Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

I've no axe to grind here.

Think it's safe to say gold and silver are down solely because of fears concerning Greece/future of the Euro, etc.

That is, that the dollar is so strong in this deflationary environment. Nothing to be smug about IMO.

If that's the case then I think it's very interesting because the price of gold and silver used to rise on news of economic uncertainty.

In the opposite case though (no economic uncertainty, good times ahead) there would be another reason for gold and silver to go down: You want to put your money in stocks instead. This is what happened in the 90s. The stock markets were roaring, and gold was very cheap. Gold did very well since 2008 by comparison.
 
Think it's safe to say gold and silver are down solely because of fears concerning Greece/future of the Euro, etc.

I don't think that's "safe to say" at all.

Post hoc, hasty generalization, correlation equals causation, all come to mind. A whole garden of fallacies from which to choose!

All those same factors had some predicting an increase in silver not so long ago in this thread.

Again, if all of these factors do not give one predictive powers, we just have essentially random free market moves being explained after the fact with "just so" stories.

What silver is going to do going forward has always been the guessing game here. And will forever remain a guess, IMHO.
 
Last edited:
What silver is going to do going forward has always been the guessing game here. And will forever remain a guess, IMHO.

not really, (on a long enough timeline) at some point market fundamentals must reassert themselves.

steadily increasing industrial demand, dwindling inventory..

.. price continues down to decline beyond it's current 600 year lows?

not very likely IMO

this guy was first a classically trained economist, who started looking in depth at the silver market

http://www.bullionbullscanada.com/silver-commentary/23894-exposing-silver-mythology-part-i

Simply, every year (for as far back as reliable data exists) production (i.e. mine supply) has been exceeded by demand, and generally by a huge margin. It is the most elementary principle of markets (and arithmetic) that no market can remain out of balance forever, and in particular any market experiencing excess demand must reverse itself (at the very latest) when inventories reach zero.

With silver mining already extremely depressed by the 600-year low in price, with inventories already having plummeted by more than 75% over the preceding 12 years, and with GFMS itself predicting that production will fall (again) in the upcoming year, it still concludes that prices are just fine. This is not “economic analysis”, it’s “creative writing” (i.e. fiction).

There is only one source of “new silver” in the entire world: mine production. Any/every other ounce of silver which comes onto the market represents a draw-down of inventories/stockpiles. By definition, this is absolutely unsustainable as inventories are finite and (obviously) can never go below zero.

I fully concur with Sprott that silver will be the investment of the next decade, like Gold was the last.
 
I fully concur with Sprott that silver will be the investment of the next decade, like Gold was the last.

Sprott's a canny one, he makes a prediction where it'll take 10 years to find out whether he was wrong or not.
 
It's not quite true that mining is the only source of silver available for industrial users.

For example in 2000, the demand for silver in the United States was 3,000 metric tonnes.

In 2000, 1,700 tonnes of silver was recovered from secondary sources (i.e. recycled)

Source: http://pubs.usgs.gov/circ/c1196n/c1196n.pdf

This may help to explain the long-term imbalance between silver usage and silver mining
 
It's not quite true that mining is the only source of silver available for industrial users.

For example in 2000, the demand for silver in the United States was 3,000 metric tonnes.

In 2000, 1,700 tonnes of silver was recovered from secondary sources (i.e. recycled)

Source: http://pubs.usgs.gov/circ/c1196n/c1196n.pdf

This may help to explain the long-term imbalance between silver usage and silver mining

interesting, although i suspect its a bit out of date now. for example, in 2000, silver was still used in photography, digital cameras were in their infancy.

For example, of the 2,500 t of silver consumed in the United States in photographic applications in 2000, some of the metal is still in use (archived X-ray film, black and white photographs), another part has been recycled (silver recovered from fixer solutions)

this would appear to be quite a large amount on it's own, now all heading into new applications, electronics, mobile phones, cruise missiles, solar (the power of the future lol)
 
I'd like to make a prediction concerning the price of silver. If the spot crosses above the $45 level, the OP will make a sudden reappearance. Thank you.
 


Link failed.

Did Bloomberg really say that? Gold might've regained some ground because it was perceived as being a good buy, what with all the losses recently and esp in light of how the Fed hinted at more quantitative easing.

The dollar is still largely perceived as the best safe haven. Gold isn't.

Like I said before, I've no axe to grind here. I'm much more with Krugman than Paul Ryan on the way out.
 
Link failed.

Did Bloomberg really say that? Gold might've regained some ground because it was perceived as being a good buy, what with all the losses recently and esp in light of how the Fed hinted at more quantitative easing.

The dollar is still largely perceived as the best safe haven. Gold isn't.

Like I said before, I've no axe to grind here. I'm much more with Krugman than Paul Ryan on the way out.

Sorry, I posted that from my mobile and I made a mistake in editing the URL.

Here's what should be the correct link:
Stocks Drop on Europe, Manufacturing Data as Gold Rallies

Stocks sank, dragging the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index to a four-month low, as concern grew about the health of Spanish banks and an U.S. gauge of manufacturing trailed projections. Gold rebounded from its lowest level of the year while 10-year Treasury yields approached a record low.

The S&P 500 tumbled 1.5 percent to close at 1,304.86 at 4 p.m. New York time and the Dow Jones Industrial Average slid 156 points. The Stoxx Europe 600 Index (SXXP) lost 1.1 percent, while Russian and Brazilian stocks entered bear markets. U.S. notes gained as a $13 billion auction of 10-year Treasury Inflation Protected Securities drew a record low negative yield. The Dollar Index (DXY) climbed for a record 14th straight day. Oil fell to a six-month low, while gold surged the most since October.

Concern about Europe’s debt crisis deepened as two people familiar with the situation said Moody’s Investors Service was set to downgrade the credit ratings of Spanish banks, with the ratings firm confirming the cuts after U.S. markets closed. The Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia’s general economic index decreased to minus 5.8 in May, indicating an unexpected contraction in manufacturing. The index of leading economic indicators dropped in April for the first time in seven months.

Note that gold is going opposite from oil, which is falling on the news.
 
Last edited:
as Frank said, Gold was reacting to the increased liklihood of QE3 because of the poor Philly Fed report yesterday.

the "safehaven" status applies to gold on geo political matters, not deflation / liquidation concerns (yet)
 
Note that gold is going opposite from oil, which is falling on the news.

Well that's the way it used to behave.

Oil is more of a "classical" commodity, the price tends to rise when there is increased "real" demand so news of economic growth would most likely result in a rise in the price of oil because there's likely to be more demand. The exception would be tensions in the Middle East which would likely cause the price of oil to rise on fears of reduced supply.

Gold used to be a hedge in times of uncertainly so the same bad economic news which results in the fall of the price of oil may cause a rise in the price of gold.
 
I believe that what he meant was "so why not spend spend spend and let your grandchildren deal with it?"

So you, like so many others, don't understand Keynes.

1) When times are rough, government can spend into the economy to smooth out the trough.
2) When times are good, the government repays the debt incurred during the bad times.

It is step 2 where the US has gone horribly wrong.
 
So you, like so many others, don't understand Keynes.

1) When times are rough, government can spend into the economy to smooth out the trough.
2) When times are good, the government repays the debt incurred during the bad times.

It is step 2 where the US has gone horribly wrong.

no I did know that's what he proposed, but as its blatently ridiculous to expect politicians to ever cut back and save during good times (as evidenced by hardly any ever doing it) he fails because he has no clue about the nature of mankind - or politician-kind anyway
 
So now I completely don't understand the price of silver.
I don't know what's to understand. It is not an asset like a stock or a bond, it does not entitle its owner to a claim on cash flows generated by economic activity, and it should have no long term real rate of return, not even the cash rate. This has been stated at various times in the thread. It has a price (where supply clears with demand, and that includes "speculative" as well as "end use" demand and supply); it does not have a value.
 
its blatently ridiculous to expect politicians to ever cut back and save during good times (as evidenced by hardly any ever doing it) he fails because he has no clue about the nature of mankind - or politician-kind anyway
Broadly correct. This is a powerful argument for non-cyclical budget balancing to be enshrined in a nation's constitution (which is the place for ethics and the public good) rather than left to legislative assemblies (which is the place for representation of constituencies' interests).

As far as I know the only country that has put such a constitutional rule in place is Germany. Maybe Spain too actually, though starting from a point of low credibility.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom