RFK Jr. suspects a second gunman killed his dad.

Cite the part were JFK:

1. Orders the coup.

2. Orders the assassination of the Diem brothers.

No such documentation exists, but documentation does exist that as early as '61 The Kennedy administration was making contacts with SVN military officers that objected to the Diem regime, and eventually when those contacts planed their coup they sought and received permission from the Kennedy administration to carry out their operation to overthrow Diem:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/index.htm

Records of the Kennedy national security meetings, both here and in our larger collection, show that none of JFK's conversations about a coup in Saigon featured consideration of what might physically happen to Ngo Dinh Diem or Ngo Dinh Nhu. The audio record of the October 29th meeting which we cite below also reveals no discussion of this issue. That meeting, the last held at the White House to consider a coup before this actually took place, would have been the key moment for such a conversation. The conclusion of the Church Committee agrees that Washington gave no consideration to killing Diem. (Note 12)

The weight of evidence therefore supports the view that President Kennedy did not conspire in the death of Diem. However, there is also the exceedingly strange transcript of Diem's final phone conversation with Ambassador Lodge on the afternoon of the coup (Document 23), which carries the distinct impression that Diem is being abandoned by the U.S. Whether this represents Lodge's contribution, or JFK's wishes, is not apparent from the evidence available today.

A second charge has to do with Kennedy administration denials that it had had anything to do with the coup itself. The documentary record is replete with evidence that President Kennedy and his advisers, both individually and collectively, had a considerable role in the coup overall, by giving initial support to Saigon military officers uncertain what the U.S. response might be, by withdrawing U.S. aid from Diem himself, and by publicly pressuring the Saigon government in a way that made clear to South Vietnamese that Diem was isolated from his American ally. In addition, at several of his meetings (Documents 7, 19, 22) Kennedy had CIA briefings and led discussions based on the estimated balance between pro- and anti-coup forces in Saigon that leave no doubt the United States had a detailed interest in the outcome of a coup against Ngo Dinh Diem. The CIA also provided $42,000 in immediate support money to the plotters the morning of the coup, carried by Lucien Conein, an act prefigured in administration planning Document 17)


Astute observers of history will no doubt note the mortality rates for deposed leaders. A retirement lunch of the sort preferred by mafiosi is the rule, rather than the exception.

If officials of the Kennedy administration and JFK himself believed they were signing off on a bloodless operation I believe that was most likely a hope born from optimism, not a rational examination of conditions on the ground in SVN.
 
Here is an interview with the coroner, Thomas Noguchi:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=DHVrn...D6Xxxlq-exJSmwMMxyu70v_OC-BEMC6TfkKNMy3Hds1yw

1-1.5 inch from behind. Sirhan was never closer than ca 2 feet from in front of RFK (with his pistol) according to the withesses who wrestled him down on a table. They were in between Sirhan and RFK at all time.

You seem to always find that eye witnesses are better evidence than real evidence, why is that. In the flash of gunshots, I remember almost everyone ducking for cover rather than judging the distance Sirhan was from RFK.
 
I see the usual CTist double-standard shuffle is in full play here. In the JFK thread, manifesto proclaims that Lyndon Johnson, Allen Dulles, and J. Edgar Hoover were "in on" the assassination of JFK, based on no more than "a whole lot of circumstantial evidence and means motive and opportunity" (and the "circumstantial evidence" is only an assertion); while, in this thread, he won't believe that RFK could have been involved in any attempted assassination of Castro unless he can be quoted plotting it in a meeting, or that JFK could have been involved in Diem's deposition and death unless someone can "cite orders" from him to that effect.


Heh. CTists are funny people- it's gotten to where I don't bother debating them on details anymore, I just sit back and wait for the inevitable comedy.
 
You can go read the documents yourself.
If you claim that the documents contains evidence of JFK ordering the assassinations of the Diem brothers, you should quote the relevant text and explain how you come to your conclusion.

It is not me who shall find support for your claims.

The CIA works on behalf of the White House and Congress, mostly the NSC. Everything they've ever done was green-lit by the White House, and the House Intelligence Oversight Committee. The CIA does not act on its own behalf.

You'd know this if you'd read real history books.
Not when JFK was president, no.

His original draft letter justifying the coup:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/vn14.pdf

Meeting checklist about the coup:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/vn18.pdf

Conference where General Taylor advises JFK not to think of Vietnam like a football game, and RFK agrees, yet they press on:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/vn19.pdf

White House advising Ambassador Lodge that they will back the RVN Generals in the coup:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/vn21.pdf

Ambassador Lodge lying to Diem:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/vn23.pdf

CIA memo touting success of the coup:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/vn24.pdf

Saying that JFK had no idea Diem would be killed is the same as Bush saying he had no idea there would be an Iraqi Insurgency.
Same here. Posting links to documents allegedly supporting your claim isn’t enough. You have to quote the relevant text and explain how you think it supports your claim.

I neither should or can do it for you.

Uh huh, Pax Americana, and he built up the military, created covert commando units in the Army and Navy, and broadened the CIA's operational scope beyond its charter. "Post Colonial" Vietnam was his model.

Bottom Line under JFK: Our way or else.
No, you are wrong, completely inverting the historical record. Shamelessly. Yes, he initiated the Green Berets and yes he gave the military additional funding in different areas, but his reasons for doing this stemmed from a completely different outlook on the role US should play on the geopolitical arena. Look at his track record:

1. He never ordered US combat troops to open fire in any of the international conflicts that developed during his precidency. Bay of Pigs. Berlin. Laos. Vietnam. Middle East. Missile crisis. Vietnam. Always using diplomacy.

2. Initiated a broad national information campaign creating a public mandate for the first atmospheric test ban treaty with the Soviet Union.

3. Consistently diverting US bilateral aid to post colonial nation’s civil institutions, not to their military.

4. Consistently turning down the ’advise/demands’ from the chicken hawks in US National Security State.

5. Working on secret rapproachment with Castro at the very instant he got assassinated.

6. Working to end the Cold War wanting to create joint ventures with the Soviets in space and other areas where cooperation were suitable.

All this and more was in sharp conflict with US National Security State and it all changed 180˚ the very second they assassinated him in Dallas, putting crazy LBJ in charge. We all know what happened then. That is recorded History with millions of innocent lives sacrified in racist megalomania.

Everything else is revisionist history writing in service of the US National Security State. Some get paid doing it. Some do it as misguided patriotism. Some do it because they are stupid and misinformed.

I’m still not sure on what motivates you.

And yet that's what he did.
Show it.
 
You seem to always find that eye witnesses are better evidence than real evidence, why is that. In the flash of gunshots, I remember almost everyone ducking for cover rather than judging the distance Sirhan was from RFK.
What ”real” evidence contradict the witnesses in the case of Sirhans positions and movents on the murder scene?
 
I'm moderately surprised I've never heard of a CT about a second gunmen for RFK before.
 
No such documentation exists, but documentation does exist that as early as '61 The Kennedy administration was making contacts with SVN military officers that objected to the Diem regime, and eventually when those contacts planed their coup they sought and received permission from the Kennedy administration to carry out their operation to overthrow Diem:

https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/index.htm

Records of the Kennedy national security meetings, both here and in our larger collection, show that none of JFK's conversations about a coup in Saigon featured consideration of what might physically happen to Ngo Dinh Diem or Ngo Dinh Nhu. The audio record of the October 29th meeting which we cite below also reveals no discussion of this issue. That meeting, the last held at the White House to consider a coup before this actually took place, would have been the key moment for such a conversation. The conclusion of the Church Committee agrees that Washington gave no consideration to killing Diem. (Note 12)

The weight of evidence therefore supports the view that President Kennedy did not conspire in the death of Diem. However, there is also the exceedingly strange transcript of Diem's final phone conversation with Ambassador Lodge on the afternoon of the coup (Document 23), which carries the distinct impression that Diem is being abandoned by the U.S. Whether this represents Lodge's contribution, or JFK's wishes, is not apparent from the evidence available today.

A second charge has to do with Kennedy administration denials that it had had anything to do with the coup itself. The documentary record is replete with evidence that President Kennedy and his advisers, both individually and collectively, had a considerable role in the coup overall, by giving initial support to Saigon military officers uncertain what the U.S. response might be, by withdrawing U.S. aid from Diem himself, and by publicly pressuring the Saigon government in a way that made clear to South Vietnamese that Diem was isolated from his American ally. In addition, at several of his meetings (Documents 7, 19, 22) Kennedy had CIA briefings and led discussions based on the estimated balance between pro- and anti-coup forces in Saigon that leave no doubt the United States had a detailed interest in the outcome of a coup against Ngo Dinh Diem. The CIA also provided $42,000 in immediate support money to the plotters the morning of the coup, carried by Lucien Conein, an act prefigured in administration planning Document 17)


Astute observers of history will no doubt note the mortality rates for deposed leaders. A retirement lunch of the sort preferred by mafiosi is the rule, rather than the exception.

If officials of the Kennedy administration and JFK himself believed they were signing off on a bloodless operation I believe that was most likely a hope born from optimism, not a rational examination of conditions on the ground in SVN.
No one is claiming that JFK did not take part in discussions on the future of US puppet Diem regime. South Vietnam was a CIA puppet State created by General Lansdale in order to hinder a complete take over by Ho Chi Mihns nationalists forces of the former part of French Indochina that today constitutes Vietnam.

Diem was a catholic in a buddhist country and extremely impopular from the get go. The only force keeping him in power was the US National Security State. When it became obvious that Diem no longer could muster a defence from the nationalist forces inside his own country the chicken hawks in US National Security State began looking for other suitable leadership among the leaders in the South Vietnam military.

Yes, they were waiting for US to ”ok” a coup, but there is no undisputable record of JFK giving that ”ok”. And, there is certainly not any record of JFK allowing the plotters to assassinate the Diem brothers.

Yes, Lodge is implicated in the assassinations and so are the CIA, but that is not the case with JFK. This is just another instance of CIA doing stuff against the will of JFK, making their own policies using their own methods bypassing US laws and democratic institutions.

Corrupting everything within their reach.
 
No one is claiming that JFK did not take part in discussions on the future of US puppet Diem regime. South Vietnam was a CIA puppet State created by General Lansdale in order to hinder a complete take over by Ho Chi Mihns nationalists forces of the former part of French Indochina that today constitutes Vietnam.

Diem was a catholic in a buddhist country and extremely impopular from the get go. The only force keeping him in power was the US National Security State. When it became obvious that Diem no longer could muster a defence from the nationalist forces inside his own country the chicken hawks in US National Security State began looking for other suitable leadership among the leaders in the South Vietnam military.

Yes, they were waiting for US to ”ok” a coup, but there is no undisputable record of JFK giving that ”ok”. And, there is certainly not any record of JFK allowing the plotters to assassinate the Diem brothers.

Yes, Lodge is implicated in the assassinations and so are the CIA, but that is not the case with JFK. This is just another instance of CIA doing stuff against the will of JFK, making their own policies using their own methods bypassing US laws and democratic institutions.

Corrupting everything within their reach.

(Re the highlighted)
Really? Cite the orders. Show it.

FWIW, I actually agree with you that JKF didn't order the killings- my sense is that the situation just got away from him, and his only culpability is on the "buck stops here" principle, that he didn't foresee a possibility that certainly should have occurred to him as one. But the same can be said for Lodge/the CIA- unless you can, using your own standard that exonerates JKF, "cite the order," from Lodge/to someone identifiably in the CIA, that implicates them in a plot to kill Diem. Otherwise, at least in the case of the CIA, you're just saying "the CIA" in the same way religious fundies say "satan," responsible for all evils because that's just what he does- a tautological definition in place of an evidenced (therefore falsifiable) hypothesis. It's easy to attribute any chosen evil to something you've essentially invented as the father of them all- it's harder to construct a chain that makes the evil attributable or the father real.
 
Last edited:
I'm moderately surprised I've never heard of a CT about a second gunmen for RFK before.

There is only a very limited number of people who have this information. We are fortunate that the information has been first exposed right here on this very forum, before it is released to national media. Now that it is out it will be front page headlines on all national media. Keep watching.
 
(Re the highlighted)
Really? Cite the orders. Show it.

FWIW, I actually agree with you that JKF didn't order the killings-
Of course he didn’t. This is Chief of Staff Maxwell Taylors description of how JFK reacted to the news that the Ngo brothers had been executed:
“Kennedy leaped to his feet and rushed from the room with a look of shock and dismay on his face which I had never seen before. He had always insisted that Diem must never suffer more than exile and had been led to believe or had persuaded himself that a change in government could be carried out without bloodshed.”​


my sense is that the situation just got away from him, and his only culpability is on the "buck stops here" principle, that he didn't foresee a possibility that certainly should have occurred to him as one. But the same can be said for Lodge/the CIA- unless you can, using your own standard that exonerates JKF, "cite the order," from Lodge/to someone identifiably in the CIA, that implicates them in a plot to kill Diem. Otherwise, at least in the case of the CIA, you're just saying "the CIA" in the same way religious fundies say "satan," responsible for all evils because that's just what he does- a tautological definition in place of an evidenced (therefore falsifiable) hypothesis. It's easy to attribute any chosen evil to something you've essentially invented as the father of them all- it's harder to construct a chain that makes the evil attributable or the father real.
Ok. When the coup makers attacked the presidential palace, the Ngo brothers fled in a tunnel to a chineese merchants house in central Saigon. From there they called Cabot who promised them protection and escort out of country. Meanwhile CIA’s Lucien Conein was stationed in the coup headquarters with radio contact with US Embassy and the White house situation room (McGeorge Bundy).

The only one who knew where the Ngo brothers were hiding was Cabot and he was in contact with Conein who was in direct contact with the coup leaders in their HQ.

Early the next morning the military picked the Ngo brothers up outside a catholic church, forced them down the hatch of an armed vehicle and shot them in head.


So, why would Conein and Cabot have the Ngo brothers killed? Well, they were massively hated by the vietnamese people and their execution provided much needed credit to the military junta that became the new government. Credit that fast evaporated since no real change in policy occured.
 
Same here. Posting links to documents allegedly supporting your claim isn’t enough. You have to quote the relevant text and explain how you think it supports your claim.

.

Nope. You're a grown-up, read them yourself. Only babies get spoon-fed.



No, you are wrong, completely inverting the historical record. Shamelessly. Yes, he initiated the Green Berets and yes he gave the military additional funding in different areas, but his reasons for doing this stemmed from a completely different outlook on the role US should play on the geopolitical arena.

Yes, PAX Americana, and having a larger military gave us the ability to conduct combat operations anywhere in the world at will. It was called "Flexible Response", and it translated into "Vietnam". Every President since JFK has embraced a version of this.

He initiated the Special Forces and Navy SEALs as part of an expansion of the US's covert military capabilities. After the Bay of Pigs it was clear that t to be a player on the world stage we would need a force to counter Spetznaz.

Look at his track record:

1. He never ordered US combat troops to open fire in any of the international conflicts that developed during his precidency. Bay of Pigs. Berlin. Laos. Vietnam. Middle East. Missile crisis. Vietnam. Always using diplomacy.

Our Special Forces in SE Asia certainly directed men to kill. JFK's CIA backed the installation of the Baath Party in Iraq which we're still paying for today.

There wasn't much wasn't much we could do in Berlin.

2. Initiated a broad national information campaign creating a public mandate for the first atmospheric test ban treaty with the Soviet Union.

That was common sense. Any President at that time would have done the same thing. We continued testing nukes underground as did the Russians.

3. Consistently diverting US bilateral aid to post colonial nation’s civil institutions, not to their military.

Uh huh...

4. Consistently turning down the ’advise/demands’ from the chicken hawks in US National Security State.

Not really.

5. Working on secret rapproachment with Castro at the very instant he got assassinated.

No, he was actively trying to kill Castro right up to October, 1963.

6. Working to end the Cold War wanting to create joint ventures with the Soviets in space and other areas where cooperation were suitable.

No.

All this and more was in sharp conflict with US National Security State and it all changed 180˚ the very second they assassinated him in Dallas, putting crazy LBJ in charge...[blah,blah,blah]

Here's the thing you need to accept. JFK was not perfect, RFK was not perfect. They were indeed trying to kill Castro.

Look into the Cuban Coordinating Committee sometime, here were some of their considered plans:

Operation Dirty Trick - Should one of the Mercury space shots fail, it would be blamed on Cuban sabotage, thus justifying an invasion.

Operation Bingo - a simulated attack on Guantanamo Bay used to justify an invasion of Cuba.

These were all forwarded to RFK, who oversaw the CCC. RFK approved Cuban Exile training camps in Central America, and Mongoose camps in Louisiana. Mongoose was one of the reasons Khrushchev put missiles in Cuba. After October, 1962, the plan evolved into OPLAN 380-63 , code named AM/TRUNK (which had sub-operations named MH/APRON, Opeation PICADOR & TOREADOR, inside Cuba the op was known as Opertion Judas).

RFK was planning a large-scale invasion of Cuba, it is safe to assume that JFK, though insulated, knew about the plans.
 
I wonder what Sirhan Sirhan said to RFK Jr. Obviously, it's in his best interest to tell a convincing story about a second gunman who did the actual killing. But unless RFK Jr. is actually in a position to make his life better on the strength of his story, there's probably not much point in trying to tell him any kind of story at all.

"Was there a second gunman?"

"Sure, buddy. There was a second gunman."

"What did you know about the second gunman, and when did you know it?"

"Look, you believe what you want to believe. For a pack of smokes, I'll even play along."

"Tell me the truth!"

"What can you do for me?"

"Do you want to go back to your cell?"

"I can carry on for another couple hours, but I'm gonna run out of material at some point."
 
I wonder what Sirhan Sirhan said to RFK Jr. Obviously, it's in his best interest to tell a convincing story about a second gunman who did the actual killing. But unless RFK Jr. is actually in a position to make his life better on the strength of his story, there's probably not much point in trying to tell him any kind of story at all.

"Was there a second gunman?"

"Sure, buddy. There was a second gunman."

"What did you know about the second gunman, and when did you know it?"

"Look, you believe what you want to believe. For a pack of smokes, I'll even play along."

"Tell me the truth!"

"What can you do for me?"

"Do you want to go back to your cell?"

"I can carry on for another couple hours, but I'm gonna run out of material at some point."
I do not think that Sirhan was pushing the second gunman narrative on RFKjr, and certainly not in the way you are suggesting. I think that Sirhan was telling RFKjr what he has been saying since day one. That he doesn’t remembering anything from the actual shooting event and therefore do not know if and how he acted during the event.

I guess that RFKjr have had a good look at the case, the technical ’evidence’, the autopsy and the testimonies and from this come to his own conclusions.

If the JFK assassination is covered in crap and sloppy cover ups, the RFK assassination is even more so.

It is almost comical in its obvious sloppy cover up masquerading as an investigation.
 
I guess that RFKjr have had a good look at the case, the technical ’evidence’, the autopsy and the testimonies and from this come to his own conclusions.

Watch out folks, here it comes; the autopsies were falsified, the x-rays and photographs were faked, the pathologists were in on the conspiracy...... yada, yada, yada.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom