Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

Do the second, and you have commited perjury and could go to jail.

He's screwed either way. Tell the truth now under oath, and the plaintiffs can argue that his former, allegedly defamatory, statements accusing them of being crisis actors were made with reckless -- if not intentional and malicious -- disregard for the truth. Admitting that you knew your alleged defamation wasn't true is tantamount to admitting it was unjustly defamatory. This is undoubtedly why Jones fought not to be deposed under oath.

I doubt Jones cares about his listeners at all. But he might lose sponsors, and that's where it hurts.
 
Good ole Alex will tell the truth on the deposition as I am sure it is just an act then afterwards he'll tell his fans that he was just saying what was necessary to the 'man'.

Well that would amount to publicly stating that he lied in his deposition. I am pretty certain that the lawyers for the families will be watching everything he does online, and every public pronouncement he makes.
 
Well that would amount to publicly stating that he lied in his deposition. I am pretty certain that the lawyers for the families will be watching everything he does online, and every public pronouncement he makes.

Have these poor folk not suffered enough?
 
Well that would amount to publicly stating that he lied in his deposition. I am pretty certain that the lawyers for the families will be watching everything he does online, and every public pronouncement he makes.



We should start an over/under pool on how many times the lawyers ask him, "Were you lying then, or are you lying now?"

I'll take "10".
 
I think the best out for him would be along the lines of “I thought at the time based on the facts and evidence I was seeing that Sandy Hook was staged. I realize now I had bad or incomplete information. “
 
I think the best out for him would be along the lines of “I thought at the time based on the facts and evidence I was seeing that Sandy Hook was staged. I realize now I had bad or incomplete information. “

Yes, the "walk a narrow line" strategy might work. If I were cross-examining for the plaintiffs, I would then say in court, "So, Mr. Jones, does that mean you failed to diligently discover the facts before you decided to air public statements about the plaintiffs? Do you realize that you had a duty to do so? You carried on making those statements for years even though there was considerable discussion and debate in the media regarding the truthfulness and factual foundation of them. How is it that you have re-examined the evidence and changed your conclusion only after you faced legal action?"

Assuming the marketing materials the plaintiffs got after their discovery motion were granted don't tell a rosy picture of his dedication to truth and careful research, I feel a good legal team wouldn't have much trouble establishing malicious intent even with a carefully penitent deposition.
 
He'll fall back on some variation of the "I'm just reporting what people are talking about" excuse that forms the backbone of right wing news. All he has to do is provide one "report" (which in this day in age can be an random anoynous online yahoo) and he'll be able to hide behind it.
 
Yes, the "walk a narrow line" strategy might work. If I were cross-examining for the plaintiffs, I would then say in court, "So, Mr. Jones, does that mean you failed to diligently discover the facts before you decided to air public statements about the plaintiffs? Do you realize that you had a duty to do so? You carried on making those statements for years even though there was considerable discussion and debate in the media regarding the truthfulness and factual foundation of them. How is it that you have re-examined the evidence and changed your conclusion only after you faced legal action?"

Assuming the marketing materials the plaintiffs got after their discovery motion were granted don't tell a rosy picture of his dedication to truth and careful research, I feel a good legal team wouldn't have much trouble establishing malicious intent even with a carefully penitent deposition.

Engage the brain prior to opening one's mouth.
 
As much as I detest Jones and his ilk, I imagine this is going to be a difficult case for them to win. 1A is very protective of journalistic speech, even journalism that is pure conspiracy tabloid trash. I will be curious to see what approach the plaintiffs take in this case.
 
Analogy

I go in for a medical test. I want the results to be accurate. I hope they are negative.

No one thinks I want the results to be negative regardless if I have an illness or not. I'm also not taking the test necessarily with the presumption that i don't have the illness.
Better analogy:

You are suffering and in pain so you go to see the doctor.

The doctor orders some tests to see if Disease X is responsible for your suffering and pain.

You hope the test comes back negative, not because it will show that Disease X isn't the cause of your suffering, but because your logic is that people with Disease X are more likely to have the pain you suffered than people who don't have Disease X, and you hope for a negative test result so that you can conclude that it's less likely that your suffering actually existed in the first place.

As if the existence of your pain and suffering was up for debate.

That these people have suffered because of the disgusting accusations thrown at them is not really up for discussion. There's no way that the parents haven't suffered because of the harassment (on top of the nightmare of having their children murderer). The courts will decide, I imagine, whether or not it meets the legal standards for defamation or whatever exactly is being sued for, and whether or not Alex Jones can be held responsible for their suffering. The fine legal points aren't important for the point I'm making.

Hoping for a certain verdict so that you can conclude it's less likely that established facts are true is such a failure of logic that it makes me wonder if you really believe what you're saying and that you're not just arguing for the sake of arguing.
 
One wonders; how are the parents going to take it during discovery when Jones's lawyers ask when they became crisis actors, how much were they paid, and are they ready to provide pay stubs?

Okay, so the parents won't testify. Then, they will be called out as being unwilling to defend their accusations in court.

:blackcat:
 
Hoping for a certain verdict so that you can conclude it's less likely that established facts are true is such a failure of logic that it makes me wonder if you really believe what you're saying and that you're not just arguing for the sake of arguing.


...and the red, red robin comes bob, bob, bobbin' along, along.....
 
lol. ultimate dumbass in litigation goes on Rogan and blames 'anomalies'

 
I think the best out for him would be along the lines of “I thought at the time based on the facts and evidence I was seeing that Sandy Hook was staged. I realize now I had bad or incomplete information. “


That's exactly what he just did on the Rogan show. For maybe twenty minutes. The rest of the almost five hours seems to be him doing everything he can to look as crazy as possible. Nazis taking DMT got tech from the clockwork elves from other dimensions and stuff. Literally. Elves which he himself met in his childhood.
 
That's exactly what he just did on the Rogan show. For maybe twenty minutes. The rest of the almost five hours seems to be him doing everything he can to look as crazy as possible. Nazis taking DMT got tech from the clockwork elves from other dimensions and stuff. Literally. Elves which he himself met in his childhood.

Maybe his lawyer neglected to inform him that an insanity defense won't work in a civil suit.
 
So... who gets to be on the "panel of people who judge free speech"? Wouldn't they be as bias as any other human? Delusional too, considering that most humans in the world believes in God, the supernatural, superstitions, etc.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom