Religion's value questioned

Wow, so it was saying it didn't matter if women stole, bore false witness, blasphemed God, worshiped idols, broke the Sabbath law, and disobeyed the rest of the commandments? :D The commandments were only given to males?
No, it was telling the women not to covet their neighbour's women, so in principle it was anti-lesbian! Come on, do you actually believe your own argument?
It didn't have to address the women because the men were to see to it that they did not steal etc.

But perhaps you're taking that a bit too literally. After all, women and men could, and did, sell themselves as slaves in the old days sometimes, for example if their crops failed and they'd starve unless they were taken in by a rich household. Not a good situation, obviously. But there was provision for them in the Law of Moses that there certainly wouldn't have been for mere property. They weren't given the full rights of others, certainly. But some laws were concerned with their well-being.

Yes. People were not only property, but a particular kind of property. So are pets today!

For instance, it says:

Leviticus chapter 25 (TEV)

39 If any Israelites living near you become so poor that they sell themselves to you as a slave, you shall not make them do the work of a slave. 40 They shall stay with you as hired workers and serve you until the next Year of Restoration. 41 At that time they and their children shall leave you and return to their family and to the property of their ancestors. 42 The people of Israel are the Lord's slaves, and he brought them out of Egypt; they must not be sold into slavery. 43 Do not treat them harshly, but obey your God.

Yes, the Lord's slaves. A wonderful concept. Was Jesus the one who promoted them to sheep? I don't remember. The rest of your quotations simply confirm that Biblical society was based on slavery.

Thank you for quoting that truly revolting Judges passage. But there was no need, since I knew it already. I'm not sure what it has to do with anything we've been talking about. But it has a good moral lesson, and I expect that was why it was put in the book. It's an anti-prejudice story. Notice the servant wanted to lodge in a foreign city, but the man insisted they didn't do that but moved on to an Israelite city. But it turned out that it was Israelites that cruelly abused the man's mistress so she died.

Yes, it was cruel of the man in the story to have pushed her out of the house. Women may well have been treated as second class citizens all over the ancient world. But we don't know all the circumstances. Who's to say a similar thing wouldn't happen today, if someone was a guest in the house of a man, and him and his house were in danger of being attacked. There might be a lot of men who'd push their wives out to the mob if they thought it would make the mob go away, or women who'd do that to their husbands. It was, after all, a crisis situation. People in danger often put themselves first.

Few, though, would call for war to be declared on the town the mob came from, I suspect, as the man did in the next chapter.
... after having dismembered the woman. Yes, that's not a way to treat other people's property, so sure he got upset.
I don't hope that a lot of men would consider behaving the way this god-fearing **** does, but at least they'll be able to take comfort in the fact that they can rely on the Bible to back them up - if only they remember to dismember her after she's been 'known'.
Your praise of the Bible becomes more and more absurd.

But that's not what I'm saying. You should know that from having followed my arguments. I'm saying that there are some good guidelines in the Bible that could help societies be better places if only more people obeyed them, and that incidentally, it's possible that people might obey them because (they are delusional and actually believe that) the guidelines have the authority of God behind them when they wouldn't otherwise, and from a pragmatic point of view, if that means less people are harmed and the well-being of some is improved, what's wrong with that? God can't be directly compared to Santa Claus, because Santa is obvious fiction, whereas the existence of God is open to debate. So it's not as if I'm advocating feeding people falsehood to make them behave. See post 76 again for my views.
(My italics and bolds, and the parenthesis is mine too, of course. dann)

Yes, I already know that you love the Bible. but it's a disgusting book full of "revolting" passages, so why the hell would anybody want to use that as some kind of guideline? Yes, of course: It has "the authority of God behind" it.
And that is more important than everything else, isn't it?
And, no, the alleged existence of God isn't more open to debate than the existence of Santa or Mickey Mouse. They are all imaginary, which, of course, doesn't prevent anybody from debating their existence.

Yes, you might say it hasn't happened so that proves the Bible isn't a worthwhile book. But while it hasn't happened wholesale, there are recorded instances of communities who turned to Christianity and then stopped warlike activity, and transformed in other ways. And there are, as I've indicated, many instances of individuals who've been inspired to change for the better. See all the testimonies I linked to earlier, for example.

No, there are many more reasons why the Bible isn't "worthwhile".
Would it be a good idea to list the instances of communities that turned to Christianity and then started ''warlike activity, and transformed in other ways"? And the many instances of individuals who've been inspired by the Bible to change for the worse?
Don't worry, I won't do so since I suspect that you already know but just don't care. By the way, old man Randi already debunked a lot of the latter ...
 
Last edited:
But if you believe God's spirit is healing you from emotional problems and helping you live a better life, for example, really, what's wrong with that?

This appears to be the trick that you resort to all the time:
IF religion results in something good, what could then possibly be wrong with that?

And the argument is very captivating since this construction cannot really be contradicted: What could possibly be wrong with something that's believed to be good? If it makes you happy to believe in a non-existent god, getting rid of this sop would surely make people unhappy, right?

Well, what is wrong with religion is that it is a delusion invented by people who seek relief from their pain and suffering in this world by believing in an alternative reality beyond reality. Now they may argue that since it comforts them and feels so good, it also is good. So may drug addicts.
And who am I do argue? God, necessarily, works in very mysterious ways.
 
And here's a Christian website full of what it claims to be scientific reasons to believe in God. On this page, the view is put forward that there are scientific reasons to question evolution. If you want to dispute what it says convincingly, you'll have to counter the points it actually makes, rather than just resorting to a sentence or two of flippant ridicule. And if you want to make the point that the entire website contradicts science, you'll have to do likewise, or come up with a critique of their overall methodology that renders what they say unscientific despite all appearances to the scientifically untrained person.

Yes, that is probably what the website claims. And, yes, that is the view that the webpage puts forward. And, yes, if I want that, that is what I'll have to do. I do notice, however, that this is not what the guy does. Instead he asks rather ill-informed questions. (You do know that the guy appears to me a mechanical engineer, not a biologist, don't you?)

But let's take a look at some of his questions:
1 Which species did the blue whale evolve from? How do you know? Can you work back three generations from any present-day whale species?

You only know which species the blue whale evolved from if its ancestors have been found somewhere in the fossil record. If they haven't been found (maybe, possibly: yet!), you're screwed. You can make informed conjectures, but only that. By comparing with the geneome of existing species you will also be able to find out which species share (more or less recent) ancestors, and it may give you an idea of a common ancestor whose fossil hasn't been found yet. The hippopotamus, for instance, seems to be related to whales.
I don't know what the guy means when he talks about working "back three generations from any present-day whale species". Three generations would be the great-grandfathers (or great-grandmothers) of present whales. Since they tend to live long lives, you might be able to find a living specimen, I don't know. But that's probably not what he means to say.

2 Have these three species progressed in near infinitely fine gradations, as Darwin postulated, or do they demonstrate "saltational" (single-step) jumps?

Again: It depends on the fossil record at your disposal to what extent this question can be answered. The science of evolution is very different from that of metallurgy.

3 If the individual species designs did "jump," what was the mechanism, exactly of the jump?

The question of the exact mechanism of an imaginary jump probably cannot be answered. And what exactly does he mean with "exactly"?

4 Why did the saltational jump occur when it occurred? Did all species modify at that time due to the same "pressure" or not?

He is probably talking about changes in the environment. And changes in the environment would not affect all species in the same manner: More rain, for instance, might benefit frogs, which would therefore prosper in the shapes they already had, whereas species adapted to drier conditions might have been disfavoured and therefore either evolved (or gone extinct).
In the case of the ancestors of whales they would, at one stage, have been amfibian. The environment may have favoured a return to the water because other maritime predators went extinct leaving a niche open for the whale ancestor to exploit, a change, which would have affected other species on land very little.
So nobody is claiming that the same "pressure" would influence all species at the same time in the same manner. Why should it?

From these first few questions it becomes fairly obvious to me that the guy doesn't really know what he is talking about. I don't think that any evolutionary biologist would take him seriously. (And I'm nowhere near being in the field.)
I get the impression that he might even be writing things in spite of his knowledge to the contrary. His writings may give people like you the impression that this is a really scientific attack on evolution, but it doesn't seem to be.
I have seen creationist biologist do a similar thing when addressing laymen: pretending that they did not know about the evolution(s) of the eye(s) in order to make it seem to laymen as if only an intelligent designer could have created this organ.
(The Bible sure does inspire people to lie and cheat in the name of the Lord, doesn't it?!)

But I will leave it to professionals to deliver a proper repudiation of his questions. I'm out of my field.

PS
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4808907#post4808907
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Ross_(creationist)
 
Last edited:
This appears to be the trick that you resort to all the time:
IF religion results in something good, what could then possibly be wrong with that?

And the argument is very captivating since this construction cannot really be contradicted: What could possibly be wrong with something that's believed to be good? If it makes you happy to believe in a non-existent god, getting rid of this sop would surely make people unhappy, right?

Well, what is wrong with religion is that it is a delusion invented by people who seek relief from their pain and suffering in this world by believing in an alternative reality beyond reality. Now they may argue that since it comforts them and feels so good, it also is good. So may drug addicts.
And who am I do argue? God, necessarily, works in very mysterious ways.

But again, I'm not talking about "tricking" anyone. I'm not suggesting for a moment that anyone who doesn't believe in God or Jesus should convince people they do exist in the hope it leads them to live better lives. What I think is that people should be given information and left to make up their own minds. And if they're inspired to live a better life by what they decide on, I don't see that there's necessarily anything wrong with that.

And really, if anyone's convinced they've experienced God, who are we to say for a certainty that they haven't? Which one of us could be certain they were under a delusion? It might be worth their while to examine whether it was just some emotional process that caused what they originally thought was God. But if they're convinced it was God after that, how can anyone be sure they're wrong?

Here are some examples. I'll quote from one of the testimonies I linked to a few posts ago. Would it really serve any purpose to convince these people the experiences they had that changed them for the better were just emotional processes and God doesn't exist? And how can we be sure it wasn't God?

From Testimony of Carl Dutton - A Captive Set Free

At the age of 16,I was arrested for public drunkenness.* I began drinking to be sociable with the men I worked with and to feel good, never dreaming I would become a drunk. Not long after the drinking began, I started smoking pot and taking pills to feel even better. In a very short time I was a drug addict.
Since my wages were only $1.00 an hour, I started dealing drugs and buying and selling stolen property to feed the habit. Every addict in town knew how to find me, to buy drugs and sell stolen property.

Although I was married, I was continually in and out of jail and went to prison twice. Soon I had lost everything, my home, wife, children, humanity, and dignity. ...

On a shelf, in the day room of that tank, was a beat up old bible that the Gideons had left there at some time. Something within me said, "You need to read that bible" I thought, "Read the bible? Only wimps and sissies read that, and I'm tough." After all, there were guys in there that I'd been in prison with, fought with and done drugs with. If I read that bible they would see me! Still, something kept saying, "Read that bible, read that bible." But, after several
days of pacing the floor in that place, I was so tormented that I went into that day room and picked up that old bible and began to read.

Oh, how the Lord convicted my heart and soul as I read. I thought, "Oh my, this book, this book it's true, it's true!" As I continued to read, God became so real to me. I knew my life was nothing, so right then I said, "Lord, my life is nothing, forgive me Lord, forgive me for the life I'm living and give
me another chance. I believe, with your help, I can do a whole lot better next time! Just give me one more chance, Lord."

I want you to know, He brought up before me all my past faults and failures, and the many times He had tried to save me, but I had rejected Him. But then He forgave me, He came into my heart and saved me, washed and cleansed me I tell you, I had never felt so good...so pure...so clean. I didn't even feel like the same man who had been put in jail for the crimes he had committed. I was a brand new person, and even though I had lost everything, I felt like the richest man in the world because the Lord Jesus Christ had saved me. Just like the old hymn says, "Just as I am, without one plea but that thy blood was shed for me".

I still had to go to prison for the third time, but this time it was different, instead of "doing time", I was using time to grow in the knowledge and grace of Jesus Christ. I read the bible every day and listened to tape. I was really serious about serving the Lord and living for Him. Then one day, while I was reading, I heard some guys getting high on dope that had been smuggled in. The thought came to my mind, "Go in there and get high." But while that thought was on my mind, I heard a voice within me saying, "No, don't do it, read the book." The struggle went on over and over as I read. Then, the next thing I knew it was 5:00 A.M.* And my first thought was, "Jesus, you kept me from getting high, oh thank you Lord Jesus, praise you Lord!" Since that time I have not been tempted with drugs and all the thanks goes to Jesus, who set me free! ...

There's a book called Chasing the Dragon by Jackie Pullinger, a woman who went to Hong Kong in her early twenties. She's actually famous and was given an MBE by Queen Elizabeth for her services. The book description on Amazon says,

The true story of how one woman's faith resulted in the conversion of hundreds of drug addicts, prostitues and hardened criminals in Hong Kong's infamous Walled City.

More than that, the book talks about how gangsters gave up violence and drug addiction when they became Christians. It even claims that through God's power, they experienced painless withdrawal from heroin. The book says,

Those who explained this extraordinary spiritual happening as an example of 'mind over matter' had to be ignorant of the facts. A drug addict facing withdrawal has a mind already half dead through continual drug abuse and is deeply fearful of pain. Most of our boys only begin to understand Jesus with their minds after they had already experienced Him in their lives and bodies.

What was really going on there? If their peaceful/painless drug withdrawal had nothing to do with God, what could have caused such a dramatically different experience for them than the agony some of them had gone through before when they'd tried to withdraw from drugs? Who is any one of us to say that whatever happened must have been a purely natural phenomenon?

I think it's good to have a critical outlook on such things, because it cuts down the risk of being conned by people making up stories, and it would certainly be interesting if someone were to come up with a scientific explanation of what was happening that made sense of it. But I don't think we should be closed to the possibility that they were correct in thinking it must be God working in their lives, because really, how can anyone be sure that couldn't happen?

I also think it might do such people good to be questioned and to have their experiences critically examined by people who suggest alternative possibilities. If they're convinced it was God working in their lives, they'll probably still be convinced at the end of it. If they do decide that something else was probably going on, it might give them valuable insights into what works for them. They might even be pleased they've realised it was something else rather than God, because it might be something they can replicate, something under their control, rather than something they have to rely on an uncertain God for. Or they might develop a more critical outlook that helps them in life in general. So I certainly don't think people should be shielded from having their views critically examined. I'm just saying their views shouldn't be dismissed out of hand. I don't think anyone's really qualified to do that.
 
But again, I'm not talking about "tricking" anyone. I'm not suggesting for a moment that anyone who doesn't believe in God or Jesus should convince people they do exist in the hope it leads them to live better lives. What I think is that people should be given information and left to make up their own minds. And if they're inspired to live a better life by what they decide on, I don't see that there's necessarily anything wrong with that.

Your argument is the trick, Baby Nemesis: 'If something good comes out of believing in a delusion, believing in the delusion must be good.'
And the next step is then to refer to alleged testimonies that indeed it is so.

It is a little like defending serial killers in the following manner: 'But if all the people they killed would have grown up to become new Hitlers, you could say that they were doing good. And since Hitler hasn't been reborn yet, they appear to have been successful so far.'
I can agree with you that people should be given information. Nobody can make up your mind for you anyway, but people can be and often are pressured into finding it opportune to act against their best judgement.

Your "And if (!) they're inspired to live a better life ... " is a repetition of your favourite trick.

And really, if (!) anyone's convinced they've experienced God, who are we to say for a certainty that they haven't? Which one of us could be certain they were under a delusion? It might be worth their while to examine whether it was just some emotional process that caused what they originally thought was God. But if (!) they're convinced it was God after that, how can anyone be sure they're wrong?

'And if anyone's convinced they've experienced Santa/the baby-carrying stork/the Easter Bunny, how can anyone be sure ...'
Anyone can be sure because God exists only as a delusion.

Your Christian fairy tales are too boring to contemplate, sorry!
You can see what other people think of your favourite Creationist in a thread I made exclusively for this purpose: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4808907#post4808907
I no longer buy your alleged interest in critical thinking and information.
 
Last edited:
I never understood the conclusion that religion, atheists, or science was bad. You have religious people purporting that atheists or science is bad or evil. You have atheists and the scientifically inclined saying religion is bad or evil.

Neither is bad. They are concepts. People are bad. People do evil things in the name of religion, in the name of stopping religion, in the name of science. A religious person can treat others far more humanely than an atheist or a scientist, and vice versa. I think we need to stop looking at various labels as evil.

I consistently see atheists point out what may very well be ridiculous religious beliefs and yet act like total ******** in regards to other people.

I consistently see religious people show hatred to a specific group such as gays, and yet sacrifice something of theirs in order to give to someone in need.

This constant hatred and condemnation on both sides serves no purpose and only exacerbates and entrenches the worst characteristics of each group.

Well said. Don't think your post went unnoticed.

Public service announcement:

I'll respond later to what Dann's written, in great and shudder-making detail, and with many scolding rebukes and much dauntingly lengthy commentary. ... And you think I'm kidding? :D

Though it will be lengthy, don't think you can enjoy a four course meal while you're reading it. The very third paragraph will drain away your appetite like a swamp-infesting blood-sucking creature might drain away your ... courage to set foot in the area. Just know that you have been warned.
 
I never understood the conclusion that religion, atheists, or science was bad. You have religious people purporting that atheists or science is bad or evil. You have atheists and the scientifically inclined saying religion is bad or evil.

Neither is bad. They are concepts. People are bad. People do evil things in the name of religion, in the name of stopping religion, in the name of science. A religious person can treat others far more humanely than an atheist or a scientist, and vice versa. I think we need to stop looking at various labels as evil.

I consistently see atheists point out what may very well be ridiculous religious beliefs and yet act like total ******** in regards to other people.

I consistently see religious people show hatred to a specific group such as gays, and yet sacrifice something of theirs in order to give to someone in need.

This constant hatred and condemnation on both sides serves no purpose and only exacerbates and entrenches the worst characteristics of each group.

Well, your post went unnoticed by me until now.

1. I'd recommend that we stick to the questions of what religion is and what science is. It is fairly easy to determine. Whether or not believers and scientists are "bad" is an entirely different question - and a very moral one.

2. I'd recommend that you treat people in the same manner: Find out why they do what they do and what they want to achieve with their behaviour and statements. And find out if what they have to say about the world is true or not. Then you don't need to decide whether or not they are also "evil".
I notice that, on the one hand, you say that
"People do evil things in the name of religion, in the name of stopping religion, in the name of science."
And on the other hand you say that
"I think we need to stop looking at various labels as evil."
You should probably follow your own advice.

3. You say that
"I consistently see atheists point out what may very well be ridiculous religious beliefs and yet act like total ******** in regards to other people."
What is the connection?

And you say that
"I consistently see religious people show hatred to a specific group such as gays, and yet sacrifice something of theirs in order to give to someone in need."
What is the connection between the two things? (And do they only give to monogamous heterosexuals in need?)

4. "This constant hatred (?!) and condemnation (?!) on both sides serves no purpose and only exacerbates and entrenches the worst characteristics of each group (!)."

Who is hating and condemning whom? And have you ever considered that dividing them into sides and labelling them the way you do might actually prevent you from seeing what characterizes religion and atheism?
If you look at the way Baby Nemesis has argued so far, you'll notice that she is apt to leave the question of religion: What characterizes religion? What is the attitude of the religious individual to the world?
Instead she prefers to spam the discussion with references to religious indiviuals who allegedly became very, very good because they found Jesus! And she does this in spite of her knowledge of the brutality committed by many religious people against their 'fellow man'. (Which, and I hope that you've noticed this as well, I have never claimed is what characterizes Christians and other believers as believers.)
 
Last edited:
Dann, I think you need to modify your style and listen better. You've interpreted The_Animus's post in all kinds of bizarre ways, much as you have failed to grasp many of the points I've made and interpreted others wrongly. It seems you see contradictions where there are none, have an ideologue-like persistence in repeating the same party line despite a wealth of counter-arguments, want to argue petty trivialities when there's no need because the person isn't even standing up in opposition to you, consistently fail to see the main issues in what a person's saying, put a spin on what your opponent says so you interpret it in the worst possible way you can, have a pedantic and rigid understanding of anything they say, and basically don't seem to be listening very well. I'll respond to all the points you've made to me. But after that, there perhaps isn't any point in continuing this argument. Neither of us is going to say anything that'll make the other one modify their arguments. That's certain. I think we'll just have to agree to disagree.
 
If you'd only address these:

1) It is not really a very good argument for religion to persist that if (!) it makes you happy and/or good to be delusional, the delusion is good. Nor does repeating it constitute a "wealth of counter-arguments".
2) Claiming that you are convinced that there is a god does not prove that there is one. It doesn't even make it probable that religion is not a delusion.
3) A reference to stupid questions about evolution from ill-informed creationists is not a good argument for anything other than opposition to creationism.
4) Testimonies from Christians that their belief in Christ has helped them and their families and communities considerably don't really constitute proof that Christianity is a blessing to mankind. However, if you could come up with a valid double-blind test to prove that religion is more than opium of the people, for instance one group receiving true religion and the control group just a placebo, I'd be very eager to hear about it. (Just kidding.)
5) Quotations about people selling themselves or purchasing their freedom don't exactly demonstrate the lack of slavery.

But it's probably easier to agree to disagree! I cannot bear having to read any more testimonies or Bible quotations, please!
 
I apologise in advance for this post to anyone with a nervous disposition. At least Atheists will be able to still sleep soundly in their beds after reading it. As for the rest of you, read it at your peril! :)

It is sad to see what has become of this man.

"What man?" you ask.

I will explain in a minute. I was hoping to use his story as an unadulterated example of how certain religious beliefs can sometimes inspire good outcomes, a further illustration of what I've been trying to use the testimonies I linked to to illustrate - the fact that possibly hundreds of thousands of people throughout the centuries have given up lifestyles where they were harming others when they were inspired by the gospel message, and thus it's a worthwhile thing to have around. But alas, no more! It cannot be done!

Is the evidence of religion's overwhelmingly corrupt influence about to come crashing into this thread like a rampaging bull charging into a china shop? Is religion's reputation about to be so thoroughly slung into the mud that it would take an archaeologist to dig it out? We will see! A shocking thing has happened! As I drag religion yelling in protest into the spotlight, let's examine it.

The man in question is the famous David Wilkerson. He's famous for leading many gangsters in New York to give up lives of violence when they became Christians in the late 1950s. His famous book about that, The Cross and the Switchblade is still a top seller. He felt as if God wanted him to go and work among the gangs, and he successfully inspired many of them to give up violence and come off drugs. He started a ministry that's grown a lot and is now helping many many drug addicts rehabilitate in several countries. They claim a high success rate.

A description of the book says:

What must be one of the most inspiring and challenging true stories of all time, this classic book tells of the author's crusade to bring the message of Christ to the brutal and often terrifying ghettos of New York.

The events depicted in this classic from the drug infested, gang dominated streets of New York happened over 30 years ago.

The tortured face of a young killer, one of seven boys on trial for a brutal murder, started country preacher David Wilkerson on his lonely crusade to the most dangerous streets in the world. Violent gangs ruled by warlords, drug pushers and pimps held the streets of New York's ghettoes in an iron grip. It was into this world that David Wilkerson stepped, armed only with the simple message of God's love and the promise of the Holy Spirit's power. Then the miracles began to happen, The Cross and the Switchblade is one of the most inspiring and challenging true stories of all time.

Could there be just a touch of hype in that?

A gang leader David Wilkerson inspired to change ended up writing a book about his experiences. He's also famous now. An excerpt or two from a web page that quotes an excerpt from an abridged version of his book, headed Nicky Cruz - The life of a former gang boss in New York says:

... As I walked along the streets of New York the people were scared of me because I had a bad reputation. I was a gang leader of 205 BOYs and 175 girls. They did everything I told them to. I controlled them! We did lots of things from murder to bad little delinquents. We did not have any respect for life nor for anything else. ...

David Wilkerson was consciously aware of what would face him but he came in anyway.

He asked: "Where is Nicky Cruz? " I pushed the girl to one side and stormed up to him: "I am Nicky, what do you want? " David said: "I want to be your friend." I retaliated: "I certainly don't want to be your friend!" He came over to me. Then I hit him. Blood came out of his nose; I attacked him and spat on him like a wild animal! Then I called him every bad name under the sun.

I even bad-mouthed God. Then I grabbed him by the hair and hit his head against the wall until some of my friends pulled me away. They tried to tell me that: "The preacher means no harm!" I went to the door. Then David Wilkerson called after me: "Nicky, before you go out of the door, I just want to tell you that Jesus loves you!"

The living Holy Ghost has etched these words into my life! As David said to me: "Nicky, Jesus loves you", I felt the words go through me like a knife being stabbed into me. I went out. However every night was like hearing a broken record which kept playing in my heart saying: "Jesus loves you, Jesus loves you!"

Everywhere I went I thought about the preacher. I could not sleep anymore. I had tried to threaten him, even pointed a knife at him, but he didn't bat an eyelid. He said to me: "You can kill me and cut me into a thousand pieces, but these thousand will call out to you: "Jesus loves you!" ...

He says he had a profound spiritual experience at a meeting held by David Wilkerson, and himself and other gang members made a decision to live for God instead of the gangs. Yes, many gang members that night made decisions to give up lives of violence. And others gave up lives of violence on other occasions.

I have experienced it! Now I could close my eyes and say my last prayer - and I could sleep again. God even cared for me in my sleep; there was no more drug addiction, prostitution and no more criminality for me! I did not have to run away anymore or move from one place the next because people could not stand me. No, I had peace and joy all of a sudden! I could go everywhere I wanted and laugh from the heart.

Please understand my point here:

Tell me: Would you have preferred it if instead of believing they'd been touched by God and resolving to give up their violent lifestyles, those gang members had been told by someone like you: "Religion is all a delusion! You don't want to get involved in that!" Just when David Wilkerson's message could have touched them, someone comes and tells them they'd be downright stupid to accept any religious belief, so they don't give up lives of violence after all and carry on killing and terrorising the streets? Tell me: Is it so important that people believe religion is a delusion that you'd prefer that to happen rather than them accepting a religious belief?

Likewise:

David Wilkerson started a ministry that's helped thousands. He started an organisation in 1958 to help drug addicts reform. From an article called Teen Challenge Offers Hope to Drug Addicts, Alcoholics, Prostitutes:

When many are bound by alcohol or drug addiction, it may seem to their loved ones that there is no hope. Those who have operated Teen Challenge, a Christian ministry for almost 50 years know better, as they have seen countless men and women overcome their addiction to drug or alcohol addiction and become productive members of society. So successful has the ministry been that it has been endorsed by a president of the United States, governors, mayors, judges, law enforcement personnel, and other prominent members of society.

Today, Teen Challenge helps gang members, drug addicts, alcoholics, prostitutes, and others with addictions through a 15-month program. The ministry was organized in 1958 by David Wilkerson, a pastor of a country church, who went to preach the gospel of Jesus Christ among gang members in New York City. Perhaps the most famous convert was Nicky Cruz, who though once the leader of the toughest street gang in New York City became a Christian and still preaches the gospel himself throughout the world as an evangelist. ...

Teen Challenge makes no apologies for offering a Christian faith-based program to help alcoholics, drug addicts, gang members, prostitutes and others to overcome their addictions. It claims that by using Biblical principles, those involved with Teen Challenge become emotionally sound, emotionally balanced, socially adjusted, physically well, and spiritually alive.

Again, would you wish to disrupt the rehabilitation of these people by telling them that any recovery regime based on Christian principles is based on a delusion and thus they should have nothing to do with it? Would you prefer it if they remained addicts and gang members? Far rather that than they fall into the delusion of Christianity?

If not, then what's the big deal about me saying Christianity shouldn't be dismissed as all bad because many people have been changed for the better by it? Why do you so vigorously object to me suggesting that any line other than, "Religion is a delusion and people should be told that, no matter what" is acceptable? Why do you consider trying to illustrate the point by giving examples of the phenomenon of changed lives spamming? Why would you consider it trickery to promote the idea that such spiritual experiences might in fact be genuine, when you can't be sure, and I can't be sure, what was really going on? Why is it so important to you to promote the idea that religion is a delusion that you can't bring yourself to accept the possibility that good can sometimes come out of it, or that it's possible that such experiences might in fact be what the people experiencing them think they are?

Of course, I'm not suggesting for one single moment that religion is the answer to the world's problems, or that it should be introduced to people who could do with being inspired by it as a matter of routine, or that it's the only thing that could ever work. Of course none of those things are the case. I'm simply illustrating the fact that it's unreasonable to dismiss it out of hand, because some people have been transformed by aspects of it and their communities have benefited.

But Pastor David Wilkerson seems to be a good religious icon turned bad! An inspirational religious figure gone rogue! The man who once told a gang leader who'd just broken his nose and bashed his head against the wall several times that Jesus loved him is now prophesying imminent death and destruction to the people of New York he once preached God's mercy to! What has religion done to this man?

David Wilkerson now has a blog. Here's the page for March. On 7 March, he wrote:

I am compelled by the Holy Spirit to send out an urgent message to all on our mailing list, and to friends and to bishops we have met all over the world.

AN EARTH-SHATTERING CALAMITY IS ABOUT TO HAPPEN. IT IS GOING TO BE SO FRIGHTENING, WE ARE ALL GOING TO TREMBLE - EVEN THE GODLIEST AMONG US.

For ten years I have been warning about a thousand fires coming to New York City. It will engulf the whole megaplex, including areas of New Jersey and Connecticut. Major cities all across America will experience riots and blazing fires—such as we saw in Watts, Los Angeles, years ago.

There will be riots and fires in cities worldwide. There will be looting—including Times Square, New York City. What we are experiencing now is not a recession, not even a depression. We are under God’s wrath. ...

Note: I do not know when these things will come to pass, but I know it is not far off. I have unburdened my soul to you. Do with the message as you choose.

Here's an old prophecy David Wilkerson made:

David Wilkerson’s prophetic message, first given in September 7, 1992, has been repeated since the September 11 tragedy

This warning is not meant to scare you.* It’s meant only for you to take to the Lord and pray.* This is what I believe God has shown me:

* Thirty days of chastisement will fall on New York City such as the world has never seen.* God is going to let down the walls.

* There will be unimaginable violence and looting.* The violence will be so ferocious, it will shock the whole world.* Our streets will be lined, not just with the National Guard, but with militia.

* A thousand fires will burn at the same time throughout the city.* The Los Angeles fires were confined to a few sections of that city, but New York will be ablaze in all its boroughs.* Fire trucks will not be able to handle it all.

* Trains and busses will be shut down.* Billions of dollars will be lost.* Broadway shows will stop completely.* Businesses will flee the city in an unstoppable hemorrhage.* Such things are expected in Third World countries, but not in a civilized nation like the United States.*

* Yet, in not too long a time afterwards, New York City will go completely bankrupt.* The Queen City will be cast into the dirt, becoming a city of poverty.

* You may ask, “When will all this happen?”* All I can say is, I believe I will be there when it happens.* Yet, when it does, God’s people are not to panic or fear. ...

I wonder how many people have in fact been assailed by great anxiety because of those prophecies.

And the reason he believes God is going to cause fiery judgment to break out in America? Interestingly, it's partly something to do with the same thing he previously believed God wanted to change by merciful means.

In 1998, David Wilkerson prophesied:

For some time I have prophesied that America is about to be stricken with an economic holocaust. ...

What is the reason for this judgment? It will come as God's wrath upon a nation that has shed rivers of innocent blood! In the Old Testament, the prophets warned the nation of Judah that judgment would come because of just such blood-shedding. ...

Manasseh's blood-shedding was only a tiny rivulet compared to the ocean of blood shed by abortionists in America. Add to that the blood of thousands of innocent people killed by drunk drivers, gunfire, murder. Then add the blood of children killed by other children - innocent lives cut down by those who have no sense of right or wrong.

The Bible makes it clear: God will not pardon the shedding of innocent blood. He will send judgment! ...

David Wilkerson has been called out by some as a false prophet though.

There's a web page with a list of what it claims to be prophecies of David Wilkerson that were proven false.

1. NO MORE GOSPEL ON TV BY 1999?

He preached this in the Solomon Church in December of 1994:

"Right now I sense in my spirit that in less than 5 years there will be no more so-called gospel television networks. They will all fall into bankruptcy and absolute ruin."

2. 1000 FIRES IN NEW YORK CITY DUE TO RACE RIOTS IN 1993?

From a prophecy of September 7, 1992:

"I have had recurring visions of over 1,000 fires burning at one time here in New York city. I am convinced race riots will soon explode! New York City is right now a powder keg-ready to blow!...federal and State Welfare cutbacks will be the spark that ignites the fuse. Next year, New York City could have over 100,000 angry men on the streets, enraged because they have been cut off from benefits....Federal troops will have to move in to restore order. New
York City will have tanks running down its avenues....Churches will be closed for a season because it will be too dangerous to travel about. Fires will rage everywhere."

Although Wilkerson set the expiration date of this prophecy himself - " Next year" (i.e. 1993), he now says that this is yet future. This is a common expedient for those who assume themselves to be prophets, moving the goal-posts, hoping that others will forget by then.

On the other hand, he did only say it "could" be the following year.

So, what are we to make of this? Is this damning proof that religion is a bad thing that turns people delusional and it needs to be scrapped?

Or could something else be going on here?

Bare in mind this is all on-topic. The thread title suggests the question of whether religion has value, or whether it is a worthless thing that should be trampled in the dust.

It's in fact simplistic to see things in terms of two extremes, to think that either religion is a good thing or it's a worthless thing. It's certainly true that religion has often been used for evil purposes that've made thousands suffer. It is also true that religion can inspire a lot of good. SO:

Doesn't it make more sense not to condemn religion out of hand as an accursed delusion or to praise it unquestioningly, but instead to try to analyse the elements of it that tempt people to do evil and work to have them eliminated, but to be tolerant of it where it can be seen to be doing good and accept that it's a good idea to have certain elements of it preserved, and to work out what those are?

For instance, it may be seen that it wasn't religion in itself that caused people such as Mary Tudor who burned Protestants at the stake to do evil, but the principle that power corrupts, a bigoted mind-set that by no means always accompanies religion, a thirst for revenge on the people affiliated with those who mistreated her and her mother and tried to put Catholicism down, an almost pathological lack of empathy, and so on. If we can tease out the causes of people's behaviour, we can seek to change those without having to dump the entirety of religion. We might also discover that a lot of what motivated them isn't intrinsic to religion at all. Then we can perhaps seek to modify religion so it can't so easily be used by people as a vehicle for their evil intentions, for instance by seeking to change the structure of it so its authority figures have less power.

On the other hand, if a religion is evil at its core, because it preaches hatred for all non-believers, or it teaches that the poor are poor through Karma, that they deserve what they get and must accept their lot in life, then atheism might bring wondrous enlightenment for those entrapped by that religion, and the quicker it spreads the better.

And so to David Wilkerson: Was it religion that made him convinced he's been seeing visions of the destruction of New York and America? Or could other things be involved? Could he have developed an organic brain disorder like temporal lobe epilepsy, perhaps because his brain was injured by having his head banged too many times against the wall, and now he's having visions induced by the illness? Could the stress of being with all those gangsters have made him descend into paranoia or at least become mentally disturbed? Could something have made him infuriated with the people of New York after initially wanting to help them so he now wants to proclaim judgment against them? Could he have become so sure his hunches are God-given because of the previous tremendous success he had when he went to work with gangsters after being convinced God wanted him to that he now believes God's speaking to him when he's really just fantasising? Could he be aware of the wide influence he's gained in the world through his famous book that was made into a movie The Cross and the Switchblade and now want to use his influence to scare people into changing their ways, after initially preaching Jesus wanted to love them into changing? Could he be trying to catch the public attention in a cynical ploy to sell more books? Who knows. But it would be simplistic to dismiss his behaviour as simple evidence of the delusional nature of religion, or to claim it strengthens the position that religion is a bad thing that altogether needs to go.

Now if you still want to make the case that religion is altogether delusional and the entirety of it should be scooped up and sent hurtling into the past like some fraudulent relic of a bygone era, your case will have to be compelling.
 
Just to clear up a few last things:

On the question of women being treated like property in the Old Testament and in particular the Ten Commandments: Oh look. Here's an interesting perspective on the issues. And here's another - Flaws in the Ten Commandments?

As to your critique of that article questioning evolution as it's currently understood, you might well be right. But it was a mere example of the interest of some Christians in scientific issues, and may not be representative of the actual Reasons to Believe website the article was put on. It wasn't written by the owner of the site. Whether it is or not is totally irrelevant to the argument I was making though, as you must have been aware. Again, you made the mistake of focusing on trivial specifics merely used to illustrate a minor point, and ignored the broad argument I was actually making, which will be obvious to anyone who views the original post. The actual article in question was of extremely little relevance to my argument, and was simply plucked out of the air at random. I assumed my post would convey something of that impression.

Incidentally, your Wikipedia link didn't work, but I found the Wikipedia page about Hugh Ross in Google. It's truly shocking to learn that he's been criticised by so many young earth creationists, isn't it. :D

You make a similar mistake in your strange assertion that I'm not interested in addressing the reasons why people behave the way they do. Your assertion is especially strange since, for example, I know you've looked at my thread which calls for social improvements to change certain behaviour, Desperation fuels belief in the supernatural.

Hey, we're all the way back to that again. What an appropriate place to end this. :)
 
I qould like some feedback on this thought:

Some religions/cults deliberately keep the living conditions down in such a way that it benefits their religion. Like the Taliban preventing girls from going to school.

I meant to reply to this ages ago but never got around to it.

Yes they do. But religions can keep people down for other reasons, not necessarily religious ones, such as when cult leaders seek to make money by having obedient members beg on the streets to bring money into the cult.

But religion can certainly be the excuse for oppression, and certain interpretations of it can lead people to believe it's right and good.

For instance, women are oppressed in countries with a strict interpretation of Islam like Saudi Arabia. From a news article called Religious police in Saudi Arabia arrest mother for sitting with a man

A 37-year-old American businesswoman and married mother of three is seeking justice after she was thrown in jail by Saudi Arabia's religious police for sitting with a male colleague at a Starbucks coffee shop in Riyadh.

Yara, who does not want her last name published for fear of retribution, was bruised and crying when she was freed from a day in prison after she was strip-searched, threatened and forced to sign false confessions by the Kingdom's “Mutaween” police.

Her story offers a rare first-hand glimpse of the discrimination faced by women living in Saudi Arabia. In her first interview with the foreign press, Yara told The Times that she would remain in Saudi Arabia to challenge its harsh enforcement of conservative Islam rather than return to America. ...

— In 2007 the victim of a gang rape was sentenced to 200 lashes and six years in jail for having been in an unrelated man’s car at the time. She was pardoned by King Abdullah, although he maintained the sentence had been fair

From the BBC: My life: Saudi Arabian women speak

In the conservative Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, women often struggle to get their voices heard.

Although women now make up more than half of all graduates from Saudi universities, they comprise only 5% of the kingdom's workforce. They cannot vote, take an open and active part of public life or even drive a car.

The BBC spoke to eight young Saudi women, aged between 17 and 27, who attend a private college in Jeddah. The women have revealed snapshots of their lives and spoke of their aspirations for the future in a country which has long constrained their freedom. ...

As for Hinduism, I once read a book by a former Hindu guru who said he thought the reason there was so much poverty in India had a lot to do with the doctrine of Karma, where people think their misfortunes are to do with something wrong they've done, perhaps in a past life, so they can think they deserve them and so won't seek to change them. And other people can think they deserve them. A point has equally been made that if you think everything around you is a god, for instance the river, you'll seek to appease it by performing sacrifices to it in the hope that it won't flood and destroy your home, rather than getting together with people to control it by building dams, and using it to improve your lot by digging irrigation channels so it will make the ground you're growing your crops on more fertile. So your belief in gods will be holding back your progress in life.

Some Hindus interpret things in a different way though.

There are Christian examples of attempts to hold back progress for religious reasons. For instance, I heard that in the 19th century, when medical advances were being made and pain relief was being introduced into medicine, a few twits in high places expressed the opinion that women shouldn't be given it in childbirth, because that would be undermining God, who'd been recorded as having said in Genesis that he was going to greatly increase women's pain in childbirth. It's perhaps a shame that this rambling yet reasonably informative apologetic wasn't around then that casts doubt on whether it meant physical pain. But it doesn't matter, since thankfully, those voices were vastly outnumbered by sensible people who thought it was a good idea.

Some cults and certain Crhistian sects can engage in abusive practices, that while not reducing people to poverty or anything like that, harm their quality of life and even put their children at risk by their control over them.

Here's the story of someone who was in a church where they wanted to control her life, making her devote huge amounts of time to it; and then they even wanted to control even petty details of her most intimate personal life: Jane Akshar's Story.

Here's a story about a Jehovah's Witness who went through mental suffering because his baby became ill and needed a blood transfusion to survive, and the Jehovah's Witnesses wouldn't allow it, even threatening to disown him if he let the doctors do it, as far as I recall. He was glad when the hospital threatened to take him to court to make him agree, because it meant the decision would be taken out of his hands and he could say it wasn't him that disobeyed the teaching: They Wanted Our Baby to Die; the Inside Story of a Former Third Generation Jehovah's Witness.

Here's the story of a disabled girl who suffered while growing up in the Christian Science movement, which teaches that all illness and pain are in the mind and it's possible to stop them if you just have the mental ability: But is it Christian - testimony of Kathy a Former Christian Scientist

My mother never called a doctor and I can well remember lying in bed screaming and sobbing in pain with frequent earaches. I suffered from asthma and many coughs and colds but had no medical help. I was taken for dental treatment, but, on one occasion, I can remember my being put through the extraction of several teeth without any pain relief, neither gas nor injection. I can remember my mother telling me off for my lack of self-control and because I was not remembering the "Truth" properly. I think I was about eight years old. I felt I was a failure and was so scared because of all the blood pouring from my mouth. Mother was unmoved and I learned that self-control was imperative. My father insisted I had an X-ray when I fell on the grass and it was believed that I had a broken arm. I can remember my parents arguing over me whilst I was still on the grass and I think that caused a major rift in my parent's marriage in that my father had to shout and insist that I went to the hospital. (I did attend artificial limb centres with my mother all through childhood, but, of course, they were offering vital walking aids and mother did not and could not object.)

And here's some information warning about abusive churches and the signs to look for to tell you you're in one:

Eleven Marks of Perverted Authority.
Abusive Churches.
Aberrant Christianity: What is it?

There are cults that deliberately use mind control techniques to get and keep recruits. Here's some information on the kinds of mind control techniques some cults are said to use. It comes from an organisation dedicated to helping people who have family members or friends involved in cults.

The techniques they say can be used include:

Hypnosis
Inducing a state of high suggestibility by hypnosis, often thinly disguised as relaxation or meditation.

Peer Group Pressure
Suppressing doubt and resistance to new ideas by exploiting the need to belong.

Love Bombing
Creating a sense of family and belonging through hugging, kissing, touching and flattery.

Rejection of Old Values
Accelerating acceptance of new life style by constantly denouncing former values and beliefs.

Confusing Doctrine
Encouraging blind acceptance and rejection of logic through complex lectures on an incomprehensible doctrine.

Metacommunication
Implanting subliminal messages by stressing certain key words or phrases in long, confusing lectures.

Removal of Privacy
Achieving loss of ability to evaluate logically by preventing private contemplation.

Time Sense Deprivation
Destroying ability to evaluate information, personal reactions, and body functions in relation to passage of time by removing all clocks and watches.

And there are more.

There's advice online from them and others about how to approach someone you care about who's trapped in a cult or something like it, such as:

What to do if a Friend Or Loved-One Joins a Cult.
 
Last edited:
Many issues about inconsistencies with religions have been discussed above already and everyone has made a great contribution to this debate. What is the solution? Have a government that legislates against religion, closes down religious-based charities, hospitals, etc? But somehow I don’t think that would work. I think if destructive people commit their crimes in the name of their religion they could easily commit these and other crimes under the umbrella of some other cause (be it for a business, political cause, etc). And even if you did stop the organisations you can’t kill an idea. The concept of God is an enduring one which is simply not going to go away. Skeptics like us will never allow it to become irrelevant or go away because we keep talking about it, even though not always in a complimentary way. How much of our lives do we spend trying to convince ourselves and others of the non-reality or irrationality of an idea we can’t stop thinking or talking about in our debates.

Perhaps a more constructive move would be to join a religious organisation and encourage other members to follow their espoused ideals in a more positive kind with an attitude of practical support and love for all people. Actually, many people in the St Vincent De Paul Society or the Salvation Army are already doing this.
 
Nice post.

That's a far more sensible attitude than one that simplistically sees religion as the enemy to be eliminated no matter what.

Yes, there are a lot of charitable efforts organised by religious communities. They don't make the headlines, because as always, what makes the headlines is any abuse and extremes of bad practice. Good news tends to be ignored. But there are organisations based on religious principles who do a lot of good, such as Tearfund. Instead of being scathing about the idea of God because how could a good God allow so much suffering in the world, this organisation spends its time in dedication to alleviate suffering around the world.

Then there's the Catholic version, CAFOD.

The Catholic Agency For Overseas Development (CAFOD), previously known as the Catholic Fund for Overseas Development, is a United Kingdom -based international aid agency working to alleviate poverty and suffering in developing countries . It is funded by the Catholic community in England and Wales, the UK government and the general public by donations.

CAFOD was founded in 1962. CAFOD's aims are to promote long-term development; respond to emergencies; raise public awareness of the causes of poverty; speak out on behalf of poor communities ; and promote social justice, in witness to Christian faith and gospel values. It is also involved in short-term relief.

Muslim countries get a lot of bad press, but there are teachings in Islam that can motivate social concern. Only a couple of days ago, I heard on the BBC World Service about a Muslim woman who's working for social improvement among some people in Egypt, and she said she was motivated by religious principles.

I once read about a Muslim man who said he'd been brought up believing in a harsh tradition of Islam, but one day, he read some Western humanistic literature, and his attitudes softened and changed. I think he became an atheist because of what he read.

But there is such a thing as Islamic humanism, or at least there was several centuries ago. While Islam inspired some to go into bloodthirsty battle to try to conquer the world, there was an intellectual branch of Islam that was moderate and progressive and open to new ideas. There's an (absurdly expensive) book about it which is reviewed here:

Tracing the course of thought, action, and expression in the golden age of Islamic civilization, L. E. Goodman's Islamic Humanism paints a vivid panorama that departs strikingly from the all too familiar image of Islamic dogma, authoritarianism, and militancy. Among the poets and philosophers, scientists and historians, ethicists and mystics of Islam, Goodman finds a warm and vital humanism, committed to the pursuit of knowledge and to the cosmopolitan values of generosity, tolerance, and understanding.

Learning in schools about the history of that tradition may inspire Muslims to try to emulate it. It could be perceived as a Muslim tradition to be proud of that could help give them a positive identity.

Some Muslim countries might not be open to anything that teaches moderation though. While in the West, there are Muslims interested in discussing how the Koran can be interpreted in a less harsh manner, so, for example, its calls for the butchery of non-believers can be seen as applicable only to certain occasions during the lifetime of Mohammed rather than being meant for all time, in countries run by extremists, debate about such things is disapproved of, and even moderate Muslims can be harshly punished for their views. See this gruesome article, for example.

There are initiatives in some Western Muslim communities to stop people becoming extremists. For instance: Mosque in Toronto offers 'detox' program for radical Islamists using Allah and the Koran:

Mr. Shaikh, a 56-year-old Indian-born Muslim, is a mediator, former police chaplain and community activist who has worked on youth crime prevention and conflict resolution. ...

The program has 12 steps, including: Allah, the Koran and Mohammad; the connections between Islam, Christianity and Judaism; other faiths; Canadian society; and countering extremism through education, public speaking and writing.

An important part of the program involves listening to the youths and talking about the damage caused by Islamist terrorist attacks such as the recent Mumbai massacre and the London bombings, Mr. Shaikh said.

"And we just want to encourage them to be faithful and do not take the law into your own hand, always try to build something rather than destroy something," he said.

After British Muslims bombed the London transit system in 2005, the U. K. introduced a program to fight radicalization; several other Western countries have done the same. ...

And this article attempts to inspire disaffected young Muslims to take a new direction in life, becoming a good influence on those around them. Whether it ever works is open to question. But if it gives any of them a new identity they can be proud of, and a purpose in life they can really believe in, they may well be less likely to turn to radicalism to fulfil those needs.

Atheism might be able to play quite a role in modifying or eliminating irrational beliefs; but it can only do that where atheists are prepared to ask intelligent questions and intelligently point out flaws in religious teaching with insight. Far too many atheists probably cause the promotion of what they seek to eliminate. If you approach the issue with bigotry, intolerance, and arguments based on ignorance, treating anyone who says anything good about religion as the enemy, you will simply influence them to put forward stronger arguments in that religion's defence and their beliefs will become more entrenched. Therefore, atheists can think they're crusading against an ever-escalating tide of religious argument, when they're the very ones causing it by their ignorant and intolerant persistent opposition. If they don't seem to be getting the point because their responses lack insight, of course the ones arguing in their religion's defence are going to turn up the volume, or should I say, argue more fervently.

The Internet might be a very good means of spreading a more tolerant attitude towards other beliefs and atheism and a more critical attitude to religion in countries ruled by extremists, because those who can access it in countries where literature opposing their religion would be illegal will now be able to read critiques of it. Still, it might not cause much change soon, since as long as hard-liners rule, public apostacy from the religion will be illegal - it's punishable by death in some Islamic countries. But positive change might have a gathering momentum. Here's a hopeful article about social initiatives in the Middle East that looks to the future with optimism.

Of course, the spotlight shouldn't just fall on religious extremism, since countries that were militantly atheistic have done equally brutal and irrational things to followers of religions.

One thing that might have the most influence is when people's quality of life is so high and they've got so much else to get involved in that they just don't feel the need for religion anymore, or for extremism of any kind. See this post in my thread about poor living conditions breeding unfortunate supernatural beliefs for example. It quotes research about how religious belief is at its lowest in countries with the most social equality and the highest living standards.
 
Interesting: According to some, it was God that did 9/11

But first:

Look at this!

Can I Get A Witness?

Shopkeepers in Poland have outraged job seekers by insisting they'll only employ Jehovah's Witnesses.

Bosses of the Occasion clothes store in Lodz say they're less likely to steal stock and cash, always turn up on time and work hard.

"They are honest, reliable and hard-working," said a spokesman.

I wonder how true that is. :)

Incidentally, I don't normally talk about religion on here, but funnily enough, I found myself talking about it in two consecutive threads, this one and one afterwards. (a bit like the old quip about buses never coming for ages and then several coming at once).

And even more funnily enough, the conversation I had in the other thread directly relates to the one that went on here. It started off discussing whether anyone who believes the Bible is literally true will share the beliefs and attitudes of Fred Phelps. You can see the conversation in the "Bigoted church members protest outside NYC Synagogue" thread.

Fred Phelps is the best recruiting sergeant the atheist movement have ever had. ...

Actually I think David Wilkerson's closer to scripture than Fred Phelps, - he who wrote the inspirational book about how Christianity changed the lives of violent gangsters who then became non-violent, The Cross And The Switchblade - even though he now says worse things than Fred Phelps! See my earlier post about him. ... Oh wait, no he doesn't, does he; Phelps says Obama is the Antichrist who will invade Israel and bring on the end of the world. :D But Wilkerson's more like Old Testament prophets in that he doesn't pick on individuals and gloat. He, like Phelps though, presumes to be able to proclaim that disasters will happen to particular places as a judgment from God, or that ones that already have happened were. I've found out he did a sermon a few days after 9/11 about how it was a judgment from God. Whereas Phelps would have gloated over that though, I presume, Wilkerson was more like Old Testament prophets in saying he was upset:

From a sermon he preached the Sunday after the 9/11 attacks called The Towers Have Fallen And We Missed The Message

But something indescribable has been happening in this church in this past seven weeks. Every service, as you witness today, a holy hush, a silence from the throne has come to this auditorium. There was one night when we sat for one hour in total silence and nobody could move. I remember putting my hands on my knees to stop them from trembling because of the awesome pres ence of God.

As the pastors began to pray and you remember if you've been here, you've seen the pastors weeping and wailing. I've seen pastor Neil laying here crying out to God. We were repenting. We were crying out to God and then the Holy Spirit spoke clearly that it was happening because a tragedy was coming, a calamity was coming to this city and to the nation and we didn't know what it was. Suddenly a calamity struck the nation and especially here in New York City. ...

Now if you are a praying, Bible believer, you know instinctively in your heart that God is trying to speak to this nation and the world through this. God is trying to send us a message. Theologians and pastors all over the country even around the world are saying to their congregations, "God had nothing to do with these calamities. God would not allow such a thing to happen."

Because of that thinking and because of that preaching, we are quickly losing the message and missing what God is trying to say. We are missing it.

Beloved, we need a word from heaven. I've wept and grieved just as others have but deep within I've experienced this week a deeper grief than just those who have been lost in this catastrophe. I'm going to show you how God weeps. I'll show you how God grieves over it and I'll show you how God has no pleasure in the death of anybody.

It's the grief that if we miss the message He's trying to proclaim to us, if we turn a deaf ear to what God is loudly proclaiming, much worse is in store for us. ...

Oh yes, so many innocent people have died. Not that there was personal judgment on them. Many righteous died. But God's trying to save a nation.

It seems to me that thinking calamity is a judgment from God could make people feel powerless to change things and apathetic when it comes to investigating the causes of it. For instance, if the space shuttle disasters had been presumed to be acts of God, the real causes wouldn't have been found, and improvements in design and the accountability of the management at the companies making parts wouldn't have been improved. Similarly, if 9/11 was widely assumed to have been a judgment of God, couldn't that have made people apathetic about trying to ensure such a thing doesn't happen again by doing things such as improving security around airports?

I wonder if disaster-preaching ever does any good. I wonder if there are any records of it ever turning people from lifestyles of violence or other harmful behaviour to a better way of living. Likewise, I wonder if there are any records of people not taking steps to combat or discover the causes of calamities because they thought they were the will of God. If anyone knows of any, it would be interesting to find out about them. I've heard that end times preaching can be harmful because people have been seen to not bother making efforts to improve their lot because they're convinced the world will end soon. But I wonder if there are people who've held back from trying to eradicate the causes of disasters because they thought they were God's will.

And if both things have happened - if disaster preaching has influenced some people to stop harming others and live better lives, and if there have also been people who've been put off seeking to eliminate the causes of disaster when they could otherwise have made quite a contribution to doing so because of it, I wonder which has had the most impact on the world. I suppose that would be impossible to find out.

And why, I wonder, does David Wilkerson think God would bring a disaster on people to try to change their ways, when most people won't believe it had anything to do with God?

Actually, David Wilkerson's writings in general on his blog have a completely different feel to Fred Phelps's, stressing all the blessings he says God wants to give. For instance:

*Yet so few Christians have this joy and exceeding gladness. Multitudes never know rest of soul or the peace of Christ’s presence. They walk around as if in mourning, picturing themselves under the thumb of God’s wrath rather than under his protective wings. They see him as a harsh taskmaster, always ready to bring a whip down on their backs. And so they live unhappily, with no hope, more dead than alive.

*But in God’s eyes, our problem isn’t sin; it is trust. Jesus settled our sin problem once and for all at Calvary. He doesn’t constantly harp on us, “This time you’ve crossed the line.” No, never! His attitude toward us is just the opposite. His Spirit is constantly wooing us, reminding us of the Father’s loving kindness even in the midst of our failures.

*When we become focused on our sin, we lose all sight of what God wants most: “Without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him” (Hebrews 11:6). This verse says it all. Our God is a rewarder, and he’s so anxious to shower us with his loving kindness that he blesses us way ahead of schedule.

How nice. But he sounds more Phelps-like in the prophecies he makes, as I quoted a few posts ago:

Right now, I believe God is speaking a warning to New York City and I wrestled with His severe word as I prepared this message and I prayed, Lord, is this really going to happen?

Again and again I heard this still small voice, "Preach it and warn the people. Those who want the truth will receive it."

Dear Saint:

This warning is not meant to scare you. It's meant only for you to take to the Lord and pray. This is what I believe the Lord has shown me.

Thirty days of chastisement will fall on New York City such as the world has never seen. God's going to let down the walls. Unimaginable violence, looting, a thousand fires will be burning at the same time throughout the city and it's Burroughs.

Times Square will be ablaze and the flames that ascend into the heaven will be seen for miles. Fire trucks will not be able to handle it all. Trains and buses will be shut down. Billions of dollars will be lost. Broadway shows will stop completely. It will cause businesses to flee the city in an unstoppable haemorrhage.

The violence will be ferocious. It will shock the whole world. Our streets will be lined not just with National Guard but the militia. The Los Angeles fires were confined to a few sections of their city but New York will be ablaze and its Burroughs.

Such things are expected in Third World countries but not in a civilized nation like the United States. Yet in not too long a time afterward New York City will go bankrupt. The city's Queen city will be cast into the dirt. A city of poverty.

You ask, when will all this happen? All I can say is, I believe I will be here when it happens. When it happens, no matter where we are, in your apartment or on the job, God's people are not to panic or fear."

Some of his fairly recent blog entries suggest something about why he believes New Yourk City is deserving of such chastisement from God:

... This is why Scripture so strongly warns us against unbelief.* We are told it grieves the Lord and shuts us off from every blessing and good work he has promised.* Our unbelief makes every promise “of no effect.”

*For us in New York City, this is not a dead theology.* We have to practice what we preach just to survive each day.* If we did not fully trust the Lord’s promises and rely on Jesus with all that is in us, we would freeze up with fear and panic.* The streets here are like war zones; people live constant fear and danger, and bystanders are murdered left and right.* Our costs to care for those we minister to are heavy, and the needs of hurting people are so enormous.*
IF WE DID NOT REST IN GOD’S STEADFAST PROMISES, WE WOULD BE OVERWHELMED.*

*But we are not overwhelmed – we are not afraid.* As the problems grow worse, we grow stronger in the power of the Holy Spirit.

And from a slightly earlier blog entry:

**WE COULD NOT GO ON HERE IN NEW YORK CITY WITHOUT COMPLETE TRUST IN THE LORD.* The problems are too overwhelming.* Millions of people are living in overcrowded conditions.* The city is going wild with violence, drugs, murder, homicides, a new strain of TB that is airborne, the plague of AIDS.

*Our workers who minister every day to the diseased street people and homeless who carry these diseases are not afraid.* They trust the Lord to protect them and to strengthen them in this work.

*I thank God for allowing us to be his channels in raising up a thriving church on Broadway, with thousands of lives being touched.* But we did not come to New York City simply to build a church.* We came to do what Jesus would have done: to minister to the poor, the hungry, the homeless, the addicted, the worst among sinners.

*We rejoice that God is enabling us to bring Christ’s redeeming gospel to many who once were considered hopeless by every human measure.* A small army has already been saved from the streets, and every day more and more are being rescued.

Crikey, it's that bad? I wouldn't want to go there! Why don't the tour guides tell us about this stuff? :)

Still, you can see this ministry has a completely different focus from Fred Phelps's. It's a much more biblical one. Having said that, I have to wonder:

Why does he imagine God is saying disaster is the only way of changing people en masse, especially since it doesn't seem to work very well? In fact, isn't God's cure sometimes worse than the disease? Why isn't God trying to change people by less harmful and more imaginative means, by telling him, for example, to campaign for wider access to parenting classes? And for more anti-bullying programs in schools that can actually influence children to change for the better so they give up violence? Here's a lot of information about one that's said to have had good results. Why doesn't he think God's calling for better promotion of marriage workshops/courses that could help couples stay together so children have more stable environments, and so parents are less dissatisfied with their marriages, and thus some will be less likely to be tempted to have affairs etc.? Why isn't God telling him to instruct employers to cut down the risk of theft by taking better security precautions? Why is Wilkerson himself seeking to change people by ministering to them in compassion, and yet teaching that God's way, a righteous way, is to bring disaster on them?

And so on. Why does he imagine God only wants to or knows how to work through disasters? Why doesn't he question God as to why he doesn't want to try more things like that first? It wouldn't be unbiblical. After all, some of the psalmists and Job criticised God and accused him of being unfair. Jeremiah also complained. If the Bible was being written today, they might have said things such as the ones I've just said. So why is David Wilkerson convinced, seemingly without question, that disasters are now the only solution?

Also, it's interesting how some of what he says about New York is similar to what Old Testament prophets said about Israel - how it was full of violence and bloodshed. It would be interesting to read the writings of a traveller/historian who toured around Israel at about the same time the prophets lived, who wrote about what he thought about the people. I wonder if he'd have a very different perspective. I wonder if such a document exists. Perhaps not. But it would be interesting if there was one that conflicted with what the prophets said.
 
Last edited:
Many issues about inconsistencies with religions have been discussed above already and everyone has made a great contribution to this debate. What is the solution? Have a government that legislates against religion, closes down religious-based charities, hospitals, etc? But somehow I don’t think that would work.

Your suggestion to have religion legislated away would be based on an even more prevalent belief in our times: that of the benevolent state, only out to serve its people. You also seem bent on making the same distinction that most of BabyNemesis's argument is based on: good religion versus bad religion - as if hospitals were still a realm of the church and not of science-based health care.
The analogy expressed in "opium of the people" makes it obvious that people's need to believe gives rise to religion, which does not in any way imply that legislation would be a solution: We all know how well it works in the prevention of drug abuse.

I think if destructive people commit their crimes in the name of their religion they could easily commit these and other crimes under the umbrella of some other cause (be it for a business, political cause, etc). And even if you did stop the organisations you can’t kill an idea. The concept of God is an enduring one which is simply not going to go away.

Very enduring, indeed! And why would anybody want to get rid of the concept of God? Even in a godless world people would still want to know about the past history of human kind. However, again you make the same mistake that BN has been making all along: Crimes committed in the name of religion really aren't religious crimes. Religion is merely abused as a pretence, "in the name of", and the real reason seems to be the "destructive" nature of (some) people, as if, for example, homophobic hate crimes committed or the killing of abortionists by Christians had nothing at all to do with religion.

Skeptics like us will never allow it to become irrelevant or go away because we keep talking about it, even though not always in a complimentary way. How much of our lives do we spend trying to convince ourselves and others of the non-reality or irrationality of an idea we can’t stop thinking or talking about in our debates.

So skeptics won't allow religion to go away? It appears to exist "because (!) we keep talking about it"? And the reason for this seems to be some kind of unfounded obsession among skeptics, who simply "can’t stop thinking or talking about" religion!!!
So apparently out the blue and not due to the prevalence of this phenomenon, which seems to pervade some societies so much that it's unavoidable to come into contact with it even to people who would much prefer to be left alone, some people, i.e. skeptics, just have to think and talk about it in their "debates".
Now, that's a peculiar deduction of religion, which does not seem to concern itself with the actual contents of any of the "debates" it refers to.

Perhaps a more constructive move would be to join a religious organisation and encourage other members to follow their espoused ideals in a more positive kind with an attitude of practical support and love for all people. Actually, many people in the St Vincent De Paul Society or the Salvation Army are already doing this.
:wow2:

Yes, that would indeed be the "constructive", albeit very wrong move - and one which fits surprisingly well with BN's argument so far: Since religion is good and even the crimes committed in its name an abuse of religion's actual good intentions, the best thing atheists and skeptics can do is to "join a religious organisation"!!!
Amen!

In other words: The argument presented here appears to be construed to fit the exact proportions of BN's argument so far, which, of course, is the reason why BN describes the absurd suggestion as a "sensible attitude".
A sock puppet couldn't have done it any better.
 
Some religions/cults deliberately keep the living conditions down in such a way that it benefits their religion. Like the Taliban preventing girls from going to school.

Yes they do. But religions can keep people down for other reasons, not necessarily religious ones, such as when cult leaders seek to make money by having obedient members beg on the streets to bring money into the cult.

But religion can certainly be the excuse for oppression, and certain interpretations of it can lead people to believe it's right and good.

For instance, women are oppressed in countries with a strict interpretation of Islam like Saudi Arabia.


Yes, this is hardly a theme where we'll run out of examples in the near future. But even when religions don't keep people down for religious reasons, for instance when a psychopath uses and abuses credulous believers for his or her own purposes, it is obvious that they are exploited by means of their beliefs, i.e. if they did not feel the need to believe in a transcendent (ir)reality beyond the real world, the psychopath would not be able to take advantage of their delusion. If you don't need to believe in angels or in communicating with your dearly departed, the psychopath can't to abuse your delusion by offering 'proof' that they are real.

And in this realm it is not possible to make a clear-cut distinction between an alleged abusive guru and an alleged honest one - unless you'll credit the 'honest' guru for being self-deluded.

Only available in Danish and German, I think:
"Selvmords-trippet til Tenerifa": Guder, guruer og sekteksperter
Der „Selbstmord-Trip nach Teneriffa“: Götter, Gurus und Gelehrte
 
Dann said:
The analogy expressed in "opium of the people" makes it obvious that people's need to believe gives rise to religion, which does not in any way imply that legislation would be a solution: We all know how well it works in the prevention of drug abuse.

You're confusing legislation Per Se with the specific type of legislation being tried in some countries. Have a look at recent drug legislation in Portugal. It's rather different from US legislation.

Dann said:
However, again you make the same mistake that BN has been making all along: Crimes committed in the name of religion really aren't religious crimes. Religion is merely abused as a pretence, "in the name of", and the real reason seems to be the "destructive" nature of (some) people,
as if, for example, homophobic hate crimes committed or the killing of abortionists by Christians had nothing at all to do with religion.

You simplify/distort both our positions, possibly accidentally. My position all along has been that things tend to be more complex than just "Religion made them do it". Naturally religious issues can be part of what motivates people to do evil things. But many people like to imagine religion is entirely to blame and ignore other factors. For instance, I've heard someone put forward the view that the English Civil War was a religious war. As a matter of fact, the causes were multiple, as this brief article explains: The Causes of the English Civil War.

Equally, the causes of the Crusades, commonly assumed to have been religious wars, were multiple, as this article explains: The First Crusade

... B.Intermediate Causes

Despite their growth, European society and economy were in a state of transition, and were unstable.

1. The aristocracy found themselves at relative peace, and were losing the importance they had enjoyed when they stood between Europe and its attackers. Their numbers were growing because there were no longer the losses in battle they had once sustained. They needed more land with which to endow their children and were beginning to fight with each other over the land that was available to them. ...

5. The middle classes were now aware of the profits of the eastern trade, and were searching for some way to bypass the middlemen of the eastern empire and to trade directly with the Muslims. They knew that they could become rich by cutting out the Byzantines and taking for themselves the profits that the Byzantine merchants had been making on trade with them.

6. The economic system was in a state of transition, with some districts specializing in some "industrial" crops to the point that they did not raise enough grain to feed themselves, and were doing so before the transportation and internal trading system had advanced enough to distribute consumer goods efficiently. So there were frequent local famines. At the same time, agriculture was improving so greatly in productivity that many people no longer had work. The peasants needed more food and more land to cultivate. In 1095, a famine and epidemic in northern France and the Lowlands was causing widespread misery and the lower classes were some miracle to deliver them.

7. Pilgrims returning from the Holy Land were bring home stories of the atrocities being committed by the Seljuk Turks, masters of the Levant, against pilgrims, and of the way in which they were desecrating the places holy to Christians. This caused great outrage, in part because the average western European was better acquainted with the Bible lands than any place other than their own villages and towns. The Holy Land was the Christians "other home." ...

It goes more into the religious issues as well.

One thing, Dann, which is obviously not your fault, is that you seem to have difficulty in understanding figures of speech like irony, where people don't mean quite what they say. Also it would help with that if you read the whole of a person's post before commenting. For instance, it appears that you opposed the argument you assume Whirligig to be making - that religion should be legislated away, which was actually posed as a question and not an argument at all, - only to discover in the next paragraph that Whirligig's saying something rather different - that religion shouldn't be legislated away. The question was obviously rhetorical.

You haven't actually explained as yet why you think it would be good for all religion to be eradicated, beyond saying it's a delusion. It seems a little strange that you haven't really explained further, given that the postulation that religion should be eradicated is the whole premise of your argument. You believe religion to simply be a delusion. You will not even allow for the possibility that God exists and that some religion is not a delusion, which makes your position reactionary and ideologue-like rather than skeptical - a true skeptic being one who critically examines evidence rather than just rejecting concepts they don't like without being able to give a good explanation as to why. Even when I have demonstrated that turning to Christianity has so changed some people's lives that they have turned from violence, shoplifting and other harmful behaviours, you still stick to your position that it needs to be eradicated because it's a delusion, without giving any explanation of why you believe that its benefits shouldn't be taken into account, or at least none in a language most of us can understand. :) You haven't given any reason whatsoever for your outrage at Whirligig's suggestion that non-religious people should join religious organisations to influence people in positive ways. Your response was simply an outpouring of apparent horror with no reasoned argument behind it.

Further, you are limiting your own arguing options by trying to close the debate down to basically one of a simple adversarial nature - basically a "did" "didn't" style of argument. For example, I linked to testimonies of people who gave up lifestyles of violence and other harmful ways when they became Christians. If you'd argued more imaginatively, you could have seen that as a coup d'etat for your position - "Ha! Those testimonies demonstrate that people turn to religion when they're dissatisfied with their lives in some way!" Instead, your argument was a simplistic reactionary one - "I don't want to read any more of those! You're spamming the thread with them!"

I think it would be better if you reason your position through more and try to think more deeply about the opposition's points.

I'll answer a couple of points you made earlier that I didn't before. You wrote a long post in response to my question as to what you perceive as being wrong with the concept of moral living. I think I can summarise it by saying you believe morality is an abstract concept that can obstruct pragmatism, such as where Christians oppose handing out condoms to men in Africa because they don't want them to be promiscuous, when actually they're going to be promiscuous anyway and why jolly well shouldn't they be, and at least giving them condoms would reduce their chances of catching AIDS.

Actually that premise is not quite right, because the concept of morality is not always immutable, and where it is, it can actually inspire more efficacious policies.

For instance, researching with stem cells from embryos is considered by some to be immoral. But opponents can argue that it isn't immoral and in fact is more moral than not doing it, given that it's being done before the embryos develop enough to be fetuses that would actually feel pain, and the research is being done to benefit fully-developed humans who are in a lot of pain and/or suffering a lot because of disabilities, so isn't trying to eliminate their pain and suffering the most moral choice?

It's also possible the controversy over morality can lead to research efforts being made on other types of stem cells which could actually prove very fruitful long-term. For instance, from the latest news items on 'Stem Cell Transplantation'

(BBC 18/06/2009)

Discarded fallopian tubes from hysterectomies could be a good source of donor stem cells, say researchers. Work shows they are an abundant source of the immature cells that have the potential to become a variety of the body's tissues, like muscle and bone. The discovery offers another "ethical" route to creating stem cell treatments for diseases like arthritis without using embryos. Other sources include: umbilical cords, menstrual blood, teeth and fat tissue.

Some of these could possibly work better than embryonic stem cells in some situations, so scientists might be grateful for being pushed into exploring other avenues by the controversy. Certainly one benefit of taking stem cells from the person being treated, rather than using embryos from people unrelated to them, eliminates the risk of the cells being rejected by the body, though whether the ethical controversy had any impact on the avenues that scientists researching into the rejection issue explored, I don't know. They might have researched alternatives anyway. Still, some finds might not have been made.

Regarding AIDS in Africa, it's true that a dogmatically moral position that condoms shouldn't be handed out and education should consist entirely of abstinence-only teaching might have led to an increase in the prevalence of AIDS. That's especially if the same thing that's been happening in America has been happening there. From an article about research findings on abstinence-only education vs comprehensive sex education:

In addition, while an abstinence pledge may work for some groups of young people as a way of delaying when they have sexual intercourse, the majority still have sex before they are married and when they do they report using condoms less often than 'non-pledgers' and are more likely to substitute anal or oral sex for vaginal sexual intercourse

Which kind of defeats the point, since anal sex is more risky as regards the transition of HIV than vaginal sex. From Wikipedia:

Unprotected anal sex is a high risk activity regardless of sexual orientation. Research suggests that although gay men are more likely to engage in anal sex, heterosexual couples are more likely not to use condoms when doing so.

Anal sex is more risky than vaginal, since being very thin tissues of anus and rectum can be easily damaged during such sex activities as anal intercourse or use of anal toys. Even slight injuries can become "open gates" for various bacteria and viruses, including HIV. This implies that anal sex does require some certain safety measures. First of all, any partners who practice anal sex should be aware of the necessity of using a condom. The condom must be put on properly, otherwise it does not provide reliable protection. Users should keep in mind that oil-based lubricants damage latex. For this reason water-based lubricants should be used for anal sex.

So refusing information about condoms could do a lot of harm.

But it could be argued that it isn't "moral" to refuse information about contraception to people who might not be swayed by abstinence-only education and so put themselves and others at risk.

Also, it may be that sex education without the moral aspect - the teaching on the benefits of abstinence - could be just as harmful as education without information on condoms.

However, your points actually seemed irrelevant to the discussion, since my points were about ordinary people living more moral lives - in other words, lives that benefited their communities rather than harmed them. They weren't about the consequences of the decisions of a few people in the higher echelons of authority. If I were to argue the AIDS/condoms issue you raised along the lines of the previous points I'd made, I'd say it may be that more morality among the populace of Africa would have prevented AIDS reaching epidemic proportions or even getting a foothold, although there are several causes, not all of them to do with immorality.

Talking of morals, ... oh no this is a little different: the moral of a story. :)

Regarding that awful story in Judges 19 you quoted about the couple not stopping for the night in a foreign land but going on to their own native Israel - where the woman was abused all night and killed: I said the story had an anti-prejudice moral in it. You responded by reminding us one and all of what came next in the story - him doing what, in the absence of gory television pictures or even a media to speak of at all, was the next best way to rouse outrage among his countrymen - sending bits of her body to them and calling for them to make war on the tribe that had killed her. You commented that my "defence of the Bible" was becoming more "absurd". In other words, what you seemed to be saying was, "How could you possibly say anything good about such a story!" I'd like to point out that just because a story contains a moral, that doesn't mean that the entire story is moral. Surely you learned that from the Hans Kristian Andersen stories you probably read as a child. :)

Dann said:
Yes, this is hardly a theme where we'll run out of examples in the near future. But even when religions don't keep people down for religious reasons, for instance when a psychopath uses and abuses credulous believers for his or her own purposes, it is obvious that they are exploited by means of their beliefs, i.e. if they did not feel the need to believe in a transcendent (ir)reality beyond the real world, the psychopath would not be able to take advantage of
their delusion. If you don't need to believe in angels or in communicating with your dearly departed, the psychopath can't to abuse your delusion by offering 'proof' that they are real.

That's a very good point. But as Whirligig suggested, if a destructive person wants to abuse someone, if one means is closed to them, they'll just find another. You can see that extremely clearly in the development of cyber-crime - when one type of software is developed to thwart it, the criminals move on to using new techniques. Why would the potential for abuse mean religion should be scrapped altogether? People should certainly be warned about ways people abuse others' beliefs. That's very important. But religion in itself doesn't make a person vulnerable to abuse. Believing in God doesn't necessarily make you vulnerable to the scam of someone telling you God's telling him you need to give him your money, for instance. Cliff Richard's a famous Christian. There's the story of how someone knocked on his door one day and told him God had told her he wanted her to become Cliff Richard's housekeeper. Cliff Richard said if that were true, he'd have heard about it himself, and in any case, other people had told him God wanted them to be his housekeeper. If they had all heard from God, what was he playing at? :D Religion doesn't have to disable the critical thinking faculties.

This gets us back to points similar to some I made earlier - religious figures themselves have campaigned vigorously against abuses perpetrated by other religious figures, for instance, Martin Luther making a bold stand against the Catholic Church's exploitation of the common people by urging them to spend money many could ill afford on a document said to get them or their loved ones out of purgatory faster. It isn't an "us and them" thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom