Dann said:
That you had an intention with your statement does not make it right. Science and religion can co-exist in as far as they are two different attitutes to the world: Science wants to know what the world is. It requires truth. Religion doesn't. On the contrary, religion does not want to know. Faced with reality, religion wants to make sense of the world by making up a meaning - beyond reality. I believe in Jesus because the illusion makes me happy, I enjoy being loved by God, which is why I invent him. Science doesn't care about stuff like that, and scientists throw themselves off the scent as soon as they start looking for comforting (instead of true) insight.
There's nothing comforting about black holes, primarily because they show us that the universe not only doesn't but actually cannot give a **** about us.
But I still say they don't have to be seen as opposites, as you seem to think they are, because a religious person won't necessarily bury their head in the sand when it comes to scientific enquiry. Religion doesn't have to stifle science or vice versa. A religious person might think of science as the investigation of what we can prove about the universe, but God as being beyond the realm of science, something that can't be proved or disproved, but something they believe in because they feel they have an emotional or an intuitive conviction that he exists, for example. They might be very involved in trying to further knowledge in their particular branch of science. But they might think of religion as being a part of their lives which has to do with the emotional side, thinking of the scientific side as separate. They might see their conviction that God exists and their desire to participate in religious activities as being in the same category in some respects as their enjoyment of reading history books, or skimming stones on ponds, or feeding the ducks in the park with their children, or looking at a nice view, or enjoying melodic music. They might see the enjoyment they find in doing all those things as barely explainable by science, but nevertheless no less valid.
Dann said:
And for some reason you seem to think that moral living is a good thing.
I once saw some kind of American bishop on the CBS 60 Minutes denounce the 10 Commandments because they obviously put women on the same footing as cattle and property: Thou shallt not covet thy neighbour's house, wife, ox ....
Moral living, my ...
Some of those Ruthlesscriticism articles you've linked to just go right over my head for some reason, including the one on morality. Could you explain in simple terms just what you perceive as being wrong with moral living, or the way you define morality? There can certainly be arguments as to whether specific things are moral or not, such as euthanasia. But I don't understand why you'd think morality in itself is a flawed concept.
I bet that man condemning the Ten Commandments would have shouted even louder if Moses had been talking to women and told them not to covet their neighbour's husband or their ox.

But the fact that men were told not to covet both other people's wives and their property in the same commandment isn't proof that women were treated as property, ... or that houses and oxen were treated as human.
In a very brief article called
Weren't women considered property in the OT, like cows or something? Didn't the Law say a father could even SELL his daughter?!! it says:
... Fourthly, who ever heard of "property OWNING property"?!
Yet women in the OT...
• Gave their personal belongings as offerings (Ex 35.22,29) ...
• Unmarried daughters could inherit property (Num 27.1-7; Elephantine papyri, Job 42.13)
• Female servants could buy their own freedom (Lev 27.1ff)
• Receive revenues from land (2 kgs 8)
• Possess nice homes (Mic 2.8)
• Sell property (Ruth 4.9)
There are several New Testament passages that I consider to be basic overviews of the biblical concept of morality, including this one. It's not comprehensive, but you get the general idea:
From Ephesians 4:
21 Since you have heard about Jesus and have learned the truth that comes from him, 22 throw off your old sinful nature and your former way of life, which is corrupted by lust and deception. 23 Instead, let the Spirit renew your thoughts and attitudes. 25 So stop telling lies. Let us tell our neighbors the truth, for we are all parts of the same body. 26 And “don’t sin by letting anger control you.” Don’t let the sun go down while you are still angry, 27 for anger gives a foothold to the devil.
*28 If you are a thief, quit stealing. Instead, use your hands for good hard work, and then give generously to others in need. 29 Don’t use foul or abusive language. Let everything you say be good and helpful, so that your words will be an encouragement to those who hear them.
*31 Get rid of all bitterness, rage, anger, harsh words, and slander, as well as all types of evil behavior. 32 Instead, be kind to each other, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, just as God through Christ has forgiven you.
To what extent it's right to follow that to the letter, or whether some of it is lost in translation, can be disputed; but surely no one can dispute that the general intent is good.
Dann said:
And that, of course, is the way that most Christians handle the Bible: They ignore the most disgusting parts of it and reinterpret the rest.
Actually, it's probable that most Christians have never read most of the Bible. And I don't see why they should, unless they want to preach or debate about it, since the Old Testament is pre-Christian.
But I didn't say the rabbis making judgments in the courts might have re-interpreted the Bible, just that they might have used examples from it as guides to help them determine how strictly to enforce the law. They would also have used their own judgment and common sense to determine whether there were mitigating circumstances that made it sensible not to carry out the punishments prescribed. There's ancient documented evidence that they did. Some of it can be seen in an article about some laws of Moses that on the face of it seem barbaric:
Are the laws in the Old Testament about rape and virginity unfair to women?
Dann said:
Do you actually read what you're writing???! And did you actually read the law? So a court case took mercy on a girl stealing a little cole to keep herself and her brother from freezing. Did the law ever question the law of property that decrees that freezing and starving people are excluded from the abundance of solid fuel and food because they belong to other people who don't need them but produce them to get rich?
And every Xmas we are encumbered with innumerable versions of A Christmas Carol (I gave up counting them last year) with the predictable Dickensian moral of the well-behaved, needy and pathetic poor people waiting for the cold-hearted Scrooge to come to his senses and see that poor people deserve to be helped by the altruistic filthy rich - if they so decide.
What could a judge in a law court have done about the state of social welfare? He wouldn't have had the power to decree that the government should be helping such people more. All he could do was to ensure that judgments against people who appeared in his court were no more harsh than they should have been. The case I referred to happened in the middle of the Great Depression. Those who should be blamed are the ones who caused it. And a case could certainly be made that the government should have been doing more for disadvantaged people. But progress was being made in those areas. There's an article about it called
Britain's long road to the welfare state.
... Radical Liberals, led by David Lloyd George, took the first steps towards Britain's first welfare state after their huge electoral victory in 1906.
Among the key measures introduced were old age pensions, a system of health insurance, and labour exchanges to help tackle unemployment.
However, the Edwardian welfare state was incomplete.
It was limited to the working class, its funding basis was insecure, and little progress was made in tackling poverty among people of working age. ...
Workers in munitions factories forced the government to introduce rent control in 1915 after a series of rent strikes, and in 1918 Lloyd George - now Coalition Prime Minister - pledged to provide "homes built for heroes" for returning war veterans.
Two million council homes were eventually built.
The end of the war also brought a slump, particularly in northern industrial towns, that deepened into the Great Depression by the 1930s.
By the time Britain entered the Second World War, the pressures for social reform were mounting.
And the shared sacrifice during the war enhanced the belief that "never again" should Britain fight for an unequal and unfair society. ...
Beveridge's report on social insurance galvanized opinion ...
His report called for a universal flat rate benefit, payable to all, on the basis of fixed national insurance contributions. It was to cover old age, unemployment, and sickness. ...
Dann said:
Are you saying the Jesus doesn't criticize the guy who's grumbling about his brother?
No, I'm saying you have no way of knowing how much money that brother had in the first place. Here's the full story, from which you will be able to determine that the brother was very unlikely to have been "dirt poor" as you suggested, and that Jesus wasn't saying any such thing as, "Be satisfied with being poor":
Luke chapter 12 (TEV)
13 A man in the crowd said to Jesus, "Teacher, tell my brother to divide with me the property our father left us."
14 Jesus answered him, "Friend, who gave me the right to judge or to divide the property between you two?"
15 And he went on to say to them all, "Watch out and guard yourselves from every kind of greed; because your true life is not made up of the things you own, no matter how rich you may be."
16 Then Jesus told them this parable: "There was once a rich man who had land which bore good crops. 17 He began to think to himself, "I don't have a place to keep all my crops. What can I do? 18 This is what I will do,' he told himself; "I will tear down my barns and build bigger ones, where I will store
the grain and all my other goods. 19 Then I will say to myself, Lucky man! You have all the good things you need for many years. Take life easy, eat, drink, and enjoy yourself!' 20 But God said to him, "You fool! This very night you will have to give up your life; then who will get all these things you have kept for yourself?' "
21 And Jesus concluded, "This is how it is with those who pile up riches for themselves but are not rich in God's sight."
In fact, the early apostles lived in a socialist-type community:
Acts chapter 4 (TEV)
32 The group of believers was one in mind and heart. None of them said that any of their belongings were their own, but they all shared with one another everything they had. 33 With great power the apostles gave witness to the resurrection of the Lord Jesus, and God poured rich blessings on them all. 34 There was no one in the group who was in need. Those who owned fields or houses would sell them, bring the money received from the sale, 35 and turn it over to the apostles; and the money was distributed according to the needs of the people. 36 And so it was that Joseph, a Levite born in Cyprus, whom the apostles called Barnabas (which means "One who Encourages"), 37 sold a field he owned, brought the money, and turned it over to the apostles.
Me said:
Really, the fact that Christianity was by far the dominant religion in the West for centuries could have been a great boon to humanity if only everyone who professed to be Christians actually behaved as if they were. The massive wealth inequalities that existed, and the oppression of the poor, just wouldn't
have happened, or at least they wouldn't have been nearly so bad, because all those rich people who so proudly sat in church thinking they looked pious would have lived Christianity out in practical ways as it was intended.
Dann said:
But they did, didn't they? And all the poor families in Dickensland would have been so much happier if all the rich guys were converted to the spirit of Xmas the way Scrooge was, right? Don't forget that these are fairytales.
The moral commands in the New Testament can't be described as fairy tales by anyone's definition. They're just instructions. I'm not talking about rich people going out every now and then and handing out baskets of food to poor people, as many well-off Victorians did do. What I mean is that if people like landowners and factory owners genuinely believed in the Christianity they claimed to believe in, they wouldn't have exploited the people who worked for them, but would have given them decent wages, done their best to ensure a safe working environment, and not over-worked them. To give an example:
From a web page on the social effects suffered by workers during the industrial revolution:
Also thousands of new workers were needed to work machines in mills and foundries and the factory owners built houses for them. ...The workers' houses were usually near to the factories so that people could walk to work. They were built really quickly and cheaply. The houses were cheap, most had between 2-4 rooms - one or two rooms downstairs, and one or two rooms upstairs. Victorian families were big with 4 or 5 children. There was no running water or toilet. A whole street would have to share an outdoor pump and a couple of outside toilets. Most houses in the North of England were "back to backs" (built in double rows) with no windows at the front, no backyards and a sewer down the middle of the street. The houses were built crammed close together, with very narrow streets between them. Most of the houses were crowded with five or more people possibly crammed into a single room. Even the cellars were full.* Most of the new towns were dirty and unhealthy. The household rubbish was thrown out into the streets. Housing conditions like these were a perfect breeding grounds for diseases. More than 31,000 people died during an outbreak of cholera in 1832 and lots more were killed by typhus, smallpox and dysentery.
Those factory owners who claimed to be Christians would have done their best to ensure living conditions for their workers were better if they'd actually been sincere enough to take seriously the many commands such as:
Colossians chapter 3 (NLT)
5 Don't be greedy for the good things of this life, for that is idolatry.
To give another example:
While thousands of children worked down the mine, thousands of others worked in the cotton mills. The mill owners often took in orphans to their workhouses, they lived at the mill and were worked as hard as possible. They spent most of their working hours at the machines with little time for fresh air or exercise. Even part of Sunday was spent cleaning machines. There were some serious accidents, some children were scalped when their hair was caught in the machine, hands were crushed and some children were killed when they went to sleep and fell into the machine.
Those factory workers who proudly paraded themselves as Christians would have done their best to make sure working conditions were much better than that if they'd been genuinely Christian and thus had aspired to obey Bible commands like:
Colossians chapter 3 (NLT)
12 ... you must clothe yourselves with tenderhearted mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience.
The whole ethos of the New Testament is anti-exploitation. But it was obviously ignored.
These were the conditions Marx saw around him; so it's no wonder he thought the solution was a revolution of workers!
But now conditions for workers have been improved so much under enlightened Capitalism, at least in the West, I don't understand why anyone would think a revolution in the West would be a good idea nowadays. Perhaps you can explain?
Dann said:
Yes, the world would be a better place if only the oppressors stopped oppressing.* They don't, however, in spite of 2.000 years of Christianity. And nobody would ever get AIDS if everybody abstained from having sex until they were married and never slept around.
And Communism didn't stop them either. Why do you think Communism would be so much better?
I'm certainly not saying Christianity is the best tool there is to combat social inequality. Obviously there are much better ones available. But that doesn't mean Christianity may as well be discounted altogether, because it has changed a lot of people for the better.
Dann said:
Yes, so in other words the Bible preaches that you should never stop acting like a true Xian sheep. The flock should obey its betters and hope that they
appreciate it so much so that they use a little of their earnings caring "for the needs of disadvantaged people".
You sound as if you think Christianity was all a big conspiracy to benefit employers and keep workers down. While it might have sometimes been twisted to fit that agenda, it was certainly not intended to do so, which it's possible to tell from the number of passages there are warning rich people against oppressing their workers or the needy, or telling them to care for the needs of less fortunate people.
Dann said:
No, "workers' rights" did not exist as a concept 2.000 years ago. And so far the rich people haven't "been shocke (...) into changing their ways", so let's wait another 2.000 years and see if it may happen.
Not en masse, certainly. But no one ever expected it to. Such verses may, though, have had sobering enough effects on some individuals to make them change. Certainly the founder of the Salvation Army thought so. From an article called
Kapital ideas meet fire and brimstone:
Ann Woodall's study of William Booth and Karl Marx is prompted by a striking coincidence: the founder of the Salvation Army and the father of Marxism both moved to London in 1849. Furthermore, she argues, what goaded each of them into action was horror at the intractable poverty of the London residuum - what Booth called the "submerged tenth" of the population and Marx dubbed the lumpen-proletariat.
Both men were domineering, impatient characters with a taste for fire-and-brimstone sermons. "Nothing moves people like the terrific," Booth wrote. "They must have hell-fire flashed before their eyes, or they will not move." Marx thought so too, portraying capital as "dead labour which, vampire-like, lives only by sucking living labour". ...
Dann said:
Yes, it's back to the old fairy tale: You don't even seem to notice the contradiction that in your fairy tale the police is supposed to benefit "rich and poor alike", and yet the poor are "the ones most likely to be victims of crime". It could not be because this is the ideal and not the reality of the law?
But there certainly isn't such a simplistic reason for that as, "The police aren't really benefiting the poor because they're tools of the rich", or any such thing. Poor people are more likely to be the victims of crime not simply because they aren't so protected, but because there are more people committing crime in their neighbourhoods. I certainly didn't suggest the police are the only solution. A whole range of things can help to reduce crime, even down to giving teenagers somewhere enjoyable to go in the evenings so they're not hanging around the streets. Education can help them become high enough earners to get out of high-crime neighbourhoods and resettle in more well-to-do ones; but that's not a simple solution either, since for example, there's a cultural attitude in some communities that it's not cool to settle down to learning. Also, in families where children aren't encouraged to get down to homework, it's more difficult, as it can be for a number of other reasons. Full employment can also cut the crime rate significantly. But one problem is a catch 22 situation where companies aren't willing to invest in high-crime areas because of the risk to their facilities, but because they don't, people who might otherwise be gainfully employed resort to crime.
So an attempt to solve the problem would have to involve several things. I'm becoming curious as to how you think a Communist revolution would help.
Dann said:
What exactly is your point? That it is better to have your protestors truncheoned than shot? The problem is that this 'choice' does not depend on the protestors.
It depends on the employers of the truncheoneers and riflemen: A state may decide that the lenient way of putting down protestors is preferable and hold back the people with guns in case the truncheons don't work. That's progress for you.
The introduction of a police force went along with a raft of legislation that made things fairer for poor people, such as prison reform. From an article called
Conditions in Prison and Types of Punishment during the 19th century:
During the 18th century the number of crimes punishable by death rose to about 200. Some, such as treason or murder, were serious crimes, but in other cases people could be sentenced to death for what we would think of as minor offences. For example, the death sentence could be passed for picking pockets, stealing bread or cutting down a tree. These were the kinds of crime likely to be committed by those in most desperate need.*
In 1823 Sir Robert Peel reduced the number of offences for which convicts could be executed by over 100. Lord John Russell abolished the death sentence for horse stealing and housebreaking in 1830. ...
And with the introduction of the police force, soldiers were no longer being ordered to break up protests even if it meant killing people in the process. Yep, things were certainly progressing. Obviously things were nowhere near ideal, but they were progressing.
And now, when things have improved out of all recognition, you'd still like a Communist revolution? Can you tell me why, in the space of one or two sentences?
Dann said:
Again you fail to notice that your facts contradict your ideal:
The police obviously help secure the safety of rich people and their property. They don't do much for you if you are dirt poor and living in the slums -except maybe harass you now and then.
But again you assume that the reason there's a higher crime rate in poorer neighbourhoods must be simply because the police aren't interested in protecting poorer neighbourhoods, when the situation's in reality far more complex than that. A case could certainly be made that those neighbourhoods should have better policing. But the fact that there's a high crime rate in some poor neighbourhoods isn't just a matter of lack of effective policing.
For instance, there's a self-perpetuating cycle where those involved in crime who have a criminal record are much less likely to get employment, so they can't afford to move to better neighbourhoods and they resort to crime again. Also, some of the criminal element will just be too unreliable or disruptive to hold down a job, so they'll be out of work a lot, and thus they'll have to live in poor neighbourhoods. Criminals are mostly low academic achievers, so they're more likely to live in poor areas. Many people who commit crimes are on drugs, which they're more likely to get into if they're living in miserable conditions. The solutions to the high crime rate in some poor areas are more complex than just allocating more police to them, although it's quite possible that should be done. But don't forget that no matter how many police there are in the area, they won't be able to prevent crime that they don't know is going on. Obviously, if there's more crime in poor areas, there will be more crime that the police just didn't foresee and thus couldn't prevent. You seem to think there's a conspiracy to protect the rich and neglect the poor. But unless you have actual statistics that prove that there are consistently more police allocated to well-off neighbourhoods per head of the population, you can't make a case for yourself. I think if you look at the statistics, you're likely to find just the opposite. Part of the problem though may be that many spend too much time doing paperwork in their offices rather than out on the beat.
Dann said:
Yes, we get the message: Poor people are unskilled and not able to market their (non-existent) products. That they also don't have the resources is fairly obvious. The resources already belong to the corporations, and they wouldn't accept poor people repossessing them so "a lot of those in the uprising might get hurt or killed".
A lot of people might get hurt or killed because the violence they were perpetrating while "kicking out" their exploitative employers would inevitably be returned with violence. Tell me why this would be acceptable to you in your vision of a good Marxist revolution.
Again, your views are simplistic. If poor people in developing countries took over the means of production, they might well be taking over large enterprises; but if they didn't have the
knowledge to market their products effectively or enough money to ship them out to places where they could sell a lot of them, - and after all why should they, if such matters have always been dealt with by people far away, - chances are the enterprises would fade quite quickly, and they wouldn't be all that much better off than they were when they were working for the multi-nationals. Instead of just making morose attempts at criticism, perhaps you could spell out your vision of how much things could improve, and exactly how they would be enabled to improve if your vision of a Marxist revolution took place? Perhaps you could tell me in a few brief sentences the essence of what is wrong with Capitalism and why a Communist system would actually be better?
Also consider whether the people would genuinely be better off, since if one set of masters was kicked out, there would be a power vacuum, and there would be people who'd want to take over and lead, and those people might not be any better. Why do you imagine they would?
It's impractical to think there could be a society where there was no hierarchy at all. A hierarchy of authority is necessary for efficiency. At least,
so says John Cleese of Monty Python fame, who has made several business training videos. I once heard him say that making those changed his views on the importance of a hierarchy of authority.
Dann said:
So what we need is good religion teaching "very good moral values" by means of the big bogeyman in the sky.
It's interesting how you can at the same time hold the view that God is represented as a big bogeyman in the sky, and the view that religion is based on the fact that people erroneously turn to him for comfort.

Your views are beginning to strike me as a bit strange.
Dann said:
And I'm sure that your teaching of critical thinking wouldn't mind looking at the 'factor' of British imperialism in Northern Ireland and its collaboration with religion.
If it was a factor that bigotry was being fuelled by the spreading of inflammatory historical stories, whether they be true or not, that issue of course would need to be looked at, in terms of how relevant it should be to forming people's current attitudes.
Dann said:
That's what you get when you actually consider it a good idea to lie to people as a 'benign' way of manipulating them into being good.
But the inspirational "Little Teddy Stoddard" story was never meant as a lie. It was actually written in a different form by someone who looked at some school records and wanted to convey in story form what she felt could happen if only teachers took a different attitude. She was surprised when she discovered the story had been changed a bit and was being circulated as fact. Whether the story is more powerful if people believe it's factual or not is open to question.
It's true that there's a lot wrong with the educational system and things need to change. A lot of teachers aren't happy with the pressure to teach according to what's going to be in important tests children are taking too young, rather than having the freedom to teach around the subject more. And literacy could certainly be improved if more inventive methods of teaching were used.
I myself posted on a few ways education ought to be improved in a thread about dyslexia.
However, education is yet another thing you seem to see as a big conspiracy to keep the masses down. While I've heard an account from someone who worked in a school where he was convinced that people
were in fact being educated merely for low-level jobs, because the standard of education was so poor, it's simplistic to imagine the entire education system is designed to serve the purpose of filtering a mass of slower learners out to go into menial jobs. After all, there's a skill shortage in jobs like science and engineering that need a high level of qualification. Menial manufacturing jobs, on the other hand, are becoming far fewer. So apart from anything else, it wouldn't be in the government's interests to perpetuate an education system that kept people down. It's in the government's interests to make it as good as it can be, and there have been efforts to improve it.
Dann said:
Yes, there you go again about "Some people": Some people have made dramatic changes in their lives that have gone on to benefit them and their communities when they've been inspired by giving up their addiction to Christianity. All in all, some people do all sorts of things for all sorts of reasons.
Not the best of arguments for lying ...
But as I said, it isn't lying, and couldhn't possibly be, because it would be impossible to teach about Jesus and the other New Testament characters
knowing that what you were teaching wasn't true, because it's impossible to be certain it wasn't true. Teaching it believing it's true and then discovering it wasn't, if that was possible, wouldn't mean you were lying when you were teaching it. Teaching it saying many people
believe it to be true would be an adequate compromise. Then people could make up their own minds.
Dann said:
This feels like , but don't worry about the absence of proof that (any kind of god) doesn't exist, as long as there is absolutely no proof that it/she/he does.
Anyway, appeals to imaginary authority are just as bad as appeals to false authority.
But on the contrary, many Christians believe they have good reasons for believing God and Jesus exist, including things like these:
The Impossible Faith.
... Below I offer a list of 17 factors to be considered -- places where Christianity "did the wrong thing" in order to be a successful religion. It is my contention that the only way Christianity did succeed is because it was a truly revealed faith -- and because it had the irrefutable witness of the resurrection. ...
Skeptics and critics must explain otherwise why, despite each and every one of these factors, Christianity survived, and thrived.
Are you up to the challenge?
Dann said:
You appear to be advocating a kind of benign delusional authoritarianism.
But of course, I'm not advocating authoritarianism at all, since I'm certainly not recommending people be forced to believe in God and follow the moral teaching of the New Testament, hence my belief that schools should teach critical thinking skills.