Yes, I think the disconnect here is that they think "That is a Conspiracy Theory" is used as an argument, when what it actually is is a conclusion.
"Your "facts" are wrong, your "logic" is skewed, your paranoia is apparent, and your conclusions are trash, therefore you're promoting a conspiracy theory." "You're just saying it's illogical because you've already dismissed it as a conspiracy theory!"
Part of the problem might stem from the fact that we can see through their BS so quickly, it appears to them that we're not actually going through that process. But of course, after you've repeatedly seen the Alex Jones "Everything is a False Flag" act that he deploys immediately after virtually everything that happens, it's not too hard to conclude that it's just his usual BS.
In this specific case these are the basic facts:
December 14, 2012, Adam Lanza shot his mother and then drove to Sandy Hook Elementary School where he murdered 20 children under 7 years of age, and 7 adults.
Immediately after the attack there were the now usual calls for new gun control legislation.
Some of the parents added their voices for new anti-gun legislation.
To date, while some states updated their gun control legislation, there has been no serious change to federal gun legislation based on the events at Sandy Hook (Trump, of all people, has successfully just banned bump-stocks, but this followed another mass shooting).
The legitimate argument to be made is that anti-Second Amendment and garden variety gun control advocates use mass shootings as an attempt to push their agendas. This is not in dispute by any one.
The legitimate counter argument is to point out that none of these shootings happened in a vacuum, and the events leading up to them are mostly different. To tar all gun owners as potential monsters is unrealistic and unreasonable.
The illegitimate argument is the CT BS line that the shooting didn't happen at all, that there were no children killed, and that the parents are really paid performers who parrot anti-gun talking points. There are no facts whatsoever to support this claim (YouTube videos made the by mentally ill, and neo-Nazis are not factual evidence).
CTists never see how this line of thinking undermines their endgame in this case because it makes it easier to dismiss gun-rights advocates who are not mentally ill because they are on the same side of the line as the Sandy Hook CT-Bozos like Alex Jones. They are figuratively shooting themselves in their clown shoes. Their actions ad strain to what is already a heated debate in this country. Their stupidity is counter productive.
What MJ and most CTists are advocating in this case can be framed this way:
I have a right to relieve myself in my pants any time and anywhere I want, no matter if its a hot city bus, subway car, trans-Atlantic flight, or fine restaurant. If the smell bothers you and if my soiled trousers ruin the furniture and carpets that's your problem because I HAVE MY RIGHTS!
