RFK Jr. suspects a second gunman killed his dad.

The beast with many names. Sounds familiar.
Why did Ike Eisenhower warn the American people of the ”military-industrial complex” in his farwell speach? He was a general and a war hero, not what you call a ”CT”. An insider if there ever was one.

A ”CT”?
 
For someone who likes to accuse non-believers in his conspiracy theories of not living in the real world, I find manifesto's naive belief that the Kennedys were some kind of saints amusing. They were politicians. JFK especially was a cold warrior, and the process that led to the Vietnam war was well underway during his presidency. Of course, there is no way of knowing if he was smart enough to avoid the disastrous decisions made by LBJ had he survived, but my guess is that he would not have. While I don't think the Kennedys were more evil than other politicians of that era, I don't see any reason to think they were less so. The Soviets certainly weren't playing nice, and it seems that the Kennedys felt that we couldn't afford to play nice either. They were likely right about that.

As for Vietnam, Johnson took the worse course possible. He took us to war, but did so in a manner that gave us no chance of winning. Far better to have avoided the war
 
I was eight years old when JFK was killed. I was twelve when RFK was killed. I was in Colorado during both assassinations. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. I don't know who Mick Jagger was referencing as "you" in "you and me", but it wasn't me. You can't pin this one on me, Mick.:D
No one is accusing you of taking part in the assassinations. I’m accusing you of willfully taking part in the ongoing cover up. That makes you an accessory after the fact.

Or immensely ignorant.
 
In secret using the CIA in manipulating the media? Show me.

I linked to it and quoted it in another thread. I showed you, you derped it.


No. RFK was one of four in the Special Group Augmented which was created by the president to oversee all Cuban operations after the CIA’s betrail of his trust during the Bay of Pigs fiasco. The operative chief of Operation Mongoose was CIA’s ”General” Edward Lansdale.

RFK ran it.
 
For someone who likes to accuse non-believers in his conspiracy theories of not living in the real world, I find manifesto's naive belief that the Kennedys were some kind of saints amusing.
Not a saint. A decent man who tried to do good for all Americans and for the downtrodden in the post colonial world.

They were politicians. JFK especially was a cold warrior,
No, he was not. He runned his campaign as a cold warrior because that was the only way he could beat cold warrior Richard Nixon.

When in power, he showed his real ideology and vision which runned contrary to the whole cold war National Security establisment in Washington, Wall Street and Langley. Look at his track record. Diplomacy, not armed conflict. Every time.

and the process that led to the Vietnam war was well underway during his presidency.
No. He had already ordered the beginning of the unconditional withdrawal of all American advisers (ca 15 000) when assassinated in Dallas nov 22. 1000 before the end of 1963. An additional 5000 before the end of 1964. The rest before the end of 1965. If he got reelected. It is a myth that LBJ just continued with JFK’s agenda and policies when acted as he did as his usurper. It’s on tape that he didn’t (1.08): https://youtu.be/myWfWk1IQrw

Of course, there is no way of knowing if he was smart enough to avoid the disastrous decisions made by LBJ had he survived, but my guess is that he would not have.
Why do you ”guess” against all evidence? The order for a complete withdrawal was unconditional and LBJ him self attests to this in his conversation with McNamara three months after the assassination. He KNEW that he reversed JFK’s agenda 180˚ when conditioning the US withdrawal on a South Vietnamese victory before that could happen. He did more than that, he lied to Congress and the rest of the world about the Tonkin incident as a false pretext for a full scale American invasion, 1965.

While I don't think the Kennedys were more evil than other politicians of that era, I don't see any reason to think they were less so.
Compare JFK with LBJ, Nixon, the Bushes ... the only one who can stand up to JFK is FDR, in spite of him lying to the American people about the Japanese ”surprise attack” on Pearl Harbor. He and the top military brass knew it was coming that day and time, sacrifying 3000 American sailors. At least, that was a necessary war for a good cause.

The Soviets certainly weren't playing nice, and it seems that the Kennedys felt that we couldn't afford to play nice either. They were likely right about that.
JFK was a fervent anti communist, no doubt about that. That said, he had a completely different vision of how to best stem the tide (if there was a tide), than the chicken hawks in US National Security State. A third way. Not totalitarian communism. Not proxy right wing military dictatorship. A third way. Peaceful aid and coopration. Carrots not sticks. Win win.

He was well on his way doing just that.

As for Vietnam, Johnson took the worse course possible. He took us to war, but did so in a manner that gave us no chance of winning. Far better to have avoided the war
He wasn’t supposed to win that or any other war. He was supposed to provide his buddies in the armaments industry with big fat government contracts making them even more wealthy at the expence of the US people and 3 million innocent South East Asians. On which he and later Tricky Dick dropped millions of tons of bombs, Agent Orange and burning napalm raining from the sky. Day in and day out for almost a decade.

$$$$$$$$$$$$ .....

What makes you think even in your wildest fantasies that JFK had done the same? His track record? Hardly.

What?
 
No, he was not. He runned his campaign as a cold warrior because that was the only way he could beat cold warrior Richard Nixon.

Gullible. He was hardcore Cold War.


When in power, he showed his real ideology and vision which runned contrary to the whole cold war National Security establisment in Washington, Wall Street and Langley. Look at his track record. Diplomacy, not armed conflict. Every time.

He was expanding the size of the military, giving it a covert wing, and expanded the role of the CIA.

He cut taxes to help the wealthy who helped get him elected under the guise of economic stimulus.

No. He had already ordered the beginning of the unconditional withdrawal of all American advisers (ca 15 000) when assassinated in Dallas nov 22. 1000 before the end of 1963. An additional 5000 before the end of 1964. The rest before the end of 1965

The assassination of Diem changed all that. JFK checkmated himself in Vietnam.

He did more than that, he lied to Congress and the rest of the world about the Tonkin incident as a false pretext for a full scale American invasion, 1965.

Except that reporters talked to the crew of the Maddox and it was reported that the Gulf of Tonkin Incident was blown out of proportion. Congress didn't care, and they gave him his war.

Compare JFK with LBJ, Nixon, the Bushes ... the only one who can stand up to JFK is FDR, in spite of him lying to the American people about the Japanese ”surprise attack” on Pearl Harbor. He and the top military brass knew it was coming that day and time, sacrifying 3000 American sailors. At least, that was a necessary war for a good cause.

Is there any anti-American conspiracy theory you won't swallow whole without question?

JFK was a fervent anti communist, no doubt about that. That said, he had a completely different vision of how to best stem the tide (if there was a tide), than the chicken hawks in US National Security State. A third way. Not totalitarian communism.

The only people who use the phrase "National Security State" are Neo Nazis. <snip>

Not proxy right wing military dictatorship.

Except installing the Baath Party in Iraq.

A third way. Peaceful aid and coopration. Carrots not sticks. Win win.

With a huge military force behind him.


On which he and later Tricky Dick dropped millions of tons of bombs, Agent Orange and burning napalm raining from the sky. Day in and day out for almost a decade.

Nixon was elected in 1968, the last US combat forces withdrew from Vietnam in February, 1973. That's less than 5 years, not a decade even using Swedish math.;)


Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited for Rules 0/12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Compare JFK with LBJ, Nixon, the Bushes ... the only one who can stand up to JFK is FDR, in spite of him lying to the American people about the Japanese ”surprise attack” on Pearl Harbor. He and the top military brass knew it was coming that day and time, sacrifying 3000 American sailors. At least, that was a necessary war for a good cause.

It's unfortunate that Gawdzilla has left the board. The last time anyone claimed this he got his theories dismembered. Why don't you tell us what is your proof that "he and the top military brass knew it was coming that day and time"?

:blackcat:
 
Is there any anti-American conspiracy theory you won't swallow whole without question?

It would seem that way. I often wonder about (if Manifesto is American) why such a person is not in an armed rebellion if he thinks everything in America is run by a murderous criminal conspiracy. AND he's telling everyone about their plans and they do nothing about it...... Puzzling.....lol
 
Not a saint. A decent man who tried to do good for all Americans and for the downtrodden in the post colonial world.

No, he was not. He runned his campaign as a cold warrior because that was the only way he could beat cold warrior Richard Nixon.

When in power, he showed his real ideology and vision which runned contrary to the whole cold war National Security establisment in Washington, Wall Street and Langley. Look at his track record. Diplomacy, not armed conflict. Every time.

No. He had already ordered the beginning of the unconditional withdrawal of all American advisers (ca 15 000) when assassinated in Dallas nov 22. 1000 before the end of 1963. An additional 5000 before the end of 1964. The rest before the end of 1965. If he got reelected. It is a myth that LBJ just continued with JFK’s agenda and policies when acted as he did as his usurper. It’s on tape that he didn’t (1.08): https://youtu.be/myWfWk1IQrw

Why do you ”guess” against all evidence? The order for a complete withdrawal was unconditional and LBJ him self attests to this in his conversation with McNamara three months after the assassination. He KNEW that he reversed JFK’s agenda 180˚ when conditioning the US withdrawal on a South Vietnamese victory before that could happen. He did more than that, he lied to Congress and the rest of the world about the Tonkin incident as a false pretext for a full scale American invasion, 1965.

Compare JFK with LBJ, Nixon, the Bushes ... the only one who can stand up to JFK is FDR, in spite of him lying to the American people about the Japanese ”surprise attack” on Pearl Harbor. He and the top military brass knew it was coming that day and time, sacrifying 3000 American sailors. At least, that was a necessary war for a good cause.

JFK was a fervent anti communist, no doubt about that. That said, he had a completely different vision of how to best stem the tide (if there was a tide), than the chicken hawks in US National Security State. A third way. Not totalitarian communism. Not proxy right wing military dictatorship. A third way. Peaceful aid and coopration. Carrots not sticks. Win win.

He was well on his way doing just that.

He wasn’t supposed to win that or any other war. He was supposed to provide his buddies in the armaments industry with big fat government contracts making them even more wealthy at the expence of the US people and 3 million innocent South East Asians. On which he and later Tricky Dick dropped millions of tons of bombs, Agent Orange and burning napalm raining from the sky. Day in and day out for almost a decade.

$$$$$$$$$$$$ .....

What makes you think even in your wildest fantasies that JFK had done the same? His track record? Hardly.

What?

Stupid, overlaid with ludicrous, with layers of moronic, piled up with with a large topping of nincompoopery, and a side order of senseless.
 
Stupid, overlaid with ludicrous, with layers of moronic, piled up with with a large topping of nincompoopery, and a side order of senseless.
Well, coming from you, thank you. I guess that is why you are not responding with a detailed attempt at refuting my contentions?

Because you can’t?
 
It would seem that way. I often wonder about (if Manifesto is American) why such a person is not in an armed rebellion if he thinks everything in America is run by a murderous criminal conspiracy. AND he's telling everyone about their plans and they do nothing about it...... Puzzling.....lol
I’m not American, but have American relatives who have mostly the same view of the US National Security State as I have.

USA ≠ US National Security State.

Lets hope that it not have to come to an armed revolution. That the American people can reclaim its country, restore the constitution and ban legalized beltway corruption in other ways.

Taking back the power stolen from them by the top one percent of the top one percent, without open armed revolution.

Hope.
 
Last edited:
It's unfortunate that Gawdzilla has left the board. The last time anyone claimed this he got his theories dismembered. Why don't you tell us what is your proof that "he and the top military brass knew it was coming that day and time"?

:blackcat:
Is there a thread on this topic? If so, I’ll post the proof in due time. Of course they knew that the Japanese would attack Pearl Harbor that very day. They had broken the Japanese codes long before that happened.

Like reading from an open book. Prime time.
 
Last edited:
No one is accusing you of taking part in the assassinations. I’m accusing you of willfully taking part in the ongoing cover up. That makes you an accessory after the fact.

Or immensely ignorant.

Well, there you go- CT as ideology (veering into religion), along with the test for ideological purity, that anyone who disagrees with it must be part of it or just plain ignorant. McCarthy would have been proud...

Gotta admit, I'm a little disappointed (though I can't say totally surprised). I mean, you seem like an intelligent person with a pretty good command of the material; and I thought it was pretty upright of you when you admitted you weren't right about something (Lodge being the only one who knew where Diem and his brother were hiding). I've no idea how old you are, but haven't you learned yet that intelligent people can look at the same facts as you and come to different conclusions from them? (Channeling old Abe there a little, I think)


And the sneering at someone who disagrees with you as, essentially, "no true skeptic" is also silly. Skepticism begins at home, meaning you start with questioning your own conclusions before starting on anyone else's. Every time you demand that people "cite the relevant parts. Explain. Argue for its veracity," and follow it with "I neither can or should do it for you," you miss the point of skepticism by a mile- that you need to read the cites in their entireties for yourself. Otherwise, you look like the creationist or flat-earther who cringes from confronting the whole of the evidence against their ideas because that whole threatens them. Nobody but you can test your ideas for yourself- only you know what it would take to admit to yourself error.
 
Lets hope that it not have to come to an armed revolution. That the American people can reclaim its country, restore the constitution and ban legalized beltway corruption in other ways.

Taking back the power stolen from them by the top one percent of the top one percent, without open armed revolution.

So your 'plan' or hope is that in some magical way the conspiracy you believe exists and which kills Presidents and other politicians and makes billions doing this and that will just throw up it hands, say sorry and do what exactly?

The political power in the US has always been moreso in the hands of the powerful than the weak. I believe you will find that trying to construct some from of 'de-powering of money' will run afoul of freedom of speech and creative slide of hand. If completely removed this would mean that very rich people would be able to garner power even further as poorer people would be unable to obtain enough money to run for office.

So why are you alive and uncensored by the way?
 
And the sneering at someone who disagrees with you as, essentially, "no true skeptic" is also silly. Skepticism begins at home, meaning you start with questioning your own conclusions before starting on anyone else's. Every time you demand that people "cite the relevant parts. Explain. Argue for its veracity," and follow it with "I neither can or should do it for you," you miss the point of skepticism by a mile- that you need to read the cites in their entireties for yourself. Otherwise, you look like the creationist or flat-earther who cringes from confronting the whole of the evidence against their ideas because that whole threatens them. Nobody but you can test your ideas for yourself- only you know what it would take to admit to yourself error.

Well said. I deal with Archaeology CT all the time and for them the elephant in the room is always the concept of consilience (also convergence of evidence or concordance of evidence) is their mind killer. They of course ignore it and try to focus on trivia and 'opinions' and especially the tyranny of 'possibilities'.
 
Well, there you go- CT Debunking as ideology (veering into religion), along with the test for ideological purity, that anyone who disagrees with it must be part of it or just plain ignorant. McCarthy would have been proud...

Gotta admit, I'm a little disappointed (though I can't say totally surprised). I mean, you seem like an intelligent person with a pretty good command of the material; and I thought it was pretty upright of you when you admitted you weren't right about something (Lodge being the only one who knew where Diem and his brother were hiding). I've no idea how old you are, but haven't you learned yet that intelligent people can look at the same facts as you and come to different conclusions from them? (Channeling old Abe there a little, I think)


And the sneering at someone who disagrees with you as, essentially, "no true skeptic" is also silly. Skepticism begins at home, meaning you start with questioning your own conclusions before starting on anyone else's. Every time you demand that people "cite the relevant parts. Explain. Argue for its veracity," and follow it with "I neither can or should do it for you," you miss the point of skepticism by a mile- that you need to read the cites in their entireties for yourself. Otherwise, you look like the creationist or flat-earther who cringes from confronting the whole of the evidence against their ideas because that whole threatens them. Nobody but you can test your ideas for yourself- only you know what it would take to admit to yourself error.
Admonishing goes both ways; for you to put the complete responsibility on manifesto is single visioned. You can go back in this thread and it is the "debunkers" who make the snide comments without moving the topic forward. It is a "debunker" who is calling manifesto a "neo nazi"... yet, that goes untouched as your focus is on manifesto's use of having his critics cite passages instead of just posting the articles. Credibility can only be earned when a person is consistent; manifesto's actions are steady and as you stated he/she will admit when they are incorrect... the same cannot be said about some "debunkers".
 
The political power in the US has always been moreso in the hands of the powerful than the weak. I believe you will find that trying to construct some from of 'de-powering of money' will run afoul of freedom of speech and creative slide of hand. If completely removed this would mean that very rich people would be able to garner power even further as poorer people would be unable to obtain enough money to run for office.
How is this different from what we have today? GW Bush had a Cabinet which had collective assets exceeding $500M.
 
Admonishing goes both ways; for you to put the complete responsibility on manifesto is single visioned. You can go back in this thread and it is the "debunkers" who make the snide comments without moving the topic forward. It is a "debunker" who is calling manifesto a "neo nazi"... yet, that goes untouched as your focus is on manifesto's use of having his critics cite passages instead of just posting the articles. Credibility can only be earned when a person is consistent; manifesto's actions are steady and as you stated he/she will admit when they are incorrect... the same cannot be said about some "debunkers".

The phrase "National Security State" was coined by Neo-Nazis on American podcasts. It's one of the Alt-Right's dog whistles.

If he was a true liberal fighting fascism he'd know that he'd know that.

We post links because there are board rules about posting long passages, and in the case of history it is much more beneficial to read the original material in its context for better understanding.

Finally, he hijacked the thread.
 
Well, there you go- CT as ideology (veering into religion), along with the test for ideological purity, that anyone who disagrees with it must be part of it or just plain ignorant. McCarthy would have been proud...
The evidence of a conspiracy and a cover up of the assassination of RFK are if at all possible, even more obvious than the same for his older brother. It’ll take time to go through all of it but be sure that I will, if not banned.

Gotta admit, I'm a little disappointed (though I can't say totally surprised). I mean, you seem like an intelligent person with a pretty good command of the material; and I thought it was pretty upright of you when you admitted you weren't right about something (Lodge being the only one who knew where Diem and his brother were hiding). I've no idea how old you are, but haven't you learned yet that intelligent people can look at the same facts as you and come to different conclusions from them? (Channeling old Abe there a little, I think)
Of course there is more than one side to every story but that doesn’t mean that truth is relative. There is only one way an event can have happened, not several ways (with reservations for multiple universes).


And the sneering at someone who disagrees with you as, essentially, "no true skeptic" is also silly.
When time and again have to deal with ”skeptics” on a forum devoted to ”scientific skepticism” that acts contrary to every reasonable definition of that concept, one has to point it out.

To remain sane.


Skepticism begins at home, meaning you start with questioning your own conclusions before starting on anyone else's. Every time you demand that people "cite the relevant parts. Explain. Argue for its veracity," and follow it with "I neither can or should do it for you," you miss the point of skepticism by a mile- that you need to read the cites in their entireties for yourself.
Do I? Really? Where do you draw the line? An essay? A book? A series of books with additional evidentiary volumes?

The thing is. If someone reads an article that is claiming to refute this and that, this same ”someone” has to understand it in order to see if that is really the case. IF this someone understands the paper, he/she should have no problems in explaining the critical data, methods and conclusions and make his/her case.

That is how it works. It is not the opponent who shall do this for him/her. That is plain nuts.

Example. There is an argument I make for CIA sanctioning the assassinations of the Ngo brothers against the expressed orders of their president, JFK.

If you in turn have issues with any of my statements, you correct them and/or request that I substantiate them with sources and maybe quotes from these if deemed proper.

Imagine me posting a couple of links to x number of books and suggests that you should read them and ”understand”.

Would you like that?

Otherwise, you look like the creationist or flat-earther who cringes from confronting the whole of the evidence against their ideas because that whole threatens them. Nobody but you can test your ideas for yourself- only you know what it would take to admit to yourself error.
When debating a controversial subject the discussion tends to be polarized.

A is listing all the facts, sources and good arguments for or against.

B is listing all the facts, sources and good arguments against or for.

May the closest to the Truth win.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom