Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

This guy is a loon.

But putting that aside, if he really truly is psychotic then he shouldn't be self-evaluating and instead should have a doctor do all the talking concerning his mental health. If he is psychotic then he can't really be expected to say rational and reasonable things about his own condition because... well, because he is psychotic.

Sometimes psychotic people figure out how to make a bunch of fame and money based on their own psychosis.
 
My understanding is that to prove defamation in the US courts one must show that the statements were published, false, injurious, and unprivileged. Public figures that are targets of defamation also have to show actual malice: that "the person who made the statement knew it wasn't true, or didn't care whether it was true or not and was reckless with the truth. IMHO pretty much a slam-dunk on all criteria for the parents.

But I believe that Alex Jones is now trying to convince the court that he believed at the time his statements were true because he was some form of crazy. But his testimony is so self-serving that if anything it convinces me that he is a coldly calculating individual whose self-serving actions extend way back and continue to this day.

Throw the book at him!
 
Sometimes psychotic people figure out how to make a bunch of fame and money based on their own psychosis.


We had one of those a couple of years ago, Graham Bishop, a British psychic, who became famous and made a lot of money, aided and abetted by a ruthless TV network, until he tried to kill his daughters (CPH Post, Nov. 20, 2013) in a fit of jealous rage.
Alex Jones appears to be much more calculating than that.
 
This guy is a loon.

But putting that aside, if he really truly is psychotic then he shouldn't be self-evaluating and instead should have a doctor do all the talking concerning his mental health. If he is psychotic then he can't really be expected to say rational and reasonable things about his own condition because... well, because he is psychotic.

Sometimes psychotic people figure out how to make a bunch of fame and money based on their own psychosis.

A perfect example of a "Catch 22" situation?
 
The show must go on, and Alex is not going to lose this one easy.


Win or lose AJ gets lots of publicity and that is exactly what his type needs to keep making money.
 
Psychosis does cover delusions, so this could easily be more accurate than not.
Psychosis can involve big cognitive errors. A psychotic can say that they previously were psychotic - when in fact they still are. That "error" would be a symptom of psychosis. The psychosis can cause them to not understand or to make excuses or assertions or explanations of any sort.
 
The nice part is, even when trying to concoct an excuse for his behavior, he just can't help being Alex Jones. He blames making up conspiracy theories on his "psychosis", but then:

He said it was the "trauma of the media and the corporations lying so much" that caused him to distrust everything, "kind of like a child whose parents lie to them over and over again."


...he blames his psychosis on a conspiracy theory.

It's elephants all the way down, folks!
 
I've watched some of the first video. I heard Jones' lawyer say that he objected to form quite a bit. Does that affect the deposition's power of evidence? What does objecting to form entail, and how is it different from a typical objection?
 
I've watched some of the first video. I heard Jones' lawyer say that he objected to form quite a bit. Does that affect the deposition's power of evidence? What does objecting to form entail, and how is it different from a typical objection?


https://www.litigationandtrial.com/2015/11/articles/attorney/objecting-to-the-form/

I was curious about that, too, so I googled it, and found this.

I listened to the first half this evening while I was doing something else. I thought Jones wasn't doing too badly at first, but he went downhill pretty rapidly. I'd say Jones is going to get his head handed to him if this goes to trial. :eek:

Also, in my non-expert opinion, Jones's lawyer is an idiot. I suppose I shouldn't be surprised, as I strongly suspect no reputable lawyer would take the case.
 
Jones is in it for the money. He will say any old **** as long as someone pays him. He needs to be bankrupted now and kept in poverty permanently.

And as for harassment, I hope he gets a long sentence at hard labour. I know a number of sub-Antarctic islands with air force runways on them that need to be swept clean of penguin-**** with a toothbrush.
 
Hm. His lawyers are letting him go to court with the affirmative defense that the Deep State pushed him into a psychosis. But he got better.

:popcorn1


Unruly mob: "She's a witch, she's a witch"
Guard: "What makes you think she is a witch?"
Peasant: "Well, she turned me into a newt!"
Guard: "A newt!?"
Peasant: *** pauses & looks around *** "I got better."
 
J
And as for harassment, I hope he gets a long sentence at hard labour. I know a number of sub-Antarctic islands with air force runways on them that need to be swept clean of penguin-**** with a toothbrush.

The spice mines of Kessel or the dilithium mines of rura penthe would both be too good for him. Straight to hell would be nice.
 
Jones is in it for the money. He will say any old **** as long as someone pays him. He needs to be bankrupted now and kept in poverty permanently.

And as for harassment, I hope he gets a long sentence at hard labour. I know a number of sub-Antarctic islands with air force runways on them that need to be swept clean of penguin-**** with a toothbrush.

If Jones isn't left destitute and, eventually, in a prison cell after all of this, we really don't have a justice system worth the name.
 
Here's a punishment for someone else who is found guilty: Having to share a cell with Jones. Imagine the torture of never having the miserable ****** shutting up but ranting like he does, day and night.
 
I've watched some of the first video. I heard Jones' lawyer say that he objected to form quite a bit. Does that affect the deposition's power of evidence? What does objecting to form entail, and how is it different from a typical objection?

An objection as to form means an objection to the form of the question. That would include questions that are vague or misleading or that require speculation or make false assumptions.

For a deposition, objections to form must be raised during the deposition so that the other side has an opportunity to rephrase the question.

An example from the article is when Bankston asks, "If a person were to stake out those addresses, they could wait for Mr. Pozner to come pick up his mail, couldn’t they?"

Barnes objects as to form. The basis for the objection would be that the question asks for speculation. Anybody could speculate as to what other people could do such as wait for someone to pick up mail. That is speculation. It is not information that the witness could actually know.
 
He won't be left penniless. You can be sure some of his assets have been transferred to tax haven accounts around the world and aren't recorded anywhere that can be found.
 
An objection as to form means an objection to the form of the question. That would include questions that are vague or misleading or that require speculation or make false assumptions.

For a deposition, objections to form must be raised during the deposition so that the other side has an opportunity to rephrase the question.

An example from the article is when Bankston asks, "If a person were to stake out those addresses, they could wait for Mr. Pozner to come pick up his mail, couldn’t they?"

Barnes objects as to form. The basis for the objection would be that the question asks for speculation. Anybody could speculate as to what other people could do such as wait for someone to pick up mail. That is speculation. It is not information that the witness could actually know.

AIUI, there another a very important aspect to this.

If, during the deposition, Jones' Lawyer does not object to certain types of questions as to form, then in so doing, he has automatically waived any right to object to those same questions during the trial. For example, if he fails to object to form when a question requires the defendant to speculate, then at trial "Objection; Calls for Speculation" will be overruled. The only questions this does not apply to are those relating to matters of law; things such as hearsay or competency of the witness.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom