Relativity Quiz

What makes you think i learned something new from your post, other than the terminology?

Terminology is what I wanted you to learn from that particular post. If you learned the terminology, then no response was needed on your part, though acknowledgment is also welcome.
 
Physics concerns complicated concepts. In order to convey them in a meaningfull, and consistant way, we need to use accepted terminology.

I don't think you should get so defensive about what you are calling nitpicks. Those nitpicks can be the difference between comments and questions which makes sense, and something that does not.
 
Physics concerns complicated concepts. In order to convey them in a meaningfull, and consistant way, we need to use accepted terminology.

I don't think you should get so defensive about what you are calling nitpicks. Those nitpicks can be the difference between comments and questions which makes sense, and something that does not.

I want to push back against the possibility that we admit, "Yes, it's a terminology nitpick, but terminology is important".

It requires no nitpicking to state that Question/Answer #2 had no physics content at all, and indeed required the poster not to understand the difference between deciding which symbols to use as variables and actually manipulating/transforming those variables. This is distinct from either (a) the perfectly-true statement that terminology is important or (b) the also-true statement that " a' " is correctly called "a-prime", not "a-superscript-prime". Both of the latter have nitpick potential to them, the former does not.
 
Yes, i've read it, I just don't know what he wants me to say... :confused:
I don't know what he wants you to say, either. But I do have some questions, based on his post:

He claims to have identified the source of your quiz. Is he correct?

He claims that in your quiz, you have badly misunderstood some of your source material, and badly botched parts of your quiz. Do you agree?

He presents reconstructions of your quiz questions, that he claims are correct versions of yoru botched attempts. Do you accept these reconstructions as correct?

He also claims that some of your questions cannot be reliably reconstructed, since your apparent misunderstanding of the material is so great that no meaningful version of your question can possibly exist. Do you agree with this assessment?
 
I don't know what he wants you to say, either. But I do have some questions, based on his post:

Me too.

My earlier guesses at the questions matched what Thabiguy found in Carrol up to minor changes (with the exception of question 1, which was so mangled I couldn't reconstruct it). Not only that, but my answers to that part and the previous were all correct.

And yet, you said:

No, you got one question right, the first (practically) - the rest was but more babbling...

So either you didn't get your questions from Carroll - good luck convincing anyone of that - or you did, and you failed to understand them so badly you couldn't even recognize my correct versions and correct answers. Or you were just lying to try to save face.

Which was it?
 
Singularitarian, this thread seems to prove rather devastatingly that you don't know general relativity well enough to parse Sean Carroll's lectures about it, much less to understand them---and moreover that either (a) you think you understand them perfectly or (b) you're willing to pretend to understand them for the sake of something to flaunt.

I don't see anyone trying to refute that; shall we take it to be understood as we go back to the science threads?

The really sad part is I think my niece who has trouble with long division, could have done a better job "parsing" Carroll's work in a foolish attempt to pass it off as something she authored.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom