Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

I could be wrong, but I believe that Horatius was describing our civil court system, albeit sarcastically.


Yes, I was being sarcastic. This highlights the fundamental problem with most of the conspiracy theorists in our society, and why I've always thought they were more dangerous than most other people think they are.

MicahJava seems to believe that if we don't let every stupid ******* say anything they want to without consequence, we're doomed to a tyrannical hellscape of an existence, where no one is allowed to say anything at all. And I suspect that a big part of why he thinks that way can be attributed to an unstated belief that the systems our society has in place to prevent such abuses cannot be trusted.

He just doesn't get it: trials like this one are part of how we protect our freedom of speech. Because you do have to prove with a preponderance of the evidence that the person committing slander and libel actually is guilty. We don't need draconian laws that dictate exactly what can and cannot be said, because we know can rely on the impartial judgement of the courts to sort it all out.

But if and when enough people lose that trust, the system breaks down. We're watching that happen now with regards to elections - lots of people have apparently concluded that it really is all rigged. And the consequences of that will be enormous.
 
SOmepeople just don't get the difference between criminal/statue law and civil law. That you can do things that are not offenses against criminal or statute law, but lleave you open for civil damages.
As has been stated time and time again, Freedom of Speech..at least in the US..does not mean freedom of condquences from what you say. It just means you cannot, except in very,very limited cases, be prosecuted by the government for speech.

And way too many people seem to have a lot of trouble wrapping their heads around that!!!
 
Nobody wants to admit how far Operation Northwoods and the Bush-Blair 2003 memo completely destroys the political/historical fabric of reality for the USA. Of course, when the fabric of reality is in question, people will choose to be denialists. People love to talk about the psychology of conspiracy theorists, but the psychology of denialists is thin as paper, it's actually disturbing to me how easy it is to see through the dunning kruger effect from people who don't want conspiracy theories to be true. People who don't even know basic history will suddenly think they're experts because they skimmed a Cracked article or something, and if called out they will just make dumb jokes, insults, and excuses.
 
Last edited:
We are talking about civil damages for slander and libel. Given the nature of the harm he's inflicted on the bereaved parents, and the fact that in his child custody case, he's admitted it's an act, we can be sure Jones knew his allegations were untrue.

He was spreading malicious lies for personal profit and the civil remedy is appropriate.

He was also responsible for inciting violence against the parents.

Freedom from the state is pointless if it simply allows non-state actors to persecute you.

We are talking about facts that prove that your notion of Western exceptionalism and planet Earth in general are as fake as the fake unicorns Westerners think North Koreans believe in. The general public should be rightfully confused. The conspiracy theorists are the last who should be blamed.

We are also talking about people who willingly chose to become public figures by appearing on the news, with some choosing to become figures in the gun control movement.

The Alex Jones Sandy Hook lawsuit was a bad thing. No question in my mind that Jones should have the right to question public figures to such an extent. If somebody goes on TV and flaps their mouth, I should be able to flip on a camera and flap my mouth about what they just said. Sorry sometimes people get hurt, but people get hurt the other way too.
 
Last edited:
By the way, if it weren't for this similar kind of denialism, every horrible phony Western war from the last 60 years wouldn't have happened. At least not the way they did.

Conspiracy theorists: a few crying old ladies.

Conspiracy denialists: millions of deaths.

Also, the emergence of climate change science can be considered a sort of "doomsday conspiracy that came true". Why wouldn't it? Because climate change has evidence while conspiracy theories don't? This is circular logic. "Conspiracy theories are dumb, because if they weren't dumb they wouldn't be called conspiracy theories". Not an argument.

Answered the first few crappy scripted arguments for you guys.

Conspiracy theorists: a few crying old ladies.

Conspiracy denialists: billions of deaths.
 
Last edited:
MicahJava seems to believe that if we don't let every stupid ******* say anything they want to without consequence, we're doomed to a tyrannical hellscape of an existence, where no one is allowed to say anything at all.

Yes, this is exactly what I'm afraid is happening, all of human conversation regulated by type of people who would be forum moderators. There will never, ever, EVER, EVER
, be a "perfect list of what speech to censor". That can not exist due to the flawed nature of humanity. Maybe literally shouting fire in a theater could be illegal, but even stuff like "verbal assault", "inciting violence", "encouraging others to break the law" can be politically manipulated so easily.
 
By the way, if it weren't for this similar kind of denialism, every horrible phony Western war from the last 60 years wouldn't have happened. At least not the way they did.

Conspiracy theorists: a few crying old ladies.

Conspiracy denialists: millions of deaths.

Also, the emergence of climate change science can be considered a sort of "doomsday conspiracy that came true". Why wouldn't it? Because climate change has evidence while conspiracy theories don't? This is circular logic. "Conspiracy theories are dumb, because if they weren't dumb they wouldn't be called conspiracy theories". Not an argument.

Answered the first few crappy scripted arguments for you guys.

Conspiracy theorists: a few crying old ladies.

Conspiracy denialists: billions of deaths.

Can you list these "horrible phony Western wars"?

I'm going to suggest that they were all staged and didn't happen and that you are being paid by those in power to.use conspiracy theories to give the sheeple an illegitimate target for their anger .
 
By the way, if it weren't for this similar kind of denialism, every horrible phony Western war from the last 60 years wouldn't have happened. At least not the way they did.

Conspiracy theorists: a few crying old ladies.

Conspiracy denialists: millions of deaths.

Also, the emergence of climate change science can be considered a sort of "doomsday conspiracy that came true". Why wouldn't it? Because climate change has evidence while conspiracy theories don't? This is circular logic. "Conspiracy theories are dumb, because if they weren't dumb they wouldn't be called conspiracy theories". Not an argument.

Answered the first few crappy scripted arguments for you guys.

Conspiracy theorists: a few crying old ladies.

Conspiracy denialists: billions of deaths.



Well, goddamnit, I'm publishing my revelations.

Just gonna toddle off and make them up, but boy, they'll be good.
 
Yes, this is exactly what I'm afraid is happening, all of human conversation regulated by type of people who would be forum moderators. There will never, ever, EVER, EVER
, be a "perfect list of what speech to censor". That can not exist due to the flawed nature of humanity. Maybe literally shouting fire in a theater could be illegal, but even stuff like "verbal assault", "inciting violence", "encouraging others to break the law" can be politically manipulated so easily.

And yet you're allowed to advocate the torture of bereaved parents on a public forum. It's almost as if there weren't an apparatus in place to prevent people from stating grossly offensive opinions and you had real freedom of speech. Strange that you feel your freedom is so much under threat that you're prepared to advocate random imprisonment of others just to preserve it.

Dave
 
And yet you're allowed to advocate the torture of bereaved parents on a public forum. It's almost as if there weren't an apparatus in place to prevent people from stating grossly offensive opinions and you had real freedom of speech. Strange that you feel your freedom is so much under threat that you're prepared to advocate random imprisonment of others just to preserve it.

Dave

I've kind of gotten used to your style, Dave. Nobody believes it. You should try something fresh.
 
And yet you're allowed to advocate the torture of bereaved parents on a public forum. It's almost as if there weren't an apparatus in place to prevent people from stating grossly offensive opinions and you had real freedom of speech. Strange that you feel your freedom is so much under threat that you're prepared to advocate random imprisonment of others just to preserve it.

Dave
It's almost amusing that the people who want to use "Free Speech" as a weapon don't understand that they also have to accept the consequences of that speech.
Also - Obligatory XKCD
I've kind of gotten used to your style, Dave. Nobody believes it. You should try something fresh.
Liar, you do not speak for me.
 
It's almost amusing that the people who want to use "Free Speech" as a weapon don't understand that they also have to accept the consequences of that speech.
Also - Obligatory XKCD

Liar, you do not speak for me.

I wish that the U.S. Government would have it's own free-speech-based social media network. Such a project sounds right up Trump's alley. Maybe even call it "Trumped" or "Trump'd". That would leave at least some kind of positive lasting legacy from Trump, and maybe it would satisfy him knowing that his name won't always just be known as a swear word.
 
I wish that the U.S. Government would have it's own free-speech-based social media network. Such a project sounds right up Trump's alley. Maybe even call it "Trumped" or "Trump'd". That would leave at least some kind of positive lasting legacy from Trump, and maybe it would satisfy him knowing that his name won't always just be known as a swear word.

We already have one sycophantic Trump propaganda media network in Trump TV (a.k.a. Faux News). The world doesn't need a Trump propaganda social media network as well.
 
I've kind of gotten used to your style, Dave. Nobody believes it. You should try something fresh.

What, nobody believes you advocated torturing grieving parents?

I would rather see the Sandy Hook parents tortured in camps than have them partially responsible for removing a sliver of freedom.

There you go.

Dave
 
Nobody believes it.

what is the vague 'it' here since that is doing all the work?
I would like to know what I allegedly don't believe.
 
Nobody wants to admit how far Operation Northwoods and the Bush-Blair 2003 memo completely destroys the political/historical fabric of reality for the USA. Of course, when the fabric of reality is in question, people will choose to be denialists. People love to talk about the psychology of conspiracy theorists, but the psychology of denialists is thin as paper, it's actually disturbing to me how easy it is to see through the dunning kruger effect from people who don't want conspiracy theories to be true. People who don't even know basic history will suddenly think they're experts because they skimmed a Cracked article or something, and if called out they will just make dumb jokes, insults, and excuses.

Boo hoo.

Couple of easy points you ignore;

Northwoods doesn't matter because:

1. It never left the room. It was just an idea.

2. It was one of a dozen ideas to justify JFK invading Cuba that never left the room.

3. There have been hundreds of such proposals over the decades following WWII that never left the room.

One of the many reasons nobody takes you seriously even as a CTist is your constant focus on THINGS THAT DIDN'T HAPPEN WHILE IGNORING THINGS THAT DID HAPPEN.

You choose to hang out at the kiddie tables of CT Land, meanwhile the big kids might come in here making their cases for nefarious US Gub'mint CT citing ACTUAL OPERATIONS THAT ACTUALLY WENT LIVE, such as:

The US Army conducting biological warfare tests in the NYC subway system in 1966:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/arch...7de-99b4-876d5e57dd9c/?utm_term=.3b2c02d3fb78

The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiments:

From the CDC: https://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/timeline.htm

From the WaPo: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...e-syphilis-experiment/?utm_term=.6c0008b1c206

The CIA & US Army Intelligence infiltrating the anti-War protest at different levels:

https://www.nytimes.com/1974/12/22/...rted-in-u-s-against-antiwar-forces-other.html

I could go on, the real world list is long (longer when you include the Soviet Union's activities), but I think I've made my point. The list above are real operations that had real consequences, and ended up re-shaping how things are done in Washington.

If I was still a CT-Moron these would be go-to government operations to attempt to support the possibility of whatever silly CT I'm trying to foist on the world.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom