Relativity Quiz

Since i was generous enough to provide half of what you initially said i required yours and others aid on, i think it only balanced and just that you do the other half, and put the Devil to shame.
 
Since i was generous enough to provide half of what you initially said i required yours and others aid on, i think it only balanced and just that you do the other half, and put the Devil to shame.

Except that not only did I post correct answers for 1-4, I also posted the correct questions - which you have to admit is harder than merely answering...
 
No, you got one question right, the first (practically) - the rest was but more babbling... but guess what, i have a dental appointment in the morning, so i must retire, which gives you plenty of homework time to proove your worth before i present it tomorrow. Then maybe you won't, including you croney little gang of worshippers be so high and mighty.
 
No, you got one question right, the first (practically) - the rest was but more babbling... but guess what, i have a dental appointment in the morning, so i must retire, which gives you plenty of homework time to proove your worth before i present it tomorrow. Then maybe you won't, including you croney little gang of worshippers be so high and mighty.

Sol's comment on question #2 is correct. A rotating frame is not inertial, yet you refer to it as inertial in your question. Hence, your question is in error.

Now please, stop ignoring points made against you. Either explain away his objection with actual references to the objection, or concede.



Edit to add: I believe the 2nd question was actualy asking about a different reference frame, rotated, with respect to the 1st. Singulatarian erroneously equated rotated with rotating.
 
Last edited:
No, you got one question right, the first (practically) - the rest was but more babbling...

Nope. Your second and fourth questions were nonsensical, and Sol got the third question right. He did it with units, you did it without units, he did it using one sign convention, you did it using the other. But, irony of ironies, the sign convention Sol used matches your question #1, whereas you used a different sign convention.

but guess what, i have a dental appointment in the morning, so i must retire, which gives you plenty of homework time to proove your worth before i present it tomorrow.

Amazing the arrogance you put on display after your earlier epic math fail.
 
Concede what?

Just get him to prove his worth for the next lot. I am not contending against someone accusing me for tying to extract information of them...

...paranoid comes to mind.
 
Nope. Your second and fourth questions were nonsensical, and Sol got the third question right. He did it with units, you did it without units, he did it using one sign convention, you did it using the other. But, irony of ironies, the sign convention Sol used matches your question #1, whereas you used a different sign convention.



Amazing the arrogance you put on display after your earlier epic math fail.


Gloat all you want on the fail.

It was a mistake i made, and something we all do, some more than others. Now, focus on the equations at hand, and lets see if your momma gave birth to someone who was more action than talk.
 
The best part is his "answer" to the second question:

"2) Mathematically you can express rotations with simple superscripts such as a'"

My guess is he was looking in a book and noticed that variables in a rotated frame were written with a prime.

The fourth question is already answered in #3, since the inverse of the diagonal matrix {-1,1,1,1} is {-1,1,1,1}.
 
I am getting an image in my mind:

4569274dec37b03de570aadcf31.jpg
 
GR:


1) According to the Einsteins Field Equations the gravitational redshift, consider two boxes. They are at a distance [latex]z[/latex] apart moving far away from any matter, thus it is in the absence of any gravitational field with some constant acceleration. At time [latex]t_0[/latex] it lags behind the box which emits a photon of wavelength λ0. Show how the boxes remain contant when distance is considered, so that the photon in consideration reaching the leading box after the time has passed [latex]\Delta t = z/c[/latex] in the reference frame of the boxes. The boxes should reatain an additional velocity of [latex]\Delta v = a \Delta t = az/c[/latex]. Show how th Doppler Effect is redshifted by an amount.

I'm going to try and translate that into common, one sentence at a time.

According to the Einsteins Field Equations the gravitational redshift, consider two boxes.

Consider 2 boxes.

They are at a distance [latex]z[/latex] apart moving far away from any matter, thus it is in the absence of any gravitational field with some constant acceleration.

The distance seperating them is [latex]z[/latex].
They are both moving.
They are not inflenced by the gravitational field of anything other than each other.
We have no information about their initial velocities or acceleration, at the time [latex]t[/latex] when their seperation is [latex]z[/latex].

At time [latex]t_0[/latex] it lags behind the box which emits a photon of wavelength λ0.

I have no freaking idea what 'it' is.
I have no freaking idea which box is 'the box'.
I'm going to guess that 'it' is one of the boxes, and 'the box' is the other box.
Under that assumption, the trailing box emits a photon, in some random direction. Or perhaps it's in some specific direction that's being kept a secret.


I'm splitting this next sentence out of necessity.
Show how the boxes remain contant when distance is considered,

Show that [latex]z[/latex] does not change.

so that the photon in consideration reaching the leading box after the time has passed [latex]\Delta t = z/c[/latex] in the reference frame of the boxes.

It would seem that the photon left the trailing box heading forward towards the leading box.
Therefore we are asked to show that [latex]z[/latex] does not change when it takes [latex]\Delta t = z/c[/latex] for it to travel from the trailing box to the leading box.

The boxes should reatain an additional velocity of [latex]\Delta v = a \Delta t = az/c[/latex].

The boxes would in fact retain that additional velocity, had it been mentioned that they were undergoing an acceleration [latex]a[/latex]. But since it was never mentioned, now seems like an odd time to bring it up.

Show how th Doppler Effect is redshifted by an amount.

This part's easy: th Doppler Effect


Does that make the question clear now?
 
[Here is a little quiz for those who think they can answer the questions. I expect the special theoretical equatons solves easier than the General, but this should be fun]

SR:

1) Can this equation be negative, positive or zero?

latex.php


This equation is a Cartesian Coordinate of spacetime.

If I were your algebra teacher, I'd take half off for asking something as dumb as, "What is the value of an equation?". S can have a value; s^2 can have a value. Depending on how you define your coordinate system, t is usually thought of as having only has positive values; x, y, and z can have any real values. c is a positive constant. Algebraically, then s^2 can have any real value, and therefore s can have any real or imaginary value. The "equation" has no value.
 
If I were your algebra teacher, I'd take half off for asking something as dumb as, "What is the value of an equation?". S can have a value; s^2 can have a value. Depending on how you define your coordinate system, t is usually thought of as having only has positive values; x, y, and z can have any real values. c is a positive constant. Algebraically, then s^2 can have any real value, and therefore s can have any real or imaginary value. The "equation" has no value.

What I find most interesting about this question, is how the correct answer, as given by Singularitarian, is in fact answering some other question. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom