Singularitarian
Banned
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2009
- Messages
- 1,007
No, I want you to learn something. If you've learned it, you don't need to reply on that point.
What makes you think i learned something new from your post, other than the terminology?
No, I want you to learn something. If you've learned it, you don't need to reply on that point.
What makes you think i learned something new from your post, other than the terminology?
Physics concerns complicated concepts. In order to convey them in a meaningfull, and consistant way, we need to use accepted terminology.
I don't think you should get so defensive about what you are calling nitpicks. Those nitpicks can be the difference between comments and questions which makes sense, and something that does not.
I don't know what he wants you to say, either. But I do have some questions, based on his post:Yes, i've read it, I just don't know what he wants me to say...![]()
I don't know what he wants you to say, either. But I do have some questions, based on his post:
No, you got one question right, the first (practically) - the rest was but more babbling...
Singularitarian, this thread seems to prove rather devastatingly that you don't know general relativity well enough to parse Sean Carroll's lectures about it, much less to understand them---and moreover that either (a) you think you understand them perfectly or (b) you're willing to pretend to understand them for the sake of something to flaunt.
I don't see anyone trying to refute that; shall we take it to be understood as we go back to the science threads?