JesseCuster
Master Poster
Um... what?Clearly, the U.S. Government is not a 100% reliable source of information, so some level of intuition must be involved. Intuition should not be allowed in court.
1. Of course "the US government" is not "a 100% reliable source of information". Is there any person or institution that is 100% reliable? Is there anyone who thinks "the US government" is 100% reliable? (Everyone has to down a shot of their favourite drink if MJ comes back with the witty retort that skeptics act as if they believe that, that's a tiresome conspiracy theory strawman). You're hardly shattering worldviews by pointing out this obvious fact.
2. "The US government" is not a monolithic institution. It is neither reliable nor unreliable. You can't point out the shady history of the CIA and use it as a blanket excuse to dismiss anything any everything that happens to come from some department or spokesperson or whatever of anything to do with the US government. What is required when determining the truth or falsehood (or likelihood or truth or falsehood) of something that comes from the US government simply requires some critical thinking and a nuanced view of how government institutions work, who from what department of the government is saying what, in what context (under oath in a court of law, a throwaway comment in a press conference, etc.) Your ideas appear to have led to simplistic black and white thinking which isn't doing you any favours.
3. If anything that isn't 100% reliable requires intuition and intuition should not be allowed in court, then good luck getting anyone to offer testimony or expert opinion on anything in a court of law. Courts couldn't function if you couldn't allow anything not 100% reliable on the bizarre idea that it requires 'intuition'. edit: Given your earlier comments about how unreliable humans are and therefore shouldn't be on juries judging cases like this, I'm going to guess that either you actually think the court system should be done away with entirely because it relies on pesky humans who aren't 100% reliable or, more likely, you're just throwing out stuff ad hoc without having thought it through at all.
Last edited: