Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

So now I completely don't understand the price of silver.

I understood that money would flow into commodities and especially precious metals when there was significant turmoil and uncertainty. Looking at the markets today, Greece is causing major upheavals and yet the price of sliver has slackened.

The price of other commodities like oil has also dropped because of fears of lack of economic growth. Is silver now behaving as a "normal" commodity rather than being a hedge ?
 
So now I completely don't understand the price of silver.

I understood that money would flow into commodities and especially precious metals when there was significant turmoil and uncertainty. Looking at the markets today, Greece is causing major upheavals and yet the price of sliver has slackened.

The price of other commodities like oil has also dropped because of fears of lack of economic growth. Is silver now behaving as a "normal" commodity rather than being a hedge ?
It is behaving like anything else on the market - the price adjusts to support ply and demand, period.

Well duh. But really, that is about all it amounts to, despite all of the tortured explanations.

I belong to a private list almost entirely composed of hedge fund and other money managers. Some currently have huge shorts on silver as part of a secular acquisition of some mining companies that have valuable assets worth owning, but they do not want to be exposed to silver price fluctuations (they do not pretend to themselves that such things are predictable). Another group has huge buys into silver because of an identified arbitrage opportunity - ie their purchase in no way denotes an expectation that the price will advance - the profit will come from the arbitrage. All of this going long and short creates supply or demand, and the price follows. None of this is accounted for by the TA people, the predictors of economic futures, or what have you, nor is it driven by any particular belief that silver is going to go up or down. I am not talking about internet clowns - the people in question have many billions of dollars under their management, and they truly have the economic clout to cause silver prices to change by their activities.
 
Last edited:
It is behaving like anything else on the market - the price adjusts to support ply and demand, period.

Well duh. But really, that is about all it amounts to, despite all of the tortured explanations.

Well if it is just responding to supply and (industrial) demand then that's a significant change to the way in which silver has apparently behaved over the past 4 years.

Over that period, the price of silver has doubled or trebled depending on where you take your start point. This is at a time of reduced industrial demand and the indication was that the price was being driven by investors shying away to equity and other investments because of uncertainty.

The current issues in Greece are causing turmoil in the equity markets but there has not yet been a corresponding rise in silver prices.
 
It is behaving like anything else on the market - the price adjusts to support ply and demand, period.

Well duh. But really, that is about all it amounts to, despite all of the tortured explanations.

I belong to a private list almost entirely composed of hedge fund and other money managers. Some currently have huge shorts on silver as part of a secular acquisition of some mining companies that have valuable assets worth owning, but they do not want to be exposed to silver price fluctuations (they do not pretend to themselves that such things are predictable). Another group has huge buys into silver because of an identified arbitrage opportunity - ie their purchase in no way denotes an expectation that the price will advance - the profit will come from the arbitrage. All of this going long and short creates supply or demand, and the price follows. None of this is accounted for by the TA people, the predictors of economic futures, or what have you, nor is it driven by any particular belief that silver is going to go up or down. I am not talking about internet clowns - the people in question have many billions of dollars under their management, and they truly have the economic clout to cause silver prices to change by their activities.

are you suggesting that a 30+% drop in a day is caused by genuine supply / demand market activity?

the entire activities you describe above seem to feature neither producer nor end user, nor likely any actual silver. leveraged derivatives most likely?

so this has exactly what to do with real market conditions?
 
Well if it is just responding to supply and (industrial) demand then that's a significant change to the way in which silver has apparently behaved over the past 4 years.

Over that period, the price of silver has doubled or trebled depending on where you take your start point. This is at a time of reduced industrial demand and the indication was that the price was being driven by investors shying away to equity and other investments because of uncertainty.

The current issues in Greece are causing turmoil in the equity markets but there has not yet been a corresponding rise in silver prices.

since I have been paying attention, both gold and silver take an initial drubbing in these periods of threat of potentially deflationary collapse scenarios, but silver is always hit worse %-wise.

then the central printers step in and silver bounces back later than gold but outperforms again on the upside.

I don't think the daily spot price really tells us much about fundamentals anymore, the price discovery mechanism is as broken as the rest of the markets IMO.
 
are you suggesting that a 30+% drop in a day is caused by genuine supply / demand market activity?

the entire activities you describe above seem to feature neither producer nor end user, nor likely any actual silver. leveraged derivatives most likely?

so this has exactly what to do with real market conditions?

How is what Roger described not a real market?
 
lol. why do you find it so hard to visualize that there are points where heavy buyers wait with order in place that would stop all but the biggest sellers?

if you look here for example you can see it live (across the LBMA during market hours) http://bullionvault.com/gold_market.do (select "Market Depth")

and silver def still doing ok YTD

fut_image.ashx

I see that both silver and gold are now down YTD.
 
Praise the Bernank for printing money which drives the value of my physical silver holdings higher.

Of course, I have sympathy for the great unwashed who will be wiped out as inflation destroys their meager incomes.

But fear not, the bankers who are currently flipping bonds back to the Fed within a week of their issuance are making a fat payday every POMO day and will continue to live in their shining mansions on the hill.

If you are kind to them, they may feel pitty for you and provide you with handouts and perhaps some rice to feed your families.

Praise Mao, and may the Bernank reign supreme forever.

This is amusing to read a year later. :D
 
I don't think there's any record on this forum of michaelsuede being bullish or long silver before 1st April, when the spot price was $37.8.

You read my mind.

To be fair to MichaelSuede, his blog/website has a post dating back to Jan 2010 where he states:
You need to pull all your money out of paper investments and put it all into gold and silver that you are personally holding. The end is very near. Get ready for it.

So I can believe that he has been long silver for some time and he probably purchased some silver at $17/ounce or less. However, I would bet that a good portion of his silver was purchased at a price equal to or higher than $28/ounce.
 
To be fair to MichaelSuede, his blog/website has a post dating back to Jan 2010 where he states:

So I can believe that he has been long silver for some time and he probably purchased some silver at $17/ounce or less. However, I would bet that a good portion of his silver was purchased at a price equal to or higher than $28/ounce.

Thank you for that info. And my apologies to MS, wherever he may be.

It does seem to me that Mr. Suede's predictions appear more ideological than analytic.

Using "Zero Hedge" as a source for anything other than a good belly laugh doesn't really help.
 
Last edited:
I've no axe to grind here.

Think it's safe to say gold and silver are down solely because of fears concerning Greece/future of the Euro, etc.

That is, that the dollar is so strong in this deflationary environment. Nothing to be smug about IMO.
 
Last edited:
I've no axe to grind here.

Think it's safe to say gold and silver are down solely because of fears concerning Greece/future of the Euro, etc.

That is, that the dollar is so strong in this deflationary environment. Nothing to be smug about IMO.

If that's the case then I think it's very interesting because the price of gold and silver used to rise on news of economic uncertainty.
 
If that's the case then I think it's very interesting because the price of gold and silver used to rise on news of economic uncertainty.

gold used to, silver not so much, and since 08 they have both always been hit very hard (initially anyway) any time there's a whiff of deflation in the air

whether its funds needing to liquidate to meet other losses or "perception management" or combinations thereof, big drops on deflationary headlines are not in anyway unusual.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom