We have many lawyers in the forum, and they can correct me. But I believe that when competency involves the qualifications of a witness who is being incorrectly treated as an expert, then an objection claiming a lack of foundation constitutes an object as to form. That is, a question asking the witness to apply expertise he does not have would be a question of improper form and therefore objectionable at deposition.
Do you write bar exam questions? That’s a bit of a tricky one. I’ll give it a shot.
First, objections as to form are not the only type of objections allowed at a deposition. Basically, all of the standard objections can be raised. The significant thing about an objection as to form is that it must be raised during the deposition, otherwise it is waived and cannot be raised at trial. The reason for that is because the form of the question can be corrected during the deposition.
Lack of foundation is perhaps not the appropriate phrase here. Lack of foundation is an objection as to form. It basically means the question came out of left field without establishing what is being talked about or how the witness would have personal knowledge to answer the question. You are perhaps thinking of lack of foundational reliability. That means an expert witness is relying on unsupported or unproven or unprovable facts or assumptions.
An objection to a deponent’s competence is not waived if it is not made at a deposition. Competency usually means that the witness understands what is going on and can answer questions. Competency for an expert witness is a bit different. But it sounds like you are asking something else.
It sounds like you are asking about a case where a non-expert pertinent witness is asked a question that would normally only be asked of an expert. At trial, a pertinent witness can only be asked about things that person has personal knowledge of. They can’t be asked for opinion (with some exceptions) or questions to establish a truth about some general subject. For example, they can’t be asked about the effectiveness of some medical procedure. That would be hearsay. Expert witnesses are largely exempt from that because their job is largely to provide information that would otherwise be objectionable as opinion or hearsay.
The purpose of a trial is to establish truth. But the purpose of a deposition is to collect evidence. Therefore, at a deposition questions may be asked that call for opinion or hearsay.
In a trial when there is a sustained objection to a question, a new question is asked. But in a deposition the witness still answers the question. Testimony in a deposition is not admissible at trial (except in certain circumstances) because it is hearsay. But the same questions can be asked of the witness at trial. If the form of the question was not objected to during the deposition, it is assumed to be in proper form. An objection as to form is really just a signal to the other side that the question would be objected to during a trial.
A witness can be asked about some expertise knowledge or opinion during a deposition. There is no need to raise an objection during the deposition because that question would not be allowed during a trial as opinion or hearsay under the rules of evidence.