Should we fear Bernie?

I think you're pretty heavily misinterpreting the desire of others here.

It's not 'Be more like Europe', it's more 'How can we have better healthcare? and 'Where in the world is the healthcare better and cheaper?'

Then you go looking for examples. Other countries do it all the time. China have decided they want to do manned missions to space, so they said 'who does this well', looked to the USA and decided to borrow a load of their methods, not because they want to be more like the USA but because they want a space program as good as the one in the US.

It's the same with healthcare. Hell, it was the same with electricity or railroads. it was probably the same with early subsistence farming or knapping - seeing it done better in the next village over and trying it that way.

You seem obsessed with the 'over there' bit of 'it works over there' rather than the 'it works' bit.


The racists don't approve of that attitude!!! :) New Ad Upsets Nazis
 
The real question is: are the various stakeholders willing to make the compromises necessary to actually make it work?

No, they aren't and won't. It would mean asking the rich to slightly lower their income. That's like expecting a highway driver to stop accelerating for one second to allow another car to merge. It is very rare for people to rein in their selfishness for the good of others, even in the most minimal way.
 
No, they aren't and won't. It would mean asking the rich to slightly lower their income. That's like expecting a highway driver to stop accelerating for one second to allow another car to merge. It is very rare for people to rein in their selfishness for the good of others, even in the most minimal way.

That post is depressing but unfortunately correct.
 
That post is depressing but unfortunately correct.

I have a very dim view of human nature for a while in mornings after my commute. Today I saw someone refuse to let a tanker truck with "Danger: Explosive" signs merge. They literally preferred a potential fiery death to taking their speed down a notch for a moment.
 
I have a very dim view of human nature for a while in mornings after my commute. Today I saw someone refuse to let a tanker truck with "Danger: Explosive" signs merge. They literally preferred a potential fiery death to taking their speed down a notch for a moment.

And don't get me started on how people park...
 
It's funny, isn't it? It's the dream of so many people all over the world to become US citizens. I was listening to This American Life and it was about this guy from Somalia, being persecuted in his homeland and his dream wasn't to become a citizen of Norway, Sweden, Denmark or some more accessable country where things would be better for him. It was to travel across an ocean and become an American citizen. I can't put my finger on the exact reasons why, but America has a lure that no other place does. Even though, objectively and by many measures there are other countries that are "better" than us on paper.

Because America is the "lottery" of countries. To them, in the US, with absolutely nothing more than hard work and determination you can be a millionaire! They're coming from extreme poverty and to them their best chance at striking it rich is in the US because there's no rhyme or reason to how people get rich here.
 
Some days it feels like the USA has a massive gambling problem that we can manage just fine, we can quit when we start to fall in the hole, anytime we want. Don't worry China, we'll pay you back once we make this big win....
 
Some days it feels like the USA has a massive gambling problem that we can manage just fine, we can quit when we start to fall in the hole, anytime we want. Don't worry China, we'll pay you back once we make this big win....

I think with the amounts owed, a default would be a much bigger problem for China than for the US. I think China would be highly motivated to restructure the debt, rather than allow themselves to fall into a situation where the US had to default.
 
Because America is the "lottery" of countries. To them, in the US, with absolutely nothing more than hard work and determination you can be a millionaire! They're coming from extreme poverty and to them their best chance at striking it rich is in the US because there's no rhyme or reason to how people get rich here.

There's also an issue where American salaries are really high compared to some countries...but people marvelling at the higher salaries sometimes don't take into account the higher cost of living. Sure, I make ten thousand times more than Sad Peasant in Poor Country...but my expenses are a hundred thousand times more than Sad Peasant's in Poor Country. He's not going to find housing for two cents a month here.
 
Bernie's been in government for a few decades now. He seems like a nice guy who's never been able to do much with his ideas.

But happens if he wins? What happens if all of his ideas suddenly are backed by major power?

I foresee basically two (widely divergent) possibilities.

1) POLITICAL GRIDLOCK: Bernie doesn't help the down-ballot (establishment Democrat) candidates enough to keep the House and take the Senate. He is actively running against the Democratic establishment, so that makes it hard for him to uplift their folks, with a few DSA-flavoured exceptions who strive to come off as outsiders. His first term ends up resembling Obama's second, at best.

2) POLITICAL REVOLUTION: A wave of disaffected former non-voters storm the polls and sweep Democrats into control of both chambers and the White House. Bernie's first term involves dramatic and hitherto unseen reforms such as breaking up most of the financial sector into fragments small enough not to show up on any list of systemically important banksWP, taxing the fortunes of the capitalist class, and forcing major corporations to provide significant equity to their employees, not to mention expansions of federal spending programs unknown since FDR. Modern monetary theoryWP will finally be put to the test.

Neither of these scenarios strikes me as particularly appealing, and while intermediate scenarios surely exist, I'm not much liking those either.
 
I foresee basically two (widely divergent) possibilities.

1) POLITICAL GRIDLOCK: Bernie doesn't help the down-ballot (establishment Democrat) candidates enough to keep the House and take the Senate. He is actively running against the Democratic establishment, so that makes it hard for him to uplift their folks, with a few DSA-flavoured exceptions who strive to come off as outsiders. His first term ends up resembling Obama's second, at best.

2) POLITICAL REVOLUTION: A wave of disaffected former non-voters storm the polls and sweep Democrats into control of both chambers and the White House. Bernie's first term involves dramatic and hitherto unseen reforms such as breaking up most of the financial sector into fragments small enough not to show up on any list of systemically important banksWP, taxing the fortunes of the capitalist class, and forcing major corporations to provide significant equity to their employees, not to mention expansions of federal spending programs unknown since FDR. Modern monetary theoryWP will finally be put to the test.

Neither of these scenarios strikes me as particularly appealing, and while intermediate scenarios surely exist, I'm not much liking those either.

And Re-education camps. Don't forget those.
 
And don't you think it's reasonable, in any arena, to look at the way similar things are done differntly in other paces and ask if it's better?
Do you ever stop and ask why things are done differently in different part of the world?

Do you hold non-white countries to the same standards? (we know the answer to this)
 
I think you're pretty heavily misinterpreting the desire of others here.

It's not 'Be more like Europe', it's more 'How can we have better healthcare? and 'Where in the world is the healthcare better and cheaper?'

Then you go looking for examples. Other countries do it all the time. China have decided they want to do manned missions to space, so they said 'who does this well', looked to the USA and decided to borrow a load of their methods, not because they want to be more like the USA but because they want a space program as good as the one in the US.

It's the same with healthcare. Hell, it was the same with electricity or railroads. it was probably the same with early subsistence farming or knapping - seeing it done better in the next village over and trying it that way.

You seem obsessed with the 'over there' bit of 'it works over there' rather than the 'it works' bit.
I know right?

Come to think of it, why isn't Estonia a global hegemony? Also, why isn't Somalia a world super power? It works over here so it must work everywhere according to skeptics.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom