Childlike Empress
Banned
I have watched part of this video. It seems to provide more supporting evidence for the claim that Edmonds was fired for political reasons within the department that she worked in. That seems likely and it seems to have been confirmed by the government investigation into her case. As a general observation, people are fired and demoted all the time for political reasons. It might be sad, but that is the nature of being human and working in organizations that are governed by the various foibles associated with human organizations. When Edmonds chose to go around her supervisor she was putting herself at risk, she may not have realized it and underestimated the petty political process that is often used to run organizations but as a 63 year old individual that has seen a lot of petty politics in organizations it doesn't surprise me at all.
The interesting question, it seems, is why wasn't her initial complaint dealt with, at least in a way that she was made aware of. I don't know and haven't followed this story close enough to know what the theories are. One possibility , seems to be that the Dickerson's were Israeli spies. Is that what you (Childlike Empress) or others think? At this point, if there is a government conspiracy to prevent the truth about Edmonds case from getting out it looks like it has succeeded. We seem to be left with facts that suggest a conspiracy but without the facts to sort out what the conspiracy is. If this isn't the case perhaps somebody could describe what they believe the conspiracy was and the evidence for their theory.
Dave, it sounds like you watched around ten minutes of the film. With that level of knowledge you ask the right questions, although the Dickerson's were not working as "spies". The wife worked with Sibel in the language unit and Sibel spotted that she was selectively translating material, and flagging other material as non-relevant. When the wife became aware of Sibel realizing what she does, the described visit of the Dickerson's at the Edmond's household took place, where they offered Sibel to join that club with huge benefits. We're talking immediately post-9/11 and these are moles in the language unit obfuscating the attempts to handle the huge amount of data that was not handled prior to 9/11, taking care that information concerning their buddies at that club didn't get into the hands of investigators.
And instead of taking up the offer, Sibel decided to go to the channels available to deal with stuff like that, first her supervisor, then up the whole chain of checks and balances. So the question here is not why her initial complaint wasn't dealt with, but why ALL her complaints weren't dealt with and she ended up as "classified woman".
In fact those first ten minutes contain the rough summary of what this has to do with Sibel personally. The rest of the story is about the system reacting to someone insisting on "doing the right thing".
So if you want to know about how rotten and corrupt that system is, I suggest you watch the film in full and then let Sibel tell her own story, ideally in the book she wrote, or in the radio interview about the publication I linked at the end of post 51.
You'll find no "9/11 was an inside job and i'm only going to tell if you give me my 15 minutes of fame" claims in that story, contrary to what morons or worse on both sides of the 9/11 issue might tell you. It touches a bit on 9/11, though, namely with of course the time frame, some of the stuff she translated, members of the Whistleblower organization she founded, and her encounter with the 9/11 commission.
The latter is covered in the documentary, IIRC.
edit - new page, for convenience:
French public television documentary "Kill the Messenger", 2006:
Detailed Interview by her podcast co-host Peter B. Collins about the release of her memoirs, 2012:
Last edited: