Relativity Quiz

I am concerned with the lack of intelligent discussion, there may be a chance i could break down into catatonic schizophrenia. But hey, that's life :(
 
And what you are guilty of doing, is completely ignoring every single proper refutation, and correction, offered. You instead focus on the side commentary, while essentialy pretending the valid objections do not exist.

Thabiguy did an excellent job of refuting your work in this thread and once again you have absolutely nothing specific top say about the very specific comments he made.

We are not the least bit fooled by your attempts to look down on the quality of responses you have received.

What was there to refute in the case of this thread?

Perhaps you would like to delve into one of the essays i have thus created so far, and try the refutations there.
 
What was there to refute in the case of this thread?

Perhaps you would like to delve into one of the essays i have thus created so far, and try the refutations there.

Singularitarian, this thread seems to prove rather devastatingly that you don't know general relativity well enough to parse Sean Carroll's lectures about it, much less to understand them---and moreover that either (a) you think you understand them perfectly or (b) you're willing to pretend to understand them for the sake of something to flaunt.

I don't see anyone trying to refute that; shall we take it to be understood as we go back to the science threads?
 
Not necesserily.

Devistating is such a strong word. Truth is, the questions are worded in such a way they are generally-correct, even if not well-described.

Besides, i am tediuosly tired of this continuation of this thread. I did this thread for two reasons; the first was more conspicuous than that of the second. The first reason is that i was sick of the comments made by people who clearly did not understand the physics i was talking about, and thus my scientific integrity was questioned. In an attempt to out some of the people who do know some physics, i wanted to oust them. The second reason was because i wanted to see how much the thread would turn out like some of my others, whilst this thread differs greately. I's not a written essay, but arguably just a list of badly posed questions.
 
Not necesserily.

Devistating is such a strong word. Truth is, the questions are worded in such a way they are generally-correct, even if not well-described.

First, the questions are not "generally correct". The text that you cut-and-pasted was correct before you copied it---a fact for which you don't get any credit---but your attempts to turn it into questions basically obliterated that correctness, and did so in ways that illustrated how poorly you understood what you were doing.

Do you understand why "the use of superscripts like a'" is a stupid answer to Question 2, no matter how you reword the question?
 
I never cut and pasted, not to my memory anyway. The fact also you have to write out latex kinda issues to that as well

The use of the superscript is used to note the rotations in spacetime. It's not about being silly, and... oh, never mind.

Bored.
 
The use of the superscript is used to note the rotations in spacetime. It's not about being silly, and... oh, never mind.

So Sol et. al. still haven't parsed your grand "Question #2" correctly. The real question, cunningly designed to "oust" the people who really know physics, should have been:

"When Sean Carroll has defined a coordinate and he wants to express it in a second reference frame, what notation does he usually choose for the new coordinate?"

That is the only question for which "add superscript prime" is the correct answer. If you thought there was something else sciencey about [latex]a'[/latex], you were mistaken.
 
Last edited:
The use of the superscript is used to note the rotations in spacetime.

It's not a superscript. The little mark after the letter in a' is called a prime. It is commonly used to represent transformed coordinates (ie, coordinates in some new reference frame), but such transformations are not limited to rotations. Nor is such notation limited to relativity, it's standard in Newtonian physics as well.
 
Well, there is the first terminology i would admit too that is not correct, from my i mean in this case. To me its a superscript, a mark, a change.
 
So Sol et. al. still haven't parsed your grand "Question #2" correctly. The real question, cunningly designed to "oust" the people who really know physics, should have been:

"When Sean Carroll has defined a coordinate and he wants to express it in a second reference frame, what notation does he usually choose for the new coordinate?"

That is the only question for which "add superscript prime" is the correct answer. If you thought there was something else sciencey about [latex]a'[/latex], you were mistaken.

The way you go on, you would think it was detestable i called it simply a superscipt and not a superscript prime.

So much nit-picking.
 
Superscript is a typographical term, along with subscript. This is a' with the ' superscript: a', as subscript: a'

You'll note that the ' character is elevated higher than the axis of the rest of the text. That is superscript.
 
The way you go on, you would think it was detestable i called it simply a superscipt and not a superscript prime.

So much nit-picking.

Listen carefully Sing: this is not nit-picking. a' is not "how you represent rotations". A rotation is a frame transformation, and after a frame transformation you usually want to rename your coordinate variables so you don't get them mixed up with the pre-transformation coordinate variables. a' is what some people choose for their renamed variables. It's like:

Q: According to Special Relativity, how do you add the velocities v and u?
A: You call the sum v'.

Q: What is the energy of the first excited state of argon?
A: My textbook calls it E

Q: What is the height of the Washington Monument?
A: it can be represented by a simple lower-case letter like h
 
Last edited:
It's not a superscript, and it's not a superscript prime either. It's just a prime.

I know I've seen subscript primes used somewhere, but I forget where. Anyway, yeah, I didn't mean to call it a superscript prime, it's just a prime.
 
Very well. How can i argue with that?

Do you want me to? I get th distinct impression many do want me to argue, but as i said earlier, i doubt i will take this place as seriously in the future.
 
I know I've seen subscript primes used somewhere, but I forget where. Anyway, yeah, I didn't mean to call it a superscript prime, it's just a prime.

Don't worry. It's obvious mistakes are easy to make.

I made one too, but then that was just as obvious...
 
You mangled the information when forming questions in a way that does indicate a lack of expertise in the field. How do you account for this?

EDIT: If the responses you are seeing here are confrontational, Singularitarian, I believe that is a direct result of much of what you have said. In all fairness, you have not comported yourself in a gentlemanly manner. Your own behaviour has inspired a distinct lack of charity.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom