Sibel Edmonds ready to tell it all

Where will we witness here spilling the beans?

  • ABC will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • NBC will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • CBS will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • CNN will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • MSNBC will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • FOX will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No MSM network will cover it - because it's conpiracy bulls* anyway

    Votes: 15 51.7%
  • No MSM network will cover it - they are bought and paid for anyway

    Votes: 3 10.3%
  • On Planet X we don't want whistleblowers on MSM - we prefer tekkkkno

    Votes: 8 27.6%

  • Total voters
    29
ETA: with a quick look, and with my layman knowledge of law, I didn't see anything relating to a gag order.


That's probably because the link that Childlike provided does not include any evidence of any gag order against Ms. Edmonds.


She seems to have been ordered not to ask specific questions pertaining to things the government deemed "state secret privileges", but where does it say that she can't speak of it outside the courtroom?

Actually, from the documents at Childlike's link, that appears not to be the case, as Ms. Edmonds was not the subject of any such order. It appears that the plaintiffs in another case issued a subpoena to Ms. Edmonds for a deposition and the plaintiffs in that other case were ultimately subjected to an order that precludes them from asking certain questions of Ms. Edmonds (for the reasons set out in the order dismissing Ms. Edmonds' wrongful dismissal complaint).

Based on the evidence provided by Childlike so far, Ms. Edmonds appears not to be under any court order at all to refrain from talking. I have not gone further than the evidence provided by Childlike so far because it's his claim and his onus, but if Childlike provides evidence that purports to back up his claims, I will certainly look at it further and assess it in as much detail as is necessary.

;)
 
The ban was on her to stop her from talking to the media and giving them something to report.


Please provide evidence of a court order that bans Ms. Edmonds from speaking to the media. I have not, to date, seen any evidence of any such order.

It is also a retroactive gag order if I recall correctly originating straight from Ashcroft.

[bolding mine]

You do not recall correctly.
 
Childlike Empress said:
Where will we witness here spilling the beans?

Dont't even try that on me. I don't have time for games, kitty. Neighter do you.

Her story - let alone the beef of the whole fuzz - is extremely embarrasing for a country that's trying to justify wars with bringing democracy to the world, and she has support from a lot of groups from ACLU to right wing civil liberties organisations.

Could someone translate the bolded bits into English?
 
Add me to the list of the unimpressed.

If this woman has decided to make some great sacrifice and tell all in the face of the evil government bureaucracy working to keep her quiet, then her path is simple. Just tell all.

Anything else she does at this time suggests a heavy dose of exaggeration or just total BS is what is going on here.
 
The Boston Globe

Translator in eye of storm on retroactive classification
By Anne E. Kornblut, Globe Staff | July 5, 2004

WASHINGTON -- Sifting through old classified materials in the days after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, FBI translator Sibel Edmonds said, she made an alarming discovery: Intercepts relevant to the terrorist plot, including references to skyscrapers, had been overlooked because they were badly translated into English.

In a rare maneuver, Attorney General John Ashcroft has ordered that information about the Edmonds case be retroactively classified, even basic facts that have been posted on websites and discussed openly in meetings with members of Congress for two years.

''I'm alarmed that the FBI is reaching back in time and classifying information it provided two years ago," Senator Charles E. Grassley, a Republican from Iowa and a leading advocate for Edmonds, said last Friday. ''Frankly, it looks like an attempt to impede legitimate oversight of a serious problem at the FBI."
 
The Boston Globe...


It's nice that you signed up just to cut and paste a link to a newspaper story without offering anything at all in the way of facts, evidence, or even opinion, but do you have anything at all to say in response to posts 3, 4, 7, 8, 11, 20, 24, 26, 29, 40, 41, 42, or 44?
 
Gord In Toronto and Corsair 115 were speculating there was, probably because in Canada such things are done.
No, we were saying that, if there were such a ban for U.S. media, it wouldn't apply to media outside the United States so what would prevent the person from telling their story to media from Canada, Britain, or wherever.
 
WASHINGTON -- Sifting through old classified materials in the days after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, FBI translator Sibel Edmonds said, she made an alarming discovery: Intercepts relevant to the terrorist plot, including references to skyscrapers, had been overlooked because they were badly translated into English.

According to her Wiki bio, she speaks Turkish, Persian and Azeri.

Weren't the hijackers speaking Arabic?
 
Don't play games, Darth; this is too important an issue to waste time on that.
One likes to see sources, rather than assertions, now and again. :)
It gets difficult, doesn't it, trying to remember what you can discuss based on knowing of it only from open sources and what you can't discuss based on it at one point somewhere having been discussed in a classified meeting? I imagine with your postings it affects you more than me.
Yep.
The DA Form 873 is not classified; I doubt the equivalent for Sibel would be. She should be able to make it available for perusal.
[/QUOTE]
I was actually referring to the material she was exposed to, not the DA form. :) I can see where my sentence might be read the other way. I would guess that the FBI has forms similar to DA, DoN, or DoD forms for the same purposes. Not sure I want to browse the FBI.gov to find the precise form.

ETA: Ah, I note that she filled out an SF-86 back in 97-98, so she had time to get a clearance. So, my assessment of her clearance status was off. There was time for her to get the clearance for the job.

http://www.fas.org/irp/agency/doj/oig/sedmonds.html

That link is a good, reasonably dry, summary of what is going on. Her complaint that things were badly translated isn't surprising, people often make errors going from one language to another. IIRC, she (and others?) brought this up to the 9-11 Commission.

ETA2: The OIG seems to agree that the FBI did a sloppy job in looking into her concerns.

the link said:
The majority of the allegations raised by Edmonds related to the actions of a co-worker. The allegations raised serious concerns that, if true, could potentially have extremely damaging consequences for the FBI. These allegations warranted a thorough and careful review by the FBI.

Our investigation concluded that the FBI did not, and still has not, adequately investigated these allegations. Our review also found that many - although not all - of Edmonds' allegations about the co-worker had some basis in fact. This evidence does not prove, and we are not suggesting, that there is sufficient evidence to conclude that espionage or any improper disclosures of FBI information occurred. However, we believe the FBI should have taken Edmonds' allegations more seriously and investigated them more thoroughly. As discussed in this report, the FBI's investigation of the information regarding the co-worker was significantly flawed. Had the FBI investigated the claims thoroughly, it would have found that many of Edmonds' allegations regarding the co-worker were supported by documentary evidence or other witnesses. Instead, the FBI seems to have discounted Edmonds' allegations, believing she was a disruptive influence and not credible, and eventually terminated her services. Even now, the FBI has not carefully investigated the allegations about the co-worker to determine if the co-worker compromised any FBI information. In light of the need for FBI vigilance about security issues, as demonstrated by the Hanssen case, we believe the FBI should have investigated these serious allegations more thoroughly.

Seems to me that the crux of the matter is the FOIA request to get some of the details referenced by the OIG report declassified. If Sibel Edmonds goes public with those details before the process is complete, then she is breaking the law, and the agreements she signed.

DR
 
Last edited:
It appears that the plaintiffs in another case issued a subpoena to Ms. Edmonds for a deposition and the plaintiffs in that other case were ultimately subjected to an order that precludes them from asking certain questions of Ms. Edmonds


Including her date of birth and the languages she speaks, you failed to mention back then. ;)

She's written her memoirs Classified Woman now and the story has really developed into something completely kafkaesk, far more profound than the initial espionage and self-enrichment she discovered in the translation unit of the FBI back in 2002.

amazon said:
In this startling new memoir, Sibel Edmonds—the most classified woman in U.S. history—takes us on a surreal journey that begins with the secretive FBI and down the dark halls of a feckless Congress to a stonewalling judiciary and finally, to the national security whistleblowers movement she spearheaded. Having lived under Middle East dictatorships, Edmonds knows firsthand what can happen when government is allowed to operate in secret. Hers is a sobering perspective that combines painful experience with a rallying cry for the public’s right to know and to hold the lawbreakers accountable. With U.S. citizens increasingly stripped of their rights in a calibrated media blackout, Edmonds’ story is a wake-up call for all Americans who, willingly or unwillingly, traded liberty for illusive security in the wake of 9/11.


In a two-and-a-half hour radio interview she shares what happened with us and Peter B. Collins: Part One | Part Two

Take note, Americans. That's a broken system. :(
 
I hope for her sake this means she's turned into a giant cockroach.

Because at this point, that's about the only way this self-centered attention whore will get what she craves.


Someone that unwilling to shut up and insistent on taking the system as it's presented must be very hard to stomach for an authoritarian mindset of a believer wearing funny underwear, so I can understand your distasteful outburst.
 
I know what she is going to say, and she is a really convincing person if you talk to her, but she can actually prove very little of what she has to say. None of it is "911 was an inside jobbie-job."

If I understand what I have heard over the years, she basically says that intelligence was too compartmentalized and too politicized and important data was lost and that after it happened people tried to sweep that ugly fact under the rug.
 
If I understand what I have heard over the years, she basically says that intelligence was too compartmentalized and too politicized and important data was lost and that after it happened people tried to sweep that ugly fact under the rug.
So she's parroting the 9/11 Commission report.
 
Someone that unwilling to shut up and insistent on taking the system as it's presented must be very hard to stomach for an authoritarian mindset of a believer wearing funny underwear, so I can understand your distasteful outburst.

First, you're a resident of the former east germany who openly shills for the former head of the east german KGB. Your complaining about authoritarians rings hollow.

Second, as Wildcat pointed out on the preceding page of this thread 5 years ago, for the "most gagged woman in America", Edmonds just doesn't seem to shut the @#$% up. She made a living for a brief period by telling people she had a card to play and was about to play it. That's never a path to long term prosperity.

Third, I'm wearing Hanes™.
 
Including her date of birth and the languages she speaks, you failed to mention back then. ;)

She's written her memoirs Classified Woman now and the story has really developed into something completely kafkaesk, far more profound than the initial espionage and self-enrichment she discovered in the translation unit of the FBI back in 2002.




In a two-and-a-half hour radio interview she shares what happened with us and Peter B. Collins: Part One | Part Two

Take note, Americans. That's a broken system. :(

For a "gagged" woman, she sure talks a lot. :oldroll:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom