RFK Jr. suspects a second gunman killed his dad.

Nope. You're a grown-up, read them yourself. Only babies get spoon-fed.
So, you haven’t read whats behind the links that you say contain support for your bald assertions?

What a strange way to argue a case.

Yes, PAX Americana,
Where do JFK say that he believes in a ”Pax Americana”? Cite. Explain. Make your case.

and having a larger military gave us the ability to conduct combat operations anywhere in the world at will. It was called "Flexible Response", and it translated into "Vietnam". Every President since JFK has embraced a version of this.
JFK’s ”flexible respons” to every international crisis and conflict he had to deal with as president was, diplomacy.

Flexible response was a recognition of a need to reorganize the military to make it relevant in the new type of warfare that developed after WWII. The point is how and when and against whom you are using it.

JFK never used it. Never.

He initiated the Special Forces and Navy SEALs as part of an expansion of the US's covert military capabilities.
Yes, he had the opinion that the military should be in charge of all types of warfare, including more or less covert such until the the domain of the CIA which he did not trust.

After the Bay of Pigs it was clear that t to be a player on the world stage we would need a force to counter Spetznaz.
The Bay of Pigs was forced upon him and he understood that the CIA pulled an ugly one on him when they demanded that he should send in the Marines when the exile invation force got beaten by Castro at the beach.

This was the plan from the get go, to create a pretext for an all out US military invasion. JFK did not take the bait and refused to comply.

Our Special Forces in SE Asia certainly directed men to kill. JFK's CIA backed the installation of the Baath Party in Iraq which we're still paying for today.
CIA was pretty much out of control when JFK was inaugurated. He had plans to rein it in and close it down when they assassinated him. He was going to take away the ”fun and games” from them once and for all.

There wasn't much wasn't much we could do in Berlin.
The chicken hawks was whining and wanted an armed conflict. When the Wall came up, JFK was labeled a traitor.

That was common sense. Any President at that time would have done the same thing.
No, it was not, not in the US National Security State. They were all outraged and believed that the country was without a leader.

We continued testing nukes underground as did the Russians.
One step at a time ...

Uh huh...

Not really.
....

No, he was actively trying to kill Castro right up to October, 1963.
Keep repeting a claim doesn’t make it more true. Supporting evidence, does. Have any?

....

Here's the thing you need to accept.
Where have I given the impression of believing he was? Cite. Explain. Make your case.

JFK was not perfect, RFK was not perfect. They were indeed trying to kill Castro.
Not perfect ≠ trying to assassinate somebody.

Look into the Cuban Coordinating Committee sometime, here were some of their considered plans:

Operation Dirty Trick - Should one of the Mercury space shots fail, it would be blamed on Cuban sabotage, thus justifying an invasion.
Did JFK accept this ”plan”?

Operation Bingo - a simulated attack on Guantanamo Bay used to justify an invasion of Cuba.
Did JFK accept this ”plan”?

These were all forwarded to RFK, who oversaw the CCC.
Did he accept false pretext/false flags in order to justify an invasion of Cuba?

RFK approved Cuban Exile training camps in Central America, and Mongoose camps in Louisiana. Mongoose was one of the reasons Khrushchev put missiles in Cuba. After October, 1962, the plan evolved into OPLAN 380-63 , code named AM/TRUNK (which had sub-operations named MH/APRON, Opeation PICADOR & TOREADOR, inside Cuba the op was known as Opertion Judas).
JFK inherited the Cuban exile problem from the Eisenhower administration. He had to very delicately keep the situation under control after the Bay of Pigs fiasco showing his comitment to the exile cuban cause while at the same time stay true to his commitment not to use US military brute force against the will of the people in any post colonial country.

When giving his ”ok” to the Bay of Pigs operation he did so on information provided by the CIA saying that the Cuban people would revolt against Castro the very moment the exile Cubans landed on the beach.

Nothing could have been further from the truth. The Castro regime had a massive popular support at the time of the invasion attempt and continued to have it all the way through the JFK precidency.

RFK was planning a large-scale invasion of Cuba, it is safe to assume that JFK, though insulated, knew about the plans.
No. There were contingency planning in case it should develop a popular uprising which at the time was utterly improbable.

Why do you think that JFK was trying to seek out a rapproachment with Castro while at the same time trying to assassinate him?

Where is the logic?
 
Watch out folks, here it comes; the autopsies were falsified, the x-rays and photographs were faked, the pathologists were in on the conspiracy...... yada, yada, yada.
No, the autopsy of RFK was exemplary. Thomas Noguchi knew his trade and did not back down when they tried to intimidate him.

The problem was Sirhans defence. It convinced Sirhan that he should confess to the murder and make an insanity plea in order to avoid the death penalty. He did and the defence ”stipulated” all technical evidence as culpatory.
 
JFK’s ”flexible respons” to every international crisis and conflict he had to deal with as president was, diplomacy.

Flexible response was a recognition of a need to reorganize the military to make it relevant in the new type of warfare that developed after WWII. The point is how and when and against whom you are using it.

JFK never used it. Never.

He didn't live long enough. The military build-up in Florida during the missile crisis was breathtaking.

Yes, he had the opinion that the military should be in charge of all types of warfare, including more or less covert such until the the domain of the CIA which he did not trust.

And yet they were designed to work with the CIA, whose powers he expanded.

The Bay of Pigs was forced upon him and he understood that the CIA pulled an ugly one on him when they demanded that he should send in the Marines when the exile invation force got beaten by Castro at the beach.

He could have stopped it. He didn't.

CIA was pretty much out of control when JFK was inaugurated. He had plans to rein it in and close it down when they assassinated him. He was going to take away the ”fun and games” from them once and for all.

Not true. The CIA has always been under control of the elected government. Every once in a while the get caught, and Congress and the President is "Shocked and Outraged", and somebody takes an early retirement, and hearings are held to "get to the bottom" of something they'd all been briefed about - and signed off on - long before it happened.

The chicken hawks was whining and wanted an armed conflict. When the Wall came up, JFK was labeled a traitor.

Nobody wanted WWIII.

No, it was not, not in the US National Security State. They were all outraged and believed that the country was without a leader.

No, they were relieved.

Need to point out that "National Security State" is a neo-Nazi phrase. You might want to stop using it.


Not perfect ≠ trying to assassinate somebody.

Did JFK accept this ”plan”?

Did JFK accept this ”plan”?

Did he accept false pretext/false flags in order to justify an invasion of Cuba?

He was killed before anything could happen. LBJ shut it down.

JFK inherited the Cuban exile problem from the Eisenhower administration. He had to very delicately keep the situation under control after the Bay of Pigs fiasco showing his comitment to the exile cuban cause while at the same time stay true to his commitment not to use US military brute force against the will of the people in any post colonial country.

Not even close.


Why do you think that JFK was trying to seek out a rapproachment with Castro while at the same time trying to assassinate him?

It's called Rope-A-Dope.
 
...FWIW, I actually agree with you that JKF didn't order the killings- my sense is that the situation just got away from him, and his only culpability is on the "buck stops here" principle, that he didn't foresee a possibility that certainly should have occurred to him as one. But the same can be said for Lodge/the CIA- unless you can, using your own standard that exonerates JKF, "cite the order," from Lodge/to someone identifiably in the CIA, that implicates them in a plot to kill Diem. Otherwise, at least in the case of the CIA, you're just saying "the CIA" in the same way religious fundies say "satan," responsible for all evils because that's just what he does- a tautological definition in place of an evidenced (therefore falsifiable) hypothesis. It's easy to attribute any chosen evil to something you've essentially invented as the father of them all- it's harder to construct a chain that makes the evil attributable or the father real.


From what I read, it was something of a "will no one rid me of this turbulent priest" thing. JFK was discussing what to do about the increasingly problematic Diem and uttered something along the lines of "can't we do something about this guy?" Which started certain wheels rolling that culminated in the assassination -- which upon hearing about, JFK reportedly freaked and literally ran from the room, in apparent realization of his role in the process. Whether he consciously called for the murder, or was just releasing some otherwise harmless exasperation and forgot the "but it would be wrong" part, probably no one will ever know for certain.
 
Last edited:
I find it insane that people are still arguing about who killed the Kennedys when after all it was you and me Mick Jagger recorded an audio confession in 1968.

(Maybe because he accused his fans of being in on it as well? How many of you were named unindicted co-conspirators? Don't all raise your hands at once.)
 
From what I read, it was something of a "will no one rid me of this turbulent priest" thing. JFK was discussing what to do about the increasingly problematic Diem and uttered something along the lines of "can't we do something about this guy?" Which started certain wheels rolling that culminated in the assassination -- which upon hearing about, JFK reportedly freaked and literally ran from the room, in apparent realization of his role in the process. Whether he consciously called for the murder, or was just releasing some otherwise harmless exasperation and forgot the "but it would be wrong" part, probably no one will ever know for certain.

Yeah, that sounds about right- the only people that we can be certain were implicated were the leaders of the coup, the ones who did the actual killing. And manifesto's claim that only Lodge knew where the brothers were hiding isn't completely accurate. In fact, they were accompanied by a couple of loyalists, one of whom, Air Force Lieutenant Ðỗ Thơ, happened to be a nephew of Colonel Đỗ Mậu, the director of military security and a participant in the coup plot; Thơ later wrote in his diary that "I consider myself responsible for having led them to their death." A tragedy of errors, it seems, for the most part...


In fact, manifesto has nothing but inference to support the idea that Lodge/the CIA were directly implicated in the killings. It's not wild inference, it's certainly possible; but the problem with the sort of CT methodology that rests on inference is that there can be plenty of inference to go around, it's a sword that can cut many ways.
 
Yeah, that sounds about right- the only people that we can be certain were implicated were the leaders of the coup, the ones who did the actual killing. And manifesto's claim that only Lodge knew where the brothers were hiding isn't completely accurate. In fact, they were accompanied by a couple of loyalists, one of whom, Air Force Lieutenant Ðỗ Thơ, happened to be a nephew of Colonel Đỗ Mậu, the director of military security and a participant in the coup plot; Thơ later wrote in his diary that "I consider myself responsible for having led them to their death." A tragedy of errors, it seems, for the most part...
Ok, my mistake, there were probably other channels than Lodge/Conein available. But this is not all that points to Lodge/CIA culpability in the assassinations.

In fact, manifesto has nothing but inference to support the idea that Lodge/the CIA were directly implicated in the killings. It's not wild inference, it's certainly possible; but the problem with the sort of CT methodology that rests on inference is that there can be plenty of inference to go around, it's a sword that can cut many ways.
It’s not just inference. Since Conein was supervising the coup at their HQ and was in radio contact with Lodge and the White house situation room (JFK was asleep) while the coup developed, they were fully informed of the developments leading up to the assassinations.

They did nothing to stop it. Could they have stopped it? Of course they could. The coup makers knew that they were 100% dependent on the approval of the US National Security State in order to survive more than a week after the coup.

They would never have killed the Ngo brothers without an OK from, in this case, CIA’s man on the spot, Lucien Conein.

Why was it important for CIA to have Diem and his brother killed? To give cred to the new rulers. The Diem regime was the most hated by its own people in modern time.

A boost in the morale in a crumbling puppet state in order to save it from its own people.
 
From what I read, it was something of a "will no one rid me of this turbulent priest" thing.
No, it was not. JFK didn’t push for a coup since he had already decided to withdraw all US personel from South Vietnam no matter how the conflict developed.

NSAM 263.

JFK was discussing what to do about the increasingly problematic Diem and uttered something along the lines of "can't we do something about this guy?" Which started certain wheels rolling that culminated in the assassination -- which upon hearing about, JFK reportedly freaked and literally ran from the room, in apparent realization of his role in the process. Whether he consciously called for the murder, or was just releasing some otherwise harmless exasperation and forgot the "but it would be wrong" part, probably no one will ever know for certain.
THIS is pure speculation without any documented support. Have any?
 
No, it was not. JFK didn’t push for a coup since he had already decided to withdraw all US personel from South Vietnam no matter how the conflict developed.

NSAM 263.

THIS is pure speculation without any documented support. Have any?

I just posted the documents. You've ignored them. They detail step-by-step the meetings where the coup was discussed and planned complete with a list of potential successors we could back afterwords.

His plan to dial back our presence in Vietnam hinged on what happened after Diem was removed, and as it turned out the new guys were even worse which lead to our build-up of forces in 1964-65.

In short, Kennedy ignored the CIA and General Taylor and green-lit the coup plan. Maybe he knew Diem would die, maybe he didn't, for a visionary JFK was often short sighted.
 
This is Chief of Staff Maxwell Taylors description of how JFK reacted to the news that the Ngo brothers had been executed:
“Kennedy leaped to his feet and rushed from the room with a look of shock and dismay on his face which I had never seen before. He had always insisted that Diem must never suffer more than exile and had been led to believe or had persuaded himself that a change in government could be carried out without bloodshed.”​

From what I read, it was something of a "will no one rid me of this turbulent priest" thing. JFK was discussing what to do about the increasingly problematic Diem and uttered something along the lines of "can't we do something about this guy?" Which started certain wheels rolling that culminated in the assassination -- which upon hearing about, JFK reportedly freaked and literally ran from the room, in apparent realization of his role in the process. Whether he consciously called for the murder, or was just releasing some otherwise harmless exasperation and forgot the "but it would be wrong" part, probably no one will ever know for certain.

THIS is pure speculation without any documented support. Have any?

You mean, apart from what you yourself quoted?
 
You mean, apart from what you yourself quoted?


Funny-men-laughing-cartoon-you-want-it-when.png


I wonder if he knows what "hoisted by one's own petard" means?
 
I just posted the documents. You've ignored them. They detail step-by-step the meetings where the coup was discussed and planned complete with a list of potential successors we could back afterwords.

His plan to dial back our presence in Vietnam hinged on what happened after Diem was removed, and as it turned out the new guys were even worse which lead to our build-up of forces in 1964-65.

In short, Kennedy ignored the CIA and General Taylor and green-lit the coup plan. Maybe he knew Diem would die, maybe he didn't, for a visionary JFK was often short sighted.
Cite. Explain. Argue.
 
You mean, apart from what you yourself quoted?
”Apparently realized his role in the process”. What ”role” did he have in what ”process”?

I claim he once more realized that the CIA was out of control. A criminal organization committing ongoing crimes against the US constitution, democracy and against humanity. He fired its leadership after the Bay of Pigs but soon realized that the cancer was deeply rooted and had metastasized through out both the military and civil society.

They assassinated him before he had the chance to root it out once and for all.

JFK was the last US president who served the American people, not the US Security State = the permanent War State = the Oligarchy = the Hidden Government = US Gangster State = US Military Industrial Complex = The Belt Way Gravy Train = The New World Order = ...

Call it what you want. It’s in power, sucking the life blood of everything it touch upon. Sooner or later.
 
Because he acted alone.

Good, you're learning.;)
The world leading expertise has explained that Sirhan was showing all known signs of post hypnotic suggestion when arrested at the Ambassador Hotel, and still does 40 years later. He was a victim of unvoluntary mind control including hypnosis, drugs and brain washing in the months preceding the assassination. Probably in connection to the CIA MKUltra project.

Sirhan is exeptionally easy to hypnotize according to all expertise reviewing his case and/or testing him on site.

The stated reason for not granting him parole have since 1985 been that he doesn’t own up to what he have done and therefore can’t be released to society.

In spite of this, Sirhan insist that he can’t remember what happened before or during the event and therefore can not explain what he did and why he did it.

That is, he would have been a free man for the last 20 years if he had ’played ball’. He is still in jail. 40 years later still counting.

His case is now under review by OAS for crimes against Sirhans human rights.
 
Last edited:
Robert Kennedy’s death, like the President’s, was mourned as an extension of the evils of senseless violence; events moved on, and the profound alterations that these deaths … brought in the equation of power in America was perceived as random …. What is odd is not that some people thought it was all random, but that so many intelligent people refused to believe that it might be anything else. Nothing can measure more graphically how limited was the general understanding of what is possible in America.

~ Congressman Allard Lowenstein​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom