Sibel Edmonds ready to tell it all

Where will we witness here spilling the beans?

  • ABC will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • NBC will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • CBS will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • CNN will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • MSNBC will provide a platform

    Votes: 1 3.4%
  • FOX will provide a platform

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No MSM network will cover it - because it's conpiracy bulls* anyway

    Votes: 15 51.7%
  • No MSM network will cover it - they are bought and paid for anyway

    Votes: 3 10.3%
  • On Planet X we don't want whistleblowers on MSM - we prefer tekkkkno

    Votes: 8 27.6%

  • Total voters
    29
I'm just curious who Ms. Edmonds or her supporters think was the second most gagged woman in American history. I mean in order to make that claim they must have an ordered list of at least the top ten (meaning her and the next nine women if their claim is correct).

I'm guessing that the top 100 actual "most gagged" women never actually talked about it and that Ms. Edmonds isn't even on that list. I'm also pretty sure that none of them wrote a book on how gagged they were and included what they were gagged from saying in the first place.
 
To those who still vote in the poll: Nobody took her offer and indeed she left the country as i've predicted. She returned after Dubya was gone, looking for that mythical "change".
 
To those who still vote in the poll: Nobody took her offer and indeed she left the country as i've predicted. She returned after Dubya was gone, looking for that mythical "change".

Apart from the fact that no one took her seriously, have any of her or your claims or predictions come true since 2007?

I mean, this is a skeptics website afterall and if one thinks one has some sort of prescience based on soopur seekrit knowledge or insight other skeptic ostensibly lack, one should be able to provide evidence that the person one supports is doing more than talking out of their ass and being ignored by media sources for that reason rather than the fact that she was talking out her ass.

Time to put up or shut up.
 
Curiously uncurious pseudo-skeptics are not my target audience. There's enough information here to clue yourself up about a topic you obviously know nothing about. Take it or leave it.
 
I am surprised she is still around pushing this stuff. All over the 9/11 pages years ago.
 

Why is it that you people are incapable of speaking any other language than youtube?

Is it really that hard to find a list of important or notable persons who support Edmonds and copy & paste here in text form so that we can tell at a glance whether she should be taken seriously?
 
What's with the whining? This isn't something to be partisan about.

The book is shooting up the amazon sales rank - now at #458. Let's hope it's not the FBI buying the whole stock like in the case of Anthony Shaffer. ;)

Yesterday on RT:


While the 2007 offers to the US MSM were refused, there was a series of articles in UK media, I think it was Times of London, although she wasn't willing to face the consequences for disclosing anything classified with the home audience staying in the dark. And the French were informed about the basics even before I started this thread - saw in the related videos to the RT report above that the french documentary "Kill the Messenger", from 2006, is up on youtube in full:

 
Last edited:
What's with the whining? This isn't something to be partisan about.

The book is shooting up the amazon sales rank - now at #458. Let's hope it's not the FBI buying the whole stock like in the case of Anthony Shaffer. ;)

Yesterday on RT:

It's the same old song and dance from Sibel; long on allegations, short on specifics. As I said years ago, she's a hootchie-kootchie dancer; you always swear she's about to reveal something and yet somehow she never quite does.
 
WASHINGTON -- Sifting through old classified materials in the days after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, FBI translator Sibel Edmonds said, she made an alarming discovery: Intercepts relevant to the terrorist plot, including references to skyscrapers, had been overlooked because they were badly translated into English

This does not support one of her more outrageous claims, or at least as she's claimed by truthers to claim: That she thinks elements in the US Government purposely ignored intelligence because they wanted the attacks to happen.
 
How much longer do we have to wait until Edmonds "tells it all"?

Or was that all there is? :boxedin:
 
How much longer do we have to wait until Edmonds "tells it all"?

Or was that all there is? :boxedin:

I couldn't remember who Sibel Edmonds was or why I was subscribed to this thread. I'm still a little confused on both of those issues but I looked around for some more information on Ms. Edmonds.

The Wikipedia article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sibel_Edmonds#cite_note-oig_update-13

Her website:
http://www.boilingfrogspost.com/

General comment: It was my intent to write a little post here mocking Ms. Edmonds. However my efforts to find material for the mocking I assumed she deserved were not successful. She may well deserve mocking but it just looks like there is enough truth to her claims that it is at least conceivable that she is not mocking worthy.

The main, mock worthy point, against her might be that she claims that she is being gagged even though she has written a book describing her travails and she seems to be a regular contributor to her blog of various anti-government articles. At any rate she seems to be doing a lot of talking for a gagged individual.

But maybe this is a timing thing, she was being gagged but now she can say what she wants about her job as a FBI translator?

Link to her book at Amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/Classified-Wo...&qid=1359707206&sr=8-1&keywords=sibel+edmonds

Anyway, I don't have enough interest to sort through all this, but I hope that some of Ms. Edmonds defenders and detractors here will take on the challenge and provide a good overview about the nature of her claims and about the overall righteousness of the woman and why she is or is not a woman that deserves to be mocked.
 
Interesting that this got bumped so timely, as she just did a kind of "tell it all" interview again. Thought about posting it in the Syria thread as it is mostly about Turkish "deep state" - one of her primary research areas - involvement in the "Arab spring" and especially Syria, but didn't do so yet because I haven't finished listening myself. Audio here.
 
Anyway, I don't have enough interest to sort through all this, but I hope that some of Ms. Edmonds defenders and detractors here will take on the challenge and provide a good overview about the nature of her claims and about the overall righteousness of the woman and why she is or is not a woman that deserves to be mocked.


Watch the second youtube video in post 69. It's a 2006 documentary by French public television.
 
Watch the second youtube video in post 69. It's a 2006 documentary by French public television.

I have watched part of this video. It seems to provide more supporting evidence for the claim that Edmonds was fired for political reasons within the department that she worked in. That seems likely and it seems to have been confirmed by the government investigation into her case. As a general observation, people are fired and demoted all the time for political reasons. It might be sad, but that is the nature of being human and working in organizations that are governed by the various foibles associated with human organizations. When Edmonds chose to go around her supervisor she was putting herself at risk, she may not have realized it and underestimated the petty political process that is often used to run organizations but as a 63 year old individual that has seen a lot of petty politics in organizations it doesn't surprise me at all.

The interesting question, it seems, is why wasn't her initial complaint dealt with, at least in a way that she was made aware of. I don't know and haven't followed this story close enough to know what the theories are. One possibility , seems to be that the Dickerson's were Israeli spies. Is that what you (Childlike Empress) or others think? At this point, if there is a government conspiracy to prevent the truth about Edmonds case from getting out it looks like it has succeeded. We seem to be left with facts that suggest a conspiracy but without the facts to sort out what the conspiracy is. If this isn't the case perhaps somebody could describe what they believe the conspiracy was and the evidence for their theory.
 
Her story - let alone the beef of the whole fuzz - is extremely embarrasing for a country that's trying to justify wars with bringing democracy to the world, and she has support from a lot of groups from ACLU to right wing civil liberties organisations.

Supporting her right to speak is not the same as supporting what she says. Your ambiguity here is dishonest.

And I guarantee you the ACLU does not support her condition that news media must agree to air her entire statement without editing in order to exercise their First Amendment rights.

They support her right to speak, but it doesn't mean they support anything that she says.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom