Should we fear Bernie?

Again I get that there is absolutely no way to say this without it coming across as some treacle nationlistic "'Murica! Love it or leave it! Yee-haw!" type screed but again we are sort of reaching the point where if "Well so and so country makes it work" is the answer to everything, questions as to what about America we are trying to save or preserve do start to be put onto the table and... why on a personal level, not as a moralistic judgement but as a simple question of personal effeciency "Well why not just move to Sweden if everything they do there is better then the way we do it here" start to become less avoidable.

I'm being 100% serious here. Wouldn't just moving to Europe just be easier if everything they do is better and nobody is going to fight you when you want to do it that way?

The people most disadvantaged by our current system as the very same people least able to pack up their lives and move abroad.

Why didn't black people in the Jim Crow South move en masse to France or some other place? Some did, of course, but most did not. Being desperately poor probably had a lot to do with it.
 
The people most disadvantaged by our current system as the very same people least able to pack up their lives and move abroad.

Why didn't black people in the Jim Crow South move en masse to France or some other place? Some did, of course, but most did not. Being desperately poor probably had a lot to do with it.

If these penniless hoodlums don't like this country they can always buy a cruise ticket to the Caribbean!
 
When your house is dirty do you a) move to a new one or b) clean it up?

In this scenario do I have a roommates he's made it clear he's going to just go behind me and dirty everything up and nothing I can say or do will stop him? He's gonna grab the mop everytime I try to mop the floor and play keep away with it? He threw out all my cleaners because they think they cause autism. He won't let me turn on the vaccum beause they don't mention those in the Bible and he wants equal time for "Intelligent Sucking."

Basically... am I living with Trump? Do I come home from work everday and there's Trump sitting on my couch in stained tighty-whiteys eating spray cheese by spraying to directly into his own mouth, while he sits there and watches porn on his laptop and right wing Youtube vidoes on his phone but... he's name on the lease to and I can't just kick him out. And he's got the landlord and the mortgage company and the HOA all buddy-buddy with him so they are going to be on his side in every possible conflict?

Essentially is there some factor in my "home" with equal or even greater power then me who's made it clear they are going to fight me, and win 9 times out 10, every step of the way as I try to make things better?

Then yeah I'm saying maybe moving to a new house is, again, something to put the table in certain circumstances.
 
Last edited:
In this scenario do I have a roommates he's made it clear he's going to just go behind me and dirty everything up and nothing I can say or do will stop him? He's gonna grab the mop everytime I try to mop the floor and play keep away with it? He threw out all my cleaners because they think they cause

Basically... am I living with Trump? Do I come home from work everday and there's Trump sitting on my couch in stained tighty-whiteys eating spray cheese by spraying to directly into his own mouth, while he sits there and watches porn on his laptop and right wing Youtube vidoes on his phone but... he's name on the lease to and I can't just kick him out. And he's got the landlord and the mortgage company and the HOA all buddy-buddy with him so they are going to be on his side in every possible conflict?

Then yeah I'm saying maybe moving to a new house is, again, something to put the table in certain circumstances.

In that scenario simply fill a wheelbarrow with melted butter and a sign reading "Do Not Drink". Your roommate will drown himself within ten minutes.
 
Again I get that there is absolutely no way to say this without it coming across as some treacle nationlistic "'Murica! Love it or leave it! Yee-haw!" type screed but again we are sort of reaching the point where if "Well so and so country makes it work" is the answer to everything, questions as to what about America we are trying to save or preserve do start to be put onto the table and... why on a personal level, not as a moralistic judgement but as a simple question of personal effeciency "Well why not just move to Sweden if everything they do there is better then the way we do it here" start to become less avoidable.

I'm being 100% serious here. Wouldn't just moving to Europe just be easier if everything they do is better and nobody is going to fight you when you want to do it that way?

What do you think is worth saving or preserving about America that people are saying should be changed, and citing European countries as examples of it working?

I understand that that sentence could come across as sarky, but it's not intended to be. It's a genuine question.
 
I think your kids should be a little disappointed in you for apparently not thinking out your position very well.
Oh, believe me, they are. ;)
"What specifically makes you think that what works there will work here?" is just not a very good question unless you can clearly state what specific historical, cultural, demographical and economical differences might prevent things from working.
I didn’t think it necessary to recount the whole conversation but we did talk about those things.

To summarize succinctly, the Nordic countries, specifically (which was the focus of our conversation), are different in a few important ways: they are much smaller, they don’t have huge militaries, they are demographically and culturally more homogenous and their economies are much simpler than ours. The current US system, flawed as it may be, is entrenched and there too many competing interests. To focus on healthcare, you simply aren’t going to convince, in the span of one Presidency, the various stakeholders to switch to a single government payer system like M4A.



I don't think the differences are so huge that the US couldn't do something similar if it decided to stop giving gazillion dollar tax cuts to bazillionaires.

I think that the “corporatism” that is so entrenched here is going to make wholesale changes to the system, like you suggest here, difficult in the short term.

The upshot of what I was trying to get across to the kids was this: there isn’t going to be a wholesale Bernie Revolution. It would be far better to support a viable candidate that starts you on the path you want to go down instead of one who vows to do something that is well-nigh impossible and is probably going to lose because of that.
 
Oh, believe me, they are. ;)I didn’t think it necessary to recount the whole conversation but we did talk about those things.

To summarize succinctly, the Nordic countries, specifically (which was the focus of our conversation), are different in a few important ways: they are much smaller, they don’t have huge militaries, they are demographically and culturally more homogenous and their economies are much simpler than ours. The current US system, flawed as it may be, is entrenched and there too many competing interests. To focus on healthcare, you simply aren’t going to convince, in the span of one Presidency, the various stakeholders to switch to a single government payer system like M4A.
We are too racist and corrupt to do this, but as older people we don't want to admit this so we try to explain to young people that these self-inflicted problems are structural and can't be fixed, mostly because we don't want to do it because we'd rather the problems caused by this remain on you and changing it might mess up our 401Ks.

My guess is they understand exactly what you are saying.

I think that the “corporatism” that is so entrenched here is going to make wholesale changes to the system, like you suggest here, difficult in the short term.

The upshot of what I was trying to get across to the kids was this: there isn’t going to be a wholesale Bernie Revolution. It would be far better to support a viable candidate that starts you on the path you want to go down instead of one who vows to do something that is well-nigh impossible and is probably going to lose because of that.

"Please make it easier for us to ignore you."

The way you get even incremental change is not to ask for it. You get it by demanding justice, making it clear just how unjust and corrupt the status quo is. Like any negotiation you don't start with what you might be willing to find acceptable, you start with what you want.
 
To summarize succinctly, the Nordic countries, specifically (which was the focus of our conversation), are different in a few important ways: they are much smaller, they don’t have huge militaries, they are demographically and culturally more homogenous and their economies are much simpler than ours.
All true, but I fail to see the relevance.

The current US system, flawed as it may be, is entrenched and there too many competing interests.
I think that is the only reason… The old enemy of all forms of progress: "What we have is bad, but we can't quit because too much has been invested in it already."

To focus on healthcare, you simply aren’t going to convince, in the span of one Presidency, the various stakeholders to switch to a single government payer system like M4A.
I agree it won't happen in the span of one presidency, perhaps not even in Bernie Sanders' lifetime. If Bernie were to win, the first things he'll have to do is return the US government to some semblance of functionality and try to claw back some of its international diplomatic influence. The most he likely achieve on healthcare is an executive order for a large scale feasibility study of medicare for all, and reversing some of the hollowing out of Obamacare. The latter may reduce the urgency for medicare for all.

It would be far better to support a viable candidate that starts you on the path you want to go down instead of one who vows to do something that is well-nigh impossible and is probably going to lose because of that.
Promising the impossible never hurt any politician. I think Bernie's plans are less impossible than some ideas out there. "Mexico will pay for it" and all that. I don't think he going to lose because of that. I think you misunderestimate how popular he is (even among many potential Trump voters) compared to for example Biden.
 
We are too racist and corrupt to do this,
Part of the problem, yes, but not the whole problem.
but as older people we don't want to admit this so we try to explain to young people that these self-inflicted problems are structural and can't be fixed, mostly because we don't want to do it because we'd rather the problems caused by this remain on you and changing it might mess up our 401Ks.

My guess is they understand exactly what you are saying.
Well, I would say that the problems are indeed structural and difficult to fix, but they can be fixed. They aren't fixed because not enough people want to do the things necessary to fix it. By and large, the American people are happy enough with things the way they are. Not enough people are seeking the economic/social/cultural revolution that would be necessary. One of the cultural differences in America vs Nordic Countries is that Americans tend to be individualists rather than collectivists.

"Please make it easier for us to ignore you."
Not my intent at all. In fact, it's more like: "If that's really what you want then get the hell out there and make your voices heard! You think arguing with me in the kitchen/on the internet is going to change anything? You and everyone else who wants what you want need to get off your asses and make it so that it's impossible to ignore you. Get out in the streets, protest, demonstrate. Demand change, vote for it, constantly adovocate for it!"

Bernie must long for those late '60s days when the youth cried out and demanded change. It was revolutionary in a cultural and social sense. There simply isn't that level of burning passion and true desire for change in the youth of today.

The way you get even incremental change is not to ask for it. You get it by demanding justice, making it clear just how unjust and corrupt the status quo is. Like any negotiation you don't start with what you might be willing to find acceptable, you start with what you want.
I get it. There just aren't enough people actually doing this to be effective.
 
Bernie deserves a lot of credit for moving the needle on healthcare. The public option is more widely accepted, I think, due in large part to Bernie. However unless the Dems take the senate -- by more than one -- even that will remain a pipe dream.

Bernie did move the needle on health care, but that does not mean his M4A solution is the right one.
 
Unfortunately for Sanders, the best way to get some of his policies enacted might be for him to remain the Communist Bogeyman who Republicans will have to deal with next time if they don't deal with a "Moderate" now.
 
All true, but I fail to see the relevance.
I think those are all things that made it much easier for the Nordic countries to pursue the path that they did.

I think that is the only reason… The old enemy of all forms of progress: "What we have is bad, but we can't quit because too much has been invested in it already."
Not only that but Americans are not dissatisfied enough to actually want such radical changes to begin with.

I agree it won't happen in the span of one presidency, perhaps not even in Bernie Sanders' lifetime. If Bernie were to win, the first things he'll have to do is return the US government to some semblance of functionality and try to claw back some of its international diplomatic influence. The most he likely achieve on healthcare is an executive order for a large scale feasibility study of medicare for all, and reversing some of the hollowing out of Obamacare. The latter may reduce the urgency for medicare for all.
I agree, but that's not what Bernie is running on and I think that hurts him amongst the general American electorate.

Promising the impossible never hurt any politician.
You are correct. I think promising the impossible has gotten him this far. But, IMO, the sheer impracticality of his sweeping proposals can only get him about this far.
I think Bernie's plans are less impossible than some ideas out there. "Mexico will pay for it" and all that. I don't think he going to lose because of that. I think you misunderestimate how popular he is (even among many potential Trump voters) compared to for example Biden.
This is also true. The problem is that I think there are far more people who were willing to accept the "Mexico will pay for it" BS (because they want stricter immigration laws in general) than there are who will accept the "Here's your free stuff" BS (because they buy into the "evil socialist" themeing of such ideas).

***
I will say that discussions with my kids, others and here on the forum have changed my views about Bernie's ideas. Not that I now think they are great ideas and I'm a Bernie Bro; rather, I'm more willing to let them take a shot at it from the "shoot for the moon; end up among the stars" type of political philosophy. The young generation deserves a chance to try and make the future world the way they want it. I'll help them try it if I get the chance.
 
I'm being 100% serious here. Wouldn't just moving to Europe just be easier if everything they do is better and nobody is going to fight you when you want to do it that way?

It costs money to move. Especially if you're going abroad. If you can't afford health care you certainly can't afford moving abroad.
 
I think it is more patriotic to try to make your country better than just settling for whatever happens to it.
And, of course, more patriotic than quitting it for a more attractive country.

Question is whether or not something that might work in, say, Norway would work equally well in the US. I am not sure it would.
 
It costs money to move. Especially if you're going abroad. If you can't afford health care you certainly can't afford moving abroad.

Refugees and economic migrants seem to do it all the time with little more than the clothes on their backs. If you can't afford health care, can you really afford *not* to move?
 
True socialism is when the government owns the means of production. Sanders isn't talking about anything like that. He just wants the benefits of capitalism to be shared with the people whose labor produces the profits.

His thinking is quite a bit more complex than you have described:
https://berniesanders.com/issues/corporate-accountability-and-democracy/

And Sanders on other issues:
https://berniesanders.com/issues/

Problem is that Bernie comes off as much more radical then his actual policies...and Bernie himself is mainly to blame for that.
He needs to tone down the 1960's radical rhetoric he is so fond of.
Yes, Trump would brand him a wild eyed radical in any case, but then Bernie with his rhetoric hands Donnie lots of ammunition.
That old rule of "it's not what you say, but how you say it, that makes or breaks a case" is truer today as it ever was.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom