Sibel Edmonds ready to tell it all

Where will we witness here spilling the beans?

  • ABC will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • NBC will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • CBS will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • CNN will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • MSNBC will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • FOX will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No MSM network will cover it - because it's conpiracy bulls* anyway

    Votes: 15 51.7%
  • No MSM network will cover it - they are bought and paid for anyway

    Votes: 3 10.3%
  • On Planet X we don't want whistleblowers on MSM - we prefer tekkkkno

    Votes: 8 27.6%

  • Total voters
    29
I have watched part of this video. It seems to provide more supporting evidence for the claim that Edmonds was fired for political reasons within the department that she worked in. That seems likely and it seems to have been confirmed by the government investigation into her case. As a general observation, people are fired and demoted all the time for political reasons. It might be sad, but that is the nature of being human and working in organizations that are governed by the various foibles associated with human organizations. When Edmonds chose to go around her supervisor she was putting herself at risk, she may not have realized it and underestimated the petty political process that is often used to run organizations but as a 63 year old individual that has seen a lot of petty politics in organizations it doesn't surprise me at all.

The interesting question, it seems, is why wasn't her initial complaint dealt with, at least in a way that she was made aware of. I don't know and haven't followed this story close enough to know what the theories are. One possibility , seems to be that the Dickerson's were Israeli spies. Is that what you (Childlike Empress) or others think? At this point, if there is a government conspiracy to prevent the truth about Edmonds case from getting out it looks like it has succeeded. We seem to be left with facts that suggest a conspiracy but without the facts to sort out what the conspiracy is. If this isn't the case perhaps somebody could describe what they believe the conspiracy was and the evidence for their theory.


Dave, it sounds like you watched around ten minutes of the film. With that level of knowledge you ask the right questions, although the Dickerson's were not working as "spies". The wife worked with Sibel in the language unit and Sibel spotted that she was selectively translating material, and flagging other material as non-relevant. When the wife became aware of Sibel realizing what she does, the described visit of the Dickerson's at the Edmond's household took place, where they offered Sibel to join that club with huge benefits. We're talking immediately post-9/11 and these are moles in the language unit obfuscating the attempts to handle the huge amount of data that was not handled prior to 9/11, taking care that information concerning their buddies at that club didn't get into the hands of investigators.

And instead of taking up the offer, Sibel decided to go to the channels available to deal with stuff like that, first her supervisor, then up the whole chain of checks and balances. So the question here is not why her initial complaint wasn't dealt with, but why ALL her complaints weren't dealt with and she ended up as "classified woman".

In fact those first ten minutes contain the rough summary of what this has to do with Sibel personally. The rest of the story is about the system reacting to someone insisting on "doing the right thing".

So if you want to know about how rotten and corrupt that system is, I suggest you watch the film in full and then let Sibel tell her own story, ideally in the book she wrote, or in the radio interview about the publication I linked at the end of post 51.

You'll find no "9/11 was an inside job and i'm only going to tell if you give me my 15 minutes of fame" claims in that story, contrary to what morons or worse on both sides of the 9/11 issue might tell you. It touches a bit on 9/11, though, namely with of course the time frame, some of the stuff she translated, members of the Whistleblower organization she founded, and her encounter with the 9/11 commission.

The latter is covered in the documentary, IIRC.

edit - new page, for convenience:

French public television documentary "Kill the Messenger", 2006:



Detailed Interview by her podcast co-host Peter B. Collins about the release of her memoirs, 2012:

In a two-and-a-half hour radio interview she shares what happened with us and Peter B. Collins: Part One | Part Two
 
Last edited:
And I guarantee you the ACLU does not support her condition that news media must agree to air her entire statement without editing in order to exercise their First Amendment rights.


The ACLU had indeed nothing to do with her decision to be willing to go to jail if one of the network takes up her challenge to air her entire statement without editing. That's what she did. You are obviously talking without any knowledge of the case. How come?
 
My apologies Childish Empress, but I just don't have enough interest in this issue to watch the documentaries and listen to the interviews you have linked to.

At this point, as I noted above, it seems like Sibel Edmonds was the victim of some political maneuvering that caused her to be fired. In most organizations one becomes immediately at risk if one is seen to be bypassing (and thus threatening the status of) one's immediate supervisors to talk to higher levels of management. Sometimes it can work out for the individual and sometimes they get fired. It's not nice, but in the real world it happens.

What beyond this is going on with the Sibel Edmonds case? I don't know and I haven't seen where evidence for the possibilities has been put forward. Maybe some place in the documentaries that you have linked to they have laid out that evidence. You seem to have watched them, could you summarize what the theories are as to why Sibel Edmonds was fired beyond the fact that she ruffled some bureaucratic feathers?

As to whether the Dickerson's were spies or not: Regardless of the terminology used isn't one theory here that the Dickerson's were working as foreign agents? There seem to be two general claims associated with this case: 1. Edmonds was treated unfairly for political reasons and 2. There is some kind of conspiracy going on here to cover up a secret that was undermining the efforts of the translation operation to provide reliable information to American officials.

OK, what is the nature of this conspiracy? Who is funding the effort? How high in the American government did the effort go? Is the basic situation at this point that Edmonds believes she got screwed but she doesn't know why except that she believes there was some sketchy activity going on that wasn't dealt with adequately by the translation department's management?
 
My apologies Childish Empress, but I just don't have enough interest in this issue to watch the documentaries and listen to the interviews you have linked to.


No problem. As it happens i'm a firm believer in "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink", so the choice to use the information I provided to inform yourself is yours, but don't expect me to waste time summarizing things you aren't really interested in in the first place.

As about what is going on in the case - nothing. The book is out, it's selling good, everybody in the relevant fields is informed about it. Between the time of the starting of this thread with her offer to the MSM and the time she published the book, nothing happened other than that she left the country, became mother, returned and became kind of an internet activist.

Oh, and that the Obama regime made the Bush regime look like paradise for whistleblowers.
 
D

You'll find no "9/11 was an inside job and i'm only going to tell if you give me my 15 minutes of fame" claims in that story, contrary to what morons or worse on both sides of the 9/11 issue might tell you. It touches a bit on 9/11, though, namely with of course the time frame, some of the stuff she translated, members of the Whistleblower organization she founded, and her encounter with the 9/11 commission.


So since your knowledge of this person is extensive, would you confirm that:

Sibel has no first hand knowledge of any government official having intelligence about the attacks of 9/11 prior to their occurrence, at least that which could be remotely actionable- nor first hand knowledge at any time which implicates government officials conspiring in allowing them to happen in willful ignorance of said intelligence.

True or false?

(It's my understanding her knowledge is limited to a recording of an informant, taped before 9/11 but heard after the event, in which she hears the informant claim a very, very vague hint toward attacks upon us, and adding that people in government knew at the time this vague rumor he spoke of. Key details, nothing actionable, nothing confirmed, no names, places, dates, all taking the word of an informant. )

Her story isn't dissimilar to that of fired LAPD cop Bob Dorner- she gets fired in an entanglement possibly their own making, and after the fact try to go public with a laundry list of malfeasance by people far outside the scope of their own contact to prove they also were wronged. Many focus on proving these other instances of malfeasance correct but they aren't relevant to her and if she's neither a principal nor provides evidence for the claims about the HUGE story (9/11) she's attached her own to, there's "nothing to see here".

Yeah lots of bogeymen in the FBI, lots of thuggery. She can't provide anything to see anyone prosecuted for the things people care about.
 
Last edited:
No first hand knowledge, that's correct. Nobody told her.

The interview about Turkey turned into a series which is absolutely essential listening and connects many dots even I wasn't able able to connect before (and I'm known for trying ;)). Part two here and part three from Friday here. tbc.
 
Does she have any travel restrictions onher?

If not she can leave the US renounce citizenship and become a citizen of another state and spill the beans
 
No first hand knowledge, that's correct. Nobody told her.

The interview about Turkey turned into a series which is absolutely essential listening and connects many dots even I wasn't able able to connect before (and I'm known for trying ;)). Part two here and part three from Friday here. tbc.

So her claims regarding intelligence existing which was ignored by government because they wanted 9/11 to happen are pure speculation based upon her ideological beliefs formed from knowledge or suspicion of other government negligence and corruption.
You don't think that creates a problem regarding her credibility, and can even be interpreted as good cause for the FBI to have canned her in the first place?
 
She is dubbed "the most gagged person in american history".
I'm just curious who Ms. Edmonds or her supporters think was the second most gagged woman in American history.
I'm guessing that the top 100 actual "most gagged" women never actually talked about it and that Ms. Edmonds isn't even on that list. I'm also pretty sure that none of them wrote a book on how gagged they were and included what they were gagged from saying in the first place.
They all dated David Allen Coe at some point, obviously. :p
because they wanted 9/11 to happen
That's the part that doesn't get to see much supporting evidence, it seems.

As usual.
 
Last edited:
Your conclusion is wrong. Make yourself familiar with her claims and case before trying to explain them away. It looks silly.

Why do you think I'm here, but to do research so I know what I'm talking about?

This isn't that hard, and you don't need to insult anyone's intelligence or waste their time directing them to radio talk shows that are effectively wild goose chases, hoping they will get so confused they forget what the issue was.

If Sibel Edmonds has stated that the government had intelligence about 9/11 beforehand, and failed to act on it because they wanted it to happen- or answered yes to the question posed to her- if that claim were credible she would have to have seen or known of this intelligence, and had evidence or first hand knowledge of an official knowing about it and not acting.

Is that perfectly clear? Please read it again it it's not.

Do you understand now why I say if she doesn't have those things and/or is unwilling to specify them, why she is only speculating and really has no credibility on the matter?
 
When you provided this:

Information omitted and covered-up regarding documented and confirmed case of a long-term FBI Informant & Asset who provided the FBI with specific information and warnings in April & June 2001 regarding 9/11 terrorist attacks.

Isn't it true that the substance of this "information" is the recorded tape of the informant offering no detailed information whatsoever, and merely the informant's claim that unspecified individuals in government knew what this information he did not detail was?

Given that is true, and I believe it is, why should this be considered anything of note- and not just a big fat nothing being offered to get people to think she has something relevant about 9/11 to reveal?

For her claims to be taken seriously, she needs to have specifics on "actionable" intelligence* and who it was who did not act on it- and proof they knew it.

*"actionable" intelligence: The President's Daily Threat Assessment, where he was told Bin Laden wanted to attack the US using planes, for instance, is NOT what is considered "actionable" intelligence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom