANCASTER, it is NOT another "let's attack Sylvia Browne and her followers" thread like the hundreds of others you people revel in.

Was Sylvia right when she said they were all German? If you subject Lancaster's statement to so much scrutiny, what happens when you apply that same standard to "They were all German" ?
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.
Last I checked, it is near impossible to do one without doing the other. RSL shows her track record sucks. For him to be a liar, you must be able to demonstrate otherwise. Go ahead, we've been waiting.
Please refer to my comments regarding Mr. Lancaster's deliberate lie about the German man in the Exploring clip being an English speaker as one example.
We've thoroughly destroyed those arguements, please be embarrassed to bring them up further.
Mr. Lancaster, in regards to your extremism, I pull this very typical quote from your front page regarding Browne, calling her "a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved".

And I'll pull the entire quote in context to show what a liar (by omission) you are.
"Is she a well-intentioned spiritual leader, with actual psychic powers? Is she a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved? Or is she something else entirely?"
 
Are you going to answer?

Opal Jo Jennings?

Holly Krewson?

Ryan Katcher?

Lynda McClelland?

Minor errors? Yes or no.

Considering the speed this thread is traveling, this may be addressed by the time I finish typing, but...

He already did, Lisa.

Sylvia's predictions for them may have been wrong, but she is right most of the other times. Why do you think so many people seek her out as an authority? Why do you think she is called back time and time again by Montel Williams? Why do you think she has become so successful as a writer, a spiritual leader and a psychic? BECAUSE SHE GETS THINGS RIGHT! That's why. That's what puts her ahead of all of the other psychics. That's why she's Sylvia.
 
Mr. Lancaster, in regards to your extremism, I pull this very typical quote from your front page regarding Browne, calling her "a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved".
Perhaps you might want to put the whole quote in there. It is quite obvious that you have edited it to say something it did not. Here is the whole quote.
StopSylviaBrowne said:
"Is she a well-intentioned spiritual leader, with actual psychic powers? Is she a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved? Or is she something else entirely?"
At no time does the site call her a fraud. It merely asks the question. You read the evidence. You decide.
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.
is his lie better or worse than your claim that she only makes "minor errors"

Please refer to my comments regarding Mr. Lancaster's deliberate lie about the German man in the Exploring clip being an English speaker as one example.
the man was speaking English, he was therefore an English speaker. You may quibble on the exact definition of this but you are stretching if you want to call it a deliberate lie.

Mr. Lancaster, in regards to your extremism, I pull this very typical quote from your front page regarding Browne, calling her "a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved".

Provide a link so we can see that phrase in context- you have been told how you can do this.

I'm sure that you wouldn't selectivity quote a phrase, which was asked as a question, as a positve statement would you?

That would be a little dishonest, don't you think?


I mean- for instance, taking the example of someone saying "Is she a well-intentioned spiritual leader, with actual psychic powers? Is she a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved? Or is she something else entirely?" and claiming that this is a positive claim that Sylvia is a fraud would border on a deliberate lie, wouldn't it?
 
Last I checked, it is near impossible to do one without doing the other. RSL shows her track record sucks. For him to be a liar, you must be able to demonstrate otherwise. Go ahead, we've been waiting.

We've thoroughly destroyed those arguements, please be embarrassed to bring them up further.


And I'll pull the entire quote in context to show what a liar (by omission) you are.

I am NOT a liar by omission because Lancaster has CONTINUALLY made it clear what his position is on this issue. Just examine the tone of StopSylviaBrowne.com, it is extremely anti-Sylvia and it is made obvious that the quotation I gave is how Lancaster really feels.
 
I am NOT a liar by omission because Lancaster has CONTINUALLY made it clear what his position is on this issue. Just examine the tone of StopSylviaBrowne.com, it is extremely anti-Sylvia and it is made obvious that the quotation I gave is how Lancaster really feels.

So you also read minds then?


Are you going to respond to Robert's direct response to you at all?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom