Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

It is a fallacy to think China will be just as hurt by this as the US.

China will still have a viable currency and will be able to trade internationally for products and services.

Further, the Chinese people will simply buy their own products, just like we used to do before we found out that printing money to pay for foreign goods is easier than trading real resources for them.

Correct, but many nations, besides the US, are inflating their currency. As I recall, pretty much across the G20 this exists. Their currencies are all falling, just at different rates. Any argument on money and value based on a single nation's perspective is going to be false. For example, if the Euro collapses, then at least for w while, the USD would look pretty good.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_as_an_investment

As recently as 2005 it was $7.31. In 2000 it was $4.95

Adjusted for inflation, that's $6.42 in 2011 dollars for 2000, and $8.36 in 2011 dollars for 2005.


You are using CPI inflation, while in my estimates, I am using ground observation inflation.

Or it may not*.



Operative word: "guessing".


*"May is the classic "weasel word". Whenever you hear it, mentally add "or may not" to the statement for balance.

what's your point?
I am not making predictions, I am just stating what I think is possible. I do not think it will go below $12, and am guessing in all likelihood, it will fall to $25 at worst.

to put it another way, Ill be surprised if it goes below $25, but I know it isn't going below $12... ever.
 
Last edited:
...but I know it isn't going below $12... ever.

Some of us old timers have been watching gold and silver prices for 30 or 40 years.

I remember when the Hunt brothers were trying to manipulate the price of silver in the 80's. It went to about $50 then, and lots of people made statements similar to yours about how low it could go from there. And most of them were wrong.

My point is? That, in principle, no one knows where precious metal prices are headed. It's part of the baggage a free market brings with it. It's NOT a reason not to own some, if it fits your overall investment strategy. But guessing is all you're doing, and attempting to profit from short-term predictions has proven to be a fool's errand in the past. I see no fundamental reason why that has changed.
 
The bolded part is just flat wrong. Historically, inflation leads, lowered currency value lags. Let's say 18 months or longer, depending on several things. So there is after some money printing, an "unrealized or latent" inflation which may be simply forecast. Consider the very first day after printing a trillion extra. The street value of a dollar has not changed. Now consider how long it takes the street to absorb that new money, and for the values to average out.

No, if new money is created and spent (or invested), the effects, in an absolute sense, are immediate. The source of confusion has to do with how inflation is measured (a doctored CPI) and more importantly, the absence of domestic asset prices (let alone foreign dollar denominated asset prices). Asset inflation is further obfuscated by the fact that the supply of financial assets can be increased just as easily and arbitrarily as fiat money. The "lag" you are speaking of only refers to how long it takes the increased asset prices to translate into an increase in the doctored index of consumer prices, but the effects on some asset prices, somewhere, is immediate.

In simple terms, the benevolent recipients of the Fed's easy money policy get richer in terms of nominal asset prices long before their increased consumption gets resolved in higher consumer prices. The man on the street doesn't notice if David Rockefeller's bond portfolio jumps from $100B to $200B, he only notices when this has a material affect on Rockefeller's consumption of real goods and services.

And in some cases, GNP growth is 2-3 percent, and money printing is 2-3 percent, and they seem to cancel out for a while leaving currency values similar.

That's not going to happen on this merry go round, though.

We always have monetary inflation that exceeds real output, because we're told that forcing the saver to spend by stealing from him is the key to prosperity, and that economic armageddon would result otherwise. But as more cronies get arbitrarily rich from what the Fed is doing, they will inevitably consume more (without producing anything), and that will translate into pain felt by everyone else.
 
One thing I think that gold has going for it that silver does not is the 800 pound gorrilas known as central banks buying the stuff.

http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/money/2011/05/05/bank-mexico-buys-100-tons-gold/

Of course if those gorrilas stop or if they turn around and sell their gold it could go the other way.

The problem with this logic, of course, is that gold and silver prices are used as a barometer of central bank monetary inflation by many. It's in the central bank's interest to perpetuate a fiat money regime by selling, not buying precious metals, so as to attempt to manage "inflation expectations". So the only central bank buyers of gold are likely to be those banks with the least to gain from their own fiat currency regimes.
 
Evidence?

Because the first thing to show an effect when you print dollars is the value of dollars goes down. It is the most immediate, and so far as we can argue, "correct" valuation of the dollar. But silver is not matching lock-step with the dollar devaluation; anything but.

The value of dollars inevitably goes down when new dollars are created, the question is, using what as the numeraire? Silver is volatile now as the result of others anticipating higher nominal silver prices due to currency devaluation, as well as others speculating on this. The equilibrium price of silver in dollars, however, will in the long run reflect the supply of dollars, among other things.

Now, if by 'cause' you mean people freak out and create a bubble, perhaps. But I would argue that is an oblique/confusing way of describing it, as the wording implies that somehow the current money status = some massive devaluation.

Have you seen this?

fredgraph.png
 
Some of us old timers have been watching gold and silver prices for 30 or 40 years.

I remember when the Hunt brothers were trying to manipulate the price of silver in the 80's. It went to about $50 then, and lots of people made statements similar to yours about how low it could go from there. And most of them were wrong.

My point is? That, in principle, no one knows where precious metal prices are headed. It's part of the baggage a free market brings with it. It's NOT a reason not to own some, if it fits your overall investment strategy. But guessing is all you're doing, and attempting to profit from short-term predictions has proven to be a fool's errand in the past. I see no fundamental reason why that has changed.

"ever" is not a short term prediction. ;) If I were trying to profit from short term predictions, I would be shorting or selling silver and hoping to buy on the dips. I am not. I am buying silver and holding it until I need it or I am dead.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
The bolded part is just flat wrong. Historically, inflation leads, lowered currency value lags. Let's say 18 months or longer, depending on several things. So there is after some money printing, an "unrealized or latent" inflation which may be simply forecast. Consider the very first day after printing a trillion extra. The street value of a dollar has not changed. Now consider how long it takes the street to absorb that new money, and for the values to average out.

No, if new money is created and spent (or invested), the effects, in an absolute sense, are immediate. The source of confusion has to do with how inflation is measured (a doctored CPI) and more importantly, the absence of domestic asset prices (let alone foreign dollar denominated asset prices).....

Suppose we were on a small remote island which had a 1000 units of currency total. We go make 1000 more units of currency, and take some of them down to the village to trade. Initially, they buy the same amount of goods. At first, nobody realizes "money is plentiful". As they are spent, there exists a latent inflation. That's the difference between the actual diluted value and the prior value at that moment in time, leaving aside factors of GNP changes and of velocity for the moment.

But it isn't instantly realized.

And this has nothing at all to do with doctored CPIs.
 
Suppose we were on a small remote island which had a 1000 units of currency total. We go make 1000 more units of currency, and take some of them down to the village to trade. Initially, they buy the same amount of goods. At first, nobody realizes "money is plentiful". As they are spent, there exists a latent inflation. That's the difference between the actual diluted value and the prior value at that moment in time, leaving aside factors of GNP changes and of velocity for the moment.

But it isn't instantly realized.

And this has nothing at all to do with doctored CPIs.

I submit that if you doubled the money supply on a small island, and used all of the proceeds to bid up goods and services right away, that the shopkeepers would find out what is going on almost immediately. But I grant your point, it's not "instant". My point wasn't that it has to do with the CPI, it has to do with massive amounts of money bidding up assets, both domestic and foreign, in a non-transparent way. What I'm essentially trying to say is, there are massive transfers of wealth going on in spite of relatively mild changes in CPI. If I counterfeit $100M and don't spend it on any goods and services, but instead buy beachfront property in Costa Rica, poor and middle class people aren't necessarily going to feel that immediately, but I'm that much richer anyway. Sure, I will use the rent proceeds to gradually ramp up my consumption of goods and services, but I'm still $100M richer than my neighbor almost overnight, and yet the CPI didn't budge. So there isn't so much of a lag as there is a complete failure to measure the effects of asset inflation.
 
.... If I counterfeit $100M and don't spend it on any goods and services, but instead buy beachfront property in Costa Rica, poor and middle class people aren't necessarily going to feel that immediately, but I'm that much richer anyway. Sure, I will use the rent proceeds to gradually ramp up my consumption of goods and services, but I'm still $100M richer than my neighbor almost overnight, and yet the CPI didn't budge. So there isn't so much of a lag as there is a complete failure to measure the effects of asset inflation.

Yep. That's the difference between asset inflation and CPI style inflation.

There is a key, seldom mentioned point. There isn't any way that money can be printed, with or without GNP rising, without it being a redistribution to the parties favored by the money printers, and a theft from the public. It's curious that any public would fall for the propaganda "this is good for you"...
 
The silver spot price is back above 38 and trending northward once again.

At no time did physical bullion being sold at online auctions dip below 40 during this episode.

During the past week, nearly 90% of SLV silver contracts traded hands. This is unprecedented. What we witnessed were the weak under-capitalized hands getting driven from the futures market while strong players that are fully capitalized came in to play with their own money.

Currently, 1 oz of silver bullion is trading for $55.00 on Ebay with heavy action.

That is a $17.00 premium on immediate physical delivery.
 
Last edited:
The silver spot price is back above 38 and trending northward once again.

At no time did physical bullion being sold at online auctions dip below 40 during this episode.

During the past week, nearly 90% of SLV silver contracts traded hands. This is unprecedented. What we witnessed were the weak under-capitalized hands getting driven from the futures market while strong players that are fully capitalized came in to play with their own money.

Currently, 1 oz of silver bullion is trading for $55.00 on Ebay with heavy action.

That is a $17.00 premium on immediate physical delivery.

1oz silver bullion coins have always carried a hefty premium to spot silver prices, though, because 1oz coins are more liquid than bars. This should come down as the price of silver rises.
 
Any kind of old **** will sell on eBay.

If you're going to buy silver, buy in bulk (multiples of 1000's of ounces) and don't take delivery.

A handful of silver coins is neither here nor there.

Whether silver is a good investment is a completely different topic but if you insist on investing, do it wholesale not retail.
 
And you know that silver isn't doing a dead cat impression because... ?

Because fundamentals say otherwise.

I'm sure there will still be some price volatility in silver following the expulsion of the weak players from the market, but there is nothing that will fundamentally make the demand for silver go away.

The US is actively debasing its currency.
 
The silver spot price is back above 38 and trending northward once again.

At no time did physical bullion being sold at online auctions dip below 40 during this episode.

During the past week, nearly 90% of SLV silver contracts traded hands. This is unprecedented. What we witnessed were the weak under-capitalized hands getting driven from the futures market while strong players that are fully capitalized came in to play with their own money.

Currently, 1 oz of silver bullion is trading for $55.00 on Ebay with heavy action.

That is a $17.00 premium on immediate physical delivery.

I can still call up my local coin ship and buy bullion for $2 over spot.
 
"ever" is not a short term prediction. ;) If I were trying to profit from short term predictions, I would be shorting or selling silver and hoping to buy on the dips. I am not. I am buying silver and holding it until I need it or I am dead.

Then we're in general agreement. Its just that I try to never make any predictions, especially about the future. ;)

I do own some gold coins and some silver coins. I've stayed away from bullion due to what I see as less liquidity. Like you, I have no plans to ever sell the coins, though who knows what the future may bring - I see the coins as some "insurance" against inflation - no more, no less.

I want to comment most everyone on this thread for generally rational and informed discourse. Another thread about $1,500 gold turned really mean and personal, with anyone electing to hold any precious metals called all sorts of names. I eventually made that the first thread I ever added to my "ignore" list.

Nice to see that intelligent individuals can just agree to disagree without any name calling (at least for now).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom